Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: waldoB on October 22, 2009, 04:51:53 PM

Title: Midi'd Boxes
Post by: waldoB on October 22, 2009, 04:51:53 PM
The talk of the Streb in For Sale prompts me to ask if there are many Midi'd conventional push pull boxes in use ? The Shand Morino's like Graeme's use it on the bass end to great effect - what about the treble playing a flute ?  DB
Title: Re: Midi'd Boxes
Post by: michik on October 22, 2009, 05:20:02 PM
Currently there is a Hohner Morino Club S with Midi-Interface on ebay Germany:
http://cgi.ebay.de/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=300358632124
Title: Re: Midi'd Boxes
Post by: DRUMKILBO on October 22, 2009, 06:20:43 PM
There are a lot of button box players in Scotland who have midi bass like Graeme [and myself] and there are a few who have the treble midi'd as well. I had a shot of a pal's a few years ago. There is a valve in the bellows to sense the bellows direction, but at that time if you were playing quick bellows movements, it couldn't keep up. It was very interesting for slower stuff with all the sampled sounds but I did find that I had to change my way of playing and just play the written note with no grace notes or embellishment at all. I was particularly impressed with the fiddle sound I could get with my expander [Roland U110 with a card for strings] but, I prefer to employ a real fiddler [ handy at the bar ] and although I use midi bass, I only use that when I can't get my keyboard player.

Ian.
Title: Re: Midi'd Boxes
Post by: graememackay on October 22, 2009, 07:02:31 PM
As Drumkilbo says it is pretty tricky to get it to react quick enough for the treble end to be midi'd.  I couldn't play a reel properly on one I tried, it was a couple of notes behind, but it is good for slower ballroom stuff.

The chap that has done pretty much 90% of dance band midi accordions invented a system which is as close as you'll get.  He basically had a small piece of gortex stretched over a hole which triggered a switch either side of it depending on which way it was "inflated".  Unfortunatly due to illness he hasn't midi'd an accordion for a few years.

I'm sure someone with a brain may be able to work out a system with more sensors, on the bellows maybe to detect direction.

But once the directional hurdle has been leaped, there's no reason why you couldn't reinact the bbc symphony orchestra as you're backing band.  Midi is a wonderful thing, the streb is a fanctastic idea, but midi can be fitted to any melodeon.
Title: Re: Midi'd Boxes
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on October 22, 2009, 09:17:07 PM
i could be very out of line here , and please forgive my ignorance,  but if you want to learn how to play a flute, why dont you learn to play a flute? im not being funny, i just dont know too much about strebs and what they do, and am curious!!! their cant be many musicians that would turn up to a gig with a stradivarius and tune it to sound like a kazoo!!!! lol  >:E
Title: Re: Midi'd Boxes
Post by: Falseknight on October 23, 2009, 08:20:30 AM
It has it's uses.  I use midied guitar on occasion (though not so much now).  It can be useful to have voices played with the style and inflection of another interest and it is an easier way at getting at some textures for accompaniment.  Not having to pay the beer bill for a brass quintet is one that springs immediately to mind ;)
Title: Re: Midi'd Boxes
Post by: Martin J on October 23, 2009, 12:28:20 PM
i could be very out of line here , and please forgive my ignorance,  but if you want to learn how to play a flute, why dont you learn to play a flute? im not being funny, i just dont know too much about strebs and what they do, and am curious!!! their cant be many musicians that would turn up to a gig with a stradivarius and tune it to sound like a kazoo!!!! lol  >:E
You are spot on the money.  We should learn to play the original instrument but sometimes when working on stage you need just that little something extra, and only for a short duration.  It's then that a midi instrument can help.  For myself I can play piano badly but using a midi melodeon I can achieve a passable performance standard on certain pieces which I could never achieve at a conventional keyboard.  I heard someone use a cello voice behind the melody, wow did it sound good.  Everyone was looking around for the cellist.  So, midi is great if used in moderation and with a sympathetic interpretation of what the piece requires.  As a pounding replacement for something it's not supposed to be then midi should be avoided.

Martin
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal