Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: diatonix on September 24, 2021, 10:39:01 PM
-
So sad to see melodeons mistreated (with consequent loss of quality and value) and customers deceived by such horrible practice...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OgpWcoprRU0&t=1203s&ab_channel=Tom%27sMusicShop
-
I've had a look at the comments, the author is not taking genuine critics very well.
-
His other "tutorials" are just as bad and unprofessional. That's how he "repairs" worn bellows: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EDYY_uNVO4I&ab_channel=Tom%27sMusicShop
-
His other "tutorials" are just as bad and unprofessional. That's how he "repairs" worn bellows
How do you recommend patching small areas of wear to the bellows tape? For example on my Pokerwork I have a handful of tiny spots on the lower right of the back of the bellows that are worn down to the white, but the rest of the bellows tape is pristine. It doesn't make sense to do a complete strip and retape job, but it seems like a good idea to repair the worn areas sooner rather than later.
-
Unable to sleep because of a blocked nose, I've been looking at some of these self-help tuning vids and notice that most of them seem to use the dreaded Dremel. I can understand the reason for not using electrically driven grinding equipment 'cause of the likelihood of overheating the metal of the tongue. But many of the untouched reeds from instrument manufacturers (which I've come across) seem to have been originally tuned in this fashion.
Am I mistaken, and all of those reeds have been retuned after all?
-
A valid question. I recall a video of a somewhat aged artisan making and profiling reeds and tuning them at least to a rough pitch. He used a hinged linisher, which hinged down onto the reed rather like a chop saw. With such a large surface contact compared with a Dremel, surely that would offer an even greater risk of upsetting the temper of the steel?
Rob.
-
How do you recommend patching small areas of wear to the bellows tape? For example on my Pokerwork I have a handful of tiny spots on the lower right of the back of the bellows that are worn down to the white, but the rest of the bellows tape is pristine. It doesn't make sense to do a complete strip and retape job, but it seems like a good idea to repair the worn areas sooner rather than later.
I don't recommend patching small areas in the first place. It looks messy, the glue doesn't attach well to the existing strip and if there are many patches (as there often are) the bellows get too thick. Replace the whole length. Easier, faster and the result looks better. And remember: this guy has an accordion repair business. He doesn't only do this to his own boxes and he charges money for a very unprofessional job.
-
His other "tutorials" are just as bad and unprofessional. That's how he "repairs" worn bellows
How do you recommend patching small areas of wear to the bellows tape? For example on my Pokerwork I have a handful of tiny spots on the lower right of the back of the bellows that are worn down to the white, but the rest of the bellows tape is pristine. It doesn't make sense to do a complete strip and retape job, but it seems like a good idea to repair the worn areas sooner rather than later.
I have sometimes touched up small spots on bellows tape with nail varnish - i.e. spots where scuff damage has taken a fleck off the surface coating of the tape. It's akin to putting a bag of cold tar in a minor pothole on a county road.
-
How do you recommend patching small areas of wear to the bellows tape? For example on my Pokerwork I have a handful of tiny spots on the lower right of the back of the bellows that are worn down to the white, but the rest of the bellows tape is pristine. It doesn't make sense to do a complete strip and retape job, but it seems like a good idea to repair the worn areas sooner rather than later.
I don't recommend patching small areas in the first place. It looks messy, the glue doesn't attach well to the existing strip and if there are many patches (as there often are) the bellows get too thick. Replace the whole length. Easier, faster and the result looks better...
Just so I'm clear, are you saying patch the whole run of tape over the existing tape, or remove the existing tape run and glue on new tape (which is what I think you mean. Neater but I don't see how it's quicker)?
-
Just so I'm clear, are you saying patch the whole run of tape over the existing tape, or remove the existing tape run and glue on new tape (which is what I think you mean. Neater but I don't see how it's quicker)?
You cannot glue new tape on existing tape. Bellows tape has only 1 glueable side. Get rid of the old worn one. Try it and you'll find out why it's quicker (which of course wasn't my main point).
-
Just so I'm clear, are you saying patch the whole run of tape over the existing tape, or remove the existing tape run and glue on new tape (which is what I think you mean. Neater but I don't see how it's quicker)?
You cannot glue new tape on existing tape. Bellows tape has only 1 glueable side. Get rid of the old worn one. Try it and you'll find out why it's quicker (which of course wasn't my main point).
i see. I have a pokerwork with shortish tape patches over the original tape. not the prettiest solution, but it's been very functional for at least 8 years.
-
i see. I have a pokerwork with shortish tape patches over the original tape. not the prettiest solution, but it's been very functional for at least 8 years.
By and large, I agree with Diatonix; I've had various boxes with bellows tape patches here and there, and apart from the unreliability of the glue joint - yes one may last 5 or more years, but it's never as secure as a "proper" repair - if patches begin to accumulate in various places around the bellows it begins to feel awkward and unwieldy. I've had repairs (not mine!) where the glue has started to let go and has stuck adjacent folds together, and one box where there were so many patches that the bellows clips wouldn't close. Granted you have to have the replacement tape and suitable adhesive to hand, but replacing a single run of tape really is a quick and straightforward job, as well as looking better than a patch.
-
Partial agreement here, depending on the type of edging tape on the bellows to start with. Italian tape peels off easily as does the buckram like material used on older German boxes. The black and gold tapes on post-war Hohners can be hard work to remove. It tears too easily to pull off in a strip and usually needs to be carefully soaked in water in order to release the glue.
Completely agree that the end result is better with replacement of complete strips.
-
I don't think it looks too bad; plus it is on the inside anyway....
-
I don't think it looks too bad; plus it is on the inside anyway....
It looks horrible. But again, if someone chooses to do this to his or her own melodeon, so be it. However, when a self-appointed melodeon "technician" considers this a professional repair job and charges money for it, that's something entirely different. He hurts his customers and in the long run, himself and his business. Customers are not stupid.
-
"when a self-appointed melodeon "technician" considers this a professional repair job and charges money for it, that's something entirely different."
It's fine for your own instrument, in my opinion, although even I have struggled on to do the lot when I had to. But as Mr diatonix says this is entirely different. When I was even greener than I am now, I asked one of our favourite fettlers to do a 'part job' on the cheap, just to get the instrument payable; he refused because he wasn't happy to lay his reputation for first class work on the line. It left me in a state of acute embarrassment in asking, but I immediately knew what he was on about and agreed with him wholeheartedly.
-
A valid question. I recall a video of a somewhat aged artisan making and profiling reeds and tuning them at least to a rough pitch. He used a hinged linisher, which hinged down onto the reed rather like a chop saw. With such a large surface contact compared with a Dremel, surely that would offer an even greater risk of upsetting the temper of the steel?
Rob.
Pigini even uses a big machine to pre-tune reeds in bulk.
I suppose the machine doesn't drive a row of tiny scratchers to accomplish this.
Probably it's all about calculating how long you can have a machine-driven device on the surface of your reeds, and at what speed, to avoid it being turned into trash.
-
Pigini even uses a big machine to pre-tune reeds in bulk.
I suppose the machine doesn't drive a row of tiny scratchers to accomplish this.
Probably it's all about calculating how long you can have a machine-driven device on the surface of your reeds, and at what speed, to avoid it being turned into trash.
I'm sure machines of all kinds are used at various manufacturing stages, but do they use a machine for final fine tuning? Or any delicate finishing and fettling jobs, come to that?
-
Pigini even uses a big machine to pre-tune reeds in bulk.
I suppose the machine doesn't drive a row of tiny scratchers to accomplish this.
Probably it's all about calculating how long you can have a machine-driven device on the surface of your reeds, and at what speed, to avoid it being turned into trash.
I'm sure machines of all kinds are used at various manufacturing stages, but do they use a machine for final fine tuning? Or any delicate finishing and fettling jobs, come to that?
I don't believe they do.
But I'm sure it can be done, by a very very expensive machine that does not exist because it isn't economical to build one.
Pigini is afaik the only manufacterer that has a machine like that, whilst other brands do that step still 'by hand'.
It is different because this is not part of the manufacturing of reeds. They feed it assembled reeds.
So it is not necessarily a bad thing that a machine touches your reeds.
-
I think this may be the video mentioned earlier by Rob:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GgYYyn72HLI (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GgYYyn72HLI)
-
Like making sausage...
(not pretty to watch, tasty when done)
-
"Like making sausage...
(not pretty to watch, tasty when done)"
I really enjoyed watching, actually! I've had quite a lot of bass reeds where most of the length of the tongue has been ground away to less than half its original thickness (at the factory) instead of adding a weight to the free end.