Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Jack Humphreys on August 02, 2021, 12:52:36 PM
-
VALSE DOUZE 12-bar waltz
https://youtu.be/yfhLa_Mip_g
It's only the A music which has 12 bars, instead of the usual eight.
I usually make up my tunes while walking on holidays, then have to work out how to play them on the box. But this one was made up directly on the box. Still, it was tricky to learn that bass movement from (DG fingering) B flat to B natural. After finalising the tune I was pleased to notice that the B music starts with a slowed-down version of how the A music starts. Played with silent metronome and Bando voicing (ML) on Clem 12 CF from Accordeons Guais.
-
That's a lovely piece of music Jack. Beautiful chord sequence.
-
Thanks Smiley. Appreciation much appreciated!
-
Fabulous, Jack. In there with the French maîtres. It had really subtle but complex minor cadence, and I felt for you in some of the changes. Real drive, at Fench speed, and “on their side of the road†😉. You made me want to get up and dance.
Be proud. You should try that in the concourse, if you get back to Château sur Allier.
-
That's a really great tune with a lot of swing to it.
Although it's not totally off, I'm not so sure about your chord choice in the fifth (?) bar of the B part.
Do you have it written out somewhere? Asking because I currently can't access your google site with your composition uploads which requires a login.
-
Dm9 on Bb bass is the “lydian†chord. A favourite of mine (eg as Am9/F). Not sure where the B note came, it’s all a bit fast to get the passing notes. Your left end’s also rather different from mine! I’d be interested in seeing its grille too, in due course, but it works for me.
I felt it a nice example of the harmonic line passing into tension, before resolving. The timing is good too. It “informed my feet†👍
-
Lovely tune to start my day. Great.
Julian
-
Many thanks for your enthusiasm and detailed listening, Chris, Fred and Julian.
Playing and practising is rather solitary these days, and it makes all the difference to know that you and others are listening and appreciating.
Fred, the slightly odd chords in the B music are deliberate, in my quest to avoid clichés. It's probably well outside the tradition, though.
Here's a photo of my scruffy notebook, written as if for a DG box.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1kxZGkUdk3eIE1b9dqBWkvHdISOM8tUcb/view?usp=sharing (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1kxZGkUdk3eIE1b9dqBWkvHdISOM8tUcb/view?usp=sharing)
The chords in the B music are as follows, two bars for each (DG fingering)
They are neutral chords, not major or minor.
G D F C; G/Bb G/B C B
I guess it was that F chord that sounded a bit odd, Fred.
It was made up intuitively, but, in hindsight, I think of it like this:
Starting the B music with a I-V in the relative major key (G ): G - D
Then sinking a tone lower to another I-V in the key of F: F - C
Then I'm not sure how to theorise the rest :-\
Thanks again guys!
PS
Thanks Fred for telling me my compositions site is inaccessible. I've now changed it to open access.
-
Nice Jack.
-
It’s called functional harmony*. Borrowing of chords from parallel scales, in the case above G major borrowing from G minor. Gm is the natural or aolian vi chord of Bb and you could look at the cadence from the either direction. ie Bb is the III chord of Gm. It’s very current in modern jazz, where you might use it to move your melodic line ‘out’. Jack is I think following his deep dance roots, in heading firmly back into his basis key.
There’s also a nice chromatic bass run going on, reinforcing the tension => relaxation. It’s lovely to my ear.
This is usually “thirds out†stuff . Jack, was that how you had your left end set up? Otherwise the rebased major chord 3rds become augmented 5th, and you have moved out of folk cadence. (Both my boxes have no thirds at all). Basically it’s the chord 3rds on left end, that anchor our music on the right end to main row keys. Though, that’s also a great strength!
These thoughts are in terms of Jack’s written out chords above. But - I heard the video as played in Dm? I was able to play along with it in that key yesterday 🤔
*Very similar things went on in TotM “Vasenâ€, February last year.
Edit: Seems that 3rds were “out†(P.M.)
-
Thanks Chris. My score is written as for DG fingering, though the box is CF. So it sounds D minor, though written E minor, and with neutral chords.
-
Valse DOUZE - con spirito:
Listening to it again, I thought my recording was a bit tame and quiet, as I was being so careful to avoid errors. So I've done another quick recording with a bit more life in it I hope.
https://youtu.be/RKVJMEwLCVY
-
That is such a nice composition.
Very atmospheric, with a lilting bounce to it.
Beautiful box, too.
Thanks. (:)
-
I really like that F chord, it doesn't sound out of place to me.
In fact the whole chord sequence in the B part is most attractive.
-
It’s called functional harmony*. Borrowing of chords from parallel scales, in the case above G major borrowing from G minor. Gm is the natural or aolian vi chord
Functional harmony as far as I teach it, is much simpler. Does the harmony contribute to the direction and / or structure of the piece? - Then it's functional. The exception is juxtaposition of chords as in the Chagall stain glass windows which use colour in a non functional sense. Most music we encounter uses harmony for structure or direction, very few are non-functional (think Debussy and parallel harmonies which by definition can't be functional). Still very nice Jack.
-
In West Yorkshire they have the Bradford Interchange. In music we have Modal Interchange, a.k.a. Borrowed Chords (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borrowed_chord).
-
When I hear such high quality compositions, played so beautifully, and discussed so knowledgeably on this forum I get confirmation that music is a vast ocean. Some swim and dive confidently in the deepest trenches. I’m happy to splash around in the shallows.
-
Functional harmony theory covers any “borrow†and tells you what “is legalâ€. It doesn’t even have to be same root note. I got into it substituting eg Bb maj, E maj, or Db maj triads where I might have had a G7 chord, it sounds chaotic and crazy, yet any order, any note even, the seeming Bedlam resolves onto C!
Mike’s wiki example refers to Picardy 3rd - the Churchy habit of ending a minor key song on a major chord. It’d picked that one up without any theory whatsoever.
It doesn’t tell you what “works†however. Or what “sounds goodâ€, and the latter is very contextual. For that you use “gutâ€. I’ve jammed with Jack and would suspect that’s how he got there, by having a good musical ear 🙂
Gosh, you can mix metaphores, too! 🤔
Edit in continuing my morning melnet perambulation I see that the Whitney event has a “finding the chords†class which looks to explore functionality in music, as well as the challenge of doing that on a limited and predominantly modal instrument. See Chris Marriott’s thread, elsewhere, today.
-
"I’m happy to splash around in the shallows."
Whilst I'm full of admiration for these folk who actually know what they're talking about, and therefore what they're trying to accomplish; I'm happy to watch the swimmers and divers from the carpark!