Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: rees on February 17, 2021, 04:41:36 PM
-
Just arrived, the new model Tommy with improved keyboard and metal action.
Looking gorgeous in Zebrano wood.
More details on my website at www.melodeons.com (http://www.melodeons.com)
-
wow, that's beautiful!
-
Just arrived, the new model Tommy with improved keyboard and metal action.
Looking gorgeous in Zebrano wood.
More details on my website at www.melodeons.com (http://www.melodeons.com)
Lovely but the grain does my head in, it makes it look like the box is permanently on a slope! (and its not just because of the camera angle...)
I still think it's a shame they changed from the lovely curved wood-veneer-on-aluminium grille (that my 1980s Tommy has got) to the three-flat-bits-of-wood one they use today. I guess it was just too expensive and time-consuming to make...
-
Lovely but the grain does my head in, it makes it look like the box is permanently on a slope! (and its not just because of the camera angle...)
I agree, I've made a couple of Clippers from Zebrano wood and they did look a bit Salvador Dali.
Having said that, this Tommy is beautiful in the flesh. (Do melodeons have flesh?)
-
I think it looks lovely too!
It looks like the keyboard is now enclosed, mine has the open type with wooden action.
Have they done anything internally?
I'm aware they have improved the bass response a while back, but haven't tried the latest version.
-
Yes, enclosed keyboard with metal action. As far as I can tell, the internals remain the same.
-
Here's another view.
-
Thanks Rees.
... looks like it's lovely from every angle ;)
-
Put a thirds stop in and I would consider buying one
-
Put a thirds stop in and I would consider buying one
Not mushroom inside (Lonnie Donegan).
-
Put a thirds stop in and I would consider buying one
Not mushroom inside (Lonnie Donegan).
My Father is a Refuse Collector.
-
Put a thirds stop in and I would consider buying one
Not mushroom inside (Lonnie Donegan).
That's a pity. I was thinking the same thing.
-
I've just spoken to Sandro Castagnari and he had this to say:
"I'm glad you're appreciating the new version of the Tommy. Let's say that the one you received is an anticipation for what the future has in store for the Tommy: the current batch that we're making will be the last ones with wooden action."
So it would seem that this Tommy is currently the only one available with metal action and in Zebrano wood.
If it was 3rd button start I'd keep it for myself. (:)
-
Will the Zebrano wood be an option later on, or is it a 'one off' batch to reflect or mark the change to a metal action?
-
Will the Zebrano wood be an option later on, or is it a 'one off' batch to reflect or mark the change to a metal action?
Not sure, I think this may have been a prototype so the jury's out on Zebrano.
-
Fair enough.
Mind you, it's a positive reaction from here!
-
Fair enough.
Mind you, it's a positive reaction from here!
I can't put it down, I may have to embezzle.
-
Blimey ... that speaks volumes!
-
Fair enough.
Mind you, it's a positive reaction from here!
In my case I was just keeping quiet. You know, "If you've nothing good to say..."
In general I like the highly contrasted grain softening the geometric lines of a box. Seeing the photo, I thought Blue Peter had covered it in Fablon and, as usual live on camera, cocked it up badly.
I wonder whether this is the beginning of a general move from open wooden keyboards to metal actions. In the past the metal action was promoted as a premium option, commanding a premium price. I suspect that in reality the metal action, which could so easily be made in a Chinese sweat shop for pennies, is a great saving over machining many strips of wood - and fitting it is just a matter of a couple of screws.
Rob.
Still a Castagnari fan!
-
I wonder whether this is the beginning of a general move from open wooden keyboards to metal actions. In the past the metal action was promoted as a premium option, commanding a premium price. I suspect that in reality the metal action, which could so easily be made in a Chinese sweat shop for pennies, is a great saving over machining many strips of wood - and fitting it is just a matter of a couple of screws.
From general experience of trying out many Castagnari models, I think that pallet return noise is slightly louder with a metal action than with a wooden open keyboard action. Perhaps the metal action transmits the sound more efficiently while the wooden action tends to absorb it.
It's not particularly a problem with the larger instruments such as the Mory and Handry (both metal action) but maybe it is more noticable on the small models.
Rees - any comments re pallet noise on the new Tommy?
-
Yes, I have noticed slightly more pallet noise on metal action keyboards.
There is a lot of open space around the levers which could tend to amplify the noise whereas there is no empty space at all on wooden keyboards.
-
Is there any real difference in response between wooden and metal action for the player?
i.e. any one type feel more 'positive' or quicker?
Just wondering...
-
Is there any real difference in response between wooden and metal action for the player?
i.e. any one type feel more 'positive' or quicker?
Just wondering...
Metal actions are at least not prone to binding due to humidity/beer in the mech, this can be a real pain on wooden actions and is less than easy to fix if the axle is jammed which I have found to be the case more than once.
-
I agree, certainly less to go wrong with a metal action.
As far as I can tell there is no difference in response.
-
I can see humidity/beer would cause problems, that makes sense.
Must admit, I always like the look of a wooden action, but nothing more than 'look'. Appreciate that a metal action has less to go wrong.
Thanks peeps.
-
I've found both types of action can perform really well in a quality build. I never had humidity problems with the open action of my Castagnari Nik, but an earlier Dino Baffetti model suffered somewhat. I cured the problem by stripping the action, scraping the sides of the lever arms, sandpapering a little off the ends, radiusing the sharp edges and rubbing them all over with a candle. The action never stuck again and was appreciably faster. On the other hand, I've found the metal actions in Castagnaris (Trilly and 1914) to be fast and quiet in contrast to a Pokerwork which is noisy and slow and whose design almost precludes improvement!
My point was that a metal action can be produced and fitted quite cheaply if design and tolerancing is right whereas to match its performance with an open mechanism is a skilled, labour intensive process. I like both.
Rob.
-
[[ADMIN]]
This topic has been in Buy & Sell for 2 months since the last posting.
It seems to have some ongoing interest so instead of deleting I’ve moved it here.
Theo
-
The Tommy has now been sold but do keep up the chat.