Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Chris Marriott on October 02, 2021, 06:20:23 PM
-
I started learning to play the box during lockdown, so almost all my playing experience has been either playing on my own, or at best playing in front of a camera in a Zoom meeting.
Last weekend I attended the session at the "Bellows and Buttons" weekend, and this afternoon I've been to a local "Slow and Steady" session. Enjoyed both tremendously, but it's made me aware of a problem. I'm going a little deaf due to my advanced age, and when I'm in a room full of other players, I can't hear a single note of what I'm playing myself, and I haven't got a clue whether I'm playing the tune correctly or making a complete hash of it! How on Earth do you hear what you're playing in a room full of other players?
-
The good news is if you can't hear what you are playing you are either playing the correct notes or at least harmonising (:)
-
That's the problem, Lester. Because I can't hear it, I could be making a complete hash of it which everyone except me could hear!
-
Chris, don't worry-I think that we all feel like that at first-at least I know that I did. Just keep going-you'll get attuned to what's going on, and be able to relax and start hearing your own playing and enjoying it all. I spent quite a long time being amazed at how good everyone else sounded, so was very hesitant to contribute. I realised eventually that once I knew the tunes I could join in, and it became fun.
Cheers,
Guy
-
Also the more you play, the more you become attuned to your own box as well, and get to know it's specific sound even through the sounds of everyone else playing.
At times I adopt the 'head in the grill' position of playing if I'm unsure of the tune, or trying to pick up a new to me tune. As I relax into it and realise the fingers are hitting the right buttons ( or am develop neck ache ;) ) I return to a more normal posture.
As ever, the more you play with others, the easier it becomes.
-
That's the problem, Lester. Because I can't hear it, I could be making a complete hash of it which everyone except me could hear!
What I meant was if you were playing it wrong you would be able top hear your playing
-
The other thing I find I do if in a new-to- me session or a bit nervous even amongst friends is try too hard.
After a while sitting back and letting the music flow over me, I often find myself picking up the tunes as I've relaxed and let the brain and fingers meet in the middle.
-
Thank you everyone - that is helpful. I think I'm going to find these monthly Slow and Steady sessions very useful, and I'm also looking forward to the Playgroup at the end of the month. Hopefully you'll tell me there, Lester, if I'm doing anything too awful!
-
It has been said that wearing a hat helps you hear what you are playing.
-
Yep, our regular session flautist often wears a brimmed hat and says it aids his hearing.
-
Chris, I was sitting next to you and couldn't hear what you were playing.
I would say it means that your playing blended in with everyone else. Well done.
-
I have a hearing problem too and I find it takes me a while to adjust to ambiant noise/room acoustics, same as a noisy restaurant. If it's an option, the adjustment may include moving to another chair to favor my good ear, or get away from the banjo or whatever... ;)
-
Chris, I was sitting next to you and couldn't hear what you were playing.
I would say it means that your playing blended in with everyone else. Well done.
Thanks, Mike!
-
When first taking my melodeon to a session I was disappointed with myself, couldn't hear myself etc.
Then several times later I moved to another position - away from my friend learning Alto Sax whom I used to sit beside - and discovered I could hear myself, I wasn't was bad as I thought, played ok considering being new to the box.
Beware sitting next to loud instruments for you ear's sake, or fiddlers for your eye's sake ;D
-
The first time I played with others, I was exactly the same as you and I couldn't hear myself at all, which is very disconcerting, to say the least. The next time I went, I sat a few feet away from and behind everyone else and this sorted out the problem. Now, a couple of years later, I sit in amongst the group and I can hear myself all the time. The thing is, now that I have built my confidence, I think I play quite a bit louder than I did at the beginning and therefore I can hear myself.
The hardest thing of all for me and probably the most important thing of all, is not just to play....but to listen to all the other musicians at the same time, so that I can react to them, support them, take the lead when it is my turn etc., etc.. It has taken me ages to be able to do this and, even now, when a piece is tricky, I find myself 'playing by myself' and not as part of the group.
Good luck, be patient and it will come - above all, don't beat yourself up over it, because, next time you go, you will be tense and that will make things worse.
-
Thanks - good tip about sitting a little distance away from other people. I’ll try that next time!
-
I asked the same question when I started playing in sessions and I was advised by a player I admired to sit in a corner, or at least next to a wall, so you can hear your sound being reflected. I tried it and it worked. As Thrupenny Bit says, after a while your ear gets attuned to your particular sound and then you can sit anywhere
-
The first Session I went to, at the Fleece.....I took my Mandolin.
Confronted with a PA (Alex/TeaCups, in "vigorous" mode - when is he not ;D ::)) and 6 / 7 Melodeons, I spent all night 'sucking' the plectrum until the pain in my head was so bad I had to go and lie down outside.
I never went to another 'music' Session for 'some years'.
Adopting an, if you can't beat them join them, approach, I am going to miss getting to this.....
https://www.facebook.com/melodeonplaygroup/videos/194164121661802
In all seriousness, as a fellow relative beginner, on a similar path, I would try to get a grip with the Tune's from the Tune Book in advance. Trying to learn tunes, on the hoof, if you can not pick them up by ear, which I know you have said that you don't find easy without the dot's - irrespective of personal "hearing" issues - is going to be hard work.
Bob ( Ellis ) kindly sent me a list of Tunes for Sidmouth ......40!! of them .....I got a 'handle' on a handful, and have learnt a few, which lit my fire since......but there so many tunes - and so many ways to play them ( and so many mistakes to make :o ::)
-
I used to play mandolin (very badly - I shudder at the memory), but gave up because I couldn't hear myself play in sessions - or keep the ******* thing in tune. The only positive aspect I suppose was that other people couldn't hear how bad I was !
I think playing in sessions can be incredibly challenging at first - if you go to a regular event I advocate recording the tunes if possible, and using them to practise against at home (slowed down if need be)- and to help in committing them to memory.
Dots can help in the learning, but as Nigel says - there are so many tunes and so many ways to play them. When I start a tune I hope that others will listen and at least try to follow my version (not including the mistakes !) and not their own ::)
Julian
-
My "second" ever Session was the Friday evening at Halsway. Feeling ( over ) confident, I "started" a tune....Part A was 'passable', a fellow player politely pointed out at the end of the 2 + 2, that they played it at their local Sessions, but that "their" B part was 'slightly' different.
No surprise as I had 'grafted' two similar tunes together. I realised next day..... :-[
Hopeless or hapless.... they were too polite to say ::) :-X
Still, no doubt, at our level/stage, it is so much easier to play a tune you know ( in a group ) rather than one you don't!!
-
It can be a problem, particularly with lots of melodeons and fiddles playing in the same octave.
Sitting back a bit does work, as does putting your head close to the grill occasionally to check.
You have a selection of boxes which have their own distinct sounds, so take more than one to the regular session, especially if you have a three voice one. You will find the one which works best for you in that session.
My 'session box' is a Rowbotham Special 3 voice Hohner Pressed Wood; it makes it much easier for me to hear my playing in a busy session. And it sounds great as well!!!
-
The revelation to me at last years playgroup (chancing my arm as an "improver") was that you only really hear yourself in a big group when you hit a (totally) bum note.....and even then with another twenty odd boxes sounding the right note the ONLY person in the room that can hear your bum note is the only person in the room that is close enough to hear your box over the sound of the massed melodeons playing in in unison....and that person dear reader is yourself.
-
I think that you need to do your homework if wanting to join in a regular session.
Make notes on tunes played, maybe just going along and listening first armed with pencil and paper and ask what tunes had been played.
A recording device is good, as tunes in books are fine, but your session might have slight local variations.
Then armed with a rough idea of the common tunes, try and learn a couple within your ability.
Essentially, that has been my approach when first starting, and I continue it now if a new tune comes along that I want to play.
You have to try and build a repertoire, and that starts with a first tune!
-
Still, no doubt, at our level/stage, it is so much easier to play a tune you know ( in a group ) rather than one you don't!!
Definitely! That's why I'm concentrating on learning a few easy tunes at the moment such as the Winster Gallop and the Bear Dance.
Great idea about recording tunes. I'll ask next time if it's OK to do this.
-
Andy makes a good point and one I touched on earlier.
Melodeons do not all sound the same, you will get used to your individual sound the more you play it.
In the summer at a Sidmouth session I was surrounded by Dino Baffettis of various types, yet could hear my Castagnari as it simply made a different sound. I was surprised at the difference having not been in such a large gathering for a long while.
-
It does take a little while to hear your own instrument. If you watch other box players’ hands you can pick up the key from the left hand playing. If you know or can pick up the melody try playing just on the right hand. It’s easier to focus on your own sound if it’s just melody or just basses/chords. Most people are concentrating on their own playing so don’t worry about not being totally accurate. Enjoyment is the aim.
-
.
I watch other melodeonista, and any guitar player’s left hands a lot 👍
New tune? Listen first. then chord. only join in on reprise 3. Uggh! 😕 medley.
-
If you ever see a melodeon player who seems close to tears whilst playing for dancing as someone tries to join in and can't keep the time nor the melody, do step in and remove the extraneous player to a safe distance before the dance ends and murder ensues.
Just saying.
-
It has been said that wearing a hat helps you hear what you are playing.
I was just about to write about a hat. My Tilley hats make a noticeable difference. Sometimes helps with bad monitors at gigs. Paddy Keenan, piper of Bothy band fame, says that this is the reason he wears a broad rimmed hat whilst playing.
In general I'd agree with others that it's mostly down to getting used to playing in groups.
-
a fellow player politely pointed out ... that "their" B part was 'slightly' different.
No surprise as I had 'grafted' two similar tunes together. I realised next day..... :-[
Fret not, far more experienced musicians have made the same mistake.
-
I think that you need to do your homework if wanting to join in a regular session.
Make notes on tunes played, maybe just going along and listening first armed with pencil and paper and ask what tunes had been played.
A recording device is good, as tunes in books are fine, but your session might have slight local variations.
Then armed with a rough idea of the common tunes, try and learn a couple within your ability.
Essentially, that has been my approach when first starting, and I continue it now if a new tune comes along that I want to play.
You have to try and build a repertoire, and that starts with a first tune!
Is it now common practice for sessions to have a "standard" repertoire? It's many years now since I've been to a session the UK, but here, at least in the ones I've run or been to regularly (pre-Covid, of course, so that's a couple of years back already) it was always unplanned and the tune was whatever the next person chose to play when it got to their turn. That's how I remember sessions back when I first started going to them,and it was a way in which I learned a good few (and also a few good!) tunes I probably wouldn't otherwise have come across.
-
The two regular sessions I've been to seem to have their own set of tunes that seem to regularly be played. I'm sure that those tunes must vary across the country, but would think each session has some regular tunes?
If starting from scratch, then my thinking was to try and work out what these tunes were and try them at home whether from dots or a recording.
Also, if trying them from dots, be aware your local session might have slight variations, so possibly 'familiarise' rather than 'learn' might be a better way forward. Then listen when playing at the next session and tweak your playing accordingly.
I'm just aware that the written tune might well vary slightly to that which is played.
-
a fellow player politely pointed out ... that "their" B part was 'slightly' different.
No surprise as I had 'grafted' two similar tunes together. I realised next day..... :-[
Fret not, far more experienced musicians have made the same mistake.
Happens all the time. Two bands I've played with had tunes that were actually composites, unwittingly created by just such a mistake.
-
Is it now common practice for sessions to have a "standard" repertoire?
It tends to happen if it's a regular session with mostly the same people.
I'd hope that anyone turning up to such a session would be welcome to start something that wasn't in the usual repertoire, though. I know some sessions have published books of their tunes and they are a useful guide for a newcomer, but I'd hate it to become prescriptive.
A few years ago, we had a super weekly session in which, though we tended to have tunes that were played frequently, it was a point of honour that a new tune or two should be introduced every time.
-
Anahata has summed up our regular session well.
Formed from a nucleus of players who've regularly attended for years. There are indeed regular favourite tunes, but everyone can start up what they like and new people are encouraged to do that. It is a way of introducing fresh tunes and fresh faces.
-
Thank goodness for that - it was beginning to sound a bit Orwellian!
-
As far as my experience goes, it's the same now as it's always been, don't worry Graham (:)
-
Novices worry too much about sessions. I've heard there are sessions where they do expect you to have mastered your instrument and to know the tunes thoroughly before you can join in, and where they expect everything to be just so, although I've not come across one myself. Most sessions in my experience are more forgiving. In a large-ish session, as long as you play fairly quietly few will notice what you are playing, and fewer will care if you get it wrong. They are a great way to develop your playing and gain confidence, for that reason. Remember that on a melodeon even if you play a wrong note it will almost certainly be in the correct key and should harmonise (more or less ;)) with the melody. It may not be right, but it shouldn't sound horribly wrong.
Don't worry about learning the tunes in every detail either. The chances are the version being played isn't the one you have dots for, and the way it is played this week may not be the way it was played last week (or even last time through). Learn to join in quietly, just chords at first, until the tune becomes familiar and you can start to pick out bits of the melody. Remember, you don't have to play all the notes, and it's fine to stop playing when you come to a tricky bit as someone else will be playing it. However it is essential to keep in time with the other players - if you don't then that will be noticed. That is how you learn to play by ear, which is an essential skill to participate fully in sessions.
The important thing is not to be intrusive - not always easy with a melodeon, but it can be done especially if there are other melodeons to hide behind. If you find you just can't get to grips with a tune, stop playing and listen so you can absorb the tune and understand what the other players are doing with it.
-
Howard's right.
At last night's session I was sat next to an old friend and very accomplished player. Whilst listening to him making some wonderful improvisations my concentration wandered. Listening at my grill I sometimes found I was a button out. No one noticed or more likely even heard, certainly not my other friend on my other side playing Oboe.
There's often so much going on no one will worry if you're slightly out!
-
Slightly of on an aside, we called the practice of quietly fiddling around finding the notes "noodling". In Irish sessions it has been frowned upon (though, I expect it depends on the session). English sessions seem to be far more tolerant and I have never come across any resistance to it.
-
Slightly of on an aside, we called the practice of quietly fiddling around finding the notes "noodling". In Irish sessions it has been frowned upon (though, I expect it depends on the session). English sessions seem to be far more tolerant and I have never come across any resistance to it.
Just don't do it in Lessons at Playgroup. The elves don't like it!
-
Slightly of on an aside, we called the practice of quietly fiddling around finding the notes "noodling". In Irish sessions it has been frowned upon (though, I expect it depends on the session). English sessions seem to be far more tolerant and I have never come across any resistance to it.
Just don't do it in Lessons at Playgroup. The elves don't like it!
You will be awarded the Pot Noodle of Shame
-
Slightly of on an aside, we called the practice of quietly fiddling around finding the notes "noodling". In Irish sessions it has been frowned upon
Irish music is predominantly about the melody, and (in some sessions anyway) you are expected to play exactly the same tune as everyone else, with no variations, and even harmonisation may be frowned on. English sessions are usually more open to variation, improvisation, harmonisation and general free-for-all. Both can be glorious when they go right, both can sometimes be awful.
In either case, any noodling should be unobtrusive and should not really be apparent to other musicians.
-
Irish music is predominantly about the melody, and (in some sessions anyway) you are expected to play exactly the same tune as everyone else, with no variations, and even harmonisation may be frowned on.
Isn’t ornamentation “a thing†in Irish music, though? It certainly is in Irish concertina playing. I always imagined that how a player ornamented a tune was a matter of personal choice and playing ability?
-
Irish music is predominantly about the melody, and (in some sessions anyway) you are expected to play exactly the same tune as everyone else, with no variations, and even harmonisation may be frowned on.
Isn’t ornamentation “a thing†in Irish music, though? It certainly is in Irish concertina playing. I always imagined that how a player ornamented a tune was a matter of personal choice and playing ability?
Re: "ornamentation".
It's articulation, an essential part of the statement...not decorative frills and arises from/parallels the breaking of the air stream in pipes, flutes, whistles and even the human voice.
Ornamentation implies decoration. Cuts, rolls, grace notes, crans, stops and the many forms of triplets are not mere window-dressing. They help define the tone of the notes and the silences between.
With respect, that's m..m..my view.
-
Re: "ornamentation".
It's articulation, an essential part of the statement...not decorative frills and arises from/parallels the breaking of the air stream in pipes, flutes, whistles and even the human voice.
Ornamentation implies decoration [snip].
I agree, in general, Dick, but I think it is an oversimplification to say "ornamentation is really articulation - end of story". Different players use all the devices you mention to a greater or lesser extent and it's actually possible to play Irish music very well using hardly any of them. In other words, a lot of the time, they are not essential, even if they may be a defining feature of a particular player's style, or of the way a particular instrument is usually played.
But the important point that emerges from what you are saying is that ornamentation/articulation (or whatever term you like to use for such devices), whether or not you see it as a form of variation, is not a big deal.
When Howard mentions variation, I understand him to mean melodic variation, significant departures from the basic melody, which solo players will use for their own interest and that of listeners. That sort of thing needs to be kept in check in a session - generally (no hard and fast rule though).
Small variations will pass unnoticed. If someone plays A3 at a certain point in a jig in the key of D while at the same time the person next to them plays AFA and someone else plays AdA or even FAA (made up for the sake of argument), nobody is going to object. This is all par for the course and creates the ensemble sound.
-
Isn’t ornamentation “a thing†in Irish music, though? It certainly is in Irish concertina playing. I always imagined that how a player ornamented a tune was a matter of personal choice and playing ability?
If people are playing together, though, it's better to agree to make similar ornamentation in the same places. Not necessarily identical, because these things are done differently according to the instrument, but there's quite a map of equivalent grace notes, crans, rolls, triplets etc. per instrument. (disclaimer: I'm not an ITM specialist and ready to be corrected!)
Such fine points are more likely to apply to a band that actually rehearses stuff, but in a good session, musicians can match phrasing, articulation and ornamentation by listening to each other.
-
Some of the best Irish sessions I get to are with people I see only once or twice a year so there's no likelihood of matching versions by familiarity. But there are recognised standard versions (often because people have learned from a common source) and, as Stiamh says, small differences pass unnoticed. If someone holds a simple long note (say Stiamh's A3) while someone else rolls it or divides it in two (A2 A), there's no real clash. One player may use all three during the tune. Other differences will often be with passing and leading notes which are gone before you've registered the difference.
Yes, it's not the same for bands rehearsing to perform, who may be very fussy. Chris Sherburn, concertina player with Last Night's Fun once told me he'd had to change the way he played a particular tune because when he hit a certain note he could hear a harmonic which clashed with what Nick was doing on the pipes. Band members will presumably match ornamentation if they aim to sound really tight.
Ornamentation or articulation? Both certainly exist. Cuts/taps are usually mostly about articulation whereas rolls are often ornamental. But then there are plenty of tunes that simply sound wrong without certain "ornaments". Plenty of reels start off with two quavers (eighth notes) followed by a crotchet (quarter note). They don't work unless you play a short roll (or equivalent) on the crotchet. e.g. George White's Favourite: Bd | eB ~B2 eBdB | ... It depends so much on the tune.