Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: southernbelle on October 18, 2009, 12:06:05 PM

Title: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: southernbelle on October 18, 2009, 12:06:05 PM
My eight year old son plays a Hohner polkerwork melodeon D/G.It was his great grandfather's so it has sentimental value!He plays mostly trad irish but enjoys ballads,waltzes etc. He loves this box and we likes the sound of it.However, lately he is limited with certain tunes as he has no C natural.We are looking into getting another instrument but are unsure which.Someone recommended a C#D box while some say B/C.His Gran has a Mengascini B/C which she says is his to have whenever he wants it but it is much larger and heavier than his melodeon and to be honest it doesn't have that old sound of the Hohner polkerwork which he likes!All suggestions welcome!
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: george garside on October 18, 2009, 12:36:26 PM
IF your son has the chance of a  decent BC box for free go for it!  The mengasini may be heavier than the pokerwork but is far lighter than the large piano accordions that are played by many 8 year olds so the weight in itself should not present any problems.

george
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Theo on October 18, 2009, 12:52:53 PM
However, lately he is limited with certain tunes as he has no C natural.
Puzzled by this.  There are two C naturals on the G row, treble side, and a C bass.   Maybe its the low C nat that he is missing? 
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 18, 2009, 01:22:18 PM
Or an F natural?, if the Pokerwork has low notes instead of accidentals.

When I only had a Hohner, (aged 21), if someone offered me a free Italian box I'd have jumped at the chance!. Semitone tuned boxes like B/C and C#/D are very different to play than a D/G but they're prefered for Irish trad and chromatic so you'll not want for any more notes on the treble side, although the bass accompaniment is limited.

The Mengascini is free so it can't hurt to try anyway. As George said, the weight and size are nothing compared to a piano box and I'm guessing it's dry or swing tuned so you could have it tremolo tuned at moderate cost and it'll sound more like a Hohner. But if you want a Hohner for Irish then a Double Ray is the obvious choice, plenty of them about secondhand.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Owen Woods on October 18, 2009, 01:41:18 PM
Get him to have a go with the italian box. He may decide that he likes the sound, but the important thing is to see whether he likes the fingering or not. Playing a chromatic box is very different from playing a quint box and you don't want to spend lots of money on something which he may not get along with.

Although I'm a little confused by your post. Do you mean that he has a one row or a two row? Apart from your "D/G" comment it appears that he has a one row in D, which would explain the lack of C naturals. In which case your choice is between a chromatic or a quint, of which you would presumably choose a chromatic if he plays irish. As for tunings, I'll leave that for more knowledgeable people to advise! Bear in mind though that if he does have a one-row than virtually any two row box will be significantly bigger and heavier than the one he has at the moment.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Simon on October 18, 2009, 02:30:03 PM
Someone recommended a C#D box while some say B/C.
If he's used to playing single row the C#/D is much easier than the B/C.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: southernbelle on October 18, 2009, 05:38:52 PM
Hi,
Sorry Theo! Maybe it's a D Melodeon not D/G! From my limited knowledge of the box I notice when he plays high C in certain tunes it sounds wrong!Also when he plays tunes with a fiddler he has no low B so he substitutes with a high one. The comment about wet and dry is interesting! We don't want to look a gift horse with Gran's Mengascini,cost her a fortune, but it doesn't sound as charming as Old Grandad's polkerwork!We got a CD of Johnny Connolly playing single row Hohner polkerwork and wow!He knocks some sound out of it! I suppose an inbetween instrument might be what he needs before he gets his hands on that Mengascini.It could get left on the school bus!Thanks for all advice.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 18, 2009, 05:51:08 PM
When you say "1 row Pokerwork" do you mean the 114 1-row 4 stop like this...

http://www.hohner.eu/zoom.php?bild=./upload/bildpoolcms/gal00000109gr.jpg

Because that has 4 voices, (sets of reeds), and with all the stops open it gives a very big and distinctive sound and the other box commonly called a 1 row Pokerwork, like this...

http://www.ac-pfister.com/04140104.JPG

...whilst only having 2 voices has the reeds mounted in a particular way, (flat mounted instead of on conventional reedblocks), that also makes them noticeably louder and bigger sounding.

So unless you have the lion's share of 10 grand for an old four voice Paolo Soprani, you're not going to get a B/C or C#/D box with that kind of sound. I don't know if the Mengascini has 2 or 3 voices but at any rate will have a more refined "modern" sound and be more responsive and generally easier to play compared to a Hohner, particularly a 1 row 4 stop.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Theo on October 18, 2009, 06:08:12 PM

So unless you have the lion's share of 10 grand for an old four voice Paolo Soprani,

I thank that is a bit of an exaggeration. I've had a red one, 1950s built, advertised on my website for about 18 months priced at £1450, with not a lot of interest.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 18, 2009, 06:15:39 PM
Of course, silly me.

The way people go on about old greys makes me forget other ones exist.  ;D
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: LJC on October 18, 2009, 06:19:45 PM
Depending on the tune, you can use the playing higher octave on a one row to get all the lower notes you need in the key of the box.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Simon on October 18, 2009, 07:06:53 PM
Also when he plays tunes with a fiddler he has no low B so he substitutes with a high one.
That's a common solution for Irish music, also on tin whistle or flute. When the tune goes below the low d you usually jump up an octave a couple of notes earlier. So not just the missing notes, but a short surrounding fragment.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: LJC on October 18, 2009, 07:41:04 PM
What I mean to say is starting tunes an octave higher than written gives you all the low notes in the first octave to descend to. Common for melodeon tunes such as Old Morpeth Rant which goes down to a low fiddle G string. The first melodeon octave doesn't extend low enough to do this meaning you have to play starting on the middle G. It's a bit wordy to explain but quite obvious if you have an experiment.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: southernbelle on October 19, 2009, 02:24:50 PM
Hi, Melodeon Mom here again! Yes, It is the first model you showed,with the 4 voices.He has been using the higher octave to get the odd note he can't get below but not an arrangement of several notes as was mentioned in the post. He's following abc notation but seems to be able to play by ear too.He improvises pretty well. I think it is that 'refined' or 'modern' sound that doesn't appeal to him or us at the moment with that Mengascini.Maybe it is the tuning.Gran says she doesn't know what tuning the mengascini has she just wanted a BC box.It does sound kind of harsh to us though.She went on to play a Jeffries concertina and that Mengascini wasn't taken out much.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: southernbelle on October 20, 2009, 02:22:27 PM
What about a two row Hohner polkerwork? Would that give him the extra notes?I weighed the Hohner 4 voice it's 2 kg while the Mengascini B/C is 4  1/2 kg.Never mind the case! There doesn't seem to be a lot of C#D boxes available around here. He plays mostly at home with family but would he be unusual with  C#/D box among other players?
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 20, 2009, 03:02:17 PM
What about a two row Hohner polkerwork? Would that give him the extra notes?I weighed the Hohner 4 voice it's 2 kg while the Mengascini B/C is 4  1/2 kg.Never mind the case! There doesn't seem to be a lot of C#D boxes available around here. He plays mostly at home with family but would he be unusual with  C#/D box among other players?
The two row Hohner Pokerwork (note spelling) is an ideal instrument for a beginner. Would recommend a D/G box. It will have the C-naturals you need on the G-row.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Owen Woods on October 20, 2009, 05:00:43 PM
I believe that you can get chromatic tuning pokerwork boxes, but they tend to be rarer.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 20, 2009, 05:54:51 PM
Mr Wesson of this parish sells jen-yew-ine Hohner reedblocks in C#/D for £200 so you could get a used D/G Pokerwork fairly easily and for not that much and try out two systems with one instrument for a similar cost to one new Pokerwork. Again, the 2 row Pokerwork is a 2 voice so you won't get the big sound of a 4 voice 1-row with all the stops out.

I don't want to start another debate about the suitability of a D/G for Irish music but it would probably be best to go for a semitone system like C#/D or B/C for playing in Irish sessions.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: southernbelle on November 03, 2009, 03:14:57 PM
My son got the Mengascini B/C from gran and immediately started playing a polka !He was delighted with himself until he brought it to his tutor and realised he was playing in the key of C? He was using one row only so his tutor put some stickers on and he now realises he must cross over and back to play in the key of D!The tutor said to put away the Hohner 4 stop for a while.My son seems disheartened to be starting all over again playing the scale.So I tell him to play a tune on the Hohner and he's happy again as he was after making great progress on that old melodeon.I know he'd rather play the Hohner but not so sure the tutor would like to see it back!Might have to move to Connemara where the melodeon is the instrument of choice!
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Owen Woods on November 03, 2009, 03:21:35 PM
Tell him to stick at it and he'll get to grips with it soon enough. It's all push-pull and [biased] he'll get more out of playing a BC than he will a one-row in time [/biased].
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Theo on November 03, 2009, 03:55:12 PM
Get him to learn some tunes in A on the D one-row then the same fingering will enable him to play in G on the C row of the B/C.

Good A tunes to start on are: Britches Full of Stitches, and Athol Highlanders.  Both can be played entirely on one row in the keys I've suggested, and both are commonly played in A and in G!   That will let him see how the two systems are related.

Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Alison Scott on November 03, 2009, 04:23:43 PM
My son got the Mengascini B/C from gran and immediately started playing a polka !He was delighted with himself until he brought it to his tutor and realised he was playing in the key of C? He was using one row only so his tutor put some stickers on and he now realises he must cross over and back to play in the key of D!The tutor said to put away the Hohner 4 stop for a while.My son seems disheartened to be starting all over again playing the scale.So I tell him to play a tune on the Hohner and he's happy again as he was after making great progress on that old melodeon.I know he'd rather play the Hohner but not so sure the tutor would like to see it back!Might have to move to Connemara where the melodeon is the instrument of choice!

Hmm. I know I'm as biased as Ukebert in the other direction, but I do think it's rather a shame for someone who is playing and loving a one-row to go to a chromatic box (eg B/C) rather than the more intuitive quint box (eg D/G) which he'd be able to play straight away. Though of course not even a D/G Pokerwork will not sound as fantastic as a four-stop Hohner one-row.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Theo on November 03, 2009, 04:32:48 PM
.. rather than the more intuitive quint box (eg D/G) which he'd be able to play straight away.

I think that is very debatable that a quint system is inherently more intuitive.  I think it's strongly influenced by what you are first taught to play.  If you learn a B/C first the a D/G will seem counter intuitive too.   I know B/C players who tell me this is true for them.
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Matthew B on November 03, 2009, 06:27:23 PM
First: what a splendidly supportive mother you are.  Cheers to you!  And to Grandma, and Grandad, and everyone else who is supporting this young man's efforts. 

Second: It might be worth listening to the recordings of Dermot Byrne --- I believe he plays both C#/D and one-row instruments.  So both styles can coexist in a single musician. 
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: southernbelle on November 03, 2009, 07:04:35 PM
Thanks for all the tips!I've learned a lot. I reckon his tutor is a real trad Irish player and probably keen to get him playing  reels and would be someone who attends sessions.On one hand, if he's going to keep it up there's a lot to be said for getting used to the B/C system.On the other hand this little fella loves all music (Teddy bear's Picnic,waltzes,polkas) so he doesn't have any bias towards trad Irish! He could play forever on a single row D. I Am toying with the idea of Pokerwork D/G as suggested by Steve. At eight,he won't be playing at sessions for a long time.I,m from trad Irish background but wouldn't mind if he plays jazz on the box if he's happy!
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: southernbelle on January 27, 2010, 02:39:50 PM
Hi there, it's melodeon mom again.I posted October 18 2009 about the next step for a child enjoying a Hohner single row pokerwork D.
Since then he was making slow progress on Gran's full size B/C Mengascini using stickers to help him find the notes.
Meanwhile, he had a try of a C#/D 2 row 3 voice box made by Sean Garvey from All About Accordions in Dublin,Ireland.
He could play all his tunes straight away and the box was about  half the weight of the Mengascini.We went on to buy the 2 voice model from Sean Garvey and we are thrilled with the sound and quality! The little guy is playing away confidently.He has the notes he was without on the Hohner one row. The new box seems to have given him a new lease of life on the box and he's enjoying the fact that some B/C players are taking a while to figure the C#/D out!
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: Gandy on January 28, 2010, 08:26:45 AM
Good result!
Title: Re: Hohner polkerwork single row: what next?
Post by: nfldbox on January 28, 2010, 03:46:42 PM
This whole thread is just delightful. I have been a parent of three musicians, with the fourth just about to start. It often is a bit of a trial but the results can be so satisfying. I just heard my 30 year old daughter play the fiddle a couple of days ago and the sound was just gorgeous.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal