Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Chris Marriott on February 20, 2021, 11:05:35 AM
-
I've had a melodeon for about a year now, but got rather distracted by learning to play the concertina, so it's been sadly neglected. Anyway, now I've got a lovely new (to me) DG box I'm determined to learn to play the thing finally...
I'm using Mally's tutor book to teach myself, and I can play melodies reasonably competently on both the D and G rows, but now the time has come to start introducing the dreaded bases. Mally advises that in 4/4 time the bass should be played on beat 1, and the chord on beat 3, so:
1 2 3 4
B C
My question is, though, how long should each be held? Listening to people play, it seems that a common practice is to play the bass quite short, but extend the chord a bit:
1 2 3 4
B C----
so the bass only lasts for beat 1, but the chord extends over beats 3 and 4. Is that regarded as good practice?
Thanks,
Chris
-
Chris, as often said here, there are no rules, but that doesn't help you much at the moment.
When I started, I adhered to Mally's book simply to get going. I used the book to establish in my brain that I had to play an accompniment to the melody. Once that had happened then I became more adventurous.
I let the tune lead me, and if I felt like hanging onto a chord or bass then I did.
I think the only thing not to do is hang onto the bass and chord all the time so you get a sludgy accompniment.
Also, experiment.
Try short taps to bass and chord.
Try playing both ot once, or maybe just a bass or just a chord.
Can you follow the melody with the basses for a small bass run?
All these things are later, once you've opened the door in your head that links both hands.
Once that has happened, go explore!
-
Don’t worry too much. There is no “correct†way, only “how†the bass end supports the melody.
so in 4 time … do what Dave says if you are following a method. But … later
1 2 3 4
B C =>
B+C =>
B+C=>off silence
C B
B add C >
B* add C all work 👍
your choice as per your tune. try silences too. Nothing emphasises the tune rhythm better
My own journey was to practice these as left only initially. Then for a tune, to get right end solid, automatic, then try different bass riffs against that. It took a month or so. But there’s no hurry. In the end you’ll be able to vary the bass at will, a nice source of “variationsâ€, despite the right side not changing! “Melodeon magic†😉
The B* refers to playing a different bass with the chord. Standard ones are
Em on C bass (Cmaj7)
C on A bass (Am7), it can be nice to “slide†that into C/C
D on B bass (Bm7)
B on G bass (“Gmaj7) sort of, it needs thirds out to be true
Hold Em and run the pull bass E>D*>C > B/B works with a surprising number of Em tunes, provided they are aoilan (G row Cnat rather than dorian, using C# on the row.
So lots to explore, but first practice getting the hands/ends working separately and take it from there. Never forget the power of elements if silence in a bass end. Good luck, it’s worth the effort 😀
-
I started out learning from Mally's tutor and it got me started, but in the end I found myself wishing I had been more aware of John Kirkpatrick's tutor videos when I first set out. I reckon at £15 it's worth taking a punt on them.
They're near the bottom on this page
https://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/shop.asp
Disclaimer: I am not the world's biggest fan of a lot of John's playing, though he's more entertaining to me live than recorded. However, he's always very competent and I really enjoy some of what he's done. I just prefer some other styles. That doesn't stop me thinking his video tutorials are the bees knees and top quality learning aids, though.
He certainly goes a lot further in developing playing basses than Mally does.
-
Thanks, all. I'm literally on the first page of Mally's treatment of basses, so a long way to go. I think I'd benefit from some lessons once we can do that again (not a Zoom fan). Hopefully I'll be able to find a teacher in the NW of England.
Cheers,
Chris
-
I've just ordered JK's DVD set. Thanks for the recommendation!
Chris
-
There are several good tutors in NW England including Ben Farmer in Lancaster, Martin Ellison in Chorley and George Garside in Southport. Click the 'Teachers' button on the home page to find more information.
-
Thanks, Bob!
Chris
-
I started out learning from Mally's tutor and it got me started, but in the end I found myself wishing I had been more aware of John Kirkpatrick's tutor videos when I first set out. I reckon at £15 it's worth taking a punt on them.
They're near the bottom on this page
https://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/shop.asp
Disclaimer: I am not the world's biggest fan of a lot of John's playing, though he's more entertaining to me live than recorded. However, he's always very competent and I really enjoy some of what he's done. I just prefer some other styles. That doesn't stop me thinking his video tutorials are the bees knees and top quality learning aids, though.
He certainly goes a lot further in developing playing basses than Mally does.
The JK DVD has everything you need and more on using the basses. Once it arrives there is a whole section (DVD!) on one row playing and so many good ideas and tips. The second one is more two row focused but the short/long, long/short basses section in the one row part is very applicable to two row. The hardest thing is to stop the DVD and then work at one specific technique >:E
The Paul Young teaching Youtube clips are great as well if you haven't seen them yet and his idea in the Donkey Riding tutorial of developing a whole range of techniques on just one tune is an interesting learning concept....rather than trying to learn loads of tunes ::)
https://youtu.be/d7DYijyLVwk
https://youtu.be/xML9B_JQ3u8
-
My question is, though, how long should each be held? Listening to people play, it seems that a common practice is to play the bass quite short, but extend the chord a bit:
1 2 3 4
B C----
so the bass only lasts for beat 1, but the chord extends over beats 3 and 4. Is that regarded as good practice?
It depends on the tune, and it's more a matter of musical taste than hard and fast rules.
Simple counterexample to yours: in a waltz, where the standard pattern is
| bass chord chord |
it is common practice to make the bass note long and the chords quite short and sharp, because a waltz has a strong first beat (if you know how to dance a waltz, you'll understand this. It's the beat where your foot tends to move further)
There's another, more practical answer that applies to melodeons. When your right hand has a push note followed by a pull note in the same beat, you don't usually want to hold the bass or chord through that change in bellows direction (making the note/chord change), so you have to cut it short. If that means shortening other basses for consistency, that's not usually a bad thing.
-
That makes sense. Thanks! Yes, I’m a pianist, so I’m familiar with emphasising the first beat in the bar in 3/4 time.
Cheers,
Chris
-
Shorter bass and chord consumes less air, which may be helpful in the beginning when you also need to concentrate on timing and finding the right button.
-
if playing for dancing ( or just playing dance tunes) the bass note ( the um of um pa) is best kept short to very short as it is on the 'um' that the dancers 'land' 'cos gravity brings them down and they can't hover!
' the 'PA' whilst also played fairly short is a beit longer than the um as it provides, or should provide the 'lift' to get the dancers feet or foot off the ground. Similarly if playing for a waltz rather than a 4/4 or 6/8 tune its a short um for gravity assisted landing purposes and toe slightly longer Pa's to assist take off!
this 'crisp' style of bass playing is helped by tapping the buttons lightly and getting the fingers off the buttons between strikes . It also provides the very useful bi product of using a lot less air than does trying to shove the buttons down the holes.
for song accompanyment caution is needed as to how long bass or chord buttons are pressed for and there are many situations eg if accompanying a solo singer that great care is needed so as not to drown out the singer - the singer is the artist and you are just the accompanyist. My usual preference in such situations is to leave the bass well alone and instead add ( usually on the row) right hand chords simply to add a bit of body or to thicken things up a wee bit.
but each to his/her own of course
george
-
I started out learning from Mally's tutor and it got me started, but in the end I found myself wishing I had been more aware of John Kirkpatrick's tutor videos when I first set out. I reckon at £15 it's worth taking a punt on them.
They're near the bottom on this page
https://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/shop.asp
Disclaimer: I am not the world's biggest fan of a lot of John's playing, though he's more entertaining to me live than recorded. However, he's always very competent and I really enjoy some of what he's done. I just prefer some other styles. That doesn't stop me thinking his video tutorials are the bees knees and top quality learning aids, though.
He certainly goes a lot further in developing playing basses than Mally does.
I will second this advice wholeheartedly. I also started with the Mally book, which is good as an intro though I gave it up once I felt competent enough to start learning tunes on my own for the Tune of the Month threads here. But the JK DVD I have probably watched a hundred times! Sometimes I let it run in the background and listen while doing other work on the computer, just to remind myself of various ideas. It is the only teaching aid I have found that goes beyond single line melody playing and talks about all the various ornaments and right hand harmony techniques that were what attracted me to the melodeon in the first place.
Disclaimer: Contrary to Greg, I am pretty much a JK superfan. It was listening to his playing that made me commit to learning to play the melodeon in the first place, so he kind of defines the way I think a Pokerwork should sound.
Regarding basses, there are no set rules and it all depends on the type of music you're playing and the effect you want to create. Playing very short and staccato is good practice for strengthening the fingers and improving your control over them. John Kirkpatrick advocates (for English dance music) for a very short "oom" and a long "paah", but that actually goes beyond the bass and implies something about the entire approach to the rhythm. You emphasize the downbeat (the "one") with a clipped note and/or a little chop of extra harmony notes, etc., and then let the backbeat stretch out like someone hopping or jumping. But even that isn't a universal rule, of course.
-
There's another, more practical answer that applies to melodeons. When your right hand has a push note followed by a pull note in the same beat, you don't usually want to hold the bass or chord through that change in bellows direction (making the note/chord change), so you have to cut it short. If that means shortening other basses for consistency, that's not usually a bad thing.
I think I disagree a little, at least for chords. There's something to be said for a little harmonic motion in the chords, and it strikes me as very idiosyncratic to the melodeon. Obviously it should be intentional and controlled, but I enjoy when there's a held down chord that creates a "zig-zag" sound in the background, especially if it's repeated in a very intentional way. Kind of like a rhythm guitar playing a little riff rather than just strumming the chords, if that makes sense.
Probably a more advanced technique than what the OP is asking about, though!
-
Mally advises that in 4/4 time the bass should be played on beat 1, and the chord on beat 3, so:
1 2 3 4
B C
Uhm, so, I'm looking at the book, The D/G Melodeon Absolute Beginners, page 13, 'Introducing the Bass Buttons', and... No? I don't think the book says this at all? Am I looking in the right book? There's 4 rows of 2 bars for the most important time signature in the middle of the page, with 4/4 having the pattern of "Fun" "Ch" "Fun" "Ch" repeated every bar, Fundamental on beats 1 and 3, Chord on beats 2 and 4:
4/4:
1 2 3 4
F C F C
Can you tell me which part of the book is giving you the impression it would be Fundamental on 1 and Chord on 3?
To answer your question - look at the 2nd half of the staves, or, think of your bar split up a step further, so a 4/4 bar filled with 1/8th notes / quavers, and think of it as:
4/4 as 8/8:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
F x C x F x C x
So, bring your basses in, but aim to leave a gap. This approach will help you later, when you must play a melody note in 1/8th note gap. There's 1000 things you can do with the basses. Step 1 is being able to play them at all, honestly the rest can come later.
-
Obviously it should be intentional and controlled, but I enjoy when there's the held down chord creates a "zig-zag" sound in the background, especially if it's repeated in a very intentional way. Kind of like a rhythm guitar playing a little riff rather than just strumming the chords, if that makes sense.
Probably a more advanced technique than what the OP is asking about, though!
I didn't want to complicate my earlier reply, but you are right that this technique works sometimes.
"Intentional and controlled" are the watchwords there. I've heard too many examples where in my opinion it wasn't "controlled".
For a beginner, it's worth learning the discipline of keeping off the button when the bellows are moving the wrong way, as a default habit.
-
I didn't want to complicate my earlier reply, but you are right that this technique works sometimes.
"Intentional and controlled" are the watchwords there. I've heard too many examples where in my opinion it wasn't "controlled".
For a beginner, it's worth learning the discipline of keeping off the button when the bellows are moving the wrong way, as a default habit.
I agree, and I think Gena's comment ("Step 1 is being able to play them at all, honestly the rest can come later.") is probably the best advice so far in this thread!
-
I'm not sure if anyone has mentioned it yet but, even if they have, it's worth repeating. Apologies if you have already moved beyond this phase.
Getting the basses going is very much like rubbing your midriff and tapping your head. To begin with it feels very odd and your brain keeps trying to persuade you to do the wrong things. The simplest exercises were the most helpful to me. Persevere with them even when things feel weird. With a lot of people they suddenly click. Once you break through this barrier you can work on controlling and varying what you do.
-
Yes Greg is on the nail.
Getting the hands linked is a real big step. Once it clicks you're away. With the link in your mind established, you can start to vary your left hand and do what you like.
Your personal style then begins to form.
Keep at it, that is the secret. One day... it happens and that is a massive step forward.
-
Apologies, Gena, I am confusing myself. It’s not Mally’s book that I got the “bass on beat 1, chord on beat 3†advice from, but an introductory lesson posted on YouTube by Paul Young. You’re right about what Mally suggests.
Apologies for the mix-up.
Chris
-
I'm not sure if anyone has mentioned it yet but, even if they have, it's worth repeating. Apologies if you have already moved beyond this phase.
Getting the basses going is very much like rubbing your midriff and tapping your head. To begin with it feels very odd and your brain keeps trying to persuade you to do the wrong things. The simplest exercises were the most helpful to me. Persevere with them even when things feel weird. With a lot of people they suddenly click. Once you break through this barrier you can work on controlling and varying what you do.
Thanks, Greg. I already play the chromatic button accordion (although not very well!) so I’m hoping it won’t be too dissimilar from playing the stradella bass on that. There are far fewer buttons, so theoretically it should be easier. We’ll see how theory translates into practice 😁
Cheers,
Chris
-
Thank you all for the excellent advice. It’s very much appreciated. I’m determined to get to grips with this instrument. I play the accordion rather badly, but have effectively given it up because the weight was hurting my back. I play the English concertina somewhat better, and the melodeon fits nicely in between the two. I love the sound of the melodeon, and it’ll be great to play some of the English folk music I already know from the concertina on it.
Chris
-
This is my first attempt at using basses. Constructive criticism would be very welcome!
https://youtu.be/PEB7o3aolbk
Thanks,
Chris
-
Good job Chris. I could see the relief on finishing. Firstly welcome and well done for getting so engaged in the community here. The box sounds lovely.
Nothing to criticise, but it will get to be more relaxed soon. At which time you could vary note lengths and start to build a variety of combinations (bass and chord at the same time on occasions for different tunes, leaving out the second bass note in each bar etc. all add to skills, but what you've done here is absolutely fine.
I'm starting again on tips from Paul Young in a lesson yesterday, and I have immediately the same tension on learning that you display so it's all about baby steps.
You'll find it really good that you have started uploading already so that you can look back on progress.
-
Thanks. I don’t get tense when I’m playing normally, just when I’m trying to film myself. That was about “take 20†and it was a case of “Will I ever get through this without messing it up?†😁. I really struggled combining the basses with the passage of quavers in the second part of the tune. Still, I got there in the end!
I love the sound of the instrument. Really happy with it!
Chris
-
WRT George’s tip in keeping the um short, I was advised 30 years ago to “play the bass as if the buttons were red hotâ€. Same issue, to avoid heaviness. This particularly for waltz rhythm. The dance is quite light, and a too heavy UM TAA TAA … doesn’t inform the feet.
The French master Stéphane Milleret recommends “anything but um ta ta†🤔 but their waltz style is faster and rather lighter than ours.
Many tunes are dance ones, or dance rhythm. If you dance yourself, that is very beneficial, particularly any Morris stuff!
But first step … get those hands working independently. As with piano?
[edit] Frère Jacques was fine rhythmically. Bass chording … as above 🙂
Do try to use at least 3 fingers though, 4 if you can. When you come
to more complex tunes you’ll be moving between the D,Em set of
buttons and the G,C pairs (towards head and foot respectively)
If you only use index and middle fingers at this stage you’ll have to
‘unlearn’ that or tolerate awkward hand shifts.
-
Thanks, Chris. I did my best to keep the bass as short taps there, if for no other reason than if you hold the bass buttons down you run out of air!
Yes, hand independence isn't easy. A matter of practice.
I was actually using my ring and middle fingers for the bass, not middle and first fingers, with the expectation of later using my first finger for the upper buttons at a later stage. I'm going to try to get used to using my little finger for the lower buttons, but that's too awkward at the moment.
Cheers,
Chris
-
That looked like a good solid start to playing basses.
Getting one tune with a simple 4/4 rhythm I think really helps.
I have been doing pretty much the same thing, but using "Merrily We Roll Along" (the first tune I learnt on the melodeon) as my practice tune.
-
Handedness:
How many of us learned to tie our shoes right hand first, then add the left hand? 😈
-
I'm very strongly left-handed. I don't know if that's a help or a hinderance for the melodeon. Probably the latter, since you do most of the work with the right hand. Perhaps I should play it upside down? 😁
Chris
-
Another South paw here. A few play the box upside down, but you’ll end up with a really strong left end driven technique. Just keep practicing
As for getting that little finger going … I recommend mowing the lawn with a petrol rotary, and as you empty it … flick the grass out of the cuttings hole with your index finger 🥴
It worked for me 😉
-
Chris's, you're in good company.
I'm a left hander too. A certain player called Andy Cutting is as well so I don't think it is too debilitating ;D
I think your left hand as a dominant one is positive, you can let it work freely and think about the melody.
As a side note, I remember Steve Freereeder of this parish ( another lefty) saying he is aware of his left hand whilst playing.
It was only after him saying it that I realised I too seem to have mental pictures of my left hand whilst playing and no idea what my right it doing.
Handedness is a peculiar thing... but don't let it worry you!
-
There's no logic to handedness and instruments. If you look at squeezeboxes, strings and other instruments they're quite randomly asymmetrical. I'd strongly advise against turning your box upside down or getting a "left handed" instrument made - it's just a recipe for expense and inconvenience for the rest of your life, and it doesn't make much difference to the amount of learning you have to do.
(I'm right handed, but I don't think my melodeon left hand suffers for that)
-
I'm very strongly left-handed. I don't know if that's a help or a hinderance for the melodeon. Probably the latter, since you do most of the work with the right hand. Perhaps I should play it upside down? 😁
Chris
If you turn it upside down you end up with your little finger and ring finger doing most of the work.
From another left hander who wouldn.t dream of turning it upside down. Playing a mirror image is even less attractive.
-
I wasn't seriously suggesting that I'd play it upside down 😁. I play all my other instruments the normal way and I'll do the same with the melodeon.
Chris
-
I wasn't seriously suggesting that I'd play it upside down 😁.
Chris
Maybe not, but I've seen people do that. Even someone who borrowed my Oakwood and played it upside down to accompany a song.
-
I'm very strongly left-handed. I don't know if that's a help or a hinderance for the melodeon. Probably the latter, since you do most of the work with the right hand. Perhaps I should play it upside down? 😁
Chris
Head of music department wouldn't allow me to learn violin at school on the grounds I was left handed.
I believe the logic is that when you get past basic level the art is in the bowing not the fingering. Still can't play vibrato....OK I still struggle to play anything with a note shorter than a quaver or in tune but that's got nothing to do with being left handed.
It seems to me that the equivalent to bowing on the button accordion is bellowsing - IMHO in between getting expression out of the bellows and the range of chords you have on that instrument you've got plenty of scope to be left hand dominant and play the thing right handed.
-
Another South paw here. A few play the box upside down, but you’ll end up with a really strong left end driven technique. Just keep practicing
Chris's, you're in good company.
I'm a left hander too. A certain player called Andy Cutting is as well so I don't think it is too debilitating ;D
Steve Freereeder of this parish ( another lefty).
Fascinating to learn I'm in such august company! On first learning anglo concertina in the 70s and after listening to William Kimber, I started playing morris tunes on my left hand with little high-pitched chords on my right! On realising my error I corrected it, but have sometimes wondered whether I shouldn't have started playing left-handed. The principle would have been extended to melodeon when I took that up.
So it's very encouraging to discover there are excellent players who are left-handed but persevered with right-handed playing. I still think my playing suffers from a lack of right-hand dexterity (no pun intended) but I'm now aiming to take advantage of my dominant left hand by thinking more about bellows technique and doing less row-crossing than I used to - after all, fiddlers use their dominant hand for the bow so logically...
Ah - I see others have posted while I typed, especially Peadar!
-
As a side note, I remember Steve Freereeder of this parish ( another lefty) saying he is aware of his left hand whilst playing.
It was only after him saying it that I realised I too seem to have mental pictures of my left hand whilst playing and no idea what my right it doing.
Handedness is a peculiar thing... but don't let it worry you!
That's an intriguing consideration. If pressed I think I might agree with you and Steve; although really, I think I try my best not to mentally look too hard in either of their directions while I'm playing, lest they get self-conscious and forget what they're supposed to be doing! ;D
I agree with Anahata that there's little rhyme or reason to handedness of instruments. Most stringed instruments would seem to put the left hand in the position of doing the more complicated stuff. Keyboards typically cover the more complex parts with the right hand but there's no guarantee there. I played French horn as a child and there the left hand does all the finger work and the right hand merely stabilizes the instrument.
-
Jesse - well I never, another one!
Like you, I try not to consciously think of anything when playing, but there's definitely an awareness of my left hand. Strange isn't it!
-
As a side note, I remember Steve Freereeder of this parish ( another lefty) saying he is aware of his left hand whilst playing.
It was only after him saying it that I realised I too seem to have mental pictures of my left hand whilst playing and no idea what my right it doing.
Handedness is a peculiar thing... but don't let it worry you!
That's an intriguing consideration. If pressed I think I might agree with you and Steve; although really, I think I try my best not to mentally look too hard in either of their directions while I'm playing, lest they get self-conscious and forget what they're supposed to be doing! ;D
I agree with Anahata that there's little rhyme or reason to handedness of instruments. Most stringed instruments would seem to put the left hand in the position of doing the more complicated stuff. Keyboards typically cover the more complex parts with the right hand but there's no guarantee there. I played French horn as a child and there the left hand does all the finger work and the right hand merely stabilizes the instrument.
I think there's plenty of rhyme and reason.
With French horns, of course the original instrument had no valves, so it made sense for the normally dominant hand to do the pitch control via hand stopping.
The guitar and string instruments focus on the rhythm driving the music to be generated by the dominant hand. Most left handed violin players play right handed as working in a section with others is awkward otherwise. Most guitarists switch it round to suit their strongest hand for the rhythm. Some pianists have had left handed pianos built - but there's the huge cost and untransferable nature of acoustic pianos.
Clarinets, flutes and saxophones bear the weight with the stronger hand, but this has no real impact on the dextrous stuff as it is shared between the hands.
Of course it is ok to challenge those original reasons to play one way or the other especially as things have changed, but they did originally have rhyme and reason.
-
The guitar and string instruments focus on the rhythm driving the music to be generated by the dominant hand. Most left handed violin players play right handed as working in a section with others is awkward otherwise. Most guitarists switch it round to suit their strongest hand for the rhythm.
Agreed there is a certain amount of logic in the choice, but where stringed instruments use the right hand to provide the rhythm and dynamics and the left hand (mostly) for selection of notes, it's the other way round for melodeons and accordions. And keyboard instruments really need equal facility with both hands. So though there might be some historical logical reason for instruments to be built the way they are, the reality is that for most instruments both hands have a lot of learning to do, and a beginner should not be encouraged to think learning to play an instrument is hard because they are left handed - it's hard because it's hard!
-
As stated, I am left handed, but that isn't the whole truth.
Though I write left handed, I am a complete mix, using different hands for different tasks. If painting up a ladder, I start on my left side with my left hand and pass the brush over to my right and continue!
Steve Freereeder and I have chatted about this and I believe he too is a bit of a mixture.
I do wonder if there is a group of people that though state their handedness based on their writing hand, are more evenly handed.
Therefore, those people when playing an instrument, are more even across the hands.
The opposite I'm sure is also true. For some their dominant hand is truly dominant and therefore have a weakness with their other hand.
Maybe!!
-
...Steve Freereeder and I have chatted about this and I believe he too is a bit of a mixture...
OK - my ears are burning... ;)
Yes - I am a mixture.
I write with my left hand and do most fine control things with my left hand.
But I think my stronger or more dominant side is on the right. I will throw a ball with my right hand, kick a football with my right foot. Similarly use a kitchen knife to chop things, use a saw in my right hand. However, when riding a bicycle (a rare event) I always have more control and stability turning round a corner to the left, rather than the right.
Bizzarely - I hadn't thought about this before but I've just tested this out - when working on melodeon reeds, I will use a file in my right hand, but a reed scratcher in my left (not both at the same time).
-
Chris's, you're in good company. I'm a left hander too. A certain player called Andy Cutting is as well so I don't think it is too debilitating ;D
Late 90’s conversation ran
“I think you are left handed, Andyâ€
“Yes, how did you know�
So I think that it does affect your play. Andy is defo chord led. And metronomically rhythmic.
When I set about a tune I always start with its chord sequence, perhaps hum it against that. Part of the magic of melodeons is that the right end notes are nearly always there, occasionally you migh hav to sub Em for G, or play D other direction
Whereas you can work out quite complicated fingerings on right end 🤔 only to find that the left chords “aren’t to hand†😕. Accept that in the end we learn to do both together, but Left>Right works for me
Acknowledge also Anahata’s right handedness, yet he plays some of the best bass runs I’ve heard 🤔
-
;D Morning Steve!
Interesting. I'm more lefty than you, as I kick left, saw left but change when tired, eat crisps left.
Chris R, I'm in total agreement. If confronted by a new tune my left hand leads the way.
No matter what handed you are, Chris has made a main point - your melody is dictated by your chord choice so I start there.
Armed only with a pencil and rubber ( and often tea (:) ) I go through the tune and look which way the tune needs the chords.
If it needs a G chord then those melody notes need to be pushed, D chord melody notes can go either way, A's need pulling etc.
I'm aware that the OP has a Pariselle, so the choices might not be as regimented as me on a 2 row 8 bass box and he probably will have options of chords and melody in both directions, but to my mind the bass and chord choice leads how I play the melody.
... and yes, Anahata's left hand is superb no matter what handedness!
-
Oh, I definitely eat crisps left-handed. And peanuts.
-
I eat crisps with my left hand because the beer is in my right hand.
-
I do wonder if there is a group of people that though state their handedness based on their writing hand, are more evenly handed.
My father was possibly the most truly ambidextrous person I ever knew. Possibly because as a leftie he grew up in an era where there the prevailing ethos was to train that out of people. Perhaps because I spent quite a lot of my childhood outdoors with him knocking nails into things, digging things or brewing things I seem to have more control with my left hand than may righties - although undoubtedly both left hand co-ordination and strength have been greatly improved by melodeon playing. There maybe a little of the chicken and the egg about handedness and playing dexterity.
-
I think I've read that your 'food hand' is significant, a bit like if someone gently lobs a tennis ball stright at you your dominant hand catches it.
Also I have in the last couple of weeks learnt exactly what Helena has mentioned. Playing melodeon strengthens both hands and massively improves co-ordination. I gave up Duet concertina a long time ago through lack of musical knowledge but mainly as my right hand let me down. Now after playing melodeon I've discovered my right hand co-ordination has massively improved so you never know where that will lead!
Benefits of melodeon = improved co-ordination.
Who'd have thought (:)
Ps. I'm immensely impressed with p&t who can drink beer *and* eat peanuts at the same time ;D
-
What I'd like is to improve my left hand memory. It is having problems remembering that my F chords are in different places on all of my 2.5 boxes - and on one it's a different direction. Saying that, my right hand is having problems as well...
Melodies are just easier for me to remember than bass lines (which I often vary as well) - perhaps I ought to notate my music but so many tunes are just in my head.
Julian
-
Although I do indeed have a Pariselle box I'm keeping things simple and treating it as a 2-row 8-bass box for the purposes of learning. I can worry about the extra twiddly bits later 😁. The 14 bass layout is essentially the standard 8 bass layout with an extra pair of bass buttons at the floor end, and two extra pairs at the chin end, so I'm just ignoring the extra buttons for the time being and playing the 8 standard buttons.
Started my second tune with basses today from Mally's book. A lovely tune called "Egan's Polka". This is on the D-row and uses the D basses. It definitely getting easier now to play the treble and bass together.
Cheers,
Chris
-
With stringed instruments, the issue of rythym is a red herring. It is the work requiring the finest touch which (in a mainly right-handed) world is given to the right hand. That's the strumming, plucking or bowing - fingering the notes is the easier bit (although it doesn't feel like it when you're learning). With melodeons and accordions, the melody side is more difficult so that is given to the right hand. However in reality both hands have to work together and the player has to learn to use both. Since many left-handed players learn to play right-handed instruments the difference is probabably not that great, although we may never know how many left-handers give up because of that, rather than for the other reasons which may cause anyone to give up learning an instrument.
-
Chris M, that's a sensible decision to follow the tutor book as it's written.
My comments about choice of chords and melody note are therefore relevant.
Yep twiddles come later when you relax and are more on autopilot.
-
I eat crisps with my left hand because the beer is in my right hand.
Which foot do you use to hold the crisp bag between your toes?
-
No rules on basses (or chords, for that matter). As clear from previous posts.
My inspiration (and sometimes perspiration) often comes from listening to Anahatas ripped YouTubes with headphones, listening for the basses and chords "only".
Sometimes they are very spare but very sweet. Just the right amount off the beat.
Slightly on topic: I don't think we beginners appreciate how often the really good players are using right hand chords instead of or to supplement the left hand chords.
This can have a big effect on what the left hand is available to to do. And it also matters if the left hand chords are without thirds; again, opens up the left hands freedom.
-
Oh, I definitely eat crisps left-handed. And peanuts.
You definitely should see a Urologist, Steve 😉
= = =
Totally concur with Steve on right hand chording. Best thing I ever set myself to learn. I was commuting to West Paris at the time and it truly opened my mind to accordéon technique
… but we forget our host in this topic. How’s it going, Chris?
-
Going well! Getting to grips with a tune called “Egan’s Polka†now with D-row basses. Interesting playing the basses at the right points around dotted quaver + semiquaver pairs! Having fun 😁.
Chris
-
You definitely should see a Urologist, Steve 😉
Oh - I have no trouble going... ;)
-
My copy of JK's "How to Play the English Melodeon" DVD set has arrived. Looking forward to watching it!
Chris
-
You definitely should see a Urologist, Steve 😉
Oh - I have no trouble going... ;)
… I was more concerned about the peeing of nuts 😉
-
I started watching JK's DVDs last night. It's about 3h long on two DVDs and covered the extent of my current knowledge in the first 15m, so I think I'm going to learn a lot from them.
Chris
-
I started watching JK's DVDs last night. It's about 3h long on two DVDs and covered the extent of my current knowledge in the first 15m, so I think I'm going to learn a lot from them.
By the end of the third program he's covering playing in just about every available key on the D/G, making use of what you have in terms of chords on both sides, etc. Crazy stuff! I love this tutorial because it's very "aspirational", definitely not something you watch once and then move on from!
If you like JK's melodeon playing style, I highly recommend the "English Choice" tunebook he did for Mally Productions, and especially the two CDs that go with it ("Orlando's Return" and "Garrick's Delight"). These are also "aspirational" recordings, in that rather than just play through the single-line melody like a lot of tunebook accompaniment CDs, he gives you a full performance with all sorts of embellishments and plenty of gusto. They're great just as albums to listen to for pleasure, let alone as an instructional aid.
-
I agree with Jesse.
JK's book and cd's are excellent, and the cd's don't sound like an instructional aid as some cd's accompanying tunebooks do.
-
Going well! Getting to grips with a tune called “Egan’s Polka†now with D-row basses. Interesting playing the basses at the right points around dotted quaver + semiquaver pairs! Having fun 😁.
Chris
Going back over the entire thread. Three things to mention:
1. Your "Frere Jaques" clip is spot on with a nice, steady pace. It sings...
2. Per the quote above, I consider it t'other way 'round. The melody notes relate rhythmically and are placed in relation to the pulse of the bass/chord rather than the bass notes fitted into the melody. Or you could consider it from either direction...but the building rests on the foundation, so to speak.
3. The diatonic box is a wonderfully tactile instrument. Keep your bellows well filled and squeeze until it pushes back at you.
Enjoying your progress reports.
-
I do agree, Dick. The bass notes define the rhythm and you fit the melody around that. I’ve found this very helpful as the rhythms get more complex.
Chris
-
I watched more of John Kirkpatrick's DVD last night. What an incredible player he is! Watching this is giving me all sorts of ideas about how I can take my own playing forward. And he's doing it all on a rather ratty old 1-row box with spoon basses! Just shows that you DON'T need to have an expensive instrument to be a great player.
Chris
-
I do agree, Dick. The bass notes define the rhythm and you fit the melody around that. I’ve found this very helpful as the rhythms get more complex.
Chris
I would qualify that somewhat...
The basses and chords could be said to define a structure around which to fit the melody, but the rhythm has to come from the meldody, not the basses or chords. A fiddle, or any other melody-only instrument, has no basses or chords, but a good player can play very rhythmically indeed. On a melodeon, it is similarly possible to play very rhythmically just using the right-hand treble end.
Sometimes the rhythm and the structure can coincide, but they don't have to.
-
I too agree with Steve.
It's an on-going argument between me and a box playing friend in our morris. Having danced to just a fiddle, or sometimes a well blown whistle it makes the point vividly that rhythm is melody driven.
-
...or it could all be interactive. On the diatonic box you also have bellows changes which participate in the rhythmic feel. And "feel" it should be.
As to dancing to whichever instrument, this is also a two-way street. Many here have owned to taking cues from the dancers for their playing.
The sum is one thing, but also a summation of factors.
-
I was taught to “accompany the best dancers†in the room. Exceptions made for any “creaky†Morris dancer 😉
One of my own nicest dance experience was 1am, Stéphane Delicq, at Gennetines. It felt like Stéphane was accompanying us! We varied a bit, and he did too 🙂 Then she “turned up†at Embraud, 2 weeks later 😃
… back to topic, but the method work for couple dance and Morris. Obviously in English sets, strict rhythm is required.
-
As to dancing to whichever instrument, this is also a two-way street. Many here have owned to taking cues from the dancers for their playing.
Attended a very interesting Zoom talk last weekend from a very experienced Morris dancer and player who said that in Morris it’s primarily the musician who takes his cue from the dancers rather than vice versa, because there’s a certain element of spontaneity in the dance, so the musician doesn’t know in advance exactly what the dancers are going to do in a given dance.
Chris
-
Absolutely right Chris.
Morris musicians spend their time watching feet, often the dancer leading at no.1 position, though not always.
They then have to start at a reasonable tempo and then adjust speed depending on how the dancers are feeling. There being a massive difference in speed between the last dance of the day on an all day tour, or a prestigious ceilidh spot at a major festival with adrenaline squirting out your ears.
Whatever the speed they produce the rhythm for the dancers which is the inspiration to dance.
The Morris musician is driven by the dancers and then in turn drives them. A complex relationship and not easy.
-
Art form for a musician, and six fools? 😉
-
Amazing feets of musicianship...
The first recording I made on 2-row was just me in the studio. For the second I brought dancers in.
-
it’s primarily the musician who takes his cue from the dancers rather than vice versa
In Dartmoor step dance competitions, by contrast, the musician sat on the wagon with his back to the dancers so he couldn't give anyone an unfair advantage.
-
True, but there is a lot of difference between Morris and step dancing.
-
True, but there is a lot of difference between Morris and step dancing.
...and between performance and adjudicated competition.
-
Indeed...
-
JK’s now into minor modes, scales, and chords. My brain hurts! I think this bit’s going to take several rewatchings. And he’s still only on the single-row instrument!
Chris
-
JK’s now into minor modes, scales, and chords. My brain hurts! I think this bit’s going to take several rewatchings. And he’s still only on the single-row instrument!
Chris
Chris...
A lot of that stuff I find to be best understood in hindsight once you've experienced its utility in the context of tunes learned. IME, progress comes in "quantum packets".
The first five or ten tunes take time, toil and sweat, but THEN...
In the next block of tunes you're able to begin to draw on what you've experienced, whether you notice similarities and/or differences. Leaps will occur, plateaus will occur, but the graph will look like a stairway over time. Onward and upward.
A good mentor will be able to help you choose tunes which contain incremental practical additions to help you on your way. When we're able to gather together again, a peer group or co-learner will enhance your experience. In the meantime, try a healthy ratio of listening : playing so you'll have a healthy idea of where you're heading.
Have fun, good luck.
-
JK’s now into minor modes, scales, and chords. My brain hurts! I think this bit’s going to take several rewatchings. And he’s still only on the single-row instrument!
Ha ha, that's why I called it an aspirational video. It is a great video to come back to repeatedly as you make progress and understand it more fully.
-
I started watching JK's DVDs last night. It's about 3h long on two DVDs and covered the extent of my current knowledge in the first 15m, so I think I'm going to learn a lot from them.
Chris
Ah Ha!!
So, I have a question about this!
I’ve been learning the DG on and off for a few months now and at the start bought the John Kirkpatrick “learning the English Melodeon†DVD as everyone said it was great.
I put it on and it launched straight into him playing some (very impressive) tunes one after the other: “This is called the something tune, plays the tune nicely at a nice pace, This is called the something something tune, plays the tune nicely at a nice pace etc...â€
As a beginner who could play one om-pah tune, slowly, it was nice to hear a melodeon played well, but no real help progressing me in any way.
Could I have bought an odd version (you said yours had 2 DVDs, mine had 1?)?
Does yours actually take you slowly/in a beginner friendly way through some tunes?
-
Sebwin -
My DVD box did include two DVDs. There were originally three VHS tapes in the series. The first DVD contains the contents of the first VHS tape and half of the second (all of the one-row stuff) and the second DVD contains the latter half of the second VHS tape and all of the third (the two-row stuff).
(It kind of sounds to me like you only have the second disc, because the first one does start off with him talking about the basics of the melodeon and demonstrating how to play a scale, etc. You're sure it's not hiding in the box or something?)
I wouldn't say John really goes particularly slowly through any of this stuff. I think the programs were made working on the theory that it was better to pack in as much as possible, relying on the viewer's ability to pause and rewind as much as they need to.
What I did was rip the DVDs to mp4 files on my hard drive (don't tell anyone! :|bl) and I use a video player like VLC to pause and even slow down the playback to really study the fingering at tricky points.
-
On mine, the first DVD contains “Part 1†and the first half of “Part 2â€; the second DVD has the second half of “Part 2†and the “Master Classâ€. JK certainly doesn’t show you how to play any tune in detail, but he tells you the titles and you’ll find the notation at any of the usual notation websites (I normally use http://abcnotation.com/ ). Like Jesse I ripped the DVDs to MP4 files for my iPad. Easier to watch that way and I can slow the playback right down to see the fingering more clearly.
Chris
-
AH HA!!!!
That makes so much sense!!!!
I was really excited to get it and, as a beginner, I thought it must just be me/my issue not picking things up as quickly as other beginners, but that’s EXACTLY what it felt like, like it was launching into a course halfway through at a surprisingly advanced level!
I watched it once or twice and then never watched it again and moved to the mallinson book.
I must have received an odd version with only one DVD (I paid full price for it new, but it was from music magpie so maybe something odd happened).
I really couldn’t understand why everyone was recommending it/managing so much better with it than I was (will see if I can buy another one).
Thanks!
-
I must have received an odd version with only one DVD (I paid full price for it new, but it was from music magpie so maybe something odd happened).
I really couldn’t understand why everyone was recommending it/managing so much better with it than I was (will see if I can buy another one).
Thanks!
It's available at John's on line shop
https://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/shop.asp
Near the bottom of the page. Only £15.00, which seems very reasonable and musicians can do do with our support.
-
That is good, I think I paid £19 before. Thanks will have a look.