Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Gonk on January 28, 2021, 03:29:13 PM
-
I've been reading about ways the best reedmakers have approached shaping the tongue. "Bombata" reeds, as well as reeds finished by the maker "E. Carloni," have a domed top. This appears to be universally understood as a positive feature, and one that is too time consuming for mass-market reeds.
When I'm removing enough metal to go from A=435 to A=440, as I often find myself doing, I think about this a bit, and I try to protect the center line of the reed a bit more, while sloping the sides just a little. Without knowing quite why, I imagine it helps keep the "spine" of the metal strong, even when removing mass. I associate hardness of reed material with strong tone and quick response, so this makes some sense to me, but it might be spurious logic.
I'm curious about the opinions here. Is this a worthwhile effort? Is it actually counterproductive?
And as separate question: in general, I feel confident about my filing technique, but I'm always open to improving it through feedback. The things I do are to keep my strokes mostly with the direction of the reed, while holding the file at a 45 degree angle. I file the bottom or top 1/5 to 1/3 of the reed, and aim for a smooth gradient from the belly to the tip when working the top. I treat the profile of the tip with care. Files are Vallorbe, mostly #2, a riffler, and a #1 and #3 for low and high reeds. (And fine sandpaper for the squeakers.)
-
You seem to be on the right lines. I have an open mind about the bombata shaping. I’m not sure if the shaping contributes to the performance of the reed or if it’s more an sign that utmost care has been taken with all aspects of making the reed. In theory it could be an advantage in having the narrowest edge so that the reed opens and closes the window as cleanly as possible.
-
Oh, that's a really interesting take, and also makes sense. So the duller or more square-cut the edge, the more delay it would add to the bottom of the "airflow over time" sine wave - a infinitesimal flat moment. I can imagine that having more effect with a thick reed. It does seem minute, but to be fair, our ears do pick up very minute fluctuations in the shape of a wave, and that can define timbre...
-
I have bombata reeds in the one row I built and love the sound also the responsiveness:)
When I got it back from tuning from the Button box I was surprised that the scratches were spread out more and possibly smaller in size. Anyway the appearance seemed like there was more of them.
So I would agree that your on the right track.
-
When I got it back from tuning from the Button box I was surprised that the scratches were spread out more and possibly smaller in size. Anyway the appearance seemed like there was more of them.
I’m curious to see what you’re describing. Could you post a photo?
-
I remember Claudio Binci telling me once that he saw no benefit in "bombare" or "tirare" his reeds. He claimed it would do more damage than anything else.
-
I’d be interested to see pictures of these bombata reeds and also a photo of your filed reeds.
-
...fine sandpaper for the squeakers.
Squeakers?
-
"Squeakers?"
Probably of no interest to you, Pearse. They're the top end, high, reeds on a D/G; I think the dogs hear them OK!
-
Of course. Sláinte.