Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Nigel Champion on August 29, 2021, 02:07:13 AM
-
I made the mistake of buying a new Salterelle C#/D/G Cheviot in the early '90s (Note for those not familiar with this particular model: despite being a 3-row externally, internally it has only 2 reed galleries).
Its compact size may be an advantage but the downside of that is the variable tone/tremolo due to the lack of cantilevers, and the problem shown in the attached image. The bass galleries extend into and are too close to the bellows causing the leather valves to become trapped in the folds of the bellows. As a result, they stop functioning as valves and might as well be removed!
Has anyone come up with a solution to this problem that they are willing to share? The only option I've considered is fixing a thin plastic sheet (ie. polyester OHP) to limit the travel of the leather valves. I'm wary of anything sliding along the bellows folds but polyester sheet should minimise wear.
I'm in New Zealand so pretty much on my own as regards repairs & modifications. I really appreciate the collective wisdom of Melodeon.Net and would welcome any advice or shared experiences.
Keep on squeezing
Nigel
-
On some PAs (older Hohner models) there is a wire rail (about the thickness of coat hanger wire) run parallel to the reeds and preventing the valves from catching the bellows folds. It’s normally about 2/3 of the way up the reeds/valves. It’s U shaped......kinda this shape. L__________I ....with the ends screwed to the ends of the reed block. The wire might be a bit thinner than coathanger wire. You can fashion a little loop on each extremity to put a screw through. This does solve your specific problem. I don’t have one immediately to hand to send a picture...but if I see one (I need to poke about in the umpteen PAs I’ve got, I will post a pic. It’s often quite close to the valves and this is ok...it need obvs not to hinder the swing of the reeds.
-
Given the lack of space (due to an incomprehensible design flaw) I doubt that the coat hanger approach would solve the problem. The wire rail itself will most likely get caught in the bellows folds. The only possible improvement I can see would be to taper the reed block sole in order to slightly alter the angle. Of course there is a certain limit, as you don't want to get too close to the other block. I'm afraid in addition to that you will also have to adapt your playing style and avoid certain bellows movements.
-
How about putting helper springs on the valves, or would they necessarily hinder the valves from opening properly?
-
I can not comment specifically on your box but Hohner liliputs suffer a similar fate use care to mount each reed and slightly shorten them This may lead to a gap that in theory effects performance but in reality may not and is better than no valves.
The lovely growl you get on these bases is often due to this and a lot of people really like this lack off or bellows curled valves, many of whom if they were or become aware of this would be the first to replace the valve.
I replace the valves but if a liliput is used a lot most often its like an oil change in a car it becomes part of the regular maintenance
schedule.
Its advantage disadvantage of small format box .What the eyes don't see the heart doesn't mind
If they come off experiment with the various solutions here I doubt you will get any tuning issues in reality if you don't move the
reeds. These valves are prob the easiest to work with and if they are fouling bad then you are forced to act.
The major thing is avoid getting glue on the reeds .You can adjust their lift by increasing the glued area further to the tips. If it don't work just revert to what ever. Experiment with different leathers repurposed leather reclaimed from else where even , if you don't have a selection of bass valves.
-
Once you have a good set of new valves that lie flat then you can keep them in good condition by being aware of the bellows technique and keeping bellows movement in a straight line so the bellows stay straight and parallel.
-
and keeping bellows movement Jin
Can we all call up a bellows movement Jin, or do they only answer the call of fettlers?
-
I have an older 3-voice Paolo Soprani in which the 4 lower reed plates on a (treble) block adjacent to the bellows have been mounted 'rivets up', presumably to solve a similar problem.
-
I'd put very thin boosters (spines) on those valves. Metal ones.
Another alternative to the metal rail, as posted by Winston in another thread, is to have strips of a somewhat flexible material glued to the top of the block and at the base. This is less likely to get caught in the bellows in the tight space.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,26994.0.html
(In my opinion this one is a little inelegant; I wouldn't personally attach the strips at the base of the valves as that maker has done, but lower down, closer to the foot of the reedblock.)
-
Many thanks for the responses; they are all much appreciated.
Roger, I'll check out whether your suggestion of a rod across all the leathers is feasible. I have more elegant (and straighter) rod than a coat-hanger maybe even a flat strip. I doubt there is room on this particular box but there might be a sweet spot that works.
Thanks for the pointer to that post, Gonk. Like you, I'm surprised at those lower attachment points plus some of the strips are much too close to the leathers! This is similar to what I envisage with a single piece of thin polyester for the whole gallery. The sheets used on old obsolete OHP projectors are thin, strong, and durable but will accept a crease where needed. If attached carefully, I doubt this would rattle or muffle the sound.
It's obviously time for new leathers so I will consider increasing the glued area, adding boosters, thicker leathers or even artificial alternatives.
Nigel
-
I have coincidentally just a couple of days ago encountered this same issue on another Saltarelle, a Pastourelle 2.
The valves on the third octave (and one 4th octave) bass reeds had all got tangled up in the bellows. I considered angling the Reed block slightly inwards but clearance between the two blocks is itself pretty minimal so this risks just create a different problem elsewhere.
Why on earth didn’t they simply make the instrument a few mm wider!?
The owner is a very gentle player who has owned it a long time and not been concerned about the bass before - so new valves, rewax and see how it goes for now. (And he is aware of the issue now. . .)
There are lots of these around so I imagine it must be a common problem? But then I’m often amazed at how tolerant many players seem to be of instruments that are desperately in need of attention, so perhaps people just don’t notice or mind?
-
Whenever I see see this I assume it’s because the bellows weren’t put back on with due care (it’s easy to catch the ends of the valves).
I have also seen straps (made from strips of bellows tape the same thickness as the valve i think) with one end glued to the valve and the other looping up and glued to the edge of the reed block. I did a double take the first time I saw it.. but it’s not that uncommon.
Also...an L profiled strip screwed to the top of the block and dropping down over the reed ends. The critical clearance is the outside reed max oscillation.
If you can fit a preventer mechanism on the outside valves, and this doesn’t extend anymore than the max swing of the outside Reed (or, actually, a bit less than), this ought to work...because when this valve is opening it’s the inside reed that is moving and it will barely escape from the slot...and the valve need only be slightly clear of this, which won’t be as much as the max oscillation of the outside Reed.
If the Reed was actually striking the bellows you would hear it...and I assume the maker actually got this right.
Personally I’d not reduce the top of the block because you will mess up the clearance of the inside Reed within the chamber (you will be reducing the clearance).
Of...fit new valves with decent return spring/stiffness..and this ought to work really. Some people don’t put glue far enough along the big valves...so they flop. You need to get that bit right too.
-
I play the Cheviot's twin, the Saltarelle Connemara II ... both compact 2 voice instruments and the same body dimensions and the only real difference is that the 27 buttons of the right hand are arranged 12,11,4 rather than the 10,9,8 of the Cheviot.
The valves *are* prone to getting trapped in the bellows folds, especially those of the chord reeds on the left hand ... but I take issue with those that say this is a design flaw ... the dimensions being this small are critical to being able to play this instrument effectively on the push and pull (which lets face it is what makes diatonic instruments distinguishable from bisonoric accordions) ... I know from experience that at just slightly bigger bellows cross sectional area than a pokerwork these are right on the cusp of becoming unwieldy to play in that style.
The advice from others on how to address the situation is all very good ... I survive by having bought a personal supply of valves and replacing them whenever they foul in the bellows enough to cause a noticeable effect on the sound of the reeds.
I wanted to post this to challenge the idea that a melodeon made this way is intrinsically bad ... suggested by the OP and encouraged by diatonix (love you man) and Graham W ... be very careful making bold sweeping statements like that ... we all have different criteria for what constitutes a good box ... and minimising bellows cross section area to allow a) very high pressure on reeds and b) ease of playing on a single row is sometimes more important to a player than other considerations ... including the occasional fouling of reed valves.
Cheers
Squeezy
-
I play the Cheviot's twin, the Saltarelle Connemara II ...
The valves *are* prone to getting trapped in the bellows folds, especially those of the chord reeds on the left hand ... but I take issue with those that say this is a design flaw ... the dimensions being this small are critical to being able to play this instrument effectively on the push and pull...
I wanted to post this to challenge the idea that a melodeon made this way is intrinsically bad ...
... including the occasional fouling of reed valves.
Cheers
Squeezy
Thanks for your comments, Squeezy.
Sadly, in my case the fouling of the reed valves is not occasional. Another annoying aspect of my Cheviot is the absence of a cantilever action. This causes a difference in "timbre" & tremolo, depending on whether there's a short lever or a long one, that drives me crazy - my D row has half of each. I'm seriously considering retro-fitting a cantilever of my own making!!!
Keep well and carry on squeezing
Nigel
-
I have coincidentally just a couple of days ago encountered this same issue on another Saltarelle, a Pastourelle 2.
The valves on the third octave (and one 4th octave) bass reeds had all got tangled up in the bellows. I considered angling the Reed block slightly inwards but clearance between the two blocks is itself pretty minimal so this risks just create a different problem elsewhere.
Why on earth didn’t they simply make the instrument a few mm wider!?
The owner is a very gentle player who has owned it a long time and not been concerned about the bass before - so new valves, rewax and see how it goes for now. (And he is aware of the issue now. . .)
There are lots of these around so I imagine it must be a common problem? But then I’m often amazed at how tolerant many players seem to be of instruments that are desperately in need of attention, so perhaps people just don’t notice or mind?
That really does surprise me. I've had my Pastourelle 2 from new in the 1980s, and never had this problem (I've had others, but that's several other stories!). I've played it in loud bands, in sessions, outdoors for morris and quietly for listening in folk clubs. I think of my style as "economical"; I try not to open the bellows more than one-third unless it's REALLY nececesary, and also try - though not always successfully - to keep my bellows movements as close to a straight line as I can.
-
The way you move the bellows can make this better or worse. Ideally move the bellows without curving it which reduces the clearance between bellows and reed block.