Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Fred on March 19, 2021, 04:29:38 PM
-
Imagine a diatonic accordion with 2 rows, 2 voices, 12 basses, and 0 thirds.
To me this combination would make perfect sense.
https://dia.to/accordeons?field_marque_tid=All&field_rangees_value=3&field_boutons_mg_value=3&field_voix_md_value=2&field_registres_mg_value=All&field_anches_value=All&field_prix_value=All&field_poids_value=All&field_occasion_value=All
Why is this list so empty? Any good guesses from the hive mind that is this forum?
-
Reasonably similar to my Pariselle box, which is 2.6 rows and 14 basses with no thirds.
-
Imagine a diatonic accordion with 2 rows, 2 voices, 12 basses, and 0 thirds.
To me this combination would make perfect sense.
I wouldn't buy one.
I like my thirds, and to me the 'perfect sense' would be, and indeed is, a stop enabling the thirds to be switched in or out as desired and as the particular tune requires.
-
I reckon the motivatlon for 12 basses is having more flexibility, and you can expect correlation between people who want more flexibility on the right hand and those who want more flexibility on the left hand.
-
I have a 2 row, 2 voice, 12 bass, no thirds box
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxAvlyfrNbc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxAvlyfrNbc)
-
I reckon the motivatlon for 12 basses is having more flexibility, and you can expect correlation between people who want more flexibility on the right hand and those who want more flexibility on the left hand.
Might people not want more chords available for the keys they already play in, though? On a D/G a pull G and a push A would be handy, as well as an F# for playing in Em and Bm, the relative minors of G and D.
-
My 'old style' Dony has 12 basses, 2 voices, albeit with the extra 4 helper buttons, so nearly fit's the bill. It did have 1/3rds, but some tape sorted that!
The "extras" are an A on the Push, an F# on the pull an F on the Push and a Bb on the pull.
They are arguably wasted on me ( for now ) mainly due to lack of dexterity rather than ambition and not ones to hit by accident most of the time.
I do quite like the look of the more unisonoric layout of Clive Williams layout on the forum pages but don't know enough to know for sure yet. It seems to have a good deal of logic to me.
-
I have a pre-war Hohner type 'Organola' branded box like that in C#D.
-
The "extras" are an A on the Push, an F# on the pull an F on the Push and a Bb on the pull.
Similar to mine. I've got a push A, pull G pair, and a push F#, pull F pair.
-
Similar to mine. I've got a push A, pull G pair, and a push F#, pull F pair.
This is the normal Saltarelle arrangement
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5saltarelle.gif
-
I reckon the motivatlon for 12 basses is having more flexibility, and you can expect correlation between people who want more flexibility on the right hand and those who want more flexibility on the left hand.
What about those who want to have more flexibility on the left hand and a 2 voice right hand while having an as light as possible instrument (thus no thirds and no half row).
Is it really the case that this is so niche that almost no accordion maker constructs these?
-
Similar to mine. I've got a push A, pull G pair, and a push F#, pull F pair.
This is the normal Saltarelle arrangement
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5saltarelle.gif
Thanks - I didn't know that's where the layout had come from!
-
To my mind, if you have a two voice 12 bass instrument, it's the weight of the left hand end that makes the difference - so having a part row on the right hand isn't critical - and is so useful.
I really like both my 12 bass boxes, with thirds stops, but I'd be very happy to have no thirds and have even more basses if it didn't add much to left hand weight. But it wouldn't be my only instrument...
Julian
-
A third's stop fills onet of the gap and gives flexibiity.
Not sure why 12 basses on a two row aren't common. Not sure which basses would give the best returns, either.
-
Not sure why 12 basses on a two row aren't common. Not sure which basses would give the best returns, either.
I guess that in a sense push A, pull G is the "obvious" pair because that then gives you push and pull on G, A, C and D, and that's really useful. What you do with the second pair is more open to question, though. Some seem to favour F#/F and others Eb/Bb. Both useful for minor keys.