Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Danny on September 03, 2021, 02:58:33 PM
-
Hi All,
Has anyone got a PDF file listing all the NOTES of scales and modes
I am playing C"D so all scales are relevant
Thanks
-
https://www.john-ferrara.com/media/sevenmodes.pdf Seems to be only the Greek classics.
But my advice would be to learn how each mode feels, where its characteristic/ sensitive notes lie. Unless you explore melodic and harmonic minor modes (another 12x 8 x 2 🥴) there are actually only 12 “scales†to learn. But 8 possible start notes.
In practice, on our instrument, it’s what works best against the bellows issues? And those bellows issues interact “musically†with a mode’s “sensitive notesâ€.
(sensitive eg’s the A natural in C dorian, the F# in C lydian, the Bb in C mixolydian)
-
Hi Danny
I wouldn't worry too much about what notes make up what modes starting on every possible note. After all in trad we only use a few modes starting on a small number of notes.
But I would say that learning all the 12 major scales at first, and then minor scales, is a very good idea for mastering your keyboard. While I don't have a chart handy, it wouldn't be hard to make one. But I did make a start on videos exploring major scales on a C#/D box. They might be useful.
G, A and E major here (https://youtu.be/0oNhYV9rAAw)
B, C, F and Bb major here (https://youtu.be/T6Xc6wRsmsg)
-
The seven diatonic modes are simply a matter of playing the normal major scale beginning at a different note. Eg for a C Major scale, you'd normally play it C-D-E-F-G-A-B-C, and this is also called the Ionian mode.
Play it D to D instead and you have the Dorian mode.
E to E is the Phrygian mode.
F to F is the Lydian mode.
G to G is the Mixolydian mode.
A to A is the Aeolian mode, which is the natural minor of the scale. This is why A minor is the relative minor of C major.
B to B is the Locrian mode.
It works the same for all twelve major scales. Just play the usual notes of the diatonic scale, but starting at different degrees of the scale for each mode.
You'll find that each mode has a distinct "feel" to it, eg Phyrgian mode sounds very "Spanish" - it's the mode that Flamenco music uses.
-
Not sure that we should go there, Chris. Flamenco gets very complicated. Agree that the flat 2nd note of the scale is “phrygianâ€, but the 3rd can be minor or major, the latter a harmonic minor mode.
But for a Flamenco, even that’s “dullâ€! They’ll do the same to the top half of the scale too, so you end up with modes of the double harmonic major or minor scales. Only another 96 more to practice up (due to symmetries)! Or they’ll even mix these, fluidly. Useful on melodeon? Barely. I use a double harmonic at end of my version of “Seven Gypsies†and … shall we say that it has the right swing ☠ï¸? Cyrille Roche has some sprinkled in bourrée “Dromadaire†too.
I’m an ex medic, and we taught students that our ability to do something is not an indication to carry it out. I suspect that Danny might be attempting the technical exercise of playing a tune in all keys? I tried that when I went 3-row, and a C#D is certainly capable of it. I believe that Luke Daniels has a party piece like that?n
Well, some keys lie easily on diatonic rows, and some … don’t. The further you stray from the main row tonalities the harder it gets. eg Ab is a tritone away from my D row, and semitone off its G scale. The box loathes Ab, and its modes eg Fm aolian.
I predict much use of the C# row’s Ab/Bb button (my outer row is C#; that’s what happened to me). I’d invite Danny to share his actual project with us 🙂
-
Well, some keys lie easily on diatonic rows, and some … don’t. The further you stray from the main row tonalities the harder it gets. eg Ab is a tritone away from my D row, and semitone off its G scale. The box loathes Ab, and its modes eg Fm aolian.
I find that surprising. On a C#/D, playing in A on the D row requires finding just one note, the leading note, i.e. G#, on the other row. (A is actually a handier key on C#/D than G is.)
Now just switch to the C# row and use almost exactly the same fingering to play in Ab - the only difference being the position of the one note you have to grab from the inner row, i.e. G. While it doesn't fall so intuitively under the fingers as the G# when you're playing in A, to me Ab is still one of the easier remote scales to play in.
At least on a C# row that hasn't been tampered with :|glug Do bear in mind that Danny plays C#/D everyone.
-
Thanks everyone for your help.
I would just like a sheet of paper in front of me to explore all the range of possibilities
of my C"D box
-
Hi Danny,
A google search of "all keys all modes" turned up this PDF, which seems like it might be what you're looking for, as long as you read sheet music: https://www.john-ferrara.com/media/sevenmodes.pdf
I haven't checked it for correctness all the way through, but at a glance it looks about right.
I do think you might get more useful responses if you shared a bit more about what you're trying to do and where you're coming from - do you already feel confident about the theory behind the different scales? It wouldn't be terribly hard to make this sort of document yourself if there's nothing out there that meets your exact needs, so long as you're comfortable with the way the scales are built.
Hope you find what you're looking for!
-
Just saw Chris already shared the same file above, sorry! Does that not answer your question then Danny?
-
Thanks everyone for your help.
I would just like a sheet of paper in front of me to explore all the range of possibilities
of my C"D box
Danny, do you read music notation? If not, let me know and over the next few days I'll try to put something useful together. Do you need diagrams of where the notes of the various scales are on the C#/D keyboard?
-
...Has anyone got a PDF file listing all the NOTES of scales and modes...
There's a 4-page theory hand-out on Paul Hardy's page:
https://pghardy.net/tunebooks/
Scroll down to 'Music Theory Handout', and download the PDF.
That may be what you are looking for?
There are also other resources including an ABC file which you can download and listen to...
I've attached a PDF of the ABC file, to which I've added the note names below the scores.
It has bar numbers added...
-
The seven diatonic modes are simply a matter of playing the normal major scale beginning at a different note. Eg for a C Major scale, you'd normally play it C-D-E-F-G-A-B-C, and this is also called the Ionian mode.
Play it D to D instead and you have the Dorian mode.
E to E is the Phrygian mode.
F to F is the Lydian mode.
G to G is the Mixolydian mode.
A to A is the Aeolian mode, which is the natural minor of the scale. This is why A minor is the relative minor of C major.
B to B is the Locrian mode.
Normally I find talk of modes extremely confusing, but I actually understood that explanation - thank you!
-
I find it interesting that this discussion has managed go on for so long without reference to and use of the terms "tonic" and "root", or maybe I missed them. :D
-
I've put together a document which lists the notes of the scale for all 7 diatonic modes of all 12 keys. It really wasn't that big of a job, and it turned out to be a useful exercise, so if you want to really get to grips with how different modes and keys work I would suggest trying something similar yourself.
I give no guarantee of accuracy, but I'm reasonably confident it's about right. A slightly odd feature is that there is a corner of the table where keys with lots of flats overlap with modes with lots of flats and I decided to rewrite some of the scales using sharps instead to avoid having to use double-flats. That might be confusing at first glance, but if you really want to learn the keyboard inside out you'll probably need to get comfortable with enharmonic notes (i.e. different names for the same note, e.g. Eb = D#).
There are more scales which I didn't include in the table (some "standard" ones that come to my mind: pentatonic scales, blues scale, harmonic minor & melodic minor - but other scales do exist on top of those!) but many can be built fairly easily on the basis of what is in the table. If you did want to include the ones I mention in your practice:
- pentatonic major is just a chopped down major scale, using the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 5th and 6th notes of the normal major scale
- pentatonic minor is just a chopped down minor scale, using the 1st, 3rd, 4th, 5th and 7th notes of the normal minor scale
- the blues scale is built the same way as a pentatonic minor scale but with a note added between the 4th and 5th notes of the normal minor scale, a so-called flat 5th (or sharp 4th I suppose!)
- harmonic minor is the normal minor scale but with the 7th note raised by a semitone, by adding a sharp or removing a flat
- melodic minor has different versions when going up vs down - the ascending version is the minor scale with 6th and 7th notes raised by a semitone each, the descending version is just the normal minor scale.
I hope all this is useful! It's hard to know what level of musical theory to pitch my explanations at because you haven't told us much about your background. If all of the lingo is going over your head I wrote a post just the other day about how the different modes and scales are constructed which might be a useful introduction: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,27358.msg329769.html#msg329769
I also found the theory handout Roger linked to above nicely put together, I really like that it gives tunes as examples! I would encourage you to have a look at that, so long as you read sheet music.
I do think Chris has a point when he says "Just because you can doesn't mean you should" (paraphrasing) - what are you hoping to achieve by working with this document? The list of musical scales is almost endless, if you really want to be completist about it. It's a bit like a painter trying to mix every possible colour, when maybe it would be useful also to think about what colours you want to mix and why.
-
There's really no need to "learn" 84 different things (12 major scales x 7 modes), though. Learn your major scales - yes, that's essential! - but all you have to remember about diatonic modes is which degree of the scale each begins with.
-
...I also found the theory handout Roger linked to above nicely put together, I really like that it gives tunes
as examples! I would encourage you to have a look at that, so long as you read sheet music...
Bizarrely, I started my musical 'career' knowing nothing about musical theory - except a little about modes.
This was due to having read A. L. Lloyds 'Folk Song in England' back in the 60s...
Still not a lot though, and I found that hand-out useful. In the version I posted, I added note-names under
the scores because I wasn't sure whether the OP wanted 'notes' or 'note-names' (or both, for that matter)...
-
In the version I posted, I added note-names under
the scores because I wasn't sure whether the OP wanted 'notes' or 'note-names' (or both, for that matter)...
Nice one Roger, I missed that!
-
There's really no need to "learn" 84 different things (12 major scales x 7 modes), though. Learn your major scales - yes, that's essential! - but all you have to remember about diatonic modes is which degree of the scale each begins with.
Well, I guess that depends on what the OP is setting out to do. If they want to be able to play the scale of every mode of every key fluently from (muscle) memory then perhaps they do need to learn 84 things. I would go the other way and argue that even learning all 12 major scales is probably unnecessary - I find it more interesting to know how the scales are constructed than knowing note names off by heart, and for a lot of traditional music I don't think you ever need to venture very far into the "weird end" of the circle of fifths. And as always, being able to hear, play and feel music doesn't necessarily depend on knowing any of this stuff!
But I guess we're all speculating about what the OP is trying to achieve, it would be interesting to hear a bit more from the horse's mouth!
-
As a 70 year old who’s been playing for about 5 years I feel the years I have left are best spent playing the thing as opposed to learning all of this. I’ve been playing a passable Bear Dance in sessions thinking it was in G. I know enough about the dots to learn a new tune if I can’t pick it up by ear. If I were 20 I would definitely dive in, however, as it is clearly very important if you want to gain a deep understanding of music, and talk knowledgeably to serious musicians.
-
"As a 70 year old who’s been playing for about 5 years I feel the years I have left are best spent playing the thing as opposed to learning all of this."
Amen!
-
There's really no need to "learn" 84 different things (12 major scales x 7 modes), though. Learn your major scales - yes, that's essential! - but all you have to remember about diatonic modes is which degree of the scale each begins with.
I find it endlessly fascinating how different individuals perceive/relate to music. Like Roger, I got my original understanding of modes from A L Lloyd back in the 60s. But I can't relate to Chris's model at all. For me, each mode starts on its own first degree - so I don't think of D mix, say, as having anything to do with G major. It shares the key sig but is a completely different beast.
I hear modes in terms of where the one semitone intervals are: so ionian has them between 3 & 4 and 7 & 8; mixolydian has them between 3 & 4 and 6 & 7; dorian between 2 & 3 and 6 & 7; aeolian between 2 & 3 and 5 & 6. (I've rarely felt the need to venture much beyond those four.) So, for example, an Eminorish tune played on the D row will be aeolian if you have to snatch C naturals from the G row but dorian if they're sharp and you can play it all on the D row.
I'm expressing it using the terminology but it's very much about hearing.
-
...I don't think of D mix, say, as having anything to do with G major. It shares the key sig but is a completely different beast.
I hear modes in terms of where the one semitone intervals are...
Yes, but sharing the key signature means that you also share the actual notes on a row of your instrument. You can easily predict and work out what your modal playing options are and tell someone what you were doing if they ask.
-
Well, I guess that depends on what the OP is setting out to do. If they want to be able to play the scale of every mode of every key fluently from (muscle) memory then perhaps they do need to learn 84 things. I would go the other way and argue that even learning all 12 major scales is probably unnecessary - I find it more interesting to know how the scales are constructed than knowing note names off by heart, and for a lot of traditional music I don't think you ever need to venture very far into the "weird end" of the circle of fifths. And as always, being able to hear, play and feel music doesn't necessarily depend on knowing any of this stuff!
I agree with you. Understanding the structure of scales probably is more important than memorising all 12. I'm primarily a classically-trained musician, and in 30-odd years of playing, there are certainly keys that I've never played in (the key of Cb Major in 7 flats, for example).
-
Thanks everyone for all your help and advice.
It's been really interesting reading your comments.
I can play quite a lot of tunes, mainly Irish. And I know you can just pick up a box and play a tune without really knowing the
theory behind it. But, for me I like to know what makes a particular mode and in which genre it is used.
-
[1] ...Like Roger, I got my original understanding of modes from A L Lloyd back in the 60s.
[2] ...I don't think of D mix, say, as having anything to do with G major. It shares the key sig but is a completely different beast.
[3] ...it's very much about hearing.
[1] Weird! After 40 years of not touching an instrument, when I finally got my grubby paws on a concertina,
I had a basic (if qualitative) understanding of modes...
[2] It is a completely different beast, but is also rather similar, in the sense that it uses the same 'pitch set'
as the key of G. This means that if you are a hard-core 'computer geek', it is possible to tailor your 'home-brew'
software to tag all such tunes as in '1-sharp', and then use the tag to extract all such tunes from a multi-tune
ABC file with a single %%select operation. I've (nearly) got this working for all the modes in all the common
'keys' (C, G, D, A, E).
[3] Right on!
-
There's really no need to "learn" 84 different things (12 major scales x 7 modes), though. Learn your major scales - yes, that's essential! - but all you have to remember about diatonic modes is which degree of the scale each begins with.
I find it endlessly fascinating how different individuals perceive/relate to music. Like Roger, I got my original understanding of modes from A L Lloyd back in the 60s. But I can't relate to Chris's model at all. For me, each mode starts on its own first degree - so I don't think of D mix, say, as having anything to do with G major. It shares the key sig but is a completely different beast.
I hear modes in terms of where the one semitone intervals are: so ionian has them between 3 & 4 and 7 & 8; mixolydian has them between 3 & 4 and 6 & 7; dorian between 2 & 3 and 6 & 7; aeolian between 2 & 3 and 5 & 6. (I've rarely felt the need to venture much beyond those four.) So, for example, an Eminorish tune played on the D row will be aeolian if you have to snatch C naturals from the G row but dorian if they're sharp and you can play it all on the D row.
I'm expressing it using the terminology but it's very much about hearing.
Your way of thinking about modes certainly makes more sense from a musical perspective, I completely agree. The D mixolydian scale is indeed a way of playing a D scale and has nothing to do with the key of G, but in terms of how you actually play it, thinking of it as a G major scale played from D to D is, I find, both the easiest way to remember it, and also the easiest way to explain it to someone.
-
Your way of thinking about modes certainly makes more sense from a musical perspective, I completely agree. The D mixolydian scale is indeed a way of playing a D scale and has nothing to do with the key of G, but in terms of how you actually play it, thinking of it as a G major scale played from D to D is, I find, both the easiest way to remember it, and also the easiest way to explain it to someone.
I see now there are good practcal reasons for thinking of it in that way as Roger and Greg explain too. My approach to modes isn't melodeon-related. Your explanation makes complete sense on a diatonic instrument.
-
I see now there are good practcal reasons for thinking of it in that way as Roger and Greg explain too...
For dedicated ABC users...
Drifting off-topic a little now, but I'm doing something which is eminently practical (for
me at least). This ability to select all the tunes in a particular 'pitch-set', is a fortuitous
by-product of another program I was writing. I needed to extract information about the
exact key in which a tune was written, and having saved the (apparently not very useful)
information, a little while later, I stumbled across the %%select directive, which lets
me extract all tunes in an ABC file with the same key signature in one 'hit'.
Very useful - to me at least.
-
Another purchaser of Lloyd’s book, back in 1971 here.
The ways of thinking about modes end up completely equivalent, so “do whatever suits youâ€. On one row, or a mouth organ there’s no choice. It has 7 notes, starting on each one gives a different, classical, Greek, “church†mode. Those 3 terms are more or less equivalent too.
With 2 rows we can play our D scale (in my head at least) on “push†or “pull†The latter is the same as on a 1-row in G. Playing on push outer row you get to “dot†the b7 C in. No sweat! C# was pull too, just move your finger.
Gosh, I can even move it mid note 🤔 A,B, C=>C#, D! No deal I’m afraid. you just entered tonal music. Bebop.
But then the mode concept expands even further. Tonal scales like melodic minor can be segmented into 7 modes too. They just aren’t “Greekâ€.
Back to practicalities. Well, it completely depends on the tune, as our notes are in a set pattern. Lazy US mixolydian bluesey stuff I’d play on the pull, as they do in Louisiana. Ashokan farewell, or “Dark girl dressed in blueâ€, for me, play better on the push, dotting the C’s in. Others might differ. I recall playing a French tune with the late Steve Harrison and he leant over afterwards saying “gosh, at every stage your bellows were going the opposite way to mine, Chrisâ€!
Do try both, when available. Both will probably work. One will work better for any specific melody.