Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Rog on July 07, 2021, 08:45:08 AM
-
I’ve got a Saltarelle Nuage with a very fast keyboard, flat, easy to play.
Looking for recommendations on instruments with very fast keyboards. The Nuage is flat and the fingers easily slide across the rows, something I struggle with on a stepped kB or ones with more defined keys with more travel.
Obvs the quality of the reeds plays a biggish part too.
I’ve tried a fair few and not many come close to the Nuage (not even a Pastourelle). The Dinos I’ve played (and owned) don’t have particularly fast keyboards (in my opinion). The Tommys I’ve tried, ditto. A Serenellini I played once was brilliant, and lighter than the Nuage. As a comparison (sorry...) I also have a Pigini 30 key PA and the keyboard on that is super fast, quick and responsive, unlike many other PAs (Pigini are sort of the Casta of the PA world).
Obvs the player's ability comes into it too, but ...well..in my case let’s not go there on this post (:)
-
With regard to Dinos, my Oakwood Super 2 and Black Pearl 2 are chalk and cheese. The OS2 is fast and responsive with a very broad dynamic range. The BP2 is a lot more clunky, air hungry and more "on or off". Which is why the BP2 is my backup box and is not played that often.
-
I agree entirely with what Nigel says. Incidentally Roger, was the Serenellini you mentioned, mine that you had to change a couple of reeds?
Doug
-
Doug... (:) I suspect it was..
Come to think of it, the Oakwoods I’ve played are pretty d nice too. Must be the reeds as well as that kB. Not sure about paying OW prices though...
-
I'm always a bit perplexed when people ask if an instrument has a "fast keyboard". A fast response to the player I understand, but that is usually more due to the quality of the reeds and how they have been set up. That's why the Dino BP is less responsive than the Oakwood/Binci. The former has good midrange reeds, the Oakwood/Binci has some of the best reeds that money can buy.
You mention the ability to slide between buttons which is important if sliding is part of your playing style, and when I've asked potential customers what makes a fast keyboard they answer usually includes most or all of these four features: flat keyboard with inset buttons, low set buttons, short button travel, rounded button profile.
-
My Oakwood, van der Aa, Gaillard and 1984 Castagnari Lilly have all been “faster than meâ€; a larger Castagnaris (Mory) and an organetto felt slightly less fast, but not enough to matter. My Castagnari 2 row GC was also fine
Older hohners (I had eg a 50’s club) I felt a slight lag, ditto my 1983 pokerwork. but the main issue there was fingers going down the holes. 🥴 A real design fault? I support Theo’s opinion about flat keyboards
Keyboard response is a balance of cantilever mass, spring power and good design. The better makers get it right.
The reeds matter a lot, and you get what you pay for. Lowest octave low register solo reeds take a noticeable while to sound, however fast the “actionâ€. Both my larger boxes go down to Bb°. Both feel faster with LM voicing.
Either the M reed helps the L dynamic, or more likely perhaps me ear doesn’t notice.The Fourier frequencies as a reed starts up are predominatly in the higher harmonics, so that makes sense to me. So “attack†in playing a note, eg a tiny bellows pull … matters too
Hope this helps
-
I'm always a bit perplexed when people ask if an instrument has a "fast keyboard". A fast response to the player I understand, but that is usually more due to the quality of the reeds and how they have been set up. That's why the Dino BP is less responsive than the Oakwood/Binci. The former has good midrange reeds, the Oakwood/Binci has some of the best reeds that money can buy.
You mention the ability to slide between buttons which is important if sliding is part of your playing style, and when I've asked potential customers what makes a fast keyboard they answer usually includes most or all of these four features: flat keyboard with inset buttons, low set buttons, short button travel, rounded button profile.
I guess you’ve answered the question at the end there... inset buttons with short travel...plus probably flat rather than stepped. Stuff like button spacing is more a personal preference thing. It is surprising though how big the key travel is on many melodeons.