Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Yooval Mann on August 09, 2021, 05:45:45 PM

Title: strange recess on the Hohner 114's growl box
Post by: Yooval Mann on August 09, 2021, 05:45:45 PM
hi
I have a Hohner 114, and it has a strange recess on the growl box between the strap and the melodeon, I would like to understand why was it designed that way? I'm used to have my left palm pressed against a flat surface (like in my B/C boxes) and it feels awkward to me to have it pressed against a recessed surface... so I'm trying to understand how was it supposed to be used or what was the thought behind it?
and whether I should fill it up with something...
thanks!
Title: Re: strange recess on the Hohner 114's growl box
Post by: Lester on August 09, 2021, 06:09:48 PM
It's specially installed by Hohner to make the growl box uncomfortable. I usually fill it with a cut off from a camping mat (https://www.halfords.com/camping/air-beds/halfords-camping-mat---blue-744593.html?istCompanyId=b8708c57-7a02-4cf6-b2c0-dc36b54a327e&istFeedId=367c5610-f937-4c81-8609-f84582324cd6&istItemId=wmqpxpiiq&istBid=t&_$ja=tsid:94971|cid:868555882|agid:49387673412|tid:aud-297219197969:pla-330964135153|crid:203456299380|nw:g|rnd:3996929090381934237|dvc:c|adp:|mt:|loc:1007211&gclid=CjwKCAjwpMOIBhBAEiwAy5M6YJuhxwhSI_5IR9JdJWZK5QlNFvjNSB3GUacdMGdIQ7C_7XiO21at7hoCabwQAvD_BwE), far more comfortable.
Title: Re: strange recess on the Hohner 114's growl box
Post by: Yooval Mann on August 09, 2021, 06:21:31 PM
lol camping mat?!?! does sound comfortable indeed!

other aspects of the design of the growl box making me think the engineers were interested in finding ingenious ways to make it uncomfortable, the spoons are too close to one another and I can't decide which finger to rest between them when ideally I would like to rest two fingers between them and operate the bass with pinky and second finger... so I place one finger down but because the spoons are so near there is  a danger the finger will get rubbed by the edge of the spoon... then the air button spoon  - I'm still trying to understand what's the advantage of having a spoon for air intake, I mean at least for the basses the spoons can create a wawawa effect which is quaint but for the air intake? what is the preferred way to press that air intake spoon?

so all these things made me think maybe there is a special way to play that particular melodeon some special unique way of playing and then all these design choices make sense, even the recess
Title: Re: strange recess on the Hohner 114's growl box
Post by: Lester on August 09, 2021, 06:26:56 PM
I rest my thumb on the growl box and operate the air spoon with the fleshy part where my thumb meets the hand. I operate the bass and chord spoons with my pointer and ring fingers. Will take a photo after we've eaten
Title: Re: strange recess on the Hohner 114's growl box
Post by: Yooval Mann on August 09, 2021, 06:31:59 PM
Bon appetit and thanks a million!
Title: Re: strange recess on the Hohner 114's growl box
Post by: Lester on August 09, 2021, 06:33:20 PM
Here you go, if you can make it out.
Title: Re: strange recess on the Hohner 114's growl box
Post by: tirpous on August 09, 2021, 06:35:07 PM
It's just the structure of the box: the 4 sides are grooved and the top panel is glued in the groove.  This construction goes way back to the old German-made one-rows of the early 20th century.

Usually in playing, the hand cradles the box with contact mostly at the edges so the hollow does not matter.  The thumb, middle and ring fingers pinch (or torque) the sides of the box and the back of the hand is backed by the strap (see pictures).  Index, small finger and base of the thumb operate the spoons.

(oops - just saw Lester's replies but I'll post anyway...)       
Title: Re: strange recess on the Hohner 114's growl box
Post by: Yooval Mann on August 09, 2021, 06:45:07 PM
superb thank you gentlemen
Title: Re: strange recess on the Hohner 114's growl box
Post by: chris hall on August 09, 2021, 08:38:57 PM
ive used black self adhesive EVA foam. feels great and looks smart. you can use a few offcuts under the spoons to stop them clacking onto the woodwork. limits the spoon travel which to me feels better but to others it might not. back in the day oscar woods used cigarette packets for same job but i don't smoke.
Title: Re: strange recess on the Hohner 114's growl box
Post by: Mike Hirst on August 09, 2021, 08:44:14 PM
oscar woods used cigarette packets
In my younger days I did experiment with woodbine packets, but, like Bill Clinton, I never inhaled.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal