Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Tongle on January 24, 2021, 02:15:08 PM
-
Phew!
I almost bid on a very nice Hohner Merlin II on eBay.
It was tempting because it had a two button row with the accidentals I’ve been looking for.
It went for £540 which was good however......
I was so close to buying a box pretty much like the one I already have.
So what I need is a proper plan. I love my Hohner Morgane and have only been playing since October.
What would be the suggested next kind of box to buy once I’ve saved my pennies? Is there a logical progression of boxes to buy?
I play the usual Tuneworks stuff at the moment and am just getting to grips with playing (you can find my latest on the FB page).
If I do buy another box I want to make sure it’s a wise and sensible decision rather than a knee jerk eBay purchase.
Any thoughts welcome!
-
I found as my playing progressed, I ended up taking different musical journeys to what I thought I would do. I followed my nose along tune paths that I pretty much still follow now.
I assumed at the start that I'd go to a 2.5row 12 bass box as that was 'better' but after listening to others playing music I liked, I simply went from a small sized Tommy to a larger sized Hascy as it had a fuller sound.
I realised I was reasonably content playing in the home keys of D, G and their relative minors, and my local session was definitely DG Land.
If you've only been playing since October, that really isn't very long!
Keep at it and follow your nose along playing the tunes you enjoy.
If you start to really find you want to play in other non DG keys, or you start to find your current box starting to hold you back, then start to explore other melodeons.
Also, hopefully during the year things will ease and you could get to local sessions, meet Morris musicians, essentially get out there and see what others are playing. Usually a quick chat will find you trying other melodeons, some you won't like, others will have your tongue hanging out for it's sound or playability. Then you gather ideas on what the next box will be.
In the meantime, keep growing the melodeon fund !
-
What would be the suggested next kind of box to buy once I’ve saved my pennies? Is there a logical progression of boxes to buy?
In a word, no.
Once you have played your first box for a while, you discover what you want out of a box that your current one does not have. It might be
- You keep wanting to play tunes needing chords or accidentals that your current one doesn't have.
- You are playing for a morris team or similar outdoors and your current one simply isn't loud enough (this happened to me. "we can't hear you. get an Oakwood!" I did and have never regretted it.)
- You want a box in different home keys for any of several reasons (playing with others, singing songs in those keys, the sound.)
- You try someone else's box and fall in love with the sound or playability and want one like it. The could be anything from a posh Castagnari to a Hohner one-row.
- You want a box that is responsive when played quietly (I needed this for song accompaniments: Saltarelle, then Dino Baffetti/Oakwood.)
- You want the versatility of three voices individually selectable.
- Your current box is too heavy and you want something lighter, even if it has fewer buttons or voices.
That's not an exhaustive list. You'll know what you want when it happens!
PS I'm pleased to see that Thrupenny Bit more or less agrees with me!
-
Yes indeed Anahata agree wholeheartedly.
It's a journey I've been on as I'm sure we all have, and continental along it still...
-
To be honest I take the view that if I get a box for a decent price, i.e. one where I would not lose money if it doesn't work out for me and I want to move it on then all is well. I view it as merely keeping a portion of my cash in wood and bellows form.
Basically you never really own a melodeon, you just rent them from the universe for a while before sending them on their way*.
*or at least that's my excuse.
-
I'd say different key and/or # of voices...or just wait until the next box finds YOU.
-
Dick has a good point.
At a festival, a music stall, in a pub chatting to friends, somewhere you will have a quick go on something and... you really can't let it go.
That's the next one!
-
I've tried two boxes that I fell in love with. But could afford neither. But the good news is that it kept me from buying others that didn't make me smile. The 2 boxes were both for sale by Pete from Acorninstruments who advertises here on this forum. There were a Trilly and a 1914 - both GC of course for me.
They sounded fantastic, but perhaps because I have too many other hobbies, I just don't have the right sort of money to throw at melodeons.
I've bought other boxes, spend some money on them and sold for pretty much what I paid for, minus the work costs - but that's ok with me. I've learnt something by having them.
However I think you are right not to buy the same thing again. I have 3 pretty much identical bikes, all aluminium, all hydraulic disc brakes. Now, if I'd only had 2, then one of them could have been twice the price - fancy light carbon, maybe.
-
If I’d have seen the Merlin first I may have have bought it.
Having said that, at that point in time, I had no idea what I was looking for and thankfully Les helped me out by becoming someone I felt I could trust.
Buying blind from eBay is often not the best idea. I feel I need to become much more educated in the world of Melodeons before committing more cash to it.
It’s just so damn tempting. I do feel as if the accidentals would have been good but I need to be patient. I’ve seen plenty of players go through a whole evening on one box and manage quite well. Maybe learning how to manage without the accidentals is a valuable skill in itself.
Thanks as always for taking the time to post. It really is very much appreciated. Now time to go play some tunes!
-
Aren't your first button on each row accidentals?
-
Un
Aren't your first button on each row accidentals?
Unfortunately no. They are low notes.
The one I nearly bid for had bo5 low notes and accidentals which would have been great.
-
UnAren't your first button on each row accidentals?
Unfortunately no. They are low notes.
The one I nearly bid for had bo5 low notes and accidentals which would have been great.
Relatively easy to change, though.
-
I'm not really a fan of either the Morgane or the Merlin but if I was then in this position I'd probably have taken a punt on the Merlin at that price and then released the Morgane into the ether to find a new home.
It all evens out in the end*. Like the time I sold my beloved Nuage to fund a Loffet. Missed the Nuage, sold the Loffet and bought another Nuage. Or the time I sold my Giordy to fund my first anglo and have somehow ended up with another Giordy (thanks Julian S) and two anglos.
*and other excuses.
-
That sounds like the Ouroboros of melodeon gods.
-
I'm not really a fan of either the Morgane or the Merlin but if I was then in this position I'd probably have taken a punt on the Merlin at that price and then released the Morgane into the ether to find a new home.
It all evens out in the end*. Like the time I sold my beloved Nuage to fund a Loffet. Missed the Nuage, sold the Loffet and bought another Nuage. Or the time I sold my Giordy to fund my first anglo and have somehow ended up with another Giordy (thanks Julian S) and two anglos.
*and other excuses.
I just wonder how many boxes Helena has at the moment.....I remember a time (February 2019) when nine boxes seemed a hilariously large number for one person to own (for want of a better word). I dare not count mine at the moment....OK some have been bought in the interests of research, others to restore. One or two I have even bought to play. The OP should be warned melodeons don't actually breed....but they have a propensity to accumulate.
In fairness to me I wanted to learn about old boxes and when you have to travel a hundred mies to get to the nearest populatin centre of more than 5,000 people the cheapest way is to buy specimens on ebay. Sad but true. If you don't have that excuse for goodness sake stick with the one you have got at least until sessions start again and you can meet people and try their boxes out.
-
I just wonder how many boxes Helena has at the moment.....I remember a time (February 2019) when nine boxes seemed a hilariously large number for one person to own (for want of a better word).
Still Nine-Box Nellie (ish).
-
Basically you never really own a melodeon, you just rent them from the universe for a while before sending them on their way*.
;D
Not sure it's literally true but the late Ciaran Carson claimed the Irish for "my flute" - "an fliuit s'agamsa" - translated as "the flute which is at me."
-
Basically you never really own a melodeon, you just rent them from the universe for a while before sending them on their way*.
[/quote]
Quite reassuring really, and true. Don’t know about flutes.
-
What would be the suggested next kind of box to buy once I’ve saved my pennies?
B/C or C#/D. You will never be stuck for an accidental note again!
If I do buy another box I want to make sure it’s a wise and sensible decision
See above.
-
Tongle, have you encountered a tune where you've needed an accidental and therefore couldn't play said tune?
It obviously depends on the tunes you want to play and you might well have already encountered a tune you can't currently play as you don't have the notes, but there's a lot out there that don't stray off the home keys of a DG box.
Just saying...
-
As others have said, there is absolutely no agreed and logical progression.
I've said before that the only box I had for about 30 years was a D/G pokerwork with low notes! So I'd say there's definitely no rush!
The most important acquisition for me has been my Hohner Pressed Wood, commissioned from Mike Rowbotham. Two reasons - I love the tone and level of swing in the tuning and because I followed the suggestion seen on here to get fourth button start, Anahata scale. I also asked Mike to give me neutral (thirdless) chords on B and A which makes some tunes a lot more accessible.
-
Tongle, have you encountered a tune where you've needed an accidental and therefore couldn't play said tune?
It obviously depends on the tunes you want to play and you might well have already encountered a tune you can't currently play as you don't have the notes, but there's a lot out there that don't stray off the home keys of a DG box.
Just saying...
I’ve found one song so far whose name escape me at the moment which goes into Gm briefly.
I’m wondering if a B/C box would be a good addition eventually? I assume it is rather a different technique in many ways but at least you’d have all the notes (as someone suggested earlier).
-
I'm not really a fan of either the Morgane or the Merlin but if I was then in this position I'd probably have taken a punt on the Merlin at that price and then released the Morgane into the ether to find a new home.
It all evens out in the end*. Like the time I sold my beloved Nuage to fund a Loffet. Missed the Nuage, sold the Loffet and bought another Nuage. Or the time I sold my Giordy to fund my first anglo and have somehow ended up with another Giordy (thanks Julian S) and two anglos.
*and other excuses.
Given my budget at the time I thought the Morgane was a good beginner box. I’ve only ever played one other briefly, a Sandpiper, so don’t really have a point of reference.
I’d be genuinely interested in knowing what the good/bad points about the Morgane are.
-
Tongle, be aware a BC system doesn't function the same as a fourth apart system such as a DG.
I.e. DG, AD, CF, BbEb all work the same.
By that I mean if you play a tune on a DG, you can pick up any of those, press the same buttons in the same order and the tune comes out but in the other key.
That is not the same for a BC, they work in a totally different way so you would learn a new system.
That might be or might not be a problem, but just be aware it is different.
-
unless you want to play only in B and C 'on the row' which works jsut the same as on a DG.!
However adding a BC is not difficult as coming from a DG or whatever you are used to having 2 notes per button and on a BC the scale of G is all C row exept for one note on the B row. D needs 2 notes on B row, A 3, etc. so its just a question of getting the hang of a different push pull sequence /scale.
60 years ago me and a mate bought hohner double ray BC boxes ( DG not being around) we played entirely on the row in B and C until almost by accident that starting on the G button would almost provide a scale but not quite! A bit of farting about led to the discovery that the 'missing' note was on t'other row. etc etc
I play both systems and have no problem playing the same tunes on both . The advantage of the DG for dance accompanyment is its ability to provide rhythmic bass accompaniment which is lacking on an 8 bass BC. However the rare souble ray with 12 stradella ( piano accordion) bass is , to me, a bigh improvement.
the two systems are completely different - but only just!
george
-
My interest in Early 20th century Scottish boxes has resulted in a collection of C/C#, and as a result I have no imagineable need for a C/F box.
-
To be honest I take the view that if I get a box for a decent price, i.e. one where I would not lose money if it doesn't work out for me and I want to move it on then all is well. I view it as merely keeping a portion of my cash in wood and bellows form.
Basically you never really own a melodeon, you just rent them from the universe for a while before sending them on their way*.
*or at least that's my excuse.
I love this.
-
quote author=george garside link=topic=26554.msg317737#msg317737 date=1611661999]
[
I play both systems and have no problem playing the same tunes on both . The advantage of the DG for dance accompanyment is its ability to provide rhythmic bass accompaniment which is lacking on an 8 bass BC. However the rare souble ray with 12 stradella ( piano accordion) bass is , to me, a big improvement.[/quote.]
I know the heavy grunting bass so many players like cannot be achieved on the BC 8 bass but is it possible to get bye with just giving them a quick tap?
The basses, that is ::)
-
I neither like nor play the 'heavy grunting' style of bass on a DG. I tap the buttons very lightly so as to provide a light um pa or whatever rhtythm in the background which minimises any 'dischords' but assists with timing particularly if playing for dancing - synchronise the bass with the feet of the dancers -
On an 8 bass semkitone box its more a question of using a bass /chord here and there to enhance the harmony' i am not expert at Irish trad but some brilliant players use very little bass and others a bit more
george
-
So after much temptation I’ve settled nicely back into focusing on D/G for now.
I really wish I had bid for the Hohner Merlin with the accidental two button row though and am keeping an eye out should one appear. I can then let my original Hohner go off in to the ether (I loved that too!).
I can see myself with a B/C box at some point in the future though. It would be another challenge I’m sure but not quite so much as starting completely from scratch as I have with the Hohner. I imagine some skills are transferable like when I went from guitar to mandolin to bouzouki!
-
Not sure it's literally true but the late Ciaran Carson claimed the Irish for "my flute" - "an fliuit s'agamsa" - translated as "the flute which is at me."
No, this is a perfectly literal translation - the only change I'd make is the italics on "me", rather than "at" (the -sa suffix is an emphatic 'me'). Irish and Gaelic don't express ownership as we do in English: something can be at you, or to emphasise ownership, it can be with you. And I can talk about my hat and my knee and my mother, but it would be a bit odd to talk about my boat.
-
Look, music is music. Many of us play more than one instrument. I was rather reluctantly and unsuccessfully obliged to learn violin and piano. The first musical instrument I bought off my own bat was a mouthorgan. Then a ukulele, a guitar, banjo, more guitars. Finally came to a melodeon about 20 years ago. Very happily squeezing away on that until I discovered the limits of the diatonic instrument were more than I could live with. Tried a G/C/Acc with 12 basses, but still found the convolutions necessary for chromaticism beyond my senescent brain. Finally, rather diffidently, got a continental button accordion, and now find that there are all the accidentals and keys I could wish for in a fairly simple system. Also stradella bass which offers oodles of various harmonies.
Still playing all the other instruments, but concentrating on getting up to speed on the CBA. It’s really very personal. One man’s vegeburger etc.