Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Gonk on March 23, 2021, 09:09:54 PM

Title: Help identifying the key of a melodeon
Post by: Gonk on March 23, 2021, 09:09:54 PM
Hi all, I'm in an odd situation.  I bought this Venezia on eBay, and the seller told me it had an outer row in the key of D, and confirmed that it had a push D on the third button, outer row - so I thought I was buying a D/G.  I was looking forward to receiving it, because those are scarce here in the US.

The instrument turned out to be in another key.  The problem is, the seller does not believe me.  So if you have the time to share your expertise with them, it would be a big help to me.  I plan to share a link to this thread with the seller.

Here is a video of me playing it.  Thanks in advance for your time.  (The more replies the merrier, including duplicate answers.)

https://www.dropbox.com/s/b1j8yzacarjxo5w/2021-03-23-170121.webm
Title: Re: Help identifying the key of a melodeon
Post by: Eshed on March 23, 2021, 09:14:47 PM
That is without doubt a Bb/Eb box.
Title: Re: Help identifying the key of a melodeon
Post by: Dick Rees on March 23, 2021, 09:18:00 PM
Yup.
Title: Re: Help identifying the key of a melodeon
Post by: rees on March 23, 2021, 11:05:57 PM
Definitely Bb/Eb which gives a push D on 4th button not 3rd.
Title: Re: Help identifying the key of a melodeon
Post by: folkloristmark on March 24, 2021, 08:04:01 AM
If you were sold a dg on ebay and it isnt, if you are intending to return it then do so . To argue is to waste energy especially if the seller has limited knowledge. If you misinterpreted the D button it might be a different matter. If you did not pay much it might not be worth the bother.As I understand it if you raise a dispute the seller will have to accept a return or you will end up with it and refund by default, unless ebay goes against you, then you still keep the box.Better to do this through the resolution center.
Title: Re: Help identifying the key of a melodeon
Post by: baz parkes on March 24, 2021, 09:54:00 AM
On the plus side, Bb/Eb boxes are lovely...and growing in popularity this side of the pond...although being sold one disguised as a D/G is definitely not a good thing...
Title: Re: Help identifying the key of a melodeon
Post by: Theo on March 24, 2021, 10:29:33 AM
And it will have nice quality reeds and a lovely sound once it's had a reed overhaul.
Title: Re: Help identifying the key of a melodeon
Post by: Helena Handcart on March 24, 2021, 12:01:10 PM
If it's not as described then you have every right to return it - and it clearly isn't a D/G. I understand it must be frustrating if the seller is refusing to accept this so just thought I would share a similar experience. Back when I first started playing I decided I 'needed' a C/F box so purchased one from E-bay. When it arrived something did not seem right but I had neither the experience to say what was wrong nor the confidence to post here for advice.  I worked out for myself that it was not a C/F so dismantled it to take a look at the blocks as the seller refused to accept that the box was not C/F.  This changed when I shared the photos of the blocks - clearly marked A/D. At that point the seller decided it was worth more than they had sold it for and wanted me to return it.

I'd fallen in love with its grunty sound by then so decided to keep it*. I realise that your box might not be marked but on the other hand, well it worked for me and it might work for you as a very visual and immediate way of making your point.



* Said box, formerly named Erica-the-Red now residing in the states with one Mr G Chapin of this parish.
Title: Re: Help identifying the key of a melodeon
Post by: Chris Marriott on March 24, 2021, 03:10:19 PM
On the plus side, Bb/Eb boxes are lovely...and growing in popularity this side of the pond...although being sold one disguised as a D/G is definitely not a good thing...

I bought a Pokerwork advertised by a well-known and reputable UK dealer as D/G which turned out to be a C/C# box 😁. Names withheld to spare their blushes!
Title: Re: Help identifying the key of a melodeon
Post by: Gonk on March 24, 2021, 03:42:32 PM
Thanks for the replies, everyone.  I think this will give the seller enough context to help the situation resolve, one way or the other.  I agree with Theo that the box has its own potential!

The seller was gracious about inspecting the fingerboard, and opening the box to check the reedblocks for labels.  They didn't find any markings, and I forgot about the listing for a few weeks.  Then they got back to me after testing the notes and told me the outer row was D.  I don't suspect any intentional deception, just a mistake.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal