Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: brianread on October 22, 2009, 10:25:37 AM

Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: brianread on October 22, 2009, 10:25:37 AM
you mean it was on ALL NIGHT?

Gulp - I might have missed it!

memo to self - must check e-bay during the night as well..
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Bananayogi on October 22, 2009, 10:26:27 AM
Prices as sent to me when I put myself on the waiting list a few months ago:

eMelodeon enhanced (melodeon samples + standard soundset, ply casework)
---------------------------------------------
8 bass       £1095
12 bass      £1350
 
eMelodeon.2 (melodeon samples + standard soundset, louder reproduction, hardwood veneer finish casework)
---------------------------------------------
8 bass        £1495
12 bass       £1695
 
2.5 row is provided as standard. A 3-row option is now available at an extra £65.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 22, 2009, 11:51:57 AM
That really is a bit much for what you get in the end IMHO.

I don't know why Mr Streb doesn't licence the technology and have them made in China. To be honest, the workmanship is hardly Castagnari or Oakwood level, it's full of Hohner parts, they out-clack all but the most decrepit, rattly old Hohners and clever idea that it is, they don't sound all that great. I was listening to John Spiers play his with Bellowhead earlier this week and even through very good professional sound equipment the friend I was with commented that it was alright with the rest of the band going but when you could hear it clearly on its own it sounded like "a wheezy bag full of cheap harmonicas". If it was £350-400 and I could pluck it off the shelf of The Music Room or any Hobgoblin branch I'd probably buy one for fun and convenient practice but £1100-1700 with a long wait?, nah.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: ganderbox on October 22, 2009, 11:56:42 AM
you mean it was on ALL NIGHT?

Gulp - I might have missed it!

memo to self - must check e-bay during the night as well..


I saw it at about 9.30pm! Good job I've got a Loffet on order, or I might have hit the Buy It Now button myself! >:E


Prices as sent to me when I put myself on the waiting list a few months ago:

eMelodeon enhanced (melodeon samples + standard soundset, ply casework)
---------------------------------------------
8 bass       £1095
12 bass      £1350
 
eMelodeon.2 (melodeon samples + standard soundset, louder reproduction, hardwood veneer finish casework)
---------------------------------------------
8 bass        £1495
12 bass       £1695
 
2.5 row is provided as standard. A 3-row option is now available at an extra £65.

Thanks for the info. They're not so expensive when you compare them with Castagnaris, Salterelles, etc, are they? But then, they are a completely different animal.


Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Bananayogi on October 22, 2009, 02:06:54 PM
I was listening to John Spiers play his with Bellowhead earlier this week and even through very good professional sound equipment the friend I was with commented that it was alright with the rest of the band going but when you could hear it clearly on its own it sounded like "a wheezy bag full of cheap harmonicas".

But the only amplified sound you could possibly have been hearing was the sound of the samples. So presumably that's what Mr Spiers had chosen. I suppose it could sound like a bag of cheap harmonicas - it could also sound like a Castagnari, a Club, a church organ, a harpsicord etc. That's the point. Unless you are unimpressed with the quality of the samples - but there are plenty to choose from. When I played one, the melodeon samples sounded remarkably accurate. It still sounded like a monkey was playing it, but that's not the fault of the instrument!!

As for being full of Hohner parts... which bits? Having played one, the buttons aren't much like Hohner buttons, the action on them is nothing like (and even if they were, what difference would that make - they are just used as switches), there are no reeds, no pallets, the fingerboard isn't Hohner, neither is the case etc. Maybe the bellows? Some of the springs? I might be very wrong of course - so, as a prospective buyer, I would love to know.

I can see that some people would have a problem with the idea of the Streb (the different way it plays, being able to play a melodeon so it sound like a set of tuned doorbells etc), but I am not sure that either of the above are particularly valid criticisms.

Too expensive? I'd guess an 18 month waiting list and a very rapid Ebay sale for more than the retail price means that for some people it isn't. Too expensive for a mass market? Probably. Would I want to charge the prices Steve does? At the risk of putting ideas into his head, no. I think his prices are very 'reasonable' for what is effectively a low-run, hand made instrument with a lot of development time invested. Would tooling up a Chinese factory to make a niche product (eMelodeon) within a niche market (melodeon players) make financial sense? I very much doubt it.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: squeezy on October 22, 2009, 03:52:37 PM
It's good to get feedback (obviously not of the squealing sound type!  that's one of the main reasons I have chosen to try and develop the Streb to be a replacement for real melodeons in Bellowhead).

I don't actually use any of the built-in sounds on the Streb - the reason is that I am looking to replicate the sound of a real melodeon as closely as possible and with sample sizes that can fit on the chips inside the Streb - that is never really going to happen.  The samples I use are all high quality recordings of notes my real melodeons make played back by a dedicated sampler/computer called a Muse Receptor.  The quality of these samples is as high as the way we record acoustic instruments in the studio so that's not the problem.  I think the problem lies with the way reeds respond to different bellows pressures and you don't realise quite how important that is to a melodeon until you try to play music on an instrument which doesn't have those qualities.

I would honestly far rather be playing real boxes - the feel of the vibration of the reeds inside the instrument is quite important to playing with feeling and because the Streb isn't making it's own noises I don't get that at all.  However with the current set I would be taking 7-8 boxes on stage with me (some of which I doubt exist in real life - anyone got an F/Bb 2� row?) - and I would be having to fiddle around with microphones in between every song.

I think that I need to go back and have a look at the samples and maybe the bellows to volume curves on the instrument to have a last go at getting it right.  So thanks for the feedback Andy - it helps to have a pair of external ears or two - especially from a box player - and the Jorgina might get a look-in on the Bellowhead set now!

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Alison Scott on October 22, 2009, 06:09:02 PM
That really is a bit much for what you get in the end IMHO.

I don't know why Mr Streb doesn't licence the technology and have them made in China. To be honest, the workmanship is hardly Castagnari or Oakwood level, it's full of Hohner parts, they out-clack all but the most decrepit, rattly old Hohners and clever idea that it is, they don't sound all that great. I was listening to John Spiers play his with Bellowhead earlier this week and even through very good professional sound equipment the friend I was with commented that it was alright with the rest of the band going but when you could hear it clearly on its own it sounded like "a wheezy bag full of cheap harmonicas". If it was �350-400 and I could pluck it off the shelf of The Music Room or any Hobgoblin branch I'd probably buy one for fun and convenient practice but �1100-1700 with a long wait?, nah.

You know, that's a really harsh assessment. I got the chance to show off my Streb last week to someone who was interested in buying one; his eyes lit up when I passed him the box because he *had not noticed* that I was playing the electric box. Now, I'm not saying it sounds like a real melodeon; I don't personally think it does. But for accompanying singing, or fitting into a band that insists on playing in weird keys, or trying out loads of different keyboard layouts, or generating synth effects directly or through midi, or acting like several different melodeons at once, it's just fantastic. And you can play it silently, which is brilliant for people who travel or live in flats. It is also a whole lot more portable than a hammer action electric keyboard, and as versatile as the multi-thousand pound synth woodwind that the BBC was puffing the other week. Needless to say, the interested party could not wait to put in an order and I am certain I could have sold mine on the spot. Not that I'm about to cos I really like mine!

I'm slightly surprised that this one was sold at only the cost of a new one; my guess is that used Strebs would command at least a 25% premium over a place on the Streb waiting list.

I also loved seeing Squeezy playing it all night at the Shepherd's Bush Empire -- it fits in really well with the Bellowhead sound and I am sure it solves a ton of setup problems. I kept grinning to myself and thinking "I've got one of those". Which is odd really as I have many other melodeons too.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Alison Scott on October 22, 2009, 06:16:56 PM
I think that I need to go back and have a look at the samples and maybe the bellows to volume curves on the instrument to have a last go at getting it right.  So thanks for the feedback Andy - it helps to have a pair of external ears or two - especially from a box player - and the Jorgina might get a look-in on the Bellowhead set now!

Listening last night (from the very front row ho ho, standing from 6:15 to 10:45 and my *feet still hurt*), I detected the classic Streb issue, which is that it's very hard to get it to generate the dynamic range, and especially the 'punch' of a real melodeon; the sound felt smoothed-out compared to your normal playing. Equally, normally the melodeon cuts through the brass in the Bellowhead sound and I didn't feel that was as clear. Which was a shame. I did not think it sounded like a bunch of cheap harmonicas -- I thought it was reasonably recognisable which boxes were being sampled in fact and I thought all the samples sounded great.

On the other hand, no fiddling with different boxes, no mic issues or feedback risk and a completely wireless sound. That's got to be worth something.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 22, 2009, 06:53:38 PM
That's quite a challenge there, John. It's taken the best part of 30 years for big international companies to make reasonably convincing digital versions of analogue electronic instruments from the 60s and 70s, (and some say they still haven't), so God know's when someone's going to be able to electronically replicate a convincing acoustic instrument sound. It doesn't sound as good as a real melodeon on stage with Bellowhead but then again, I wouldn't really expect it to.

The Streb reminds me of the Line6 Variax electric guitar, when it was announced I remember everyone getting hugely excited by the idea of having all the sounds of desireable vintage guitars in one instrument and thinking that surely it was going to kill off most of the lower and middle end of the electric guitar market. When it finally arrived it was a very ordinary Chinese plank that sounded sort of like these other guitars and even played through thousands of pounds worth of pro audio gear still wasn't much better and has since become little more than a fairly expensive novelty for most people but filling specific demands very well for some people like the rather excellent comedian Mitch Benn, much like the Streb does in Bellowhead.

To the best of my knowledge, Steve Rouse is holding down a full time job as a teacher and I doubt he's making a worthwhile profit from making Strebs, in fact, I wouldn't be surprised if he wasn't making a profit at all on them. The current situation of a one man making them by himself as time allows during evenings, weekends and holidays can't be delivering very good value for either the maker, who probably doesn't earn enough back from it to really justify the time and effort he puts in, or the customer, who is at the mercy of his limited time and has to bear the cost of his overheads. If the technology was licenced to a company with the resources to produce them efficiently in quantity in China then it'll become afforable and available enough for all the people who'd like one to mess around with for fun or practice silently on but are put off by the relatively high cost and long waiting list and I'd be willing to bet that it'd be far more financially lucrative for Steve.

I'm guessing that if one private individual can do it then the electronics of the Streb must be based on components that are either already commercially available or very easy to fabricate, the bellows are definitely standard Hohner Erica/Pokerwork ones and I'm sure I read the buttons and springs were all Hohner as well . Either way, it shouldn't be a problem for one of the far eastern manufacturers to make the electronics very cheaply and even less of a problem for them to make a box or even modify the shell of an existing model for them and without the time and material costs of the reeds themselves, making and fitting the reedblocks and waxing and tuning the reeds then a sizeable chunk of the cost of manufacturing a box is out the window. Electronic instruments don't benefit from individual artisanal manufacture in the same way that acoustic ones do and no offence to Mr Rouse if he's reading this but whilst I think the Streb is a very clever concept and the price isn't outrageous, it doesn't look, feel or sound like a high status handmade instrument and there's no way I'd pay �1700 and wait 18 months for one in its present form.

�400 or so, a price not possible for a one man operation, and I'd buy one right now.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Lester on October 22, 2009, 07:38:04 PM
I'm sure I read the buttons and springs were all Hohner as well .

There are no buttons and springs just switches
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: streb on October 22, 2009, 08:26:56 PM
"I don't know why Mr Streb doesn't licence the technology and have them made in China."

Because I am not ruthlessly driven by profit. I want people to own something hand-made by me to the best of my ability in my own workshop, not churned out by twelve year old children in a backstreet sweatshop.

"Would tooling up a Chinese factory to make a niche product (eMelodeon) within a niche market (melodeon players) make financial sense? I very much doubt it."

Exactly.

@ Brian Read: if you want any bespoke layouts adding or if it needs fettling in any way then let me know.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: waldoB on October 22, 2009, 08:42:36 PM
Well said. Being a pioneer has never been easy. Are there many theatre critics writing decent plays ?
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: brianread on October 22, 2009, 10:31:15 PM
@ Brian Read: if you want any bespoke layouts adding or if it needs fettling in any way then let me know.

Many thanks for the offer, I am going to be on the edge of my seat until about Weds next week..Can't wait!
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: rees on October 22, 2009, 10:47:18 PM
Well said, Steve.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: upmine3 on October 23, 2009, 12:11:34 AM
I'm glad this debate is going on because i for one am intrigued about the Streb and I'm glad to hear from the maker and the purchasers. Having read comments about the bellow pressures, buttons and springs i might add the one thing that would definitely sell it to me (funds down at the moment) is the ability to play silently.
I'm restricted in my house to playing in my daughters nursery room (obviously when she's not in it) because it's a semi detached house and her room is on the end so I'm not annoying the neighbours.
Also my walls are paper thin to my adjoining neighbours so when i do play in other rooms i usually play my last tune at about 9:30 to be reasonable so the Streb would be ideal to me.
To think i could play a melodeon with headphones on till the wee hours to me is priceless.
The only concern to me about buying anything electric or with circuitry is that if i do buy it would it be like last years DVD player when the new one comes out? I mean you spend say £1495 on one then bang the new one comes out and sounds more realistic and you're left feeling like you've got to upgrade, or would the Streb circuitry be upgradable without getting a whole new box?
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: ACE on October 23, 2009, 08:19:45 AM


 I am going to be on the edge of my seat until about Weds next week..Can't wait!

If it was me I would not be waiting for the postman. It could be after xmas before you get a delivery.

Get on the train and fetch it yourself.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Sandy on October 23, 2009, 08:55:15 AM
But for accompanying singing, or fitting into a band that insists on playing in weird keys, or trying out loads of different keyboard layouts, or generating synth effects directly or through midi, or acting like several different melodeons at once, it's just fantastic. And you can play it silently, which is brilliant for people who travel or live in flats. It is also a whole lot more portable than a hammer action electric keyboard, and as versatile as the multi-thousand pound synth woodwind that the BBC was puffing the other week.
 

If the Streb suits your requirements then fantastic and If I was buying, then I would be so happy to actually deal with someone personally in terms of it's build and specification.

As for price...I wouldn't make a comparison to a real melodeon as they are two totally different instruments. The Streb seems to be  selling well as a practical instrument (not a fashion accessory). Think that speaks for itself.

Just out of interest, in 1982, I was in a musical instrument technology department of a London college that payed around 25k for a fairlight synthesizer. (the staff spent days trying to sample the cello playing of ELO's Hugh McDowell for an authentic sound).

Cheers

Sandy
 (:)




Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Guy on October 23, 2009, 11:04:16 AM

The only concern to me about buying anything electric or with circuitry is that if i do buy it would it be like last years DVD player when the new one comes out? I mean you spend say £1495 on one then bang the new one comes out and sounds more realistic and you're left feeling like you've got to upgrade, or would the Streb circuitry be upgradable without getting a whole new box?

I've had mine for several years, and have never felt the need to upgrade or change. I understand that Steve can provide updated sounds on request, and he's offered this during the course of this thread...



@ Brian Read: if you want any bespoke layouts adding or if it needs fettling in any way then let me know.

The Streb is just great fun (and different) to play, and I feel a fine example of someone having an original idea and executing it personally. The usual response to mine is "Wow! Can I try it?", followed after a prolonged period in which they refuse to put it down by "Where can I get one?", which I think speaks for itself. The fact that it seems to play better in other people's hands is another matter....

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: C age ing on October 23, 2009, 11:31:52 AM
That's quite a challenge there, John. It's taken the best part of 30 years for big international companies to make reasonably convincing digital versions of analogue electronic instruments from the 60s and 70s, (and some say they still haven't), so God know's when someone's going to be able to electronically replicate a convincing acoustic instrument sound. It doesn't sound as good as a real melodeon on stage with Bellowhead but then again, I wouldn't really expect it to.

Two simple questions from an owner of an Erika, Hanson ST-8 saxophone, Akai Electronic Wind Instrument, a Yamaha 9000 Pro and a good set of samples.

Can a person who states "It doesn't sound as good as a real melodeon on stage with Bellowhead but then again, I wouldn't really expect it to." be classified as unbiased?

Equally, does my  owner's audit make me biased?

Seems a bit like 'The digital is not as good as analogue CD versus vinyl' argument which was a reflection of the 'Valves are better than solid state amplification', 'Acoustic is better than electric reproduction' and 'Electric recording is not as good as acoustic recording' arguments and so on ad infinitum.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: brianread on October 23, 2009, 01:45:36 PM


 I am going to be on the edge of my seat until about Weds next week..Can't wait!

If it was me I would not be waiting for the postman. It could be after xmas before you get a delivery.

Get on the train and fetch it yourself.

there are alternatives to the PO you know?
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Andy Simpson on October 23, 2009, 02:01:35 PM
Right...

To clarify my position on this, I am not a naysayer, I don't think the Streb is a bad idea nor do I think the price is extortionate or unfair for an individually made instrument, as I said, I wouldn't be surprised if they aren't actually profitable. I have first hand knowledge of the difficulties involved in being an instrument maker and completely understand the motivation behind and satisfaction gained from making something to the best of your ability and seeing it in the hands of musicians you admire and profit is not my raison d'etre, (if you're ever at the Music Room ask Jon Loomes how much I'm charging him for his 8-string baritone guitar...).

However, I don't think the box feels, sounds or plays like its pricetag, a keyboard that noisy isn't acceptable on a handmade instrument costing up to £1700 with a year and a half wait IMHO. Citing the precedent of the Variax, digitial modelling amps, etc, whilst there will be the odd pro in particular circumstances willing to compromise sound and playability for the sake of the features and convenience it provides, the natural market for something like that is beginners, people who can't afford the things it's imitating, people buying it for a bit of fun, travelling or the ability to practice silently, etc and most of them would consider £1100-1700 and 18 months a bit much. I think the basic idea is very clever and Steve can be proud of having developed it and brought a usable instrument to the market, I just don't think that an electronic instrument really benefits from being made by one person in the same way an acoustic one does and there's a bigger market for it out there if it can be brought out at a lower price point by outsourcing production, which doesn't require "tooling up a Chinese factory", it can probably be incorporated into existing facilities reasonably easily, and "being churned out by 12 year old children in a backstreet sweatshop" is an emotive exagerration for the musical instrument and electronics industries. Aren't those already Chinese bellows on it anyway?.
Title: Streb on eBay
Post by: Lester on October 23, 2009, 02:30:31 PM
Right...

To clarify my position on this, I am not a naysayer, I don't think the Streb is a bad idea nor do I think the price is extortionate or unfair for an individually made instrument, as I said, I wouldn't be surprised if they aren't actually profitable. I have first hand knowledge of the difficulties involved in being an instrument maker and completely understand the motivation behind and satisfaction gained from making something to the best of your ability and seeing it in the hands of musicians you admire and profit is not my raison d'etre, (if you're ever at the Music Room ask Jon Loomes how much I'm charging him for his 8-string baritone guitar...).

However, I don't think the box feels, sounds or plays like its pricetag, a keyboard that noisy isn't acceptable on a handmade instrument costing up to �1700 with a year and a half wait IMHO. Citing the precedent of the Variax, digitial modelling amps, etc, whilst there will be the odd pro in particular circumstances willing to compromise sound and playability for the sake of the features and convenience it provides, the natural market for something like that is beginners, people who can't afford the things it's imitating, people buying it for a bit of fun, travelling or the ability to practice silently, etc and most of them would consider �1100-1700 and 18 months a bit much. I think the basic idea is very clever and Steve can be proud of having developed it and brought a usable instrument to the market, I just don't think that an electronic instrument really benefits from being made by one person in the same way an acoustic one does and there's a bigger market for it out there if it can be brought out at a lower price point by outsourcing production, which doesn't require "tooling up a Chinese factory", it can probably be incorporated into existing facilities reasonably easily, and "being churned out by 12 year old children in a backstreet sweatshop" is an emotive exagerration for the musical instrument and electronics industries. Aren't those already Chinese bellows on it anyway?.

Suggest you don't buy one then!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal