Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Luke Hillman on August 30, 2021, 12:59:12 AM

Title: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Luke Hillman on August 30, 2021, 12:59:12 AM
Hi everyone! I rely completely on my bike for transportation out here in California, and for the most part it suits me perfectly well. We've lately been having outdoor, distanced morris practice in a park, and so I'm lugging my melodeon in a backpack and my concertina in a pannier. I would dearly love to find a pannier, or some other method of carrying the melodeon, that doesn't involve it being on my back while pedaling up my hill at the end of the day. Trouble is, most panniers aren't really melodeon-shaped. My box is pretty small—just a two-row Baffetti/Oakwood—but it won't fit into any of my panniers alone, much less in its padded gig bag.

Figured I'd ask here before trying to devise a custom solution: do any cyclists on the forum have recommendations for a large pannier or other melodeon-carrying apparatus?
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Jesse Smith on August 30, 2021, 03:41:09 AM
A few months ago I took my Pokerwork in its hard case to a park via bicycle, by putting the case on the rear rack and lashing it sufficiently tight with bungee cords. It didn't slip or anything, but when I unloaded it at the park and took the melodeon out, the treble grille fell off! The vibrations had rotated the little screw eyes that hold it on. Luckily, there weren't any issues with the reeds or anything else. Despite the vibration issue, that's probably the simplest way of doing it, if you have a flat rack on the back of your bike.

I can't imagine any kind of standard commuter's pannier fitting a melodeon in a gig bag or hard case. Maybe a larger pannier like on a heavy-duty touring setup, but then you are talking about low-rider racks, etc.

By the way, Norfolk dulcimer player Billy Bennington was nicknamed the Barford Angel, because he would ride his bike to the pub with the dulcimer strapped to his back like angel wings.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Jozz on August 30, 2021, 08:48:29 AM
I have hauled a 32-bass weltmeister in its gigbag in a 50 litre "newspaper" pannier.

This was totally an emergency and not something I recommend should you have lots of bumps on the way....

I also had it sit on a kid's front bicycle chair (type without side arm rests), then it doesn't gets tossed around that much.

But for the most part, I simply carry it on my back.

Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 30, 2021, 10:49:12 AM
Took my Lilly as far as Italy in a motor cycle (sealed) pannier.

Teenage son on the back too!

Rain ingress is an important issue here
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on August 30, 2021, 11:32:41 AM
Like Jesse, I've strapped a well-padded gig bag to the top of the rear bike rack on a few occasions without problems. To my mind, it is also a slightly safer place for an expensive instrument than hanging on the side. (When I owned a Lilliput and a Lilly, either would fit in a large pannier but I found it safer and comfortable to carry them in a backpack)

If you are keen to have a pannier,  I would look at finding someone to make a custom job for you. Quality pannier fittings are available from Ortlieb and Rixen & Kaul. Something similar to the Ortlieb pannier design of the right size should be a comparatively simple construction. I presume rain is less on an issue in California than it is in the UK!!!!!
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Gena Crisman on August 30, 2021, 11:47:38 AM
I bought a metal folding pannier basket that was the right size to fit one of the Fuselli gig bags into - I was commuting to practice with a black pearl 2, which is modestly small, and fit I think the 2nd smallest fuselli bag Acorn sold at the time? I have since had to get a slightly bigger, 8-12 bassi size (according to the label, & also fuselli) bag due to a change of instrument, and, I don't believe the newer one fits in, at least not as comfortably.

It was a Giant (brand, not size) Metro folding pannier basket, but, I think they've discontinued it now. For the time being, this uk based online retailer is selling some, so you can get an idea of price/what it looks like: https://www.pedalpower.org.uk/products/giant-metro-folding-pannier-basket (nb I've also attached an image because this post will likely outlive that website's listing)

It does weigh quite a bit, though, also that's on top of the gig bag itself as I still needed it in that. And, the basket had to be zip tied onto my rack to really stay in place properly as the suggested mounting hardware involved a large thumb screw jutting into the middle of the basket, so it became a permanent (and slightly weighty) fixture. It did work, though, and I pedalled to practice with it for a couple of seasons. Now it gets used for shopping.

Fitting the distance the box would have to projected from the side of the bike was always the problem, and, I had to actually email Giant to get the dimensions of the basket. I found very little off the shelf that would easily accommodate either my gig bag or even just the box, and like Andy notes, I was often worried about it being there & projecting out as much as it did. The basket was metal though, so, that afforded it some protection, but it wasn't particularly rigid or anything.

Getting it off of your back is the best feeling, though, so, best of luck on your quest!
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: ACE on August 30, 2021, 12:41:02 PM
Get a front mounted rack and and add a crate or big basket, like the old butchers bikes. I carry mine in it's box or in it's gig bag. I can see it so no worries about it shaking loose. Mine also doubles up fetching my veg from the allotment.   forgot to say the crate I use is a plastic lidded one that holds melodeon, top hat, tailcoat, four pack and tankard.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Winston Smith on August 30, 2021, 01:17:35 PM
It's a lot easier to put it in the car.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Peadar on August 30, 2021, 01:42:40 PM
It's a lot easier to put it in the car.
On yer bike Winnie!!!
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Stiamh on August 30, 2021, 02:18:19 PM
My Double-Ray fits easily into an Arkel panier - an old model but similar to the Dolphin 32 shown on this page (https://www.arkel-od.com/bike-panniers/).

Not in case, but wrapped in a blanket inside a sturdy plastic rubbish bag it has done several hundred kilometres so packed, including several hours in driving rain.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: CAB on August 30, 2021, 02:28:55 PM
Just make sure it's securely in a case.  My policeman brother-in-law once attended an accident caused when an accordionist attached his instrument to the rear rack of his motor-bike and the bellows straps came undone as he was taking a bend.  :o
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 30, 2021, 06:17:45 PM
Was the accordion badly hurt?
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: CAB on August 30, 2021, 06:43:23 PM
Was the accordion badly hurt?
  ;D  I like to imagine it dismounting like a slinky going downstairs.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 30, 2021, 07:02:00 PM
Was the accordion badly hurt?
  ;D  I like to imagine it dismounting like a slinky going downstairs.

 ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Mark Anderson on August 30, 2021, 08:10:16 PM
Another option might be a bike trailer.  I have a Burley Nomad, which would easily hold a couple melodeons or concertinas.  It could easily swallow more stuff than you probably want to pull up your hill home.    >:E 

Downsides are that they're expensive-ish, though not much more than Arkel Dolphins (which are great bags) and storage at home, though the Nomad collapses down a little bit.

A cheaper option is to pick up a used kiddie trailer.  Folks often only have trailer-sized children for a few years and then sell the trailers on the cheap.

Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Luke Hillman on September 02, 2021, 03:24:29 AM
Like Jesse, I've strapped a well-padded gig bag to the top of the rear bike rack on a few occasions without problems. To my mind, it is also a slightly safer place for an expensive instrument than hanging on the side [...] I presume rain is less on an issue in California than it is in the UK!!!!!

I think this could work. The route from my house to really anywhere is quite bumpy though, and I don't have one of the bikes with shock absorbers, so I'm a little concerned with transmission of jolts from the rear rack. My current thinking is possibly to try attaching the gig bag itself to the rack like a pannier, and rig something up with a thick elastic or rubber tubing for the attachment points.

I bought a metal folding pannier basket [...] Giant (brand, not size) Metro folding pannier basket, but, I think they've discontinued it now. For the time being, this uk based online retailer is selling some, so you can get an idea of price/what it looks like: https://www.pedalpower.org.uk/products/giant-metro-folding-pannier-basket (nb I've also attached an image because this post will likely outlive that website's listing)

On behalf of future readers, bless you for attaching an image! I believe I probably have the same fuselli bag as you, so this might be just the ticket, if I can find a basket with the same dimensions over here. Seems like a good grocery basket too.

My Double-Ray fits easily into an Arkel panier - an old model but similar to the Dolphin 32 shown on this page (https://www.arkel-od.com/bike-panniers/).

This also looks like a possibility- thanks! It's surprisingly difficult to find a rectangular pannier that doesn't taper off ridiculously toward the bottom.

Thanks everyone, got plenty of ideas to try now. I'll post again if I somehow hit upon a holy grail solution.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Luke Hillman on September 02, 2021, 03:26:49 AM
[...] the crate I use is a plastic lidded one that holds melodeon, top hat, tailcoat, four pack and tankard.

All the essentials.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 02, 2021, 04:09:59 AM
Bags and boxes always strike me as ridiculously expensive - I've known a few that cost more than the content!  A lot will, pf course, depend on the style of bike and how it is fitted out.  The old style town bike is becoming more popular again now and I believe the modern versions are lighter than their forebears but still come with e.g. full mudguards and chainguard.  This type will probably accommodate larger bags and boxes before they risk rubbing or catching on any mechanism.  Probably also less sensitive about weight distribution. 

Although one's first thoughts are to mount luggage as low as possible, I'd hate to have my box mounted as a pannier load - it just seems too vulnerable.  On top of the rear carrier is probably favourite, though (now in my dotage) I'd expect to catch my leg on it a few times when dismounting...  Another option would be to fasten the Fuselli bag's top straps around the handlebars if that would allow it to rest on a front carrier or a substantial mudguard. 

Best of luck whichever way you go.  I once set off down a cobbled hill with a seriously overloaded rucksack.  Obviously I survived, but it proved to me that weight carried too high overcomes the directional stability of the steering geometry (even when sober)!

Rob.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 02, 2021, 07:45:21 AM
Another option would be to fasten the Fuselli bag's top straps around the handlebars if that would allow it to rest on a front carrier or a substantial mudguard.

Rob.

You need a Butcher's Bike, like Ger-Ger-G-Granville's for that
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 02, 2021, 02:24:16 PM
That's a very Anglophile joke for California! 

I'd agree that a butcher's bike is the perfect load carrier except that they weighed so much they may have been made of wrought iron and the small front wheel did nothing for stability with the reduced gyroscopic effect.  All told, maybe not what you want to peddle uphill at the end of the day.  It's a shame that no-one seems to have made something similar in a lighter form though.

Rob.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Bill Young on September 02, 2021, 03:07:21 PM
…It's surprisingly difficult to find a rectangular pannier that doesn't taper off ridiculously toward the bottom.

They taper to avoid your heel hitting them when pedalling. Look out for that if you’re thinking of fitting a large rectangular pannier to a rear rack.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 02, 2021, 05:51:06 PM
That's a very Anglophile joke for California! 

I'd agree that a butcher's bike is the perfect load carrier except that they weighed so much they may have been made of wrought iron and the small front wheel did nothing for stability with the reduced gyroscopic effect.  All told, maybe not what you want to peddle uphill at the end of the day.  It's a shame that no-one seems to have made something similar in a lighter form though.

Rob.

 ;D Open All Hours
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2dgYdMTg5Zs

How about something on the lines of this?



Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Anne Croucher on September 02, 2021, 07:57:13 PM
I put everything else in the pannier and carry my melodeon on my back - I know from long years of cycling through Sidmouth park in the pitch black that in an emergency I can leap off the bike and land on all fours like the proverbial cat, and leave the bike to its own devices. It has not yet fallen into the river, but there might come a time when it does.
Human musculature is a superb shock absorber, and having seen the damage which can be done to things jolting on the back of a vehicle, I would not risk a melodeon. 
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Luke Hillman on March 21, 2022, 09:21:09 PM
Just an update for any interested parties: I found one of these (https://www.greengurugear.com/products/freerider-31l-pannier) on sale at my local bike shop, and it works perfectly for the Fuselli bag I use for my Baffetti/Oakwood 2-row. Like a metal basket, it can collapse flat against the rack when not in use (though it's also easy enough to remove it), is very lightweight, and extremely loudly colored. Perfect for morris gigs, in other words! Pictures attached.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Mick on March 22, 2022, 02:16:33 AM
Looks like a good solution, Luke.

Would you mind sharing the maker / model of the carrier you purchased?

Mick
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Luke Hillman on March 22, 2022, 02:53:21 AM
Would you mind sharing the maker / model of the carrier you purchased?
It's a Green Guru freerider 31L. Link in previous post. Bit expensive on their site; you might be able to find it discounted at a local store.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Stiamh on March 22, 2022, 05:43:15 PM
I see now, Luke. When you said cyclists, you meant moped riders. >:E

Gratuitous snobbery aside, it looks like an excellent solution. 👍
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Lester on March 22, 2022, 05:49:23 PM
I see now, Luke. When you said cyclists, you meant moped riders. >:E
As an eBike rider I must disagree with your moped comment as the Gazelle is a pedalec bike which requires you to pedal to get any output from the motor.
There I feel better now  (:)
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Luke Hillman on March 22, 2022, 06:18:51 PM
I see now, Luke. When you said cyclists, you meant moped riders. >:E

Ha! When I started this thread, I was mainly riding my regular ol' human-powered commuter bicycle. The ebike was an indulgence after we got solar panels installed back in October, and I'm pleased to say I'm still managing to be car-free! (I still ride the other one, and my Brompton, when I'm not hauling groceries or multiple squeezeboxes).

Lester, thank you for your support ✊
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Mick on March 22, 2022, 11:14:13 PM
Just an update for any interested parties: I found one of these (https://www.greengurugear.com/products/freerider-31l-pannier) on sale at my local bike shop, and it works perfectly for the Fuselli bag I use for my Baffetti/Oakwood 2-row. Like a metal basket, it can collapse flat against the rack when not in use (though it's also easy enough to remove it), is very lightweight, and extremely loudly colored. Perfect for morris gigs, in other words! Pictures attached.

Thanks for the Green Guru link, Luke. 

Good to know it can work with a Topeak rack and bag which I currently have (and love).
I bike to the grocery and this could expand my haul as well.

Mick
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: rees on March 23, 2022, 08:39:06 AM
Here's my elegant solution.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Luke Hillman on March 23, 2022, 05:19:32 PM
Good to know it can work with a Topeak rack and bag which I currently have (and love).
I bike to the grocery and this could expand my haul as well.

The Topeak rack system is lovely, isn't it? The rack in the pics is actually the one that came on the Gazelle. I added a Topeak rack adapter so I could use my existing bags. The Gazelle rack has an upper and a lower tube, and I've got the melodeon pannier on the lower tube. Pics attached. I think you could make it work on the standard Topeak rack with some fiddling.
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: george garside on March 23, 2022, 07:40:17 PM
Here's my elegant solution.

presumably the only way to get one is  find one that sembody had dumped somewhere other than where it should be.  the noble art  of "aquisition" !
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Chris Rayner on March 23, 2022, 08:16:29 PM
One of these:https://www.cargocycling.co.uk/the-bikes (https://www.cargocycling.co.uk/the-bikes)?
Title: Re: Any cyclists have a perfect pannier for a melodeon?
Post by: Mick on March 23, 2022, 10:50:02 PM
The Topeak rack system is lovely, isn't it? The rack in the pics is actually the one that came on the Gazelle. I added a Topeak rack adapter so I could use my existing bags. The Gazelle rack has an upper and a lower tube, and I've got the melodeon pannier on the lower tube. Pics attached. I think you could make it work on the standard Topeak rack with some fiddling.
[/quote]

Thanks, Luke.  This reminds me that I need to follow up on my plan to make some of my own customized slide in inserts for my Topeak rack.

But I did just look at their folding "Trolley Tote" which could serve me a host of uses, and fit my Fusili box bag as well.

Mick
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal