Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Winston Smith on March 22, 2021, 02:55:48 PM
-
"It makes sense to add a repeat to make it Ax2 Bx2 when playing."
Obviously taken from another thread, but this is something which has always bothered me. I've brought the subject (of A's and B's etc) up in different questions several times, without receiving an answer which satisfied my curiosity. The above statement has again tickled me, and makes me ask, "Why does it make sense?". What's wrong with playing it as ABAB; you still get to play each part twice, and in the order that outsiders (like singers, when it's a song) could recognise and join in, as well as keeping faith with the composer or the tradition.
Anyone?
-
Slippery slope. Pretty soon you'll be advocating for rearranging some of the notes!
(Sorry.) Is it a dance tune?
-
Unfortunately the way you have presented this, without the original context makes it difficult to interpret what the OP meant and therefore to answer your question.
Is the quote saying that you should play a repeat or just that in terms of notation adding repeat marks is an economical way of notating the tune?
-
Sometimes it’s best not to ask ‘why’.
https://youtu.be/36GT2zI8lVA
-
Melodeon goes in, melodeon goes out. You can't explain that.
-
Unfortunately the way you have presented this, without the original context makes it difficult to interpret what the OP meant and therefore to answer your question.
Is the quote saying that you should play a repeat or just that in terms of notation adding repeat marks is an economical way of notating the tune?
As I recall the OP found a tune notated without repeat marks, and commented that he'd added repeats to make it AABB to bring it in line with modern style.
-
Here's the original quote: Some 'basic' tunes are in my opinion almost complete, it's just a case of your emphasis and making it your own with your personal expression.
Other basic tunes are less complete.
I expect we've all dug out the original dots and discover perhaps the basic tune had no repeat bars in. It makes sense to add a repeat to make it Ax2 Bx2 when playing.
I think we've all seen such tweaks to older tunes to 'bring them into the modern style'. Not a major change and suits our ear and idea of tunes we play.
Personally I swap around to suit my mood. I often play AB as AABB but more often I will cut the tune in half and play AABB as AB (one example would be Off To California, also The Sweetness of Mary).
As long as you're not playing for dance then it really doesn't matter and can be left to personal interpretation. It is folk music and as I've often said before "the music don't mind".
-
Hi Winston
I suspect there are a couple of reasons why it might be a good idea. One is to embed the tune into the ears - establishing it in much the same way as a repeat in the classical period is now ignored, because we can relisten at will, but first listenings are important to get each part... not just to learn it to play, but also to grasp the differences between the sections for any audience. But also because repetition builds expectation. If you listen to a minimalist piece (take Electric Counterpoint by Reich) the groove builds up then repeats, and the release into the key change is of psychodelic proportions.
Listen to the start of the 3rd movement, and hear the eventual key change at 12.40;
https://youtu.be/MOAS6ik796s?t=624
But also, more simply, depending on the tempo and time signature, the A section might just be too short to feel like a completed episode.
I'm not saying it's the right thing to do, or the only thing to do, but that's why it might be done.
-
Well, as I said it, I'll jump in.
I think it is much as p&t says, expectation.
We seem to be in that habit nowadays of playing Ax2 then Bx2.
If I'm sat in a session and listening to a tune new to me, it is a great help. The repeat helps me put the tune together piece by piece. I tend to latch on to a phrase or string of notes, and as it comes around again in the second A then have I got it right?
Oh, right, I think the next bit is...
As Rees says absolutely nothing wrong with AB and AB again.
In old manuscripts often the repeats aren't there. The manuscripts creator's habit, or the habit of the day at that time.
Just where I am, the habit nowadays and therefore expectation is Ax2 then Bx2.
-
It's just a way of making things more predictable. Personally, I rather like them less predictable or, at least, less regimented.
We have lots of structures. AAB and ABB are two that come to mind.
We usually play Ring O'Bells the way we play for dancing: A BB A BB AA BBB.
-
As Greg says, it will change to fit a Morris dance, to allow the dance to work.
I think ( though am not certain ) that my ceilidh band and caller friends work in Ax2 and Bx2 unless the dance being called dictates otherwise. Then the formula will totally depend on the dance being called.
-
Playandteach, your answer about classical music repeats is really interesting to me and leads to other questions (like Feynman's "why"). Why are some classical repeats ignored and not others? The same questions of taste come up and it seems like a contentious question in the classical world. I'm reading about it now. It sounds like most of the interesting arguments (the ones not related to the length of a CD, or the attention span of listeners) look at the sections of music in question in terms of their narrative functions, like development, transformation, or exposition. A transformative development doesn't need to happen twice, so a conductor might leave it out with no harm to the piece's overall narrative. And some composers seem to have viewed repeats as most helpful to first-time listeners.
That makes sense to me. But with little folk tunes, we stop being first-time listeners almost immediately. As players we have the task of making the same expositions and transformations over and over, without losing interest. Development is clearly still important, but it takes places cyclically. If we want to create long-format development we have to use tricks like changing the dynamics, backing chords, voices and instrumentation, adding harmonies or variations, and so on. From one point of view, AABB gives you twice the options, because repeating a phrase allows you to respond to what you've just done, and develop it "in place" before moving on. Tunes with A1/A2, B1/B2 format do this by explicitly changing the endings, but there are other ways. ABAB structure still allows for development, but limits your options.
Put another way, AABB gives you these transitions: A->A, A->B, B->B, and B->A. ABAB gives you only: A->B, or B->A.
I think ABAB is sometimes great and has its own very useful character. There's something relentless about the constant transition between parts. I think it's often used to good effect in Irish music, when a single reel is used in a set, for example.
E.g. the role of "Drowsy Maggie" in this set from De Dannan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z9L_Ul8hHtk
The 4-part jig (AABBCCDD) functions as an opener, and you hear developments between the doubled parts, subtly at first, with varied ornaments, held notes, and so on. It's like the first movement of a symphony. The entire thing intensifies just slightly the second time around. Then there's a very emphatic transition, featuring only the bodhran. We're on the edge of our seats. A single reel explodes out the gate like a horse. As it gathers momentum, we see it's not a horse, but an airplane. Three times around is enough to lift off: it is now airborne (the double reel). They take full advantage of the various transitions occurring in the AABB format. Each one is a special event.
Very subjective territory here, but I think it can at least be said that the character of each form has its own function.
-
In the most common structure of large scale classical works it is the first section that gets repeated (normally we leave out this repeat though). Some people feel the need to keep the repeat in for two reasons: one is to do with the overall balance where the first section repeated is similar in weight to the following 2 sections unrepeated (they never are for harmonic structural reasons).
The other is to do with the little turn around figure which we otherwise never get to hear at all. In recordings some engineers insist on having two subtly different versions of the first section to edit if they are intending to release a recording with the repeat, others cynically use takes in any order to create the final edit.
The first section introduces all (in most cases) the main melodic material. The development section fragments these at will and creates new combinations of these motifs to go on a journey through keys.
The final section is all the main ideas again, but in a single key. So really the main reason for the repeat is like a magic trick: look at these ideas because in a second I'm going to cut them up into pieces and blow on them to make them form a whole again.
It isn't formulaic though (another thread) any more than a novel having chapters is necessarily a formula, and interestingly we've only labelled these ideas into a single form in the modern period. Although I'm really not a Beethoven fan, the journey from Beethoven 1 to 9 shows more in their difference than their similarity.
It's a bit like a jazz arrangement starting with the head, then the solos, and returning to the head.
-
If it's the tune of a song, it makes it a bit hard for anyone to sing along! And, after reading all these replies (thank you everyone) I still cannot see why it should be a good idea to change something (anything?) from an original ABAB to AABB. Other than personal taste, that is; but then why foist that onto everyone else as being normal?
Coming from a singing background, it would be a complete nonsense to sing two verses and then two choruses, in almost every case.
-
If it's the tune of a song, it makes it a bit hard for anyone to sing along! And, after reading all these replies (thank you everyone) I still cannot see why it should be a good idea to change something (anything?) from an original ABAB to AABB. Other than personal taste, that is; but then why foist that onto everyone else as being normal?
Coming from a singing background, it would be a complete nonsense to sing two verses and then two choruses, in almost every case.
I don't think anyone in the thread has advocated AABB as the only way to play tunes and certainly not when accompanying a singer. The secret is in the accompany part if someone is singing you are backing them not leading them.
Whereas for dance and therefore in most sessions AABB is the usual way to play tunes to get 32 bars to suit the dance.
-
Gonk,
One of the fundementals of any traditional music is the canon of songs and to a lesser extent tunes which individually remain stable over generations. The language and subject of the songs roots them in the culture and socio-economic environment of the people they spring from.
Don't conflate the living foundations (living because they are transmitted by live repetition in kitchen and classroom), and maintained by repetition, with the settings developed for stage and recording work by the big name bands and leading performers.
P
-
As Lester says, most of the tunes we are talking about and play on melnet are dance tunes.
-
If it's the tune of a song, it makes it a bit hard for anyone to sing along! And, after reading all these replies (thank you everyone) I still cannot see why it should be a good idea to change something (anything?) from an original ABAB to AABB. Other than personal taste, that is; but then why foist that onto everyone else as being normal?
Coming from a singing background, it would be a complete nonsense to sing two verses and then two choruses, in almost every case.
Some song tunes take being doubled up better than others. As has been suggested, many morris tunes were pop songs and for a corner dance you'd be playing 3 choruses. I can remember using British Grenadiers as a barn dance tune years ago and that always sounded wrong to my ear when played as 2 verses plus 2 choruses, mainly because each part already contains repetition so in effect you're playing each phrase 4 times.
-
Gonk, One of the fundementals of any traditional music is the canon of songs and to a lesser extent tunes which individually remain stable over generations. The language and subject of the songs roots them in the culture and socio-economic environment of the people they spring from.
Don't conflate the living foundations (living because they are transmitted by live repetition in kitchen and classroom), and maintained by repetition, with the settings developed for stage and recording work by the big name bands and leading performers.
Peadar, I apologize if it seemed I was holding up De Dannan as pure drop. Would it help the issue if I changed "Irish music" in my post to "music from Ireland?" (Sincere question.)
I interpreted Winston's original question to boil down to "what are the possible reasons that would motivate a contemporary player to take an ABAB tune and play it as AABB." My approach was to muse about my subjective experience of ABAB vs AABB in the form of a reel played singly or doubly. But I'm not trying to hold forth on ITM.
-
And what about ABBB?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oy8WWDKIn8c
Feynman is so right about answers to the question 'Why?' only making sense if answered within terms the questioner understands.
If dance is your frame of reference (Lester's answer) then the various AB combinations makes sense to you.
-
... but then why foist that onto everyone else as being normal?
'Foisting' seems a bit strong - this is really just suggesting a little standardisation. It's not a controversial suggestion either -as it mirrors a fairly common convention. Equally there's no compulsion to follow the suggested pattern of playing the tune - it is mere suggestion, surely?
'Foisting' something on someone suggests that the thing is inherently unwelcome and unpleasant as well as suggesting a degree of forcefulness. Perhaps something like, oh I don't know, just off the top of my head - let's say something like sending PMs to forum members with unsolicited zenophobic or mysoginistic content. That, to me, would be foisting one's views on others. Not simply suggesting that a tune might be played in a certain way.
-
The original comment was in the context of interpreting manuscripts. My take is that these were not intended as scores to play from but were muscians' aide-memoires. If they made an error or apparent inconsistency in transcribing it probably didn't matter, they knew what they intended. Or perhaps they weren't errors, and a "missing" repeat was deliberate and to fit a particular dance.
The 32-bar AABB "modern standard" is just that, and there are many tunes which have different structures, including much of Playford and many Morris tunes. Trying to force everything into this pattern I think should be avoided. It's one thing to consciously adapt a tune in order to use it for a dance, it's quite another to do it for no reason. To take an example, I deplore the tendency to play "From Night til Morn" as a 32-bar even in sessions, which loses the character of the extended version. Just don't.
I enjoy playing Walter Bulwer's version of "Off She Goes" with its 8 1/2 bar B part (a bar of 9/8 in an otherwise 6/8 tune). Get's 'em every time, and far more interesting than the usual version.
These irregularities and inconsistencies are one of the joys of traditional music. Make the most of them.
-
... but then why foist that onto everyone else as being normal?
'Foisting' seems a bit strong - this is really just suggesting a little standardisation. It's not a controversial suggestion either -as it mirrors a fairly common convention. Equally there's no compulsion to follow the suggested pattern of playing the tune - it is mere suggestion, surely?
'Foisting' something on someone suggests that the thing is inherently unwelcome and unpleasant as well as suggesting a degree of forcefulness. Perhaps something like, oh I don't know, just off the top of my head - let's say something like sending PMs to forum members with unsolicited zenophobic or mysoginistic content. That, to me, would be foisting one's views on others. Not simply suggesting that a tune might be played in a certain way.
Spot on, Helena.
-
Thank you for all these thoughtful explanations. Especially Mr Bailey and Little Eggy, as they both seem to get through!