Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Yooval Mann on November 10, 2021, 03:59:59 PM

Title: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Yooval Mann on November 10, 2021, 03:59:59 PM
Hi

I would like to understand better the difference between MM and MMM tremolo

as far as I gathered so far, MM is one reed above pitch one below and then the perceived sound is on with a calculated certain amount of beating, so for instance one reed A 442hz the other reed A 438 and the result is a note of A 440, is that true?

I am not sure what is the method of an MMM configuration, is it the same like two but with another reed right on pitch so one reed A 440 one reed A 442 one reed A 438?

what distinguishes the "true" tremolo MMM sound from the MM sound? is it mainly that added reed on the frequency which does not actually exist on the MM?

thank you
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Anahata on November 10, 2021, 04:33:39 PM
You've got it right, except that the two voice tuning is sometimes done with one set on pitch and the other slightly higher. This means the instrument sounds slightly sharp. The above-and-below scheme you describe is far better for a two voice box.

Also with a three voice tuning, it is quite common for the higher voice to have a wider gap than the lower, e.g. 443, 440 and 438, which produces a more complex tremolo (and again makes the box slightly sharp to concert pitch.)
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: mselic on November 10, 2021, 05:13:40 PM
You've got it right, except that the two voice tuning is sometimes done with one set on pitch and the other slightly higher. This means the instrument sounds slightly sharp. The above-and-below scheme you describe is far better for a two voice box.

I would say that the vast majority of two-voiced instruments are still tuned this way, with one being on pitch and the other sharp.  The equal offset makes sense but it certainly isn't as common as the other way, and you'd have to specify that tuning with a builder or tuner otherwise it would arrive as 'standard' (0, +).

Regarding MMM tremolo, it can either be equal offsets from zero or (eg. -10, 0,+10) or an unequal offset (with Anahata's example of a wider gap for the higher voice being more common in that case).  Personally, I much prefer the cleaner sound of the equal offset.
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Yooval Mann on November 10, 2021, 05:19:54 PM
thank you Anahata and mselic, that explains how the one row melodeon works with the one reed ON pitch so it will match the L and H reeds while the other M reed can go higher, so when one plays a one row in its MM setting it's not going to sound exactly on pitch...

therefore if I have an instrument with just MM reeds and no couplers it will be better to tune it in the high low method, but if it's an LMM instrument it would be better to tune the M and L ON PITCH and the other M off but then the box when played MM or LMM will never truly sound on pitch right? will I be able to blend  in and match a fiddle's pitch when trying to play in unison?

do you happen to have or know of examples of a sound comparison for MM in the two tuning approaches?

mselic, I would be interested to hear the effect of that MMM equal offset tuning you mentioned


Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: diatonix on November 10, 2021, 05:30:39 PM
It's better to define the gap in C (Cent) rather than Hz, always keeping in mind that the amount in Cent must decrease the higher up the scale one gets. Unfortunately not all tuners seem to be aware of this important fact...
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Rog on November 10, 2021, 05:35:38 PM
On MMM (sometimes referred to as musette tuned) piano accordions, where there are a lot of couplers to give all combinations of reeds, the asymmetric tuning of MMM has a specific purpose. It allows the player to select different rates of tremolo, depending on the selected couplers. Personally I’m not convinced there is any other reason for asymmetric MMM tuning (I’m not convinced by the ‘more complex tremolo sound' argument. But this is just my own view and is quite possible misguided).
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: -Y- on November 10, 2021, 05:47:43 PM
On MMM (sometimes referred to as musette tuned) piano accordions, where there are a lot of couplers to give all combinations of reeds, the asymmetric tuning of MMM has a specific purpose. It allows the player to select different rates of tremolo, depending on the selected couplers. Personally I’m not convinced there is any other reason for asymmetric MMM tuning (I’m not convinced by the ‘more complex tremolo sound' argument. But this is just my own view and is quite possible misguided).

So it's a regular practice to do these asymmetric tuning ? I've always wondered but it's good to know it's an existing practice, thanks.
Could be useful to have a 3 or 4 voices with a light MM+ tremolo but also a heavy M-MM+ tremolo whenever you need this timbre.
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Peadar on November 10, 2021, 05:56:47 PM
thank you Anahata and mselic, that explains how the one row melodeon works with the one reed ON pitch so it will match the L and H reeds while the other M reed can go higher, so when one plays a one row in its MM setting it's not going to sound exactly on pitch...

therefore if I have an instrument with just MM reeds and no couplers it will be better to tune it in the high low method, but if it's an LMM instrument it would be better to tune the M and L ON PITCH and the other M off but then the box when played MM or LMM will never truly sound on pitch right? will I be able to blend  in and match a fiddle's pitch when trying to play in unison?

do you happen to have or know of examples of a sound comparison for MM in the two tuning approaches?

mselic, I would be interested to hear the effect of that MMM equal offset tuning you mentioned
You may be under the delusion that a fiddle produces a pure tone. It doesn't. The vibration of the string may be pure, but it excites other resonant frequencies in the body of the instrument and this combination of secondary frequencies is what gives each individual instrument it's own unique tone. The same thing applies to all acoustic instruments.

The Free reed instruments produce the nearest thing to a "pure" tone of any acoustic instrument I know of... but even they produce some secondary vibrations which is why boxes don't all sound the same....and why some sets of reeds are more expensive than others.

The split tuning is (I think) technically called dedic or Viennese tuning. Something tells me it's harder to acheive than tuning one set of reeds to a scale and the other to an offset , whether higher or lower. Sometimes on older boxes the offset reeds were tuned lower than the main set - this is really apparent only of half stop two voice boxes - boxes in which only the tremelo set can be stopped off. Sometimes the stopped reed bank is lower pitched than the main bank rather than higher.

The thing is playing with others in a recreational rather than a professional setting- almost everything blends in unless it is absolutely horrifically car-crash off pitch.
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Yooval Mann on November 10, 2021, 06:01:46 PM
very interesting thank you
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Lester on November 10, 2021, 06:05:30 PM
The split tuning is (I think) technically called dedic or Viennese tuning. Something tells me it's harder to acheive than tuning one set of reeds to a scale and the other to an offset , whether higher or lower.
No more difficult, you are just tuning reeds to a pitch the fact that it is on a scale or offset is of no significance.
Quote
Sometimes on older boxes the offset reeds were tuned lower than the main set - this is really apparent only of half stop two voice boxes - boxes in which only the tremelo set can be stopped off. Sometimes the stopped reed bank is lower pitched than the main bank rather than higher.
All the boxes (not many) I had to look at that were presented as tuned to pitch and lower were in fact just boxes tuned to pitches lower that 440 which gave the impression of pitch and lower but were in fact pitch and higher.
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Kon on November 10, 2021, 06:08:23 PM
Hi Yooval,

It's a tricky topic, because there are a lot of variables. As a rule, there isn't one definitive way to do any particular tuning - there are lots of different possible approaches to tuning even a "simple" two-voice box. What's hard is that you will never find sound samples for every possible variable and/or combination of variables, so it will always stay a bit nebulous. Also, different boxes may well sound different even if tuned identically, so there aren't any universal answers. Probably your best bet is finding boxes you like the sound of and finding out how they're set up, which may or may not reveal some consistent preferences on your part. And if you're buying a box or having it tuned, make sure first and foremost that you are happy with the sound (ask for sound samples), whether or not it's the exact tuning you think you might like.

As far as I am aware, the traditional two-voice tremolo is one reed at pitch, one reed sharp (abbreviated M/M+). (Possibly because the equal M+/M- offset would have been much harder to achieve using traditional tuning methods before digital tuners.) The equal M+/M- offset is called Viennese tuning, or often Dedic tuning on here because forum member Ian Dedic is an exponent of this method. (In fact, I believe "true" Dedic tuning also uses a constant offset in Hz from the highest to the lowest note, i.e. the beat frequency is identical up and down the keyboard - whereas most people will adjust the beat frequency going up and down the keyboard, so-called tuning "on the curve" - this is a whole other kettle of fish, but perhaps worth being aware of!) Whether the instrument is tuned M/M+ or M+/M- will make no difference to the perceived wetness if the offset is the same, the M/M+ one will just sound a bit sharper (which may well make it sound a bit brighter and more pleasing - some people argue that's why standard orchestra pitch keeps slowly creeping upwards).

The question for an LMM instruments is a bit more complicated, and depends partly on whether you have couplers and how you intend to use them. If you ever want to play using the LM two-voice setting ("bandoneon" register) you pretty much *must* have an on-pitch M reed - having LM+ or LM- will spoil the pureness of the octave and sound off. But if you only have a stop for the low voice, or no stops at all, or only plan to play in the LMM and MM settings then M+/M- is still a viable choice - the L reed will sound in tune with the perceived pitch of the M reeds. I hope that makes sense!

As to MMM, as has been pointed out it can be symmetric or asymmetric, so there are no definitive answers. I do think the asymmetric M-/M/M+ *must* mathematically speaking have a more complex beat pattern, as we will have three different beat frequencies (M- and M reeds interacting, M and M+ reeds interacting, and M- and M+ reeds interacting), and the three different beat frequencies will move in and out of sync with each other. How audible that will be I can't say, but certainly MMM boxes sound richer and fuller to my ears than MM boxes - here's an old listing (with a sound sample!) on Theo's shop of one that I really love the sound of, for example: https://theboxplace.co.uk/product/sander-dg/

Here are some resources I've found useful in learning about different tunings:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,voices_tunings.html - the melnet guide(apologies if you're already familiar with this)
https://dia.to/guides/voix-vibrato-registres - this detailed page (in French, try google translate if required) gives lots of sound samples (simulated I believe), including MMM with equal offset

Re: diatonix - the benefit I see in giving the offset in Hz is that it gives you the expected beat frequency very plainly. Surely the messy reality is that both measurements exist and we have to be explicit about what units we are using if we are to communicate effectively, rather than trying to unilaterally impose our own standards on others.
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Yooval Mann on November 10, 2021, 06:13:14 PM
thank you Kon extremely helpful
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Peadar on November 10, 2021, 06:13:56 PM
The split tuning is (I think) technically called dedic or Viennese tuning. Something tells me it's harder to acheive than tuning one set of reeds to a scale and the other to an offset , whether higher or lower.
No more difficult, you are just tuning reeds to a pitch the fact that it is on a scale or offset is of no significance.
Quote
Sometimes on older boxes the offset reeds were tuned lower than the main set - this is really apparent only of half stop two voice boxes - boxes in which only the tremelo set can be stopped off. Sometimes the stopped reed bank is lower pitched than the main bank rather than higher.
All the boxes (not many) I had to look at that were presented as tuned to pitch and lower were in fact just boxes tuned to pitches lower that 440 which gave the impression of pitch and lower but were in fact pitch and higher.
The specific example I own is a Kalbe "Little Lord", which is tuned A452 on the unstopped voice and 452- on the stopped voice

(Point taken on the Dedic tuning)
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Theo on November 10, 2021, 08:17:49 PM
The question for an LMM instruments is a bit more complicated, and depends partly on whether you have couplers and how you intend to use them. If you ever want to play using the LM two-voice setting ("bandoneon" register) you pretty much *must* have an on-pitch M reed - having LM+ or LM- will spoil the pureness of the octave and sound off. But if you only have a stop for the low voice, or no stops at all, or only plan to play in the LMM and MM settings then M+/M- is still a viable choice - the L reed will sound in tune with the perceived pitch of the M reeds. I hope that makes sense!

Here is yet another subtle difference. With LMM setup there is a difference in sound quality between LMM+ and LM-M+ even if the offset between the two M reeds is the same.  There are no simple answers!
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: diatonix on November 10, 2021, 09:41:26 PM
Re: diatonix - the benefit I see in giving the offset in Hz is that it gives you the expected beat frequency very plainly. Surely the messy reality is that both measurements exist and we have to be explicit about what units we are using if we are to communicate effectively, rather than trying to unilaterally impose our own standards on others.

Far be it from me to impose anything on anyone. I just voiced my opinion, based on what I learned during 4 tough years under the watchful eyes and ears of unforgiving German master tuners and subsequently, after graduating in 1994, having during my career tuned I've no idea how many thousands of accordions, both diatonic and chromatic.
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMMy
Post by: Rog on November 11, 2021, 04:02:05 AM
Quote
Here is yet another subtle difference. With LMM setup there is a difference in sound quality between LMM+ and LM-M+ even if the offset between the two M reeds is the same.  There are no simple answers!
Sorry to mention the dreaded PA again (roll eyes)…but the multiple coupler instruments do offer some help in   understanding the voicings of free reed boxes… Some PAs have labelled couplers (rather than the dot arrangement). On some, the L, M+ coupler (not an octave, or it can be the L, M- coupler, which is part of the L, M-, M+ sound mentioned by Theo) is sometimes described as 'saxaphone' (L= bassoon, M, flute, H, piccolo, MM+ violin, LH organ…though the descriptions do vary). That particular coupler combo is an acquired taste i.e. it’s horrible ….unless you want a saxaphone sound (:)
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Joel on November 12, 2021, 03:43:32 PM
Couldn't find the answer on Google. I found it here. thanks.
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 12, 2021, 04:25:55 PM
I have LMM+ … and … 🥴 Not quite right. Tend to play L, or LM.

As for M-MM+ .. does it have to be symmetrical about M?

Would eg M--, M+ M+’ work, where the “average” pitch was M? Just asking …
Title: Re: Understanding tremolo and the differences between MM and MMM
Post by: Theo on November 12, 2021, 04:55:49 PM
[[ADMIN]]

Unrelated question moved to it's own topic: Missing buttons (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,27651.0.html)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal