Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Owen Woods on October 12, 2009, 03:55:58 PM

Title: A rather stupid question
Post by: Owen Woods on October 12, 2009, 03:55:58 PM
Even for me :P

I have heard people talk about "fettling" on here and elsewhere. Now the word fettling puts me in mind of horses, presumably because it is close to "fetlock". I was wondering what fettling entails and how one would go about doing it and how one would know whether it needed to be done.

At the moment I'm presuming that fettling means "doing stuff that isn't tuning". So a plain service or set-up on a woodwind instrument.
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Lester on October 12, 2009, 04:01:34 PM
A fettler is is someone whose job it is to sand and grind small imperfections from metal and ceramic castings.

In more general usage it is exactly what you said.

Now don't start me on the downgrading of the job of Bodger to what it now means from the fine craft workers of the Chilterns whence the term sprang.   :-[
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: waltzman on October 12, 2009, 06:06:58 PM
Yes, I never knew fettle was a verb until I starting reading this forum.  On this side of the pond fettle is a noun.  Typical usage would be to say something is in 'fine fettle' meaning good condition.
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Andy in Vermont on October 12, 2009, 06:41:22 PM
Yes, I never knew fettle was a verb until I starting reading this forum.  On this side of the pond fettle is a noun.  Typical usage would be to say something is in 'fine fettle' meaning good condition.

Side of the pond isn't the issue, it's 'tradesman' vocabulary, and it comes up regarding tools -- "to fettle an old handplane"; "I spent an hour fettling my saws," etc. 
Andy, in Yankee territory
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Bob Ellis on October 12, 2009, 07:52:30 PM
In Yorkshire Dales dialect (and in some other regional dialects) the verb 'to fettle' means to refurbish, service or put right. Therefore something that is 'in fine fettle' has already been treated in this way and is therefore in good working order. A lot of Dales dialect comes from Old Norse and when I was in Norway a few years ago I found myself comparing Dales dialect words with words in the modern Norwegian language (which I don't speak). However, friends told me that there is a similar word to 'fettle' in Norwegian with a similar meaning.
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 12, 2009, 08:29:48 PM
See the attached 1975 record cover "Very Canny" by the group Canny Fettle of Newcastle upon Tyne. The dialect there is 'Geordie' but you'll hear the same words in Teeside and parts of Yorkshire. Both the words 'canny' and 'fettle' are still in common usage in Newcastle

Canny prob from Scotland but cf the Norse kennen to know - knowledgeable, wise, shrewd
Fettle  from middle English/ middle high german fetlen - to make ready, good, sound ... eg

 He's a canny lad = fine young man
 I'll soon fettle that = I'll soon fix that
 I'm in fine fettle  = I'm in good healt, here as a noun
 
So the group's name translates to something like 'fit in mind and body'  'in good spirits'. Fettle applied to a melodeon = "to put to rights" or "make it work properly" ... Yes Bob, when I learned Dutch back in the 70's I was struck by the close similarity of many Geordie words.

Remember The Teesside Fettlers?
[edit] Whoops for that omission! As for the verb/noun thing - English has always been very flexible in this respect. See for example this 'edit' ;)
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: rees on October 12, 2009, 09:40:50 PM
................... and then there's grindling, to grindle, to have grindled 
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: george garside on October 12, 2009, 10:24:35 PM
................... and then there's grindling, to grindle, to have grindled 

does one do this   horizontally without ones clothes on!

george ;D
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on October 12, 2009, 11:09:13 PM
Remember The Teesside Fettlers?  ;D
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: rees on October 13, 2009, 12:08:31 AM
.............aye, and the Gungrog Grindlers!
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: waltzman on October 13, 2009, 12:17:11 AM
Yes, I never knew fettle was a verb until I starting reading this forum.  On this side of the pond fettle is a noun.  Typical usage would be to say something is in 'fine fettle' meaning good condition.

Side of the pond isn't the issue, it's 'tradesman' vocabulary, and it comes up regarding tools -- "to fettle an old handplane"; "I spent an hour fettling my saws," etc. 
Andy, in Yankee territory

Must be a yankee thing rather than a 'tradesman' thing.  I grew up in the south with lots of hand tools and a 'we fix anything' attitude from my father and I never heard of anyone fettling a tool or anything else.
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Bill Young on October 13, 2009, 08:25:57 AM
The verb, to "fettle", is in Chambers dictionary, the Scots' preferred dictionary of English. Here are their definitions. (http://www.chambersharrap.co.uk/chambers/features/chref/chref.py/main?query=fettle&title=21st) The sense of "putting something right" I've always known; the bits about ceramics and furnaces are new to me. (But then, I found an entirely new (to me) meaning of "heckle" and "heckling" just a few weeks ago.)
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: triskel on October 13, 2009, 06:02:48 PM
See the attached 1975 record cover "Very Canny" by the group Canny Fettle of Newcastle upon Tyne.

That takes me back to my student days in Manchester, and they were the resident band at the local folk club - I've still got the LP.

Side of the pond isn't the issue, it's 'tradesman' vocabulary, and it comes up regarding tools -- "to fettle an old handplane"; "I spent an hour fettling my saws," etc. 
Andy, in Yankee territory

Must be a yankee thing rather than a 'tradesman' thing.  I grew up in the south with lots of hand tools and a 'we fix anything' attitude from my father and I never heard of anyone fettling a tool or anything else.

Maybe it's something that's not known south of Watford Gap, or something/somewhere, but we'd use it in the Midlands.

The verb, to "fettle", is in Chambers dictionary, the Scots' preferred dictionary of English.

Ye cannae beat Chambers!  ;)
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Owen Woods on October 13, 2009, 06:23:37 PM
Maybe it's something that's not known south of Watford Gap, or something/somewhere, but we'd use it in the Midlands.

Ah, well I am south of Watford Gap (outside of term-time at least) :D
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Andy in Vermont on October 14, 2009, 04:14:25 AM
I grew up in the south with lots of hand tools and a 'we fix anything' attitude from my father and I never heard of anyone fettling a tool or anything else.

Well, that's the thing... "we fix anything" isn't tradesman-speak -- there is a difference between a tradesman and a "jack of all trades."  (We've got lots of them here, too, and they do come in handy!)  If "fettle" (as a verb) isn't in Southern vocabulary, there is probably a historical reason for that, since it certainly came to these shores along with the artisans who pretty much ruled Philadelphia and had their run of Boston as well.  I can imagine some explanations as to why it apparently doesn't occur in the South but it would be speculation.  However, I can say for certain that I've heard the word plenty of times on the left side of the pond -- in Pennsylvania, in Baltimore, in New York, and now in Vermont.  At any rate, Webster's dictionary of American English notes fettle as a noun (as in: "in fine fettle") as well as a verb, both with origins in British English.
I think that it is a nice term to apply to accordions, by the way.  In some discussions of used boxes or new boxes that can benefit from some improvement, I would say that they require "fettling," much like a new handplane.
-Andy
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Theo on October 14, 2009, 08:53:40 AM
To 'fettle' is the ideal word to describe the process of taking an instrument and sorting out all the little niggling problems that individually might go unnoticed but together have a significant effect. 

Its looking at the whole instrument and making all the parts work in concert.  When you pick up an instrument and it all just works without fuss then its been well fettled. 

Its particularly about small adjustments requiring trial and error and checking details, then going back and checking for knock on effects elsewhere of what you have done.

Its obsessive attention to detail, its keeping at it until its right, not just till its good enough. 

Its thinking about things that can go wrong and working back to what lies behind the problem. 

Its using the appropriate materials and tools, sometimes the traditional ones, but sometimes trying new.

Its keeping an open mind and not automatically always doing things the same way that you did last time.

Its being prepared to learn from every job you work on. 


It was not a stupid question. (:)
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 14, 2009, 09:09:51 AM
To 'fettle' is the ideal word to describe the process of taking an instrument and sorting out all the little niggling problems that individually might go unnoticed but together have a significant effect. 

Its looking at the whole instrument and making all the parts work in concert.  When you pick up an instrument and it all just works without fuss then its been well fettled. 

Its particularly about small adjustments requiring trial and error and checking details, then going back and checking for knock on effects elsewhere of what you have done.

Its obsessive attention to detail, its keeping at it until its right, not just till its good enough. 

Its thinking about things that can go wrong and working back to what lies behind the problem. 

Its using the appropriate materials and tools, sometimes the traditional ones, but sometimes trying new.

Its keeping an open mind and not automatically always doing things the same way that you did last time.

Its being prepared to learn from every job you work on. 


It was not a stupid question. (:)
That is a great philosophy, Theo. Many thanks for posting it. I shall print it out and stick it on my wall.
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: ladydetemps on October 14, 2009, 09:12:19 AM

That is a great philosophy, Theo. Many thanks for posting it. I shall print it out and stick it on my wall.
It would make a great poster. :)
Its almost a poem.
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Lester on October 14, 2009, 09:22:57 AM
Theo.

I wish I had said all that, in fact I will in the future as it is a marvellous philosophy.
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Owen Woods on October 14, 2009, 01:56:43 PM
Thanks Theo! In that case I know what fettling means in the context of a woodwind instrument. I'm guessing that with a squeezebox it would be things like adjusting the mechanism, testing the resistance of springs, making sure the wax was sound, valve replacement and that kind of thing?
Title: Re: A rather stupid question
Post by: Theo on October 14, 2009, 02:18:33 PM
I'm guessing that with a squeezebox it would be things like adjusting the mechanism, testing the resistance of springs, making sure the wax was sound, valve replacement and that kind of thing?
Yes those and a number of other things.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal