Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Luke Alexander Holstein on January 23, 2022, 02:48:03 AM

Title: Any recommended upgrades on a 12 bass PA
Post by: Luke Alexander Holstein on January 23, 2022, 02:48:03 AM
I have a Hohner Student II I'm working on. Besides new bellows, repad pallets, voicing then tuning reeds and replacing bellows gaskets, what else can I do? The two things off my head is maybe adding resonation bars between the reed blocks and drilling really small relief holes into the blocks on the high reeds. Also I've been thinking about modifying the bass end so that I can simulate minor chords for the meantime untill I swap in the bass end half of a student IV 24 bass version. Is there also a way to reduce clacking of the bass mechanism not relating to the pallets?
Title: Re: Any recommended upgrades on a 12 bass PA
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on January 23, 2022, 09:24:09 AM
I have a Hohner Student II I'm working on. Besides new bellows, repad pallets, voicing then tuning reeds and replacing bellows gaskets, what else can I do? The two things off my head is maybe adding resonation bars between the reed blocks and drilling really small relief holes into the blocks on the high reeds. Also I've been thinking about modifying the bass end so that I can simulate minor chords for the meantime untill I swap in the bass end half of a student IV 24 bass version. Is there also a way to reduce clacking of the bass mechanism not relating to the pallets?

Retune the basses to be DG friendly?
Or, convert it to a diatonic accordion?
Title: Re: Any recommended upgrades on a 12 bass PA
Post by: Theo on January 23, 2022, 10:18:18 AM
Greg you may be thinking of the Student I which is based on the same case as a pokerwork.  The Student II is a bigger box, and while nothing is impossible it would not readily lend itself to conversion to diatonic.
Title: Re: Any recommended upgrades on a 12 bass PA
Post by: Theo on January 23, 2022, 10:19:17 AM
I have a Hohner Student II I'm working on. Besides new bellows, repad pallets, voicing then tuning reeds and replacing bellows gaskets, what else can I do? The two things off my head is maybe adding resonation bars between the reed blocks and drilling really small relief holes into the blocks on the high reeds. Also I've been thinking about modifying the bass end so that I can simulate minor chords for the meantime untill I swap in the bass end half of a student IV 24 bass version. Is there also a way to reduce clacking of the bass mechanism not relating to the pallets?

You would be better asking this question on the accordionists forum https://www.accordionists.info
Title: Re: Any recommended upgrades on a 12 bass PA
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on January 23, 2022, 10:39:37 AM
Greg you may be thinking of the Student I which is based on the same case as a pokerwork.  The Student II is a bigger box, and while nothing is impossible it would not readily lend itself to conversion to diatonic.

You're quite right. To be honest, I was being  ironic. I was going to post the link to the accordionists forum https://www.accordionists.info, but I couldn't remember what it was called.

[With regard to the basses, I have a good friend who plays an umpteen bass PA for morris and was looking for a lighter instrument so she could play and dance more easily. I suggested one of the very pretty 12 bass Students, but she said that wouldn't work because it didn't have the basses she likes to use. Significantly, it was missing Em, but Bm and Am are commonly encountered, as well. F is consciously avoided  in our dance music.  I have speculated about a bass retune that would get around this. It would suit DG sessions as well, of course]
Title: Re: Any recommended upgrades on a 12 bass PA
Post by: Rog on January 23, 2022, 12:40:54 PM
You could shift the basses along to remove the F and Bb and replace them (on the other end) with E and B (to be consistent with the stradella system). On the 12 bass you don’t have a bass machine to contend with. You could also tape off the thirds to give a modal 5th interval 'chord'. If the bass shifting is too much just tape off the thirds. It’s v easy on the 12 bass Hohner Student (use masking tape).
….the F and Bb are v useful so personally I wouldn’t get rid….
Title: Re: Any recommended upgrades on a 12 bass PA
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on January 23, 2022, 01:05:43 PM
... remove the F and Bb and replace them (on the other end) with E and B (to be consistent with the stradella system)...
….the F and Bb are v useful so personally I wouldn’t get rid….

Bearing in mind that I am talking, very specifically, about an instrument designed to be compatible with a 21/8 DG melodeon for playing in a morris band (hence Bb and F being redundant), I would be inclined to go with the same basses generally available on those, so I would include an Em. Otherwise, yes, just move everything along. These leaves the same compromise solutions available as a DG melodeon.

I wonder if #minor7th fudges would be acceptable to someone used to a full pallet of chords.
It strikes me, also, that a fourteen bass  instrument, which retained Bb and F and added E and B, would be rather useful in a lot of contexts, but I doubt most accordionists would see it that way.

[What do you think, Luke?]
Title: Re: Any recommended upgrades on a 12 bass PA
Post by: Rog on January 24, 2022, 08:16:45 AM
Quote
It strikes me, also, that a fourteen bass  instrument, which retained Bb and F and added E and B, would be rather useful in a lot of contexts, but I doubt most accordionists would see it that way.
This is where one goes for a 48 or 60 bass  (:)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal