Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Blake on January 22, 2021, 09:24:59 PM
-
Okay. Here goes the soul baring post.
So I'm pretty solidly deaf. Yet, I play melodeon because:
- I love the sound of the instrument- yes, I can hear it!
- it's a challenge
- I thoroughly enjoy trad music played on it
- it's fun
I love to share about this music and my experience because I love this instrument and the music it is associated with. And, as fairly deaf and not very good, but well-seasoned musician (I've been playing music in a flailing manner for 45 years now, amateur like), If I post on the beginner forums, I'm honestly not a beginner, and feel silly doing so, because it takes away from the awesome efforts of true beginners, who are putting in work and making real musical progress! And yet I feel like when I post where the people with experience post like TotM, I just look and sound like a fool. So therein lies the question about social media. I just don't see my brand of mediocrity fitting in, and it's been crushing.
So help me folks. Help this poor deaf melodion player who kind of sucks but loves it anyway figure out the best place to post their efforts, so they can share in the joy and mediocority.
Presently, I have not played for two months because I feel so discouraged, and that is not a good thing. It's too cold outside to play for the squirrels.
The deeper question is that of music and sharing. Do we play for ourselves, or do we play for each other? It's fun to learn and play on my own, but I get totally jazzed when someone says, "hey! That sounded cool!"
Where to you find that balance? What's all this to you?
Peace and good health, and hoping for some inspiration.
-
If I were you I would just start a new thread on Recordings and Videos called Blake's Tunes and post up some videos. People here are interested and mostly supportive (ignoring the phantom YouTube downvoter).
Just be careful I did that and am now up to tune 524 :)
-
That's an interesting idea, and I will consider. Thank you, Lester. I am subscribed to your channel and enjoy your renditions very much! They have a decipherable clarity that someone at my level finds so helpful!
-
(ignoring the phantom YouTube downvoter)
I have noticed this! LOL. Someone needs to find a squeezebox to play!
-
The deeper question is that of music and sharing. Do we play for ourselves, or do we play for each other? It's fun to learn and play on my own, but I get totally jazzed when someone says, "hey! That sounded cool!"
Back when I brought my guitar to parties, I had the rule of keeping it in its case unless somebody asks me to play something, to make sure I'm actually make the party better and not worse.
If I were you I would just start a new thread on Recordings and Videos called Blake's Tunes and post up some videos.
I think this counts as such a request, so you're in the clear :|||:
And personally, I also think that you sharing your playing will make the melnet party better!
-
If you call it Blake and friends it might not be such a lonely place.
-
I totally understand the not picking it up cycle. Partly because of busy teaching life but also because who needs another tune in the same old key. I've plateaued whilst others have accelerated, but that's fine. I didn't take it up to stay in the fast lane.
I'm not worried, I know I'll always pick it up again. For a long time it was the escapism of writing simple tunes that kept me playing, then writing countermelodies - and I guess we all need projects to make us play or do anything.
Some people collect tunes, some catalogue their work, some set new challenges with bigger instruments, or learning to restore boxes.
On the other hand some people find a routine really helps - pick the box up at 10am with a coffee etc.
You play GC I think? Maybe some online duets to go with your Blake's thread. You only need 6 others to have a throw back sci-fi show name for your thread. Let me know if you fancy a collaboration on a tune or two. I can manage the editing this end, unless you fancy making that your new project?
Best of luck with finding your mojo.
-
If I post on the beginner forums, I'm honestly not a beginner, and feel silly doing so, because it takes away from the awesome efforts of true beginners, who are putting in work and making real musical progress! And yet I feel like when I post where the people with experience post like TotM, I just look and sound like a fool.
I'm sorry you feel like that, because you don't come across that way at all. First, it's quite easy to tell the difference between somebody who is making an effort to play as well as they can and somebody who really doesn't care. Second, your enjoyment of playing is visible and infectious.
The deeper question is that of music and sharing. Do we play for ourselves, or do we play for each other? It's fun to learn and play on my own, but I get totally jazzed when someone says, "hey! That sounded cool!"
I think we quite rightly do both. It's good that you enjoy learning and playing on your own, because a musician has to devote a lot of time to practice and you'd go mad (or just stop) if you didn't enjoy it, but when you find you've created something special (on any level) out of that work, why not share it with others? That buzz when you get favourable comments from others is a real bonus. As long as you don't get addicted to it there's no harm in allowing it to be an incentive to keep going.
-
I think you are not the only one in difficulty at present. All of our normal music routes have been pulled from under our feet. Personally, I have left social media. I did not find the same interaction i was used to when i had a life, and found it was not helping me during the lockdown, always seeing people better at playing than I am, but not appearing to be enjoying themselves, and most of what i saw was not helping me, great people playing great things, but not for the general good, always appeared self serving.
Not picking the box up for 2 months is not the death of music. It is just time away, or the box gets a holiday. You have a relationship, nurture it.
I listen to a lot of music, and eventually through the fug of annoyance or music peristently knocking on my ears, the box or fiddle says to me “I could do that if you just had a go†and then i do have a go and feel a lot better.
-
That's an interesting idea, and I will consider. Thank you, Lester. I am subscribed to your channel and enjoy your renditions very much! They have a decipherable clarity that someone at my level finds so helpful!
: If you call it Blake and friends it might not be such a lonely place.
I think it is the best idea, Blake. I was expecting your version of Ljouwerter skots. You promised in October 2020. That can be the first one of a great thread. Good luck!
Janneke
-
“I just feel and sound like a foolâ€.
No you don’t!!!!
Whatever level you are at there will be many players who are less skilled than you, as well as those who are better.
Ask yourself ‘What is the worst that can happen if I post a video?â€
Most of mine attract very little attention. I get occasional comments most of which are very supportive which is lovely.
So my advice is to go ahead and post your videos!!
Good luck and very best wishes!
-
Hi Blake.
Firstly, you're a much better player than you're telling yourself.
I probably wouldn't be picking my box up if it wasn't for Tune and Theme of the Month and a fortnightly Zoom session with a few friends which forces us to perform solo.
ToTM is for anyone of any level to share their efforts with other Melnetters. I try and post something most months but know at the same time that someone will post a better played/arranged/filmed/sounding vid than mine! I've heard a saying that goes 'there will always be someone who's twice as good as you and they'll always be half your age!'.
I agree with you and Eggy that one of the nicest things is to play something and for someone/anyone to say they liked it. We play a very niche type of music which will never appeal to a mass audience but I can always be pretty sure that if someone on here makes a comment it will be friendly. As Lester says, there's always the facility here to post your own things if ToTm doesn't appeal.
I suppose I'm saying that I don't (maybe can't) play just for myself - I need a performance goal. I suspect, like me, you might have started performing at an early age - the wish to keep doing it stays with you.
I think a lot of players here in the UK will have stopped playing because of the absence of live sessions but they've never been a big thing for me as I'm not the most sociable person. Saying that, I used to go to one monthly session and have been surprised how much I've enjoyed the fortnightly Zoom version which has been a big incentive to practice.
I do so hope that you won't give up something that you clearly get pleasure from.
-
Hi Blake
I totally agree with others who say that you are a far better player than you give yourself credit for. You just keep on doing what you do - I hope that this forum is one place where all the nonsense from social media can be forgotten. There's no pressure to be perfect, or pretend to be, here.
Personally I just really like to see recordings of my fellow players, and to all of you that share your playing I am grateful. I really should make more effort to make more recordings of my own but at the moment locked down at home with a lovely neighbour who has a brand new baby I am really trying to be kind - my beginner concertina playing is quite enough for them to cope with I think,
BTW, if you do take up Playandteach's suggestion of a throwback TV show bagsie I get to be Avon. For those not in the UK and/or under about 45 P&T is referring to this televisual gem (https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4mltgh) from the late '70s.
-
“I just feel and sound like a foolâ€.
No you don’t!!!!
Whatever level you are at there will be many players who are less skilled than you, as well as those who are better.
Ask yourself ‘What is the worst that can happen if I post a video?â€
Most of mine attract very little attention. I get occasional comments most of which are very supportive which is lovely.
So my advice is to go ahead and post your videos!!
Good luck and very best wishes!
I second that sentiment and I add one of my own:
It's OK to be mediocre.
Or to put it another way it's OK to be a beta musician. It's OK to have a low ceiling.
Speaking very much for myself as a melodeon player: I have learnt to play a few tunes in the last couple of years. I will learn to play a few more and maybe a bit better but I don't have the capacity to improve much more. I am OK with that.
Other people are driven much more and have prepared theselves much better to begin a new instrument and will progress. I know ten year olds who could use me to wipe the floor. I am OK with that. They use their parents to wipe the floor when they get home.
I find melnet a very encouraging place...but I completely empathise with the sentiment that after a year or so you feel you are cheating to post in begginers showcase but fall well short of the topflight postings in tune of the month. That doesn't really phase me - Tune/Theme of the month aren't about reaching a standard...they are abuot saying "This is where I am at". For some people that includes very classy videos and sound effects. For me - when I take part it's best of three as it comes out of the box. I guess I have just accepted my limitations and take part at my own level.
But there is a bit of me that wants to start a thread on the Lines of "Desperadoes Corner" or "Mediocrity of the month".
Given the massive numbers of boxes that Kligenthal manufactured in the late 19th century - many of them indubitably mediocre it isn't unreasonable to think that theer must have been very many mediocre melodeon players. Perhaps - as Jimmy Shand recalled of his own upbringing in a Fife pit village - mainly playing hymn tunes at the fireside on a Sunday night, doubtless with the rest of the family singing along.
-
BTW, if you do take up Playandteach's suggestion of a throwback TV show bagsie I get to be Avon. For those not in the UK and/or under about 45 P&T is referring to this televisual gem (https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4mltgh) from the late '70s.
I would have said you were more Servalan (:)
-
BTW, if you do take up Playandteach's suggestion of a throwback TV show bagsie I get to be Avon. For those not in the UK and/or under about 45 P&T is referring to this televisual gem (https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4mltgh) from the late '70s.
I would have said you were more Servalan (:)
Brave Bailey, Brave. Mind you I once had a domain controller called Servalan, on the grounds that it did.
-
BTW, if you do take up Playandteach's suggestion of a throwback TV show bagsie I get to be Avon. For those not in the UK and/or under about 45 P&T is referring to this televisual gem (https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4mltgh) from the late '70s.
I would have said you were more Servalan (:)
Brave Bailey, Brave. Mind you I once had a domain controller called Servalan, on the grounds that it did.
It's easier to say these things when the worst anyone can do to you for many months is give you a thumbs down on Youtube. So..... late 1970's .....that would be P&T reliving adolescence, Helena childhood and Lester middle age.
Edited to add:
- I'll get my coat. And Deo says I'm on my own unless I come back with cheesy chips.
-
Blake, do your thing here. We love you.
Melnet = unconditional love for the melodeon and its players.
No thumbs up/thumbs down, snide comments, trends, "followers", etc. etc.
Think of it like this fellow:
-
Blake, do your thing here. We love you.
Melnet = unconditional love for the melodeon and its players.
No thumbs up/thumbs down, snide comments, trends, "followers", etc. etc.
Think of it like this fellow:
Well said that man!
-
Oh my goodness!
I certainly didn't expect this kind of upwelling of support. I'm deeply moved and truly inspired to continue on my
squeezy journey.
You folks picked up on so much-you're an insightful bunch. And, I learned about Blake's 7 (Way cool!)
The pandemic has in large part isolated communal musicians- and others as well.
I have tried hard to embrace the solitude, but often it stings, and I get pangs for interaction, sharing, feedback. I'm surely not alone in this. I also left FB social media. The politics in the US turned it into a source of deep cultural inflammation.
I will start a thread for people to post their good efforts for encouragement and constructive support. I have received some fantastic comments about bellows control, tempo, and phrasing when I have posted.
Thank you again for the tremendous encouragement. I wouldn't have posted like that had I not been in a real funk, and your responsiveness and support bears weight. I'll get back to it today!
-
👍 🙂
-
And Blake, I notice you are in Pennsylvania.
It could be worse! (i.e. Georgia)
:Ph
-
And Blake, I notice you are in Pennsylvania.
It could be worse! (i.e. Georgia)
:Ph
lol. I was hoping at least there would be an Appalachian folk scene here. And unfortunately, it's only the scenes that I make which qualify.
-
Just wanted to say hello -- I'm in Maine now, but grew up and lived much of my life in Ohio and New York, so on average, am also from Pennsylvania. I recall reading a while back that you were collecting old Hohners to dissect and learn to repair them, and I felt some kinship because that's also how I have spent lockdown. (I'm still neck deep in accordions, and though my partner and I share a tiny 3-room apartment, she has graciously accepted that the kitchen is now half accordion workshop.) I also noticed you were interested in some creative experiments (two treble ends? How's that going?) and would sometimes chime in to offer spare parts... so you are a good egg in my book.
I'm also not quite a beginner anymore (maybe) and not an expert either (definitely). We're all learners, hopefully. There's that famous quote from Pablo Casals, about why he practiced Bach daily in his later years -- "I think I'm making progress." (I suspect this comes to mind because Theo mentioned it just the other day in another thread.)
I don't know if it counts as Appalachian music, but I play a bit of what gets called "Old Time" where I'm from.
-
I went through this in 1997 when after playing for over 20 years I stopped playing altogether for various reasons. I didn't feel I had any reason to start again though occasionally I'd try.
Just over 2 years ago I was persuaded to join a session and found I could almost fit in.
Since then I have rediscovered a lot of.my enthusiasm and found fettling, tuning and rebuilding old instruments so rewarding that I wish I'd tried it ages ago.
Then covid hit.
I am relearning my playing now in a more dedicated way. A 2.6 row instrument found its way to me via an extraordinary act of kindness and I have taken to it in a way really didn't expect.
So I can see that like you I don't know where I fit. I have played for years but I feel like a beginner. I am constantly disappointed with my playing but I can hear a little progress.
The biggest problem is my confidence is shot. I used to be quite happy.leading a session, but I get into a complete funk when it's my turn to even just choose a tune and play the first few bars. YouTube is a new thing to me but I need 20 or 30 takes to get through a tune without grinding to a halt.
Melnet has been a lifeline in these times and some members have been a far greater support than they realise. I suspect there are many members in a similar position.
By the way and on a lighter note, I post mostly in my phone and the various members signature pictures take a strange look when reduced so small. I had always thought yours was rather like jack Nicholson in the shining, but on enlarging it I see you are quite.....normal.
-
... yours was rather like jack Nicholson in the shining, but on enlarging it I see you are quite.....normal.
OMG... I am laughing so hard! I can indeed see that! I have another picture where I look like a young Marlon Brando.
I went through a stint of voluntary quasi-homelessness (to save money to build a house), and didn't play much for 18 months. Now my house is built and I am happy to have time to play again. I'm surprised this funk has interrupted my fun, but I'll get back to it tonight. I was playing around with a couple tunes tonight, and it felt good. :)
-
Most of us pay ourselves on the back for restoring an instrument or having it restored by someone else. Building a house is (my daughter and I are long time Grand Design addicts) a supposedly very stressful period.
Hope you have a nice spot in it to play.
-
Just wanted to say hello -- I'm in Maine now, but grew up and lived much of my life in Ohio and New York, so on average, am also from Pennsylvania. I recall reading a while back that you were collecting old Hohners to dissect and learn to repair them, and I felt some kinship because that's also how I have spent lockdown. (I'm still neck deep in accordions, and though my partner and I share a tiny 3-room apartment, she has graciously accepted that the kitchen is now half accordion workshop.) I also noticed you were interested in some creative experiments (two treble ends? How's that going?) and would sometimes chime in to offer spare parts... so you are a good egg in my book.
I'm also not quite a beginner anymore (maybe) and not an expert either (definitely). We're all learners, hopefully. There's that famous quote from Pablo Casals, about why he practiced Bach daily in his later years -- "I think I'm making progress." (I suspect this comes to mind because Theo mentioned it just the other day in another thread.)
Your partner is a sensible person. Perhaps the other half of the kitchen table will serve for their hurdy-gurdy project! ;) I hope to get back to my accordion repair soon. I've gotten very good at taking them apart! I also would like to build one of those foot pedal bass squeezers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZRL8Ftv2J4 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZRL8Ftv2J4)
All in good time! Give a heads up if you ever head south!
-
Anyone tackling Bach cello suites on the melodeon is doing all right in my book!
I think many musicians are very prone to excessive self-criticism and envy of other musicians. We spend so much time inwardly focused on our own practice, and are painfully aware of the weeks or months it takes us to make progress, and it's easy to watch other musicians play something seemingly effortlessly and seethe with envy at their apparent unnatural talent (forgetting that they almost certainly put in the same hard work). With YouTube it can be even worse, since we don't see the 50 flubbed takes before the keeper.
-
I also would like to build one of those foot pedal bass squeezers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZRL8Ftv2J4 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZRL8Ftv2J4)
I love that clip. Gorgeous sound and running repairs ;D
-
[quote author=Gonk link=topic=26546.msg317507#msg317507 date=1611435959
Your partner is a sensible person. Perhaps the other half of the kitchen table will serve for their hurdy-gurdy project! ;) I hope to get back to my accordion repair soon. I've gotten very good at taking them apart! I also would like to build one of those foot pedal bass squeezers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZRL8Ftv2J4 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZRL8Ftv2J4)
Likewise! I have made drawings, and have a sackful of suitable reeds. Just need to find the time.
Dave
-
The deeper question is that of music and sharing. Do we play for ourselves, or do we play for each other? It's fun to learn and play on my own, but I get totally jazzed when someone says, "hey! That sounded cool!"
Where to you find that balance? What's all this to you?
Peace and good health, and hoping for some inspiration.
Hi Blake - thank you so much for starting this thread, and everyone who has responded to it. I have been wanting to post something about being dispirited and discouraged but every time I tried, it just sounded whiny.....
I too sit in the ‘okay but not great’ group, a late starter to diato and I know that I am not going to suddenly (or ever) become a good player. This past year has been hard, I usually play in a group for traditional dances and with friends for regular sessions. That has all stopped for now.
One of my resolutions during confinement and curfew - I live in France - has been to accept whatever I have become without self-criticism/analysis. We are living in very strange times; so what if I don’t practice music much, so what if I have become a bit of a lazy slob.....etc.
In the meantime, a section in this forum for those of us with confidence and motivation problems would be good
Maggie :|||:
-
Hi Blake,
Thought I'd weigh in with my thrupence worth. I've been playing 20 years intermittently, always alone and I still play like a newbie. The really important thing is not what others may think but what playing does for you. The feeling of satisfaction when you get to grips with a dauntingly difficult tune is fabulous even if it's jerky and not fit to perform in public.
I have a teflon memory and take decades to learn simple things, all signs of a misspent youth I guess but its great to have this hobby that keeps me pushing on.
Anyway, as others on here have stated this is a supportive and non judgemental community, keep the faith, practice often and you'll eventually feel the benefit.
Paul :||:
-
There are some wonderful players here.
I’m not one of them!
I don’t care as I’m not in competition with anyone.
I don’t play box because I’m good at it....I play because I like it! (Saw this on a t-shirt about banjos but it seemed apt).
Sometimes I feel like sharing my efforts....look at my videos....I don’t wait till it’s perfect...I strongly believe in a ‘warts and all’ approach...mine are full of fluffs and mistakes. Why?
1) So far I’ve had nothing but friendly encouraging feedback here and much of it has informed my playing. (Thanks folks!)
2) If others see it’s ok not to be perfect, then maybe they will be happy not being perfect too!
3) Nobody tends to describe themselves as perfect! We are all on a journey of improvement....even the best players here would agree I think!
Playing any instrument is most of all, FUN!!! If you have fun sometimes playing for yourself then do so. If you have fun sharing, then do so. If it doesn’t feel like fun then don’t do it!
Finally, it is often not productive to overthink things. Just go with the flow, it is what it is and you’ll get nothing but support here if you choose to share.
FYI...I’ve only been playing since October so probably don’t have much wise advice about boxes but as an experienced musician in other genres I have learned over time not to give a ********* about how good or not I am!
-
I don't look forward to being able to have lunch with my friend because of how good the food will be. I mean OK maybe a little but, moving on from the metaphor, while music exercises me creatively and broadens/deepens my experience of the world, I want to add other people to the equation not so they can tell me how good mine is, but so I can form social connections with them and have conversations and enjoy being with/hanging out with other people.
So, don't assume that, even if you genuinely feel like what you're doing is mediocre, that it is 'wrong' to be present and to be part of the conversation and the community.
-
Anyone tackling Bach cello suites on the melodeon is doing all right in my book!
I think many musicians are very prone to excessive self-criticism and envy of other musicians. We spend so much time inwardly focused on our own practice, and are painfully aware of the weeks or months it takes us to make progress, and it's easy to watch other musicians play something seemingly effortlessly and seethe with envy at their apparent unnatural talent (forgetting that they almost certainly put in the same hard work). With YouTube it can be even worse, since we don't see the 50 flubbed takes before the keeper.
^^^ You NAILED it! And thanks for the kindness about the Bach. It sounds better on my melodeon than when I butchered it on the cello! lol
-
I want to add other people to the equation...
I think you certainly do this with your enriched music theory videos and posts, Gena. For those that can grasp your contributions (not usually me) I think they lend a robust validity to these peculiarly configured instruments. For those that don't grasp them, they are interesting learning opportunities!
-
I am quite lost in admiration.
My own hardest time was a slightly mangled left shoulder (collar bone, blade, loads of ribs) in 2003. In the end playing my melodeon was really good physio, and the dislocation on other side is a handy hook for the strap 😉 I did move to lighter instruments as a result, (the driver was insured 🙂).
Yes, it’s one of my better ways of self expression. 😃 Emotionally that is, my technique is lacking
-
... a section in this forum for those of us with confidence and motivation problems would be good
Well, Maggie, thank you. It seems based on this and several other replies that I'm not alone in the unexpected impasses that this pandemic poses to melodeonship!
As this is not only my challenge, How about a more generic thread name for those needing inspiration and coddling.
How does this sound? Other ideas, please?
"Squeeze me: Melodeonist Advocacy and Support."
-
I'm not alone in the unexpected impasses that this pandemic poses to melodeonship!
Sounds like a thread for melodeon-based poetry (possibly anglo-saxon alliterative).
-
Anyone tackling Bach cello suites on the melodeon is doing all right in my book!
..thanks for the kindness about the Bach.
Blake, I haven't heard you play. I would like to hear the above mentioned piece. Any link?
-
Blake, I haven't heard you play. I would like to hear the above mentioned piece. Any link?
Here ya go! Just a once through part A, but it's a start!
https://youtu.be/DRDCMrToQrE (https://youtu.be/DRDCMrToQrE)
-
Well done. I like it.