Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Will Searby on January 09, 2021, 03:02:17 PM
-
What kind of balance do people advise for practising between expanding your repertoire and 'working on' tunes that you've learnt?
I know it's a highly subjective question, but I get the feeling that as one expands one's repertoire it becomes easier to find notes quickly, since you become more familiar with the instrument and have a more instinctive feel for the button layout.
That being said, my attitude to learning tunes for a long time was just learning one way to play them, learning them well enough to busk with (without much variation), and then treating them as 'finished'. I don't think this is a good attitude at all to take towards playing and doesn't tend towards engaging with the instrument in a constructive and creative way. In order to develop tunes I tend to have to break them down (as I'm sure is true for all of us), but I tend to visualise this a bit like 'taking them apart' - I think I struggle with the leap of faith or the confidence necessary to develop tunes because I get very frustrated when it feels like the roughly 50? tunes I know are all 'in pieces' and I can't play any of them from muscle memory because I'm working on different ways to play them, which is a real block on developing my technique.
So, basically, what I'm asking is, as an estimate, how much time do you think you spend trying to rapidly expand your repertoire versus really getting into an individual tune and playing around with it, which do you think delivers the most results as the standard way that you practice? Or, against both of these, do you find that it's better to practice just by playing common phrases over and over again in different ways? Do you have any kind of practice regimen?
-
When learning music nothing is ever “finishedâ€.
https://quoteinvestigator.com/2014/02/12/casals-progress/
-
I practice to ‘perform’ - for TOTM/ThOTM or what is currently a fortnightly Zoom music session. Knowing there’ll be an audience is what makes me practice.
Quite often TOTM will involve learning a new tune where my aim will be to get it to a standard which I think is good enough to record. This entails a number of stages. The first is getting familiar enough with the tune by watching/listening to it being played. Secondly if there’s abc avaiable I’ll copy that to my abc software, without chords or LH indicators so that I'll hopefully play (most of) the right notes. Then I’ll work on both hands to try and find chords and LH basses I like. This and airflow tends to sort out bellows direction. Whilst practising a new tune, I’ll often find new finger patterns which allow me to get round all the notes.
The final stage is recording, at which stage I’ll very often find that I can’t play it through without loads of mistakes so I’ll play it through as many times as needed to perform it without too many hiccups. Even then I’ll sometimes find new patterns. If it’s not a tune I want to play in the future, recording it will often be the last time I play it.
For a live (Zoom) session, I’d never normally play a new tune. But I often re-visit tunes I’ve played in the past, some of which will need a lot of practice to get to performance level. Others might only take a few play throughs to ‘get them back’. Finally, as might be obvious from what I’ve said, I don’t try and keep a big repertoire completely up to performance level.
Hope this helps. O(thers)MMV.
-
to me the imortant thing is to really learn to play the instrument (using a small number of relatively easy tuneas a vehicle '
most imortant is to become absolutely fluent with wharver scales your box can provide as scales are simplly the route along which tunes go back and forth. no concious thought should be needed to paly scales using any 'alternative'notes your box has
then have a go at whatever tunes take your fancy either by ear or from the dots or a bit of both.
next keeping to a small repertoire move on from polaying the right notes in the tight order to playing musically, adding rhythm, dynamcs abnd phrasing. rhythm is what makes you or others and particularly dancers 'move' to yourf music
dynamics makes it interesting by varying the volume here and there i.e for an individual note or a group of notes using variations in bellows presure even for a singlenote
phrasing is about 'playing the gaps between notes' rather than just playing the right notes in the right order and in some ways playing the gaps is more important than playing the notes
when you can do all of the above adding 'new' tunes is much easier
george
-
I think you should ask yourself ‘What do I want to be?’ as a box player. My practising is geared towards wanting to be able to contribute to sessions by knowing a pretty wide range of tunes; whilst having a limited number of tunes I might play at a sing around or Zoom session. So I’d say I spend about 75% of my time learning new (to me) tunes and 25% on tunes to perform.
Along the way I guess I’m picking up new skills, technique and knowledge, but as a by product. I sense that George’s comments (I have his book which helped me a lot especially in my early playing days) would advise a more structured approach to developing and honing the knowledge and skills needed to be a much better musician. Apologies to George if I am misrepresenting his post.
-
I practice to ‘perform’
I think I have typically done the same, and I'm trying to post videos now to facilitate setting goals for my practising. The trouble was, when I was practising to 'perform' for busking, it was very easy to get complacent, the average person on the street is not going to notice if you miss out a couple of notes here and there or get the left hand slightly wrong, and playing tunes over and over throughout the day (as with busking) can mean that one tends to simplify the tunes. So an objective for me now is to be more precise with my playing.
I think you should ask yourself ‘What do I want to be?’ as a box player.
Yes, quite - I think that's changed quite a bit since I was busking - since for that the objective is simply to get a large enough repertoire that you can play for a couple of hours without repetition. Now I think I'm far more interested in developing tunes, bringing out harmonies, using the left hand more inventively etc.
On another note - are there any practice exercises that others would recommend. Most of the time I pick up my melodeon all I do is play the tunes I know (not all of them of course but whichever ones I'm feeling like), sometimes a little slower, sometimes faster and experiment a bit with the left hand. Is it worth, for instance, playing scales as with other instruments, or, on a D/G box, practising different progressions in different ways (like G-A-B progressions cross row of the push and pull and push-pull on the single row)?
-
there are indeed many ways of developing, improvingor whatever ones playing skillls and techniques and the important thing is to always keep that in mind whatever you are playing/learning a new to you tune/ revisiting a long lost tune etc etc.
Its often small things, helpful comments etc that can brinbg about real inprovements, eg a very long time ago i was playing ( i thought) in a sing round type session in which we played or sung in turnwithout others jjoining in. I played a tune , cant remeber what,that I knew well and thought I could play well. I got the standard clap for my efforts and was quite chuffed.
Later in the vvening I was at the bar with the guy running the session and he said something on the lines of '' nice tune but you werent phrasing it george' I said oh and I hadnt a clue what he meant by phrasing. I consulted a friene who was a classical violinist and he explained that in simple terms it was like punctuation in the spoken or sung word in essence full stops and commas etc.
that simple bit of honest criticism resulted in a marked improvement in my playing, not only of 'that' tune but to every tunes I have played in the following 50 odd years.
Over the years I have picked up loads more useful tips ( and some shite ones) which is all part of the lifelong learning process
george
-
Is it worth, for instance, playing scales as with other instruments, or, on a D/G box, practising different progressions in different ways (like G-A-B progressions cross row of the push and pull and push-pull on the single row)?
From the perspective of a semitone box player, I would say yes, definitely. It sounds to me as though you have an idea of things you could be trying (being more precise, for example). I'd encourage you not to wait for others to say such-and-such is, or is not, a good idea. Just get stuck in and do it!
My approach is, the more time you spend with your instrument, and the more different things you try, the better. I tell everyone that no effort on the path of music is wasted. I'm not sure that holds true in every circumstance but you get the idea.
-
https://amazon.co.uk/First-Learn-Practice-Tom-Heany/dp/1072224461/
I think this very short but practical little book is a fantastic investment. A lot of books on musical development and practice are overwhelmingly large and/or cater to advanced musicians. This one is very practical but grounded in the psychology of what works, and it's not prescriptive.
-
For me, I know how to practise. Having been there on another instrument. But I just don't want to. This is a hobby, when I get time, when I feel like it. I'm spending more time riding a bike than playing any instrument these days - which might well change. If I feel like it.
The biggest tip I could give someone who wants to practise is to realise that if you don't enjoy the micro control of tiny gains with massive repetitions, then you are possibly better off playing tunes. I used to love taking my playing to bits (not the melodeon, but the clarinet), and finding ways to secure a solid technique. That was WAY more interesting to me than playing pieces. I would often spend whole mornings working on varieties of starting single notes. Certainly controlling pitch and volume (not always as simple as it looks).
So my advice would be look carefully at your motivation, and capacity for divorcing yourself from tunes. Then reduce everything to tiny movements. The most important thing is listening to every part of every note in every exercise. Or just play tunes.
-
I'd encourage you not to wait for others to say such-and-such is, or is not, a good idea. Just get stuck in and do it!
My approach is, the more time you spend with your instrument, and the more different things you try, the better. I tell everyone that no effort on the path of music is wasted. I'm not sure that holds true in every circumstance but you get the idea.
I agree, and it's much more the case than most instruments that most of us on melodeon will be self taught, so there is a much less prescriptive 'pathway' for learning the instrument. But nevertheless I'm haunted by the prospect that there potentially *was* a lot of 'wasted' time I spent playing (playing quite carelessly whilst busking).
I suspect there are a couple of things which can help in general - for instance; how does one practice bellows-control, is it best just to try to play the tunes you know very quietly? Is it useful to try to do this on a less responsive box?
-
For me, I know how to practise. Having been there on another instrument. But I just don't want to.
Yes, I suspect I'm very much the same - there's a reason I've been able to stick with melodeon and not with other instruments where I had a more defined pathway and grades, and that does probably reflect my motivation in the way you're talking about. It's difficult to parse though, because obviously I also feel like I want to do the tunes justice.
So my advice would be look carefully at your motivation, and capacity for divorcing yourself from tunes. Then reduce everything to tiny movements. The most important thing is listening to every part of every note in every exercise. Or just play tunes.
Thanks, this is actually really useful - I have to admit I tend not to really break my playing down this far.
-
you then have c
- for instance; how does one practice bellows-control, is it best just to try to play the tunes you know very quietly? Is it useful to try to do this on a less responsive box?
a good way of developing bellows control is to play the bulk of a tune at about half the volume your box is capable of - when you have got the hang of playing at mid volume it is comparitively easy to add a considerable degree of 'character' to a tune by increasing or decreaseing the volume here and there , maybe for a bar or two maybe for a single note or phrase eg lowering the volume on the last bar or two of a tune and starting the repeat of it (or start of another tune) at a much higher volume before dropping back to mid volume with variations of bellows pressure/volume here and there as takes your fancy!
there is as much or even more skill required to play the bellows than to play the notes or to put it another way the bellows is to the box player what the bow is to the fidler
r
george
ps playing mostly around half volume/bellows pressure makes fast in and outing easier and more precise bkeeping the bellows as 'tight 'as possible rather than waving them about at near full extension
george
-
For me, I know how to practise. Having been there on another instrument. But I just don't want to. This is a hobby, when I get time, when I feel like it. I'm spending more time riding a bike than playing any instrument these days - which might well change. If I feel like it.
The biggest tip I could give someone who wants to practise is to realise that if you don't enjoy the micro control of tiny gains with massive repetitions, then you are possibly better off playing tunes. I used to love taking my playing to bits (not the melodeon, but the clarinet), and finding ways to secure a solid technique. That was WAY more interesting to me than playing pieces. I would often spend whole mornings working on varieties of starting single notes. Certainly controlling pitch and volume (not always as simple as it looks).
So my advice would be look carefully at your motivation, and capacity for divorcing yourself from tunes. Then reduce everything to tiny movements. The most important thing is listening to every part of every note in every exercise. Or just play tunes.
Sometimes someone just writes something that makes perfect sense. Thanks Pete....and Will for asking the question.
-
Apropos Georges comment on phrasing, Inveterate educators, Milleret and Pignol published a DVD a few years back covering phrasing issues, use of the “most important button†air valve and subtlties of use of bellows, left arm, and posture.
Also simple things like how to hold a melodeon. How to stand.
Seems to have been done by a pupil, who acts as that in the video. He finishes with a nice candid interview about the duo’s musical journey. (I met them as musically “flat out†post grads in St Chartier). subtitles in English and Spanish
https://mustradem.com/boutique/en/dvd/9-l-air-et-le-geste-3760238260375.html
My own tip would be to learn the tune, but then practice it focusing on “expressionâ€. Don’t medley! Rather develop ways of playing it in different ways. Yes,to inversions and to arpegio or chord substitutions.
Others will be little flicks, pauses, leaving notes out, quite tiny pauses that turn a phrase from simple melody to something emotional. As with speech that could be a joke, a pregnant pause, on occasion something even seductive. It’s partly in the modulation, most powerful in the spaces you put between the notes
Make it “funâ€
-
Everyone learning to play any instrument goes through stages of learning and plateaux when they have achieved their next aim. There is nothing wrong with busking, but it requires a different approach to playing than that you're now addressing. I went through a similar phase, playing as an apprentice in our morris band - simply adding some thickness to the sound. I've seen very accomplished buskers and their performances attract a static audience rather than passing trade who drop money in the hat!
You obviously know where you are going next, and now have a selection of advice to take you there.
I don't have any advice on how much to concentrate on existing repertoire, but it is restricted by the demands of learning more tunes - and one cannot stint on that. I would recommend that when playing tunes you know well, you allow yourself to try variations in phrasing, decoration and dynamics according to mood - put something of your own soul into it.
Rob.
-
My own tip would be to learn the tune, but then practice it focusing on “expressionâ€. Don’t medley! Rather develop ways of playing it in different ways. Yes,to inversions and to arpegio or chord substitutions...
...Make it “funâ€
The best advice yet.
-
Will, practicing in small doses to learn a few tunes "well" seems to work better for me than to learn a bunch of tunes with barely discernible skill.
Always in awe of this Paul Young example. Can't get a simpler tune. But Lord, Lord, if I I could play it like this!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d7DYijyLVwk
-
Listen. Practice listening. Listen some more.
-
Yep - I'll go with making it fun. Personally, I could just do with learning to concentrate and apply myself more ! And also to improve my melodeon face (tips anyone >:E?)
J
-
...also to improve my melodeon face (tips anyone >:E?)
Step 1: Obtain photograph of professional artist playing with serene expression on face (Andy C [or, possibly, Winston. Whoever takes your fancy ;D] should be ideal)
Step 2: Print out full face at A4
Step 3: Trim to oval face shape
Step 4: Attach two elastic bands at ear height
Step 5: Wear whenever making recording, or performing in public.
Easy really.
-
"(Andy C should be ideal)"
Really? I think I'd rather have someone better looking than I already am! Saul Rose, perhaps? (Or maybe Sir J McK, full set and all?)
-
1) I learn a tune best when I hear it and see the dots. Or sometimes just use the dots if it’s an instrument I’m more proficient in.
I know I know the tune when I find myself whistling it. I’ll often go back and check I’m whistling it right though.
2) I then find where the notes lie on the instrument, consider fingering options, breathing techniques if appropriate, and begin to put phrases together.
3) Then, the best advice I’ve ever been given, GO SLOW!!! The theory goes that in order to get the right brain neurons to join up they need time and repetition. If you go too fast and make a mistake you then start to practise the mistake and that gets embedded in there by instead. I have found this is true for me “why the hell am I doing that again?â€
So the idea is to go so slow that you play a phrase perfectly.....once it’s perfect you can the increase speed. As soon as you make a mistake .....go back to SLOW! This also builds muscle memory.
4) Once you get the phrases right you work on the ‘between’ bits i.e. moving from one phrase to another but only the last few notes of the first phrase going into the first few notes of the next.
5) Once the whole tune is sound you work on performance points...making it musical.
Et voila.....you have your tune!
(Of course you could just ignore all that and play the damn tune.....I think when someone gets really good on their chosen instrument learning becomes a bit easier as the muscle memory is already there).
The final thing is it should be fun! Garry Moore once said “If you can walk past your instrument and not at least ‘FEEL’ like picking it up then it’s probably not for you!â€
Hope that helps.
-
“If you go too fast and make a mistake you then start to practise the mistake and that gets embedded “
So true........ so very true.
-
1) I learn a tune best when I hear it and see the dots. Or sometimes just use the dots if it’s an instrument I’m more proficient in.
I know I know the tune when I find myself whistling it. I’ll often go back and check I’m whistling it right though.
2) I then find where the notes lie on the instrument, consider fingering options, breathing techniques if appropriate, and begin to put phrases together.
3) Then, the best advice I’ve ever been given, GO SLOW!!! The theory goes that in order to get the right brain neurons to join up they need time and repetition. If you go too fast and make a mistake you then start to practise the mistake and that gets embedded in there by instead. I have found this is true for me “why the hell am I doing that again?â€
So the idea is to go so slow that you play a phrase perfectly.....once it’s perfect you can the increase speed. As soon as you make a mistake .....go back to SLOW! This also builds muscle memory.
4) Once you get the phrases right you work on the ‘between’ bits i.e. moving from one phrase to another but only the last few notes of the first phrase going into the first few notes of the next.
5) Once the whole tune is sound you work on performance points...making it musical.
1)-4)...as Tongle
5) Make a first recording to see what it sounds like
6) Once the whole tune is sound you work on performance points...making it musical and making further recordings
8) Decide the first recording sounds better than all those done after and post that recording.
-
My first Melinar of 2021 is entitled "Practise Smarter (Not Harder): Tips & Tricks for the unmotivated!"
Wednesday 20th January 7pm GMT
Practise Smarter (Not Harder): Tips & tricks for the unmotivated!
If there was one thing I heard over and over again from my students in 2020, it was that they were unmotivated to pick up their instrument. Bleurgh - I hear you! It was an awful year to feel productive (understandably).
However - you still want to play and improve, right?! There are some simple, easy tricks you can apply to encourage yourself to pick up & play. Music is great therapy and losing yourself in The Melodeon Zone is a place to heal from!
So I'm really passionate to motivate you, gently, with these tips & tricks of mine.
More info and sign up (reiterate: read for free!):
https://www.patreon.com/posts/46033834
-
I was reminiscing about my life in music to a tutee the other day regarding practicing and learning and remembered the contrast between being unemployed and working a full-time job.
On the one hand, having nothing to do but practice and play yielded results from the effort. On the other hand, spending 8-10 hours/day at work and just playing after work for a short time produced pretty much the same rate of progress.
Now this might reflect more on my personal level of discipline and ability, but it puts me in mind of the old tale of the young Truth seeker who apprenticed himself to a noted Zen master to attain enlightenment.
The aspirant asked what he should do and the Master said "Nothing right now. Go get a broom and sweep the floor while I think about it". This goes on for several years and eventually the young apprentice asks, "Master, when will you teach me?"
The Master replied, "There is nothing more for you to do. Your life has become one of mindfulness. Such is enlightenment."
Mindfullness... living a life of aspiration, faith and acceptance...has, in hindsight, been the path followed to musical fulfillment. The Answer is always there, always right in front of us. If our desire is sincere and we listen carefully, the "still, small voice" will reveal that which we thought hidden and unattainable.
-
1) I learn a tune best when I hear it and see the dots. Or sometimes just use the dots if it’s an instrument I’m more proficient in.
I know I know the tune when I find myself whistling it. I’ll often go back and check I’m whistling it right though.
2) I then find where the notes lie on the instrument, consider fingering options, breathing techniques if appropriate, and begin to put phrases together.
3) Then, the best advice I’ve ever been given, GO SLOW!!! The theory goes that in order to get the right brain neurons to join up they need time and repetition. If you go too fast and make a mistake you then start to practise the mistake and that gets embedded in there by instead. I have found this is true for me “why the hell am I doing that again?â€
So the idea is to go so slow that you play a phrase perfectly.....once it’s perfect you can the increase speed. As soon as you make a mistake .....go back to SLOW! This also builds muscle memory.
4) Once you get the phrases right you work on the ‘between’ bits i.e. moving from one phrase to another but only the last few notes of the first phrase going into the first few notes of the next.
5) Once the whole tune is sound you work on performance points...making it musical.
1)-4)...as Tongle
5) Make a first recording to see what it sounds like
6) Once the whole tune is sound you work on performance points...making it musical and making further recordings
8) Decide the first recording sounds better than all those done after and post that recording.
That’s really good advice. The ability to easily record yourself is a massively powerful tool which gives a completely honest and valuable source of feedback. And Greg is spot on with the ‘first recording’!😂
I would add another final step....to go along with that;
9) Accept the imperfections. As I think Greg implied it’s so easy to get into making 50 videos / recordings which can lead to frustration. If I record a video to share it’s usually the first or second take. As long as I don’t come to a complete stop I just leave mistakes in. I think it’s reassuring to see others fluffing bits, sometimes a full-on polished performance is a wonder to behold but can feel somewhat unattainable. Remember, it’s meant to be FUN!
-
Personally, I've found recording my playing to be an excellent way to highlight all the faults, but it can be pretty demanding ! I must have recorded Glory of the Sun twenty or more times, in full or in part, but by focussing on that tune for several days - and thinking of it as a little performance, quality definitely improved, and the tune was completely embedded. My key problem has always been concentration, and a tendency to work on too many tunes at the same time, so having tune and theme of the month definitely helps - even though I don't always record the tune.
Now to think about the theme tune, whilst trying not to be distracted by 'Trollpolska' - which probably requires me to learn at least the rudiments of the dance !
Julian
-
I have taught myself, mostly, to play a number of instruments. Mostly guitar like. Taking up free reeds relatively late in life I have become aware of the limited time available before I get awarded my heavenly harp, or possibly devilish digeridoo. So I cast about for advice in hastening the progress. A teacher is good, but practicing can be more or less productive depending on the approach to and habit of it. I looked for advice in writing, and found this https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0113AJLPA/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?_encoding=UTF8&btkr=1 (https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0113AJLPA/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?_encoding=UTF8&btkr=1) fairly helpful.
Ultimately you will be the final arbiter of what works and what doesn’t, but a number of experimental forays into the less obvious paths to take may prove illuminating.
-
theres a lot to be said for keeping a box handy, not in its case, but perhaps covered with a towel ti keep the dust out.
this enables you to pick the box up without the faf of getting it out of its case to have a quick practice/play/blast or whatever while the kettle is boining.
I have done this for many years and often the quick blast lasts for half an hour or more and fortunately the electric kettle switches off all by itself.
i also think the use of the word 'practice' can be off putting as it has connotations of hard work/study/ must get it right or whatever. Iprefer to enjoy 'playing' the box while listening carefully to the way a tune sounds and making ,often very small adjustments to improve the rendition.
Practicing, particularly stopping after every cock up and starting the tune again can be more negative than positive,In my experienceits more productve ( and enjoyable) to carry on with the rest of the tune whilst noting where you havn't got it quite the way you want it. Then start at the beginning again and try not to repeat the cock up whilst playing the whole tune.
Stopping at every cock up can be soul destroying and self perpetuating
george
-
Following on from George's post re-cock ups. I received some lessons from a well known professional box player and when I played
a wrong note, his advice was to play the same note again when repeating that part and very few will notice. Others will think it was written
into the music. It is what he does and has always got away with it.
-
indeed! think of it as simply your arrangement of a tune. Unlike deadly seriarse classical stuff 'traditional/folk music has developed in much that way and will hopefully continue so to do and whatever 'arrangemnt' yours or somebody elses the the tune will .or should still be, recognisable.
george
-
when I played a wrong note, his advice was to play the same note again when repeating that part and very few will notice.
Another very effective practice trick along these lines is to repeat such a phrase several times over and alternate between your correct and incorrect versions until you can play them both with ease.
-
Thanks so much for all the comments on here. Something P&T said made me consider (probably should have been obvious really) that there is a meaningful (though of course not total) distinction between 'practising the instrument' and 'practising tunes'. I'm now embarking on a painful journey of unlearning some of my bad habits (including, not least, the way I hold the box, which some people already picked up on - learning to play with my thumb away from the fingerboard and having my left hand far enough through the strap that I can use all four fingers for basses and chords).
-
Thanks so much for all the comments on here. Something P&T said made me consider (probably should have been obvious really) that there is a meaningful (though of course not total) distinction between 'practising the instrument' and 'practising tunes'.
I totally agree. I'd like some printed material for say, air valve melodic bellows reversals, and some right hand finger ex's in the style of the Hanon (piano) pieces. This type of material may be available in other languages?
I look out for a tunes that have specific bars that can be practiced in a looped fashion, but I do wonder if there's not a better way.
-
The more tunes you know, the easier the instrument. It's a cumulative thing. One tune informs another both moving forward and in retrospect.
A mentor can help in addition to or in lieu of a peer group. With today's phone technology, remote consultations are a snap.
-
when I played a wrong note, his advice was to play the same note again when repeating that pa' rt and very few will notice.
Another very effective practice trick along these lines is to repeat such a phrase several times over and alternate between your correct and incorrect versions until you can play them both with ease.
[/quot
better still look on both versions as 'correct' i.e simply different arangements of the same tune.
george
-
when I played a wrong note, his advice was to play the same note again when repeating that pa' rt and very few will notice.
Another very effective practice trick along these lines is to repeat such a phrase several times over and alternate between your correct and incorrect versions until you can play them both with ease.
[/quot
better still look on both versions as 'correct' i.e simply different arangements of the same tune.
george
If you are playing for dancers and you play a bum note just keep going - all dancers care about is the rythm.....can't remember who said that but he was being interviewed by the RSCDS house magazine when he said it!
-
I have to say, having played for dances (both ceilidhs, morris, and occasionally French/Breton) off and on for forty years, playing a tune without at least one 'bum note' is a rarity for me. Like others, I justify it as interpreting the tune in my own way ! And I doubt I ever play any tune quite the same, twice.
The only times I've had to stop have been when I play completely the wrong tune ! >:E
I'll never forget the first time I did that playing for Cotswold Morris way back. However, it was at a beer festival m'lud. And then there was the time when a reed stuck on the first note of the intro to a dance at the Sidmouth arena - I believe my curse came clearly over the p.a. (though maybe that is a recurring nightmare I have).
Seriously, no matter how well practised one is, bringing that to the gig is another problem and maybe one for another long discussion.
Julian
-
...The only times I've had to stop have been when I play completely the wrong tune ! >:E
Oh yes - I've been there, done that, usually at practices, but very occasionally at dance-outs too!
My excuse is that some of the Lizzie's tunes have very similar introductions. Starting the wrong one always results in a chorus of voices from the lined-up dancers 'Wrong tune!' together with puzzled looks from the other musicians.
:|bl
-
I’ve done the the wrong tune too, my band mates are very quick on the uptake and just go with it. All part of the fun!
-
In Morris situations, most of our dances are tune specific.
If you haven't started the dance there's a few leg pulling moments at the musician's expense whilst adjustmentsare made.
If you've started and hadn't realised it's the wrong tune there's a quick shout to change the dance to fit, with accompanying wild glint in the eye, hoping we all will have made the mental shift :Ph :M
It can be fun for all ::)
-
Then there's the time I played Bear Dance as a jig (we'd been playing it like that in the pub, for fun).
I couldn't work out what was wrong. Didn't half make the dancers feet shift, though.
-
and then there's the tune, the same tune that's been used for years, practised weekly. The Side's up and ready and
the lead musician sez
'How does it start?
:|bl Deafening silence!
NB Brain phartz are infectious ;D
-
I’ve done the the wrong tune too, my band mates are very quick on the uptake and just go with it. All part of the fun!
That's familiar. I used to play in a band in the 70s -80s whose leader would sometimes change into a different tune from the one' expected. You just learn to grin and follow.
-
and then there's the tune, the same tune that's been used for years, practised weekly. The Side's up and ready and
the lead musician sez
'How does it start?
:|bl Deafening silence!
NB Brain phartz are infectious ;D
Prefer 'Deafening silence' to 6 different tuneless la la las of two different tunes.
-
Prefer 'Deafening silence' to 6 different tuneless la la las of two different tunes.
You miss it really. I know I do.
-
I do wonder whether I'm being masochistic watching some of the dancing, whilst being sadistic inflicting my playing on them ! Particularly when we extemporise minor key versions of the tunes, or both myself and the fiddler go off the tune at complete tangents due to boredom. Completely unprofessional I know.
Off topic again, sorry. Perhaps it's best I go and do some practise - but the dichotomy between sitting in my music room trying to concentrate and apply myself and playing back before all this just seems particularly great today. I find setting myself a daily target helpful - and todays is recording a tune for theme of the month on the new Mory.
Julian
-
One suggestion for useful practice. Take a tune played really well that grabs your attention and spend some time working out what it is about the playing that grabs you and try and emulate it..or, at least, some element of it. e.g., I'm working on this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gcl9Hz65zVc
-
Thanks so much for all the comments on here. Something P&T said made me consider (probably should have been obvious really) that there is a meaningful (though of course not total) distinction between 'practising the instrument' and 'practising tunes'.
I totally agree. I'd like some printed material for say, air valve melodic bellows reversals, and some right hand finger ex's in the style of the Hanon (piano) pieces. This type of material may be available in other languages?
I look out for a tunes that have specific bars that can be practiced in a looped fashion, but I do wonder if there's not a better way.
In the spirit if you can't find it, invent it, I've "made up" a simple piece that combines a couple of issues that I'd like to improve, the main one being to include the RH 4th finger on longer flowing phrases. That's the way to go, methinks..
-
One suggestion for useful practice. Take a tune played really well that grabs your attention and spend some time working out what it is about the playing that grabs you and try and emulate it..or, at least, some element of it. e.g., I'm working on this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gcl9Hz65zVc
Definitely!!!
I call mine my "coathook" tune. I go back to it almost daily and it keeps teaching me.
And when I spend time working out the latest earworm that captures my interest, I return to my coathook and it reveals things I didn't even realize I was picking up from the new tune.
Contextual focus...