Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 11, 2021, 07:45:38 AM

Title: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 11, 2021, 07:45:38 AM
I recently bought an "Eastar" brand toy accordion on Amazon in the US, for US$45.

It's a pretty standard "Chanson" as y'all call it here, 7-button diatonic with left-hand base and chord buttons. Notably, it's all plastic body, no wood in the fingerboard or whatever, and melody reedback is a solid plastic piece.

I had some "learning by doing" in terms of figuring out the best way to silence the extra reed in each double-reeded note, and had to play around because in some cases the push reed closest to in-tune was on a different channel from the pull reed that was closest. Also I learned the hard way that I should put the tape on the base of the reedlbock itself, not over the holes leading to the action, since the tape really loves to stick to the padding and is hard to remove without tearing it. So at this point I have a cheapie box that's decently in tune with itself. So my remaining questions:


Thanks for any pointers!
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Peadar on February 11, 2021, 08:22:42 AM
I recently bought an "Eastar" brand toy accordion on Amazon in the US, for US$45.

It's a pretty standard "Chanson" as y'all call it here, 7-button diatonic with left-hand base and chord buttons. Notably, it's all plastic body, no wood in the fingerboard or whatever, and melody reedback is a solid plastic piece.

I had some "learning by doing" in terms of figuring out the best way to silence the extra reed in each double-reeded note, and had to play around because in some cases the push reed closest to in-tune was on a different channel from the pull reed that was closest. Also I learned the hard way that I should put the tape on the base of the reedlbock itself, not over the holes leading to the action, since the tape really loves to stick to the padding and is hard to remove without tearing it. So at this point I have a cheapie box that's decently in tune with itself. So my remaining questions:

  • I have one reed that just doesn't want to voice. Do I slid thin paper under it to clear fluff out? "Sproing" it gently to knock loose any dust?
  • The rubbery padding the reedblock sits on is kinda loose, glue it down?
  • Any other ways, at least on the treble end, to check for any gaps where it might be losing air?
  • On the bass side, best way to "de-third" the chords?
  • I've seen mention of improving action by limiting key travel beyond what's necessary. There's a plate under the fingerboard that would give access to the keys, so do I just drop that plate and put in a thin line of foam or cardboard or whatever and see if the keys with shortened travel still lift the pallets enough for the note to sound
  • Is there anything to be done about how noisy/crackly the bellows are? Do they get better as they get played in? Flying Duck Concertinas has been make "origami" paper bellows, might contact them to see if the same idea can be transferred to a Toy Accordion to remove the lame bellows from the equation
  • Any other ways to make this decently playable? It's already substantially better just from my initial steps. I know it won't ever be a Hohner, but it's been pretty fun already thus far, and I'm working up some tutorial videos on how to modify it as I learn by doing and from advice gleaned from this forum

Thanks for any pointers!
Why are you wnting to limit button travel?
Unless your "Eastar" is a completely different model to the recent wood bodied Chanson's the buttons bottom out without disappearing down the the keyholes any way.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Anahata on February 11, 2021, 10:35:23 AM
I have one reed that just doesn't want to voice. Do I slid thin paper under it to clear fluff out? "Sproing" it gently to knock loose any dust?
That should do it - one or the other of those methods.
Quote
Any other ways, at least on the treble end, to check for any gaps where it might be losing air?
Those things lose a fair amount of air through the bellows. Also check the pallets, perhaps?
Quote
On the bass side, best way to "de-third" the chords?
I'm pretty sure mine doesn't have thirds anyway.
Quote
Is there anything to be done about how noisy/crackly the bellows are? Do they get better as they get played in? Flying Duck Concertinas has been make "origami" paper bellows, might contact them to see if the same idea can be transferred to a Toy Accordion to remove the lame bellows from the equation
They'll probably get leakier as they get played in... yes, replacing the bellows might well improve things.
Quote
Any other ways to make this decently playable?
From what I've read, blocking one reed of each pair (which you've already done) to reduce air usage is one of the best treatments.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 11, 2021, 10:59:01 AM

  • Any other ways to make this decently playable? It's already substantially better just from my initial steps. I know it won't ever be a Hohner, but it's been pretty fun already thus far, and I'm working up some tutorial videos on how to modify it as I learn by doing and from advice gleaned from this forum


If your serious about playing melodeon, you could throw it out and buy a Geordie. Great little instruments. Couldn't believe it, the first time I met one in the flesh.

https://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/listing.cfm?inst=1[/list]
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Theo on February 11, 2021, 11:28:15 AM

Quote
Is there anything to be done about how noisy/crackly the bellows are? Do they get better as they get played in? Flying Duck Concertinas has been make "origami" paper bellows, might contact them to see if the same idea can be transferred to a Toy Accordion to remove the lame bellows from the equation
They'll probably get leakier as they get played in... yes, replacing the bellows might well improve things.

You can replace the reeds with better quality ones.  I've heard of people doing that.  Will give you a quicker response, and probably a bit louder.

Once you've replace the reeds and bellows then you only have the mechanism to worry about. When I messed about with one of these I found that the treble levers would bend quite easily. 

Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Tiposx on February 11, 2021, 11:46:00 AM
I have fitted conventional melodeon reed plates to give D and G (both Horner and Cagnoni) into four of these plastic bodied instruments. They are single voiced with accidentals instead of chords on the left hand buttons. I fitted a separate air lever assembly into one, which freed up the third l/h button for a third accidental button. They are all second button start.
I find that most of the air leaks through the standard air button, which doesn’t fit or seal in any plane I can think of. The pads need re-surfacing also. It is easy to re- surface or replace the air button with something that works. I found that the bellows weren’t actually leaking vey much. A few dabs of pva into where the gussets join the folds sorted any minor leaks out.
The leaky pads and air button affect things more on the push than the draw, so for instance the G tuning with accidentals works very well on tunes in D.
The new reeds are much louder than the originals, and the creaking of the bellows doesn’t seem to matter as much as a result. There was room for two voices in the G using Hohner reeds on the original reed block, but I didn’t fit them as it was loud enough for the pub sessions with one voice.
The buttons can stick under the keyboard, but the fix is to straighten the aluminium mechanism out so that the buttons move without contacting the sides of the holes. Also the holes may need a little sanding at the narrow points. White plastic dust from the buttons will show where the sanding needs to be done.
Also I fitted proper strap brackets with nuts and bolts instead of screws.
I can’t recall all the the improvements, but they can be pretty quick players. The plastic tone doesn’t go away though, even with a wooden fondo  fitted. That is why I moved on , I didn’t really care for the tone.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Tiposx on February 11, 2021, 11:50:14 AM
Look up “Toy melodeon mods” in this forum, I posted some details and photos. That was a D version with Cagnoni reeds, which later I converted to flat mounted reeds for more volume.

The Hohner G reeds fitted onto the original reed black and you can fit two voices if you really want to...
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 11, 2021, 02:56:30 PM
If your serious about playing melodeon, you could throw it out and buy a Geordie. Great little instruments. Couldn't believe it, the first time I met one in the flesh.

I appreciate, but I do already own a properly-fettled HA-112, and a Toy re-reeded to D by Michael Usui, and previously owned a C#/D Erica.

I bought this Eastar because I want to learn how to improve them and make a YouTube tutorial showing how to do so, so that more people who would never budget for even a US$300 used Hohner 1-row might be willing to drop US$45 on a toy and clean it up to just feel out the instrument.

At US$965, the Geordie I'm sure is lovely but in a completely different category at 21x the price. I will note though that I did write the Angelo Piccoli shop to get a quote on a similar model of "organetto": http://www.angelopiccoli.com/shop/en/legno/8-mini-eco-i.html

It seems Piccoli is filling the "tiny Italian diatonic" niche that Giustozzi formerly filled.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 11, 2021, 02:57:34 PM
Why are you wnting to limit button travel?
Unless your "Eastar" is a completely different model to the recent wood bodied Chanson's the buttons bottom out without disappearing down the the keyholes any way.

It seemed a few folks mentioned limiting the action in some past threads on the Chansons here, and iirc one of the makers who converts/ed these to better reeds mentioned limiting button travel for speed.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 11, 2021, 03:01:06 PM
You can replace the reeds with better quality ones.  I've heard of people doing that.  Will give you a quicker response, and probably a bit louder.

Yes, I've owned several re-reeded Toys by Michael Usui (not sure if he still offers that), and I know Smythe does a similar job but on higher-quality Russian toys.

So far as replacing the reeds though, my understanding is that some folks replace the whole reedblock to fit larger reeds, which is beyond my skill level, though I wouldn't be opposed to trying it with any reeds of the right size to "drop in" to the current reedblock.

Quote
Once you've replace the reeds and bellows then you only have the mechanism to worry about. When I messed about with one of these I found that the treble levers would bend quite easily.

The one where the levers bent on you, was it the kind with the exposed stamped-metal levers (Cajun-esque), or with concealed levers like is more common currently? My first toy melodeon in the 1990s was a Hero and had the exposed levers, but when I first got a re-reed from Michael he was quite firm on my getting one with internal levers, due to the bending risk of the exposed ones.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 11, 2021, 03:03:29 PM
The Hohner G reeds fitted onto the original reed black and you can fit two voices if you really want to...

Were the Hohner G reeds the octave above the stock C pitch, or the octave below that C?
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 11, 2021, 03:07:42 PM
I have fitted conventional melodeon reed plates to give D and G (both Horner and Cagnoni) into four of these plastic bodied instruments. They are single voiced with accidentals instead of chords on the left hand buttons. I fitted a separate air lever assembly into one, which freed up the third l/h button for a third accidental button. They are all second button start.

Quote
I find that most of the air leaks through the standard air button, which doesn’t fit or seal in any plane I can think of. The pads need re-surfacing also. It is easy to re- surface or replace the air button with something that works. I found that the bellows weren’t actually leaking vey much. A few dabs of pva into where the gussets join the folds sorted any minor leaks out.

This is dynamite insight, thanks! I'll check the air button pad to see if that's the issue first, and then start considering the other pads. Do you have a recommended material for re-facing pads on these? Anything accessible and affordable?


Quote
The buttons can stick under the keyboard, but the fix is to straighten the aluminium mechanism out so that the buttons move without contacting the sides of the holes. Also the holes may need a little sanding at the narrow points. White plastic dust from the buttons will show where the sanding needs to be done.

Again, awesome insight, I would never have thought of this on my own without months of discovery!


Quote
Also I fitted proper strap brackets with nuts and bolts instead of screws.

Yup, had this on my professional re-reed, so I could use a one-shoulder strap.. Though I will say the Eastar has nicer "leather" on the left-hand strap and right thumb-strap than any of the 20+ toys I've previously handled.


Quote
I can’t recall all the the improvements, but they can be pretty quick players. The plastic tone doesn’t go away though, even with a wooden fondo  fitted. That is why I moved on , I didn’t really care for the tone.

My Usui models have been surprisingly decent players (even in my amateur hands) compared to the stock; night and day difference.

Thanks so much for the detailed post of brilliant fixes!
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Theo on February 11, 2021, 03:30:42 PM
Yes the bent levers I had were the external type.

The cheapest way to get better reeds is to harvest some from an old PA and retune them.  It does require some time and skill, but the skill is something that you could acquire with a little practice.  That I turn will open up other possibilities for reed work.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Tiposx on February 11, 2021, 06:03:01 PM
When I ordered the G reeds from Charlie Marshall I gave him the approx dimensions and that I wanted to cover  buttons 2 to 8 of the G row on a DG melodeon (if I remember right) They just happened to fit almost perfectly.
I used my own pallet facing material, made of felt and leather, as is normal on melodeons. I used thin double-sided tape to fix the felt to the plastic pallets, (also normal for me). The main thing is to get the right thickness so that the pallets close correctly. I reattached the pallets with hot glue or wax,  once everything had settled down.
I still have two of these boxes, so I can check anything else on the build if needed.
Oh and the buttons are floppy on the levers. - I aligned mine properly and then fixed them securely with hot glue, but go easy as it can distort the plastic. This improves the feel and reliability of the action a lot.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 13, 2021, 01:10:47 AM
When I ordered the G reeds from Charlie Marshall ... This improves the feel and reliability of the action a lot.

Really good info! I took mine further apart and it seems that the pallet facing is some kind of soft white styrofoam, which seems to be working okay. Same thing on my air button, which has the same size of hole/pallet/facing as everything else.

I'm taking pictures for my own records, but if anyone is curious to see the insides, I can post it.

The reeds are sounding pretty good now, the action isn't terrible (I need to puzzle out if your way to improve the buttons is doable for me). At this point it's really the bellows that are the worst aspect (so crackly). So I'm going to talk to the guy at Flying Duck Concertinas who makes paper bellows, about how his simplified technique might apply to the Toys. I'm too busy to do this commercially, but it might turn out that a bored hobbyist could knock out a stack of paper bellows on Etsy and sell them as an upgrade, because it's really the worst part of these little things now that I've single-voiced mine.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Kimric Smythe on February 13, 2021, 08:39:39 AM
I rebuilt a bunch of these for a class years ago.
Some improvement of the reeds can be had by looking for ones with excess clearance and drifting the aluminum in to close up the gaps on the tip and sides. This makes a huge difference.
It looks nasty but it works, I use a small flat tip screw driver and a anvil. https://www.instagram.com/p/CBl6ur1Js49/
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Tiposx on February 13, 2021, 09:11:59 AM
That is an excellent tip, I will use it I am sure
Thank you!
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Winston Smith on February 13, 2021, 09:20:42 AM
I remember a posting where someone told us about reducing the gap all around the reed tongue using nail varnish, or something related. Did anyone ever try that, according to what I read at the time, it seemed to do the trick admirably. Perhaps it could be a safer (and reversible) method?
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Helena Handcart on February 13, 2021, 09:22:42 AM
Didn't Nick CB solve the bellows problem (to an extent) by connecting two sets of chanson bellows together and covering the whole lot in some sort of car paint?

Found this video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OwKEW9304Mg) on YouTube
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 13, 2021, 11:20:12 AM
I rebuilt a bunch of these for a class years ago.
Some improvement of the reeds can be had by looking for ones with excess clearance and drifting the aluminum in to close up the gaps on the tip and sides. This makes a huge difference.
It looks nasty but it works, I use a small flat tip screw driver and a anvil. https://www.instagram.com/p/CBl6ur1Js49/

Instagram Caption: Closing up the side clearance on a Chinese concertina reed. I learned this trick from old instruments made during WWll that were made from rejected reeds. The clearance makes a huge difference in response and tone. I did this using a small hammer and the tip of a small screwdriver, it looks ugly but really works. This is a two tone reed so I could not just use a used Italian reed. #concertina #accordionreeds #accordion #accordionrepair

Ah, so "drifting" means you kinda pounded the edges of the reed opening to get them closer to the reed itself?

Is "anvil" in this context an actual small smith/cobbler anvil, or used more broadly to mean you just used something flat and heavy to be a solid surface for pounding around the reed? I assume this requires removing the individual reed from the reedblock, and can't be done while reeds are installed?

Quote
I remember a posting where someone told us about reducing the gap all around the reed tongue using nail varnish, or something related.

I am also keenly interested in this option, as it might be a more accessible tactic for the average novice. I'm pretty open to ideas at this stage, just figuring out how to make melodeons accessible as best as one can.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Gav Wood on February 13, 2021, 05:09:17 PM
Some people call the edge in coining, same as the process used for coins, obviously. Coins start as flat disks and are stamped and coined to make the face and the edge. Spent some time, a few days over the last few years in a coin factory, interesting how it is done.

Had a go at coining but it seemed a lot easier to use old junker pa reeds with already suitable gaps of which i have a plentiful supply.

The nail varnish was brendan power, harmonica legend. Harmonicas are a lot more critical for air usage, you cannot make a bigger pair of lungs.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Gav Wood on February 14, 2021, 08:05:45 AM
Not sure how to paste a link in here, but this is the copy and paste of the reed response varnish thread.

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,23380.msg278688.html#msg278688

If the gap is too wide this may not work as is planned for closing small gaps.



Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Kimric Smythe on February 14, 2021, 08:41:01 AM
"Anvil" in this case is the magnet core from a very large hard drive disc comb. it weighs about 2 lbs and is about the size of my fist.It has a odd shape and is a all purpose heavy object in the shop.
Reed plate aluminum is pretty ductile , you just have to get a feel for how far back you can drift the metal from, get too close and you can just end up chipping off the edge.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 14, 2021, 09:01:43 PM
"Anvil" in this case is the magnet core from a very large hard drive disc comb. it weighs about 2 lbs and is about the size of my fist.It has a odd shape and is a all purpose heavy object in the shop.

Great info, thanks!

Can you clarify slightly what materials you recommend for replacing the valves on the Toys? And do you recommend replacing the valves just as soon as one gets the instrument, or just if the current valves start causing trouble?
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 15, 2021, 01:03:27 AM
Can you clarify slightly what materials you recommend for replacing the valves on the Toys? And do you recommend replacing the valves just as soon as one gets the instrument, or just if the current valves start causing trouble?

If you are restoring/rebuilding the instrument, it's worth installing new valves throughout - it's not always possible just by looking to see if a valve needs replacing. I would recommend the vinyl type for the toy melodeons, although you could go for overkill and use leather valves. Either way, don't try making your own; it's just not worth it and you are unlikely to be able to achieve the thinness and flexibilty of both the main and subsidiary leaves which act as booster springs. The proper valves are cheap as chips* to buy and will give you the best response possible from your reeds.

Measure the lengths you need and order them from Charlie Marshall (CGM Musical) (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Reed_Valves.html). He's based in Scotland but will ship internationally. Very good, very reliable. Just be sure to order a few more than what you think you need, to give you a few spares in case you mess up a few valves during the installation. Use sharp scissors to trim the valves to length and trim the booster leaves by a proportional amount.

If you don't want to order from Charlie, I guess Kymric Smythe in Oakland CA might be able to help, or the Button Box in Sunderland MA might supply you with some valves (although they don't advertise spare parts on their website; it might be worth giving them a call).

The importance of good quality, well fitted, valves is so easily overlooked. These cheap and innocent looking things can make the difference between an instrument playing well or being an absolute dog.


*french fries
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on February 15, 2021, 07:13:25 AM
Didn't Nick CB solve the bellows problem (to an extent) by connecting two sets of chanson bellows together and covering the whole lot in some sort of car paint?

Found this video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OwKEW9304Mg) on YouTube


Ha, yes I did. I’d more or less forgotten that. It was car glitter paint.
  Having set out to see if I could improve the instrument I think I nearly achieved that, then lost interest when the Organetto came along!
    In the end, the whole thing went to our own Malcolm Bebb for further fiddling with.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Kimric Smythe on February 15, 2021, 07:45:15 AM


[/quote]

Great info, thanks!

Can you clarify slightly what materials you recommend for replacing the valves on the Toys? And do you recommend replacing the valves just as soon as one gets the instrument, or just if the current valves start causing trouble?
[/quote]

If it is just one of the little toy accordions then old audio or VHS tape should work for valves.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 15, 2021, 03:56:32 PM
  Having set out to see if I could improve the instrument I think I nearly achieved that, then lost interest when the Organetto came along!

Which make of Organetto did you get? I'm tempted to get one of the toy-sized yet quality options by Angelo Piccoli or Cailloux.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: malcolmbebb on February 15, 2021, 11:32:43 PM
The big problem with the bellows is that the gusset material is both highly porous and very well glued to the card. The rounded shape of the bellows makes it a much bigger job to build a new set.
Nick sprayed his bellows with silver car paint and glued two sets end to end, it has Hohner reeds. Still leaks but you do get longer before you run out of air and it's less flapping your arms about than the unmodified version.
I tried covering the gussets with thin leather, which worked to an extent but was difficult to get right. Previously I tried sealing the gussets with flexible tent seam cement, also partially successfully.
I ditched the original brass reeds, they are horrible, and used a set of modified German or Italian (probably a mix of both!) PA reeds retuned to D using the original blocks. I made new mounts for the bass reeds, but gave up before I got them working properly. 
The mechs are flimsy and can be a poor fit, they can foul the case and not fully close, but OK for a box that's never going to be played hard  :||: I stole a single treble lever from a donor box to make a Hohner style air button, but it wasn't a job I would care to exhibit. 
PS after completing this box I put all the Chanson parts I had left in a cardboard box and sold them on Ebay to prevent me spending more time playing with them! But it was fun and instructive, and I still play one occasionally.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on February 16, 2021, 07:22:57 AM
  Having set out to see if I could improve the instrument I think I nearly achieved that, then lost interest when the Organetto came along!

Which make of Organetto did you get? I'm tempted to get one of the toy-sized yet quality options by Angelo Piccoli or Cailloux.

   Sorry, I meant Organett. On the box it says THE ENCORE. MOST POPULAR, LOUDER THAN A CORNET
Made by Hohner of Germany
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 16, 2021, 07:55:26 AM
  Having set out to see if I could improve the instrument I think I nearly achieved that, then lost interest when the Organetto came along!

Which make of Organetto did you get? I'm tempted to get one of the toy-sized yet quality options by Angelo Piccoli or Cailloux.

   Sorry, I meant Organett. On the box it says THE ENCORE. MOST POPULAR, LOUDER THAN A CORNET
Made by Hohner of Germany

The Hohner Organetta? The little electric reed organ?

Or is this a Melnet running joke that's going over my head?
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 16, 2021, 07:59:42 AM
  Having set out to see if I could improve the instrument I think I nearly achieved that, then lost interest when the Organetto came along!

Which make of Organetto did you get? I'm tempted to get one of the toy-sized yet quality options by Angelo Piccoli or Cailloux.

   Sorry, I meant Organett. On the box it says THE ENCORE. MOST POPULAR, LOUDER THAN A CORNET
Made by Hohner of Germany

The Hohner Organetta? The little electric reed organ?

Or is this a Melnet running joke that's going over my head?

Hohner Organette. Google is your friend:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jbFFV87suOI
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Kimric Smythe on February 16, 2021, 08:30:16 AM

I ditched the original brass reeds, they are horrible, and used a set of modified German or Italian (probably a mix of both!) PA reeds retuned to D using the original blocks. I made new mounts for the bass reeds, but gave up before I got them working properly. 

The bass reeds are touchy, a regular accordion reed wants to choke at the higher pressure involved , opening the gap makes little difference. It has to do with how the reed works and it is something I only really got my head around recently since these little things work at a pretty high air pressure.
 You need a narrow reed with a weighted tip, shorter than you would normally use. The performance is not awesome but it works pretty well.
 The reeds are hard to come by and I end up having to use my limited supply of old (San Francisco made?) Colombo reeds from the 40's. Beautiful hand made reeds with a curve like a airplane wing sanded in ,but only about 70% as wide as is typical,
 Opening up the hole for that reed helps too, the turbulence of the air going through the small valve opening causes distortion. The stock chinese reed is very narrow and rather short so it also uses less air.
 The little Flea accordions are eating up my supply so I will need to keep an eye out for another donor.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 17, 2021, 04:06:25 PM
I'm going to be posting a video review of my Eastar toy on YouTube soon (still teaching myself to do fancier stuff on iMovie), and will post that when done. The first video will be just of the unmodified instrument, and I'll do follow-up videos about how to single-voice one of these.

Mine is playing way better since I single-voiced it, but with the wetness gone I can much more clearly note some discord in tuning. The main issue I'm facing is that the overall box is running a quarter-step sharp of Key of C, which is not a total dealbreaker but means that someone playing with say a fiddler or guitarist would have to ask that person to tune to the melodeon. But for vocal accompaniment or solo, not a major deal, and sailors/miners/factory laborers who played these probably had them at various weird pitches (and cheap bronze reeds).

The stickiest wicket though is everything is pretty reliably running C half-sharp, but the actual C reeds are both at concert C. So I need to either raise one of the C reeds to C half-sharp, or bring every other reed in the box down to concert pitch. I'm lazy, so I'm going to go reed read up on how to tune reeds. I'm nomadic so most of my gear is in storage, but I do have a set of needle files in my little traveling tool bag (all fits in a shaving bag), so I imagine I have what I need. Anyone recommend any specific tutorial on reed tuning that I can follow to raise a reed up a quarter-step?
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Gena Crisman on February 17, 2021, 05:14:40 PM
how exactly did you single voice it? I cut out a square piece of paper with a straight line cutout for all the reeds I wanted on on one side (e) and stuck it under the reedblock. I realised though that, some reeds on one side of the block or the other performed better or were more usefully in tune, and was going to alternate which reeds I allowed to be active by punching holes on alternative sides in my blocking material.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Kimric Smythe on February 17, 2021, 05:15:16 PM
"The main issue I'm facing is that the overall box is running a quarter-step sharp of Key of C"

You may have set yourself up with the wet tuned bank of reeds. Try the other bank and see if they are better.
It is entirely possible that the entire thing is out of tune though.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 17, 2021, 05:24:45 PM
"The main issue I'm facing is that the overall box is running a quarter-step sharp of Key of C"

You may have set yourself up with the wet tuned bank of reeds. Try the other bank and see if they are better.
It is entirely possible that the entire thing is out of tune though.

Try what Kimric has suggested first, to check whther you have inadvertently blocked off the M 'at pitch' reeds so that only the M+ reeds are sounding.

I would advise against sharpening the reeds to match the others. It's much easier to flatten reeds than to sharpen them, especially those pesky underneath pull reeds. Far better to bring the whole thing down to concert pitch C. Then you also would not need to ask fiddle players too tune sharp, and would be able to play along with other melodeons and concertinas, etc., which are already at concert pitch.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 18, 2021, 09:12:40 PM
This is one of those moments that really hammer-home "take notes on what you're doing." I have spent too many times opening and closing this box because I keep thinking I'm going to remember what stage of the game I'm at, then I realize I don't. So when I make a video about this, I'm going to make it very clear that taking notes is key, at least for free reed novices like me.

So, I bristled a bit at the suggestion that I'd be so thick as to mistake the M+ for the M, since I'd tried both banks and found them unsatisfactory. So I finally sat down and took a few minutes to tape off one bank and then the other, testing each with a tuner... and actually wrote down this time what was what, and the one I had sounding when I posted above is the worse of the two, so would be the M+. But in my defense the "M" set is still somewhat off, just not as much.

I'm using Instuner so it has five little lines between each half-step, and the "M+" bank reliably runs 2-3 lines sharp (so up to a quarter-step sharp), while the "M" bank runs 0.5 to 1 line sharp. So one is better than the other, but the better one is still slightly sharp. (Note this is setting aside the C/D and the f/g which are presenting their own little problems).

I am totally new to tuning reeds, so I had no idea it's easier to lower a reed than to raise it, but that's good news in my case. I don't want to make anyone repeat things that have been discussed plenty of times, and I can google up tutorials, but does anyone have a totally preferred tutorial that would apply well to this instrument that I should read? And if anyone has the 10-second explanation "why it's easier to lower than raise a reed", I'm all ears.

As noted above, the C/D is actually in-tune somehow, but the C of one bank and the D of the other are the best ones, so I have to tape off reeds directly vice taping the bottom of the chamber. And on the f/g there's one note in each bank that's only plays at high pressure or not at all, and I've tried "sproinging" them and sliding a dollar bill under each but with no success thus far, so open to other ideas.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 19, 2021, 07:52:38 AM
And if anyone has the 10-second explanation "why it's easier to lower than raise a reed", I'm all ears.
Quick explanation:
1. To sharpen a reed you have to use a file to remove metal from the tip of the reed. It's easy enough for the push reeds because they are the ones which are visible on the top of the reed plate. You just need to support the reed with a thin shim while you're doing it. To sharpen the underneath pull reeds is slightly more tricky because you can't immediately get to the reed to (a) support the tip and (b) file the tip. You need to use a reed lifter to do this and there is a definite skill to be learned to work the reed lifter to bring the tip up through the reed plate slot.

2. To flatten a reed you have to remove metal with a file or scraper/scratcher from the belly of the reed, normally about 2/3 to 3/4 the way along the length of the reed towards the rivet end.  Again, the push reeds are easy - just support the reed tongue with a shim while you are doing it. The underneath pull reeds can be scratched just by lifting the valve slightly and employing the scratcher directly on the reed tongue, working against the inherent springiness of the reed. One or two linear scratches from the 2/3 point to the rivet end will flatten the reed by a cent or two at a time. So long as you are careful and don't use too much pressure, you don't need to lift the reed or support the reed tongue with a shim - and that is why it is easier to flatten reeds rather than sharpen them.

You might find these videos instructive.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdap-lYsKbw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xy8dizq8Tks

... I'm using Instuner so it has five little lines between each half-step, and the "M+" bank reliably runs 2-3 lines sharp (so up to a quarter-step sharp), while the "M" bank runs 0.5 to 1 line sharp....

That sort of tuning device is OK for tuning guitar strings, but nowhere near precise enough for tuning reeds. You need a tuner which will read at least to the nearest cent. (A cent is one hundredth part of a semitone), so your 'five little lines' are each equivalent to 20 cents. Not really good enough for tuning reeds, where even a couple of cents difference can make a noticeable impact on the tremolo rate or the tuning of octaves and other intervals along the reed bank row.

And on the f/g there's one note in each bank that's only plays at high pressure or not at all, and I've tried "sproinging" them and sliding a dollar bill under each but with no success thus far, so open to other ideas.

First, check all the valves are working - lying flat against the reed plate and not curled or bent. Replace if necessary.

If the valves are all OK, the reed problem then is almost certainly due to the reed tip gap above the reed plate being incorrectly set. In summary, if it is too high, the reed will be slow to start, probably sound loud and breathy, and needing greater bellows pressure to start, or may not sound at all. If it is too low, the sound may be weak and variable in pitch as the bellows pressure changes. If the reed tip gap is very small, the reed will 'choke off' and again, not sound at all.

Adjusting the reed tip gap involves very carefully using a reed lifter or pointy thing like a cocktail stick to open up or close the gap, by bending the reed one way or the other against its springiness. There is a sweet spot where each reed performs at its best, and the difference in the tip opening between good and bad is tiny, often not enough to be seen by eye. Nor is it something which can be reliably measured; each reed behaves slightly differently. Some people will tell you that the reed tip gap needs to be the same as the thickness of the reed itself. While this may be a rough rule of thumb, in my experience it is just an approximate guide. As before, every reed behaves differently.

Adjusting the reed tip gap takes a lot of patience, experience, and care to get it just right, and while learning, the risk of overdoing it and ruining a reed is always present. Be very careful if you try doing this.

Adjusting the opening also affects the tuning, so if you have to alter the tip gap, you may well need to retune the reed. Using excess pressure while tuning the reed can also affect the tip gap, so tuning and adjustment can be a reiterative process.

Now you know why professional reed technicians charge so much for their work. 
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 19, 2021, 01:14:49 PM
For tuners, are there any phone app tuners that are precise enough?

I also have ClearTune on my iPhone, which goes down to 0.1hz of accuracy, so would that suffice? I also have a Peterson Tuning Pickup (basically a clamp with a transducer and cord that plugs into my phone) so I can pick up the vibrations of the instrument without ambient noise.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 19, 2021, 01:23:49 PM
For tuners, are there any phone app tuners that are precise enough?

I also have ClearTune on my iPhone, which goes down to 0.1hz of accuracy, so would that suffice? I also have a Peterson Tuning Pickup (basically a clamp with a transducer and cord that plugs into my phone) so I can pick up the vibrations of the instrument without ambient noise.

Peterson iStrobosoft.
https://www.petersontuners.com/products/istrobosoft/

Also, think of your tuning work in cents, not Hz. Much more convenient.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Theo on February 19, 2021, 01:50:39 PM
The Peterson app is just about the best and very reasonable cost. Because it uses a simulated strobe display it is much easier to read, and much more precise at showing when you have reached your target pitch.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Anahata on February 19, 2021, 05:26:22 PM
I also have ClearTune on my iPhone, which goes down to 0.1hz of accuracy, so would that suffice?

It would, because 0.1Hz corresponds to a tremolo beat rate of 1 beat in 10 seconds.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Gena Crisman on February 19, 2021, 05:26:38 PM
Well, yeah, but pretty much any phone app should suffice, ideally you would like one that has some kind of strobe tuning feature. You probably do not want to tune based on vibrational noise, the phones mic is probably a better choice.

That resolution is more than sufficient. Typically reeds are tuned very precisely to the appropriate pitch but that isn't really... Vital in this case.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 20, 2021, 05:30:11 AM
I had to google what a "strobe tuner" even is, and I'm still not entirely clear on what's great about them, but the Peterson iStroboSoft app is $10 so I guess I'll give it a whirl if they're that great.

I read the summary, I can sorta visualize it, but still don't entirely understand why it's better than a usual dial, but I guess I'll learn by doing: https://www.sweetwater.com/insync/what-is-a-strobe-tuner/

If I have fine tweezers for poking things, and needle files for scraping things, and combine those with an iStrobe, I should be equipped enough to work on a $35 melodeon?

UPDATE: I paid $10 on the App Store for the Peterson strobe tuner app, plugged in my $15 Peterson clamp-on transducer that plugs in my phone's earphone jack, and tuned up my $45 made-in-China 7-string pentatonic lyre. I emphasize this is just an initial impression, but said impression was "dang, this is way, way easier." I don't understand why it's easier, but I'ma gonna roll with it.

UPDATE2: used it on my Puerto Rican cuatro, which I have tuned open as a small cittern, and likewise very pleased with the ease. But it appears there are in-app purchases for "Sweeteners" like Just Temperament and similar, so we'll see how those add up since I do really need a tuner to do non-Equal options for my string instruments.

UPDATE3: $5.99 in-app purchase for the "Guitar Sweetener Pack" and $9.99 for the "World Instruments Sweetener Pack." So those have various DADGAD, perfect-fifths, etc. options, so I bought those under "in for a penny, in for a pound." There is also an Accordion Sweeter Pack that seems pretty informed on free-reed issues, but I'm holding off on that one for now since it's beyond what I need for toy fettling.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Rog on February 20, 2021, 12:11:35 PM
'Not clear on what's great about [strobe tuners]'
I have to sympathise because it’s not immediately obvious. The 'strobe' display, which is a simulation of the electromechanical strobe/spinning wheel thing on an old fashioned strobe tuner, shifts upwards for sharp and downwards for flat (of your target note) and sits still when your pitch matches, so it's easy to read (as Theo said). If you happen to be tuning (say) a guitar string, where you alter the pitch while the note sounds, this is really helpful. But tuning reeds (mostly) doesn’t work like this, cos you can’t alter the pitch while the reed oscilates. The Petersen iStroboSoft app also shows fractions of a cent, so it gives a degree of accuracy you can’t really get with a needle display (and it does a load of other things...check out the settings).  I do use this app (I’ve got two old iPads in my workshop..v handy), but I am a fan of the Kong Orchestral tuner (which costs quite a lot more than the Petersen). This has a real meter with a real needle, and little red lights that show when you are on target. It has a lot of other settings too, *and* you can get it to sound the pitch you want. BTW Not all tuners use the meter to tune. Some (well, at least one I know of) come from the piano tuning world and compare a reference sound with the reed, to get a match. So you can if you want do this with the Korg tuner. (Aside....old tuning benches before modern electronic tuners used this method...they had a set of reference reeds as part of the tuning bench).  Anyway, I often find it easier to grab the little Korg...it switches on quickly and is v handy. But I’m in minority of one on this, I suspect.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Gena Crisman on February 20, 2021, 04:21:41 PM
My understanding is that you can also explain strobe tuners as: it lets you use a note's harmonics as a magnifying lens to more accurately detect the correct fundamental frequency.

Paying attention to the harmonics lets the device be more precise: if the device can only work to a precision of 1 Hz, then 1 Hz at the 2nd harmonic divides down to 0.5 Hz of precision at the fundamental. 1 Hz at the 4th harmonic is going to be 0.25 Hz of precision. It also helps you - as, in reverse, if you're 0.2 Hz 'off' at the fundamental, you would be 0.8 Hz off at the 4th harmonic, so, effectively, any error at the fundamental is magnified and easier to observe and gauge, and in turn, correct.

The 'strobe' element relates to how this approach could originally be implemented. If you've ever seen someone test a record player (https://www.youtube.com/watch/f5mgY25MLtI) with a disc with black and white squares that 'drift' one way or the other when the record player is spinning too fast or too slow, but appear to stay in the same place when rotating at the correct speed, then, well, that's basically the same methodology - your home lighting is used as a 50 or 60hz strobe light that snapshots the position of the squares as they spin, playing a known frequency vs that of your record player. A the strobe tuner would spin a disc at the 'correct' speed, and flicker a light based on the sound it heard. Nowadays, quite a few mobile apps offer some kind of virtual display that reflects this same kind of information, although they may not display it in exactly the same way as a strobe disc.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Rog on February 20, 2021, 07:08:16 PM
Probably very useful for tuning a bell, which has all sorts of harmonics going on.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on February 21, 2021, 05:57:32 PM
@Steve_freereeder, the Peterson iStroboSoft is already earning its keep, both on my lyre and cuatro, as well as on the toy melodeon.

Played through the mic, it quickly showed me the M bank is running mostly on average +15c, with a few notes being +8c and a couple being +23c. As noted the C/D button I need to play musical chairs with since the decent reeds are on differing banks, and the High g is still clogged and I need to puzzle that one out.

So with that in mind, should I first experiment in lowering the pitch of the M+ reeds so if I muck it up I ruined the worse of the two? And I'm glad to hear it's filework, because I know nothing about reed fettling had assumed that one lowered pitch by adding mass via a smear of solder or something, so this should be easier.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on March 02, 2021, 08:01:13 PM
Been tied up with work, but definitely going to get back to fine-tuning my M bank down to C.

Quick question: would it be removed feasible to tune my M+ bank up to D, so I could have both a C box and a D box (on the right hand at least) depending which bank I taped off? Or is tuning a reed up nearly a full-step just not viable?
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Theo on March 02, 2021, 08:06:10 PM
Probably ok on the lowest reeds but progressively more tricky as you go higher and on the highest reeds not possible.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on March 03, 2021, 07:45:06 PM
One more question before I get back to hacking on this critter: when folks tune reeds, do they usually do it with their bare eyes (with goggles), or is it common to use magnification so you can see more clearly what you're scraping?

I keep a jeweler's loupe (5x magnification) in my kit for various tasks, so should I try wearing that, or just protective goggles when tuning reeds?
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Theo on March 03, 2021, 08:13:03 PM
I use unaided eyes for tuning.  I do keep a 10x magnifier handy to examine the edge of reeds that are not sounding correctly.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 03, 2021, 11:57:17 PM
One more question before I get back to hacking on this critter: when folks tune reeds, do they usually do it with their bare eyes (with goggles), or is it common to use magnification so you can see more clearly what you're scraping?

I keep a jeweler's loupe (5x magnification) in my kit for various tasks, so should I try wearing that, or just protective goggles when tuning reeds?

Goggles?? What are you using to tune your reeds? A grinding wheel?

Filing or scraping reeds should be done using hand tools only, and these used very gently. No dremels or other mechanical devices, despite what you may find on Youtube. Wear magnifying glasses by all means if it helps your vision, but goggles are not necessary - there should be no flying debris. (If there is, you're doing it wrong.)

I've posted this video earlier in the thread. This is how it should be done:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdap-lYsKbw

How not to do it:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHi9W0YxFTI
Tuning with the reed blocks outside the instrument (pitch will change when replaced in the instrument)
Using a dremel (too harsh, risks damaging reed tongue and reed plate slot, either through abrasion or overheating)
Using inappropriate valve material (old magnetic tape)
I wouldn't let this person get within a mile of my instruments.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: TapTheForwardAssist on March 05, 2021, 05:56:52 PM
I'll be using hand tools (got a full set of needle files), but I've got some worksite safety background so whenever I deal with small pieces of wood or metal  I like to wear goggles.

Thanks for posting the do/don't examples on tuning, very helpful!
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Kimric Smythe on March 11, 2021, 07:15:14 AM
"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHi9W0YxFTI
Tuning with the reed blocks outside the instrument (pitch will change when replaced in the instrument)
Using a dremel (too harsh, risks damaging reed tongue and reed plate slot, either through abrasion or overheating)
Using inappropriate valve material (old magnetic tape)
I wouldn't let this person get within a mile of my instruments".

Pretty rude to slag on somebody you have never met.

You are off on several accounts here by the way. You can't really heat the reed up enough in this manner to have any effect on the temper under normal circumstances, many Honers show signs of this sort of tuning from the factory going back decades.
A properly set up tuning table will give very little deflection to the tuning. I seldom have to tune more than 1-2 reeds post table on a 3 reed 120 bass piano accordion.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 11, 2021, 07:45:48 AM
"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHi9W0YxFTI
Tuning with the reed blocks outside the instrument (pitch will change when replaced in the instrument)
Using a dremel (too harsh, risks damaging reed tongue and reed plate slot, either through abrasion or overheating)
Using inappropriate valve material (old magnetic tape)
I wouldn't let this person get within a mile of my instruments".

Pretty rude to slag on somebody you have never met.

You are off on several accounts here by the way. You can't really heat the reed up enough in this manner to have any effect on the temper under normal circumstances, many Honers show signs of this sort of tuning from the factory going back decades.
A properly set up tuning table will give very little deflection to the tuning. I seldom have to tune more than 1-2 reeds post table on a 3 reed 120 bass piano accordion.

Sorry, I totally disagree.

Using a dremel to tune reeds risks damage to the reed tongue or the reed plate slot. It's as simple as that. Why use a noisy machine which is slow to run up to speed and potentially difficult to control in a small confined space? Hand tools are ready for immediate use, are silent, and completely controllable.

Any tuning table, no matter how it is set up, will always show a variation when comparing the pitch of the reeds on the block outside the instrument to the pitch in situ in the instrument. It's to do with the proximity of other components inside the instrument, which usually cause flattening in pitch compared with the pitch outside the instrument. Which is why professional tuners at the factories tune the instruments with the reeds mounted inside the instrument. That's good enough for me.

Finally, using old magnetic tape, instead of proper valves with multiple spring leaves, is simply bad practice. Proper valves are available. If we are working on other people's instruments and charging money for our services, we have a responsibility to use proper components and working practices.


Edited to add this:

Quote
many Honers show signs of this sort of tuning [i.e. with a dremel] from the factory going back decades.

Maybe, but you don't see dremel marks on Castagnari instruments. Sometimes the occasional diagonal filed area in the middle of the reed, but usually any fine flattening adjustments are made using longitudinal scratch marks with a reed scraper, which leave the edges of the reed tongue intact, and therefore less likely to initiate a crack across the reed.

Using a dremel for tuning will usually result in a concave zone across the width of the reed tongue, and the reed will be thinned and weakened in that area, again leading to a zone for potential subsequent fracturing. Furthermore, the concave zone makes it less likely that the reed will withstand future tuning adjustments, due to relatively large amounts of metal having been removed from a small area.

Hand tools such as files and scrapers allow you to 'feel the steel' as you are working, and you get to know by experience how much to to scrape or file to achieve the required adjustment. I learned very early on to always treat reeds with respect. The bit in the Hippocratic Oath primum non nocere (first do no harm) definitely applies to working with reeds.
Title: Re: Converted my "toy accordion" melodeon to single voice; next steps?
Post by: malcolmbebb on March 11, 2021, 08:31:13 AM
This is getting wonderful, we now have two threads that are individually guaranteed to run for ever under one topic. For those new age philistines who admit to using social media, this is the time to insert the popcorn GIF.  >:E >:E >:E >:E 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal