Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Dave Praties on April 15, 2021, 02:18:38 PM

Title: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Dave Praties on April 15, 2021, 02:18:38 PM
Breaking off/resting from making my G/C 2.5 row, to convert the Bb/Eb Club3Bs I got from P&T of this parish, (Lovely instrument by the way - thanks P&T), to 12 bass with stops to remove 3rds and low reed. Here is a picture of progress. New fondo in, registers and stops in, and first reed block made. I aim to change the tuning to match my Mory, and keep it at work as a practice instrument.
Dave
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Squeaky Pete on April 15, 2021, 03:16:13 PM
Looking good.
How are you dealing with the air button?
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Dave Praties on April 15, 2021, 03:27:15 PM
A good question Pete! I will need to re-route the rod from the button, as it will currently foul the extra action rods at that end. I have an idea of how I will do it in my mind, but not an exact plan. I'm sure it is possible one way or another though. Will post pictures when I get round to it.
D
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Squeaky Pete on April 15, 2021, 04:47:57 PM
I removed the pivot, button and spring and just drilled the extra holes. I intended to rebuild the mechanism but there appears to be enough left for it all still to work.
I may try to strengthen the bits before it gets played in anger.
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Dave Praties on April 15, 2021, 05:46:59 PM
yes, that's sort of what I had in mind. Have you finished your conversion, are you happy with it? Any pitfalls to look out for?
D
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Gonk on April 15, 2021, 05:54:40 PM
Dave, what a beautiful reedblock.
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Dave Praties on April 15, 2021, 05:58:16 PM
Oooh thank you! It is made from 6 separate pieces of walnut, shaped, glued together, then sanded to produce the taper. The separator is 1.5mm aircraft ply, which I think, looks a bit like an inlay. What doesn't show are the small holes to take the screws which will affix the reeds to an Olovisc gasket.
D
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Fred on April 15, 2021, 06:09:40 PM
Olovisc

I wonder if it's the same stuff that we used during the workshop to build our Pariselle boxes (allowing to screw instead of wax the reeds in place)?
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Lester on April 15, 2021, 06:15:58 PM
Olovisc

I wonder if it's the same stuff that we used during the workshop to build our Pariselle boxes (allowing to screw instead of wax the reeds in place)?
Yep
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Dave Praties on April 15, 2021, 06:17:46 PM
Probably is. I may have got the spelling wrong though. I get mine from Charlie Marshall. It is self-adhesive, and I find that it sticks nicely to a Danish Oiled surface, but also peels off nicely if required.
D
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: rees on April 15, 2021, 06:47:44 PM
and keep it at work as a practice instrument.
Dave
 

.............. I learned to play in a cheese factory. Twenty tons of cheddar produced every day.
I was on the nightshift as a maintenance engineer. Big empty steel workshop, great sound!
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Dave Praties on April 15, 2021, 06:52:49 PM
Ohhh, just the job! And free cheese to avoid night starvation.
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Lester on April 15, 2021, 06:53:54 PM
and keep it at work as a practice instrument.
Am I the only one with an emergency standby/practice box permanently in the back of my car?

Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Graham W on April 15, 2021, 07:18:57 PM
That's looking very nice.
It will be interesting to know if you notice any difference in sound quality between the reeds as mounted on the Walnut blocks as compared to Hohner blocks . . . .

Graham
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Matthew B on April 15, 2021, 08:05:11 PM
and keep it at work as a practice instrument.
Am I the only one with an emergency standby/practice box permanently in the back of my car?
My two field-work Liliputs currently live in the pandemic-isolation of my office to support productive procrastination while work-travel remains prohibited. 
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Dave Praties on April 15, 2021, 08:22:05 PM

It will be interesting to know if you notice any difference in sound quality between the reeds as mounted on the Walnut blocks as compared to Hohner blocks

It will indeed, this has interested me for a while. I have made the blocks for my DIY 2.5 row out of walnut, but not fitted any reeds yet. I may try some experiments with hard/soft wood blocks with the same reeds. My guess is that they will sound the same, but there mst be people here who can speak from experience - it would be interesting to hear from them.
Dave
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: rees on April 15, 2021, 10:20:03 PM
If there is any difference in sound it will probably be most apparent when reed plates are waxed in, i.e. directly in contact with the wood.
If screwed onto gaskets perhaps not so much.
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Graham W on April 15, 2021, 10:34:25 PM
It intrigues me too.  I suppose the ideal thing is to make new reed blocks out of different wood for a familiar instrument and swap the existing reeds to them for a direct comparison.
Maybe one day . . .
There are so many interactions going on between different parts of the instrument, different materials, dimensions etc though that I think it will never be a simple or entirely definitive answer.

I once had two Castagnari Riks, a Walnut DG and a much younger Cherry GC.  Each had a very different and distinct sound, and on swapping the reed blocks between them the distinctive nature or timbre of the sound stayed very definately with the reeds blocks (or reeds!) whichever case they were in. From which I took that the wood species of the case didn't make any difference that I could discern.

Doug Briggs uses Walnut and Sycamore for reed blocks, and his sound great to me.

It's all a mystery . .
Title: Re: Club 3Bs 12 bass conversion
Post by: Dave Praties on April 16, 2021, 10:57:36 AM
All very interesting stuff, and the experimenter in me is tempted to make matching, identical resonating chambers from a variety of woods, and with the reeds affixed with both wax and screws, then do a spectral analysis of the sound produced. (Perhaps it has been done?), But I would rather use the time to carry on making instruments I think. I worked for some years with a musical instrument academic who memorably said to me "If you want a violin with a particular sound, you go to a man who knows how to use a chisel, not to a man who knows how to use a computer", and I understand what he meant. Back to the workbench!
Dave.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal