Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Peadar on November 13, 2021, 01:04:54 PM

Title: A Question on 3 Stop Voices.
Post by: Peadar on November 13, 2021, 01:04:54 PM
Two Voice 1 rows are almost always MM. But what is normal for 3 stop boxes in C or D - Are they usually MHH like G and A 3 stops or in these higher pitches are they LMM?

As I understand it the "M" voices centre round middle C, with G below middle C as the lowest M voice and F above middle C as the highest.

I have long plate 3 stops in G and A which are both voiced MHH but I have no idea how a D would normally be voiced.

Thanks All

P
Title: Re: A Question on 3 Stop C or D one row.
Post by: Peadar on November 22, 2021, 06:39:40 PM
Still hoping for an answer.

I presume someone on here actually owns a 3 stop in C or D
Title: Re: A Question on 3 Stop Voices.
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 22, 2021, 08:02:02 PM
I own an F#GC 4th start which is … “equivalent”  It is 2 voiced, L+M. Bertrand Guaillard advised me me very strongly to order MM voicing,  saying that the L Notes ‘would not sound well’.

In his terms, I think that he was correct.  My very low end LM pairs are … fairly stable but not as rock solid as those in the middle of the keyboard. Played alone the lowest L reads voice slowly, and are easily ‘bent’ frequency-wise in play. The physical reeds needed for those L notes have weights on.  That is to say they are as low register has my bass notes on the left end.

My C#DG VanderAa is 3 voiced with the same general layout. Its low D notes are again weighted, slow sounding and stabilise only with LM or LMM selected. Lowest note is G3 (C5 = middle)

C boxes are of course designed to play in the middle of the keyboard, where there is no problem whatsoever.  I just don’t find it a problem, playing normal repertoire. But, I’m notorious here for liking Blues and similar genres, and in that repertoire bendability is an asset, not a liability 😉 Nor is there a problem singing.  I suspect that keen tune players … might have a different attitude?

This wasn’t quite your question, but I hope it helps. I don’t think that there is a standard, although there are plenty of people here who can contradict me if necessary.   In my view “it depends what you play”
Title: Re: A Question on 3 Stop Voices.
Post by: Peadar on November 23, 2021, 12:51:40 AM
Thanks Chris....what I'm trying to get at is what the standard layout would be for an old 3 stop.
The MHH sounds good (at least to me) on my Antoria in A I just wondered whether the higher pitched boxes might be voiced LMM - which on a D box would take you into the squeaky end of 3rd button start D&G .
Title: Re: A Question on 3 Stop Voices.
Post by: gettabettabox on November 23, 2021, 01:46:18 AM
My older model Hohner HA113 in D is voiced LMM.
Title: Re: A Question on 3 Stop Voices.
Post by: tirpous on November 23, 2021, 02:57:03 AM
I have an older 3-voice in D and it is MMH.  It seems (to me anyway)  that recent ones are mostly LMM.
Title: Re: A Question on 3 Stop Voices.
Post by: mselic on November 23, 2021, 04:40:03 AM
All HA113 models are LMM.
Title: Re: A Question on 3 Stop Voices.
Post by: gettabettabox on November 23, 2021, 11:03:12 AM
Yes, mine is as old as they come, wooden fingerboard, wick gasket etc. Older 2 voice in D as well, voiced MM.
Title: Re: A Question on 3 Stop Voices.
Post by: tirpous on November 23, 2021, 03:28:46 PM
Quote
I have an older 3-voice in D and it is MMH.  It seems (to me anyway)  that recent ones are mostly LMM.

Ooops sorry, this comment was about 3-voice one-rows in general (reply to Peadar), not about HA 113s.  My older 3-voice is not a Hohner !
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal