Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: John Burks on February 06, 2022, 05:35:20 PM
-
I'm a bit stuck.
A while back I picked up an old M Hohner 19 key 8 bass circa 1920's B/E. I have seen it described as a 5A and a similar model features in the 1929 instruction manual/catalogue Model 374
Its build quality is pretty impressive and it has all the marks of age that you look for (no grill but all original). The surface patina is actually pretty amazing. It's fully brass reeded. Zinc H plates mounted on leather gaskets (all original) ....but .......It came though with reeds broken (2 bass and 3 treble). To get it going I made some reeds for the bass and after struggling with the treble plates at the time re making new reeds I eventually decided to make a quick temporary repair by "piggy backing" smaller plate/reeds sections from a similar era long plate model (albiet cheaper construction). Just to get it playing.
All went well and it at least it became playable.
I now want to fully restore the internals to as near as original as possible and fine tune. This means that I need to remove the "piggy backs" and mount replacement reeds. My problem is the reed quality. I have tried to fit hand made reeds and have failed numerous times.
The plates I have are a mix of parallel sided and tapered reeds. I have to replace tapered. I have made new reeds to fit but I just can't get them to sound as well as the originals. I also am struggling to get the frequency given the aperture length and shape. It is to do with the flexibility of the material. The brass I am using simply cannot achieve the aperture dimensions. It is the same era but I don't think its as good a quality. The original reeds feel different. They seem to have a higher copper content looking at the colour. Having dusted off beam theory I have also calculated that I am unlikely to achieve the desired frequency with the brass I have. (Youngs modulus too low)
I can only surmise that the original reeds are some sort of bronze alloy? They must have been around just before steel reeds took off.
Does anybody have any experience re history, fettling them or sourcing base material to work with? If I could get hold of a few old reeds it would suit but what models era should I be looking for?
-
Post a picture please
-
Box (excuse the grill ;)):
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51866007916_be03ae568f_c.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2n2dRaN)M Hohner - Box (https://flic.kr/p/2n2dRaN) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr
Reedblock:
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51866655370_f855e42070_c.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2n2haCN)M Hohner - Full Reedblock (https://flic.kr/p/2n2haCN) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr
Reeds:
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51866654255_2a4602c42c_c.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2n2haiz)M Hohner Reedblock (https://flic.kr/p/2n2haiz) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr
Eg. Piggy-back reed = Problem:
There are three broken so I want to remove piggy-back and make new as original.
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51866370089_5a0b97d798_c.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2n2fGQa)M Hohner - Problem Reed (https://flic.kr/p/2n2fGQa) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr
-
Those reeds appear to be steel.
-
The plates I have are a mix of parallel sided and tapered reeds. I have to replace tapered. I have made new reeds to fit but I just can't get them to sound as well as the originals. I also am struggling to get the frequency given the aperture length and shape. It is to do with the flexibility of the material. The brass I am using simply cannot achieve the aperture dimensions. It is the same era but I don't think its as good a quality. The original reeds feel different. They seem to have a higher copper content looking at the colour. Having dusted off beam theory I have also calculated that I am unlikely to achieve the desired frequency with the brass I have. (Youngs modulus too low)
I can only surmise that the original reeds are some sort of bronze alloy? They must have been around just before steel reeds took off.
Does anybody have any experience re history, fettling them or sourcing base material to work with? If I could get hold of a few old reeds it would suit but what models era should I be looking for?
John,
I recommend that you take strips of ordinary sheet brass stock and hammer them as evenly as possible using a flat faced hammer and a small block of steel as an anvil. This will reduce the thickness of your brass strips so choose your original thickness accordingly. Maybe avoid the immediate area that you'll drill for the rivet. The hammering will also increase the length and width dimensions of your strips but those will be reduced again when you file the reedtongue exactly to fit the aperture in the reedplate. Then drill the tongue for the rivet hole, file the width and length to fit exactly, and then file the top of the reedtongue to tune it to pitch. A slight upward bend is needed, especially for the lower reeds. Compare with your working reeds of similar pitch for an idea of how the thickness profile should be for reeds of various sizes/pitches.
Some experimentation will be necessary to get the stiffness and dimensions (including the thickness taper) just right to provide the right pitch and to be as responsive as possible.
But the point of this hammering is to work-harden the brass, increasing its stiffness to a spring quality brass. This is exactly the technique recommended in the 19th century to replace brass reeds and I have used it for concertina reedtongues. I'll see if I can find the old article that got me into hammering the brass for these tongues.
PG
-
Hi again John,
My original source for the idea of hammering brass tongues to increase their springiness came originally from an article published in the late 19th century in "Amateur Work (Illustrated)," published by Ward, Lock & Co.
Here is a digitized volume of that magazine (?) but I don't think the one from which my first source came. However, this volume also has articles on concertina tuning and repair and you can search its contents to find those:
https://library.si.edu/digital-library/book/amateurworkillus03lond
My own immediate source however, was an excerpt from Amateur Work (I think a different volume than the one linked above) that was submitted by Wes Williams to the Concertina Newsletter No. 3, January 1972. (Just 50 years ago), p. 3.
Here's the key quote:
"Sometimes the new brass [that you use to replace a reed tongue] is a different temper from the other notes. To harden it before fitting hammer the tongue on a small smooth anvil, thinning it out toward the point. "
I hope this helps,
PG
-
Hi Theo and PG,
Many thanks for the responses. Both are really appreciated.
Having worked with the reeds a bit more this evening I am pretty convinced that they are Phosphor Bronze. They have that deep red hue when you work with them. They are not as hard as steel and respond well to a very fine diamond file. They have that hard bronze feel though and certain springiness. Having researched a bit more it would have been a natural development to use this material when they did. High tin content + Phosphor.
PG .... Many thanks for the idea of work hardening. I will try this next. I have some brass stock so will sort my peening hammers out and give it a go. I also want to say a big thanks though for the link to Ward Lock and Co document. Its just the sort of reading I enjoy believe it or not! An absolutely wonderful treat. Many thanks. Very much appreciated and I very much suspect that I will gradually print off the 460 pages!
Anyway I will try work hardening and report on how I get on :D
Thanks. This is a great site for those like minded (:)
John
-
Hi John,
Great, let us know how you get on.
I understood Theo's take on your photos. Depending on the lighting, steel reeds can sometimes glint yellowish or conversely in your case brass/bronze reeds can appear silvery. I could see by the texture of the metal especially in the transition from the vibrating part of the reed tongue to its riveted foot that it did not seem to have been filed out of steel and had no rust specks. So they looked like brass or nickel-silver to me.
You can try various alloys of brass, and bronze, and again nickel silver (white bronze) but I've had pretty good success from a variety of brass scraps given me by a friend who ran a machine shop. You can also hammer down round wire stock to flat reeds and I've done that with nickel-silver wire. This was all for english-style concertina reedtongues so I didn't have to rivet them. Obviously too much or too uneven with the hammering and you risk introducing stress that could lead to cracks or flaking. But the material is cheap so then try again. The combination of hammering, and playing with the thickness profile of the reeds will allow many different ways to get the same pitch out of a reed, but usually one combination is the sweet spot for volume and response.
Glad you like that book (periodical?). I've seen copies come up for sale and always wanted to buy one but other things were priorities for the budget. I wish all the volumes were available digitized! Just searched and there are multiple copies of various volumes available for sale right now. PM me for details.
Best
PG
-
hi the brass reeds you are making may need tempering which can be done by heating with a blowtorch to cherry red and allowing to cool slowly at room temp this makes them "springy "
-
Hi John,
Great, let us know how you get on.
I understood Theo's take on your photos. Depending on the lighting, steel reeds can sometimes glint yellowish or conversely in your case brass/bronze reeds can appear silvery. I could see by the texture of the metal especially in the transition from the vibrating part of the reed tongue to its riveted foot that it did not seem to have been filed out of steel and had no rust specks. So they looked like brass or nickel-silver to me.
I was viewing the photos on a very small screen on my phone. Now I look on a large screen I see the brass colour is quite obvious.
-
hi the brass reeds you are making may need tempering which can be done by heating with a blowtorch to cherry red and allowing to cool slowly at room temp this makes them "springy "
Hi Frank, Thanks. :D I will give it a go. I have sent off for some Phosphor Bronze so intend to try that and brass to see which suits best. Its a great box that I want to get right. Plays pretty well now but I need to fine tune to get the best out of those reeds.
Thanks again
John
-
I was viewing the photos on a very small screen on my phone. Now I look on a large screen I see the brass colour is quite obvious.
Hi Theo, the photos were pretty deceptive. Also the colour changes in different light. I struggled to work out what they are and I have them in front of me! (:)
I am going to try use phosphor bronze and hand make.
I could take some reeds from the chord bank as I have thirds taped but I'm reluctant to use these if I can.
Pretty sure I will succeed. Perseverance pays off .... usually ;)
-
hi the brass reeds you are making may need tempering which can be done by heating with a blowtorch to cherry red and allowing to cool slowly at room temp this makes them "springy "
Hi Frank
This is not my experience with brass or bronze. Sometimes you'll read that heat-treating brass is the opposite of hardening vs. annealing carbon steel, because heating brass to red hot heat and quenching it will anneal it. (Heating carbon steel to red hot and quenching it will harden it). But in my experience, brass is not the opposite of steel because heating to red hot and cooling slowly will also anneal it.
In my experience, with brass, the most hardening will occur with work hardening: cold rolling, hammering, and/or bending. If brass is hardened too much (for example by bending) it can become prone to breaking and then should be annealed.
However, you are using the word "tempering" which really means backing off from the hardest state in a controlled way to reduce stiffness and brittleness.
I assumed that this was not John's goal, in other words I assumed that the brass he was using at first may not be sufficiently hardened.
If John's brass is very hard already (for example from cold-rolling) and his reeds are too stiff, then his initial problem may have been that he didn't thin his reeds enough when filing.
PG
-
Just to back up Paul’s comments above. Heating brass and allowing it to cool slowly will anneal (soften) it. In addition heating brass to cherry red is getting close to the melting temperature and may result in permanent damage.
-
my experience of making springs from brass for old flute keys by this method must be a delusion then ! also I remember annealing copper cylinder head gaskets( for my motorcyles ) by heating to cherry red and quenching in cold water to soften ,( very successful ) so copper and brass are the opposite of steel IMHO I agree that brass is work hardening and hammering might be useful
-
Hi Frank
From John's post I assumed that he needed to make his brass *harder,* not softer (see his comment "Young's modulus too low"). Thus I gave advice on making brass harder via work-hardening.
Let's compare typical carbon steel and brass and how they respond to heat-treatment:
Carbon steel (simplified):
To anneal, heat to red hot (demagnetized), then cool slowly
To harden, heat to red hot, then quench quickly
To temper (after hardening), heat to controlled specific temperatures lower than red hot - this slightly reduces hardness but does not anneal, and can be important for making springs or reeds out of steel so that they are springy but not too stiff/brittle
Brass:
To anneal, heat to red hot (gas burner on a range is hot enough), then cool slowly OR quench quickly - the latter is just for convenience
To harden, deform by work-hardening (bending, hammering, or cold rolling
To temper (after hardening): I have found some references to tempering brass, but they seem to describe the process that I would call annealing (see above); I would be surprised to see this annealing process used to make a spring or a good reed out of brass as it would leave the metal very soft *
This is why I say that heat treating brass is not merely "the opposite of carbon steel," although one specific treatment (heating and quenching) has the opposite effect on the two materials. Another specific treatment (heating and slow cooling) has a *similar effect* on the two materials.
"Annealing is a heat treatment method where a metal such as aluminum, copper, steel, silver, or brass is heated to a specific temperature, held at that temperature for some time to allow transformation to occur, and then air cooled. This process increases the metal’s ductility and decreases hardness to make the metal more workable. Copper, silver, and brass can be cooled quickly or slowly, whereas ferrous metals like steel must always be cooled gradually to allow annealing to occur."
Source for latter quote:
https://inversesolutionsinc.com/5-types-of-heat-treating-and-their-purpose-in-precision-machining/
* Discussion of "tempering" (I would say, annealing) brass:
https://www.highettmetal.com.au/blog/brass/how-to-temper-brass
PG
-
Paul, a very detailed explanation with all the practical details set out.
I would take issue with your reference to Youngs Modulus. My understanding is that hardening and annealing are altering the yield point rather than Youngs Modulus, though it’s many years since I studied materials science so I may be mis-remembering😀
-
Paul, a very detailed explanation with all the practical details set out.
I would take issue with your reference to Youngs Modulus. My understanding is that hardening and annealing are altering the yield point rather than You gs Modulus.
Hi Theo, i was quoting John's post where he tried to explain the problem with his first brass reeds.
PG
-
Ah I see.
I’ve done some checking and it does seem to be the case that Young’s Modulus only changes slightly with annealing or hardening. What does change by a large amount is the yield pint — the amount of elongation (or bending) that the material will take and still return to its original shape.
-
Hi all,
I think I need both an increase in Youngs Modulus and Yield Point ???
The fundamental material properties dictate Youngs Modulus (springiness) within the elastic range and work hardening increases elastic range by shifting the Yield Point. You want both to optimise. Work hardening increases range of elasticity which is good. For the brass I was using in the first post above work hardening was the next logical step as it would give me more space to work (leeway) with the given material.
But .... I need to fit the reed to a given aperture 23mm long tapered 3mm-2mm and I now believe that the brass I was using was not up to it. Work hardening will extend the range and give me more leeway but .... I have realised ... I am simply using the wrong material. It will never match the aperture. You can't stretch its properties far enough.
The reed I am replacing is Phosphor Bronze. Youngs modulus for brass is 97GPa and for phosphor bronze its 121GPa. For steel its 200GPa. You can see the historic development of reeds here. They transitioned from brass to phosphor bronze to steel.
I have today very roughly modeled the Frequencies generated in all three materials (via Moment of Inertia - Vibration of a Cantilever Beam) and my best way forward i realise now is to use Phosphor bronze...... so I am using PB102. The resultant frequency range should be enough. (for pure brass I can't get higher than 600Hz and I need 830Hz - work hardening will help but its too tight)
I have therefore gone for work hardened PB102 strip and I have enough of it to try further work hardening to increase range and annealing if I have enough elastic range built in to the stuff I have bought (to make less prone to breakage)
The most wonderful thing is that talking about this on this forum has helped me work though this....... so thanks :D The quality of the discussion is excellent and I really appreciate it.
I will post once I have made a new reed in PB102.
If you want to do a reed generated frequency calc then here is a link >> https://calcdevice.com/natural-frequency-of-cantilever-beam-id181.html
(Note: Modified to give right web address)
Further down the page is the Moment of Inertia calc. You have to make some assumptions as reeds are not uniform thickness/width but you can get a feel of the dynamics at play.
John
-
Hi John,
I still suspect that you can get the pitches you need with a variety of brass or bronze alloys. I've seen them made from many types of brass and made them myself.
Work hardening is only part of the trick.
Another key component that influences pitch, besides the properties of the material and the length of the reedtongue, is the thickness taper of the reed. This will greatly influence the frequency of vibration. There's a lot of art to it, that you'll learn by experimentation, but as I recommended above it can help to model your reeds on a working one of similar pitch. In general, the lowest pitched reeds will be thickest at the tip, the middle pitches will have a relatively equal thickness along their length, and the highest pitched reeds will be thinner at the tip than at the foot.
But you want to thin the reed enough that it is flexible for good volume.
PG
-
Hi John,
I still suspect that you can get the pitches you need with a variety of brass or bronze alloys. I've seen them made from many types of brass and made them myself.
Work hardening is only part of the trick.
Another key component that influences pitch, besides the properties of the material and the length of the reedtongue, is the thickness taper of the reed. This will greatly influence the frequency of vibration. There's a lot of art to it, that you'll learn by experimentation, but as I recommended above it can help to model your reeds on a working one of similar pitch. In general, the lowest pitched reeds will be thickest at the tip, the middle pitches will have a relatively equal thickness along their length, and the highest pitched reeds will be thinner at the tip than at the foot.
But you want to thin the reed enough that it is flexible for good volume.
PG
Hi Paul, Thanks (:) My phosphor Bronze arrives today and I have acquired some small diameter brass rod that will suit the job so I will have a go with both. I have also topped up on emery wheels. What I thought I would do is try thinning by peening and by taking the material down by abrasion. As you say it will be a bit of a feel thing to get right. Its all about where you establish the moment of area and mass as you say.
May have to get the micrometer out!
John
John
-
Hi John,
I still suspect that you can get the pitches you need with a variety of brass or bronze alloys. I've seen them made from many types of brass and made them myself.
Work hardening is only part of the trick.
Another key component that influences pitch, besides the properties of the material and the length of the reedtongue, is the thickness taper of the reed. This will greatly influence the frequency of vibration. There's a lot of art to it, that you'll learn by experimentation, but as I recommended above it can help to model your reeds on a working one of similar pitch. In general, the lowest pitched reeds will be thickest at the tip, the middle pitches will have a relatively equal thickness along their length, and the highest pitched reeds will be thinner at the tip than at the foot.
But you want to thin the reed enough that it is flexible for good volume.
PG
Just wanted to say a big thanks for all the advice :D I seem to have achieved today what I thought was impossible. I have a working reed. You are right you do need work hardened material. You need it to stretch the yield point. I also did an experiment and made a reed and then annealed ..... the lower yield point gives you far less leeway.
Also really good advice re the profile. It took a while but you can really take the reed down across its length and see and feel an improved dynamic.
For this one today I used work hardened phosphor bronze strip (cold rolled PB102). I cut a blank at the max aperture width. I then took it down with a hand held rotary emery wheel (lengthwise) and files. I concentrated on getting a high frequency profile (thick>thin). This gave me a blank working at roughly my target frequency (G# 830Hz). I then trimmed the length and tapered the reed to suit the aperture. This raised the frequency to 1030Hz. I then gradually took down the root thickness to lower the frequency and increase flexibility. This brought flexibility back down the length of the reed. If you keep twanging the reed you can see the bend profile. I found that it was a combination of reducing the reed root and down the length of the reed that improved the dynamic. I used diamond files and then emery boards for the final tuning down to 830hz. The emery boards were good as they ensured a smooth thickness profile down the reed length.
So ...... I want to say a big thanks to all that responded… I now have a reed that works at 830.6 Hz ;D
I really appreciate the help and encouragement you get from this site ....... Thank you :||:
John
...... Two more to go ;)
Here are some pictures:
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51895837954_971d8b3131_c.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2n4RJAN)Reed Blank - Hand filed (https://flic.kr/p/2n4RJAN) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51895591733_9ce69ae3e5_c.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2n4QtpB)Reed Fitted - hand filed (https://flic.kr/p/2n4QtpB) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51896258227_8f714f0486_c.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2n4TTwT)Replacement Reed - Fitted to Aperture (https://flic.kr/p/2n4TTwT) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51897614956_79b676d448_c.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2n51QQL)Reed Replacement - Reed Gap .0015†(https://flic.kr/p/2n51QQL) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51897843279_c69b7e160c_c.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2n531Hn)Reed Replacement - Tuned Reed (https://flic.kr/p/2n531Hn) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51897508646_a75aa27387_c.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2n51ieQ)Reed Replacement - Fitted (https://flic.kr/p/2n51ieQ) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr
-
Great to hear John, thank you very much for sharing your work with us!
Paul
-
Great to hear John, thank you very much for sharing your work with us!
Paul
Seconded! - Job well done and your detail description of method ( and mechanics) is invaluable to others.
-
Nice work. You seem to have developed a good feel for the process of crafting a reed tongue.