Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Thomas Barnatt on February 13, 2022, 09:37:41 PM

Title: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 13, 2022, 09:37:41 PM
I just bought this old melodeon as a project to restore. I've restored, rebuilt, all kinds of things over the years but this will be a first. It was pretty cheap and I just love the look of it. I'm wondering if anyone can give me an idea of it's age, before 1900 or after? I'm going to have a million questions I'm sure but for now just a few. I got it Saturday and it's now in many pieces on the bench. There are only three pallets, three buttons are missing, the bellows are pretty much toast and the bass end frame and board the bass reeds sit on are now apart. I removed the bass box and will have to rebuild the pallets inside that. The treble pallets are  1 3/4" long, 11/16" wide and about 3/32" thick. Very thin, very worn, soft leather on them. At first I thought they were made of masonite but on close examination I believe it's cardboard. Question 1,I'm looking for suggestions on what to use to make new ones. If I use wood, (what's the best kind, should I use quarter sawn?) I'm concerned with shrinkage with them being so thin. I would want to seal top side after padding is glued to underside to create a moisture barrier, I would think. Question 2, The bellows are 1 1/8" wide, from fold to fold, no metal corners. A center frame about 3/8" thick with bellows on either side. There is a guy on Ebay, Bossetto Accordions, who sells bellows card stock one piece about 28" long, about 18 folds and 1 3/8" folds, could I use that on this Melodion? Even though it has 1/4" wider folds I thought it might still work. I'm going to need all kinds of things but will get to that as I progress. I want to get all the woodworking done first, the rebuilding of the box etc. before I start on the technical, mechanical stuff and reed issues. I believe it's in the key of C, having. Looking forward to working on this, it will be fun. I'm a retired carpenter/cabinetmaker and am always looking for good projects to keep me busy, this will be a good one. To be continued.  Tom       P.S,  Should I have posted this on Repairs etc.?   
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 13, 2022, 09:39:11 PM
Two more photos
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Pete Dunk on February 13, 2022, 11:12:55 PM
The way the reeds are mounted is something new to me. On first sight it looks like a typical cheapo German box but the reeds are on individual plates that are fitted a little like traditional concertina reed shoes from the look of it. This might be a very good box!
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 14, 2022, 12:59:38 AM
Pete Dunk, I assumed it was what you said, a typical cheapo German box, but because it's a cheapo box is the reason I got it. I was firstly looking for a project, I don't care about how good an instrument it is, I just love the way it looks and was made and would like to restore it. It is also much different looking than all the other cheapo German boxes I've seen, which includes the way the reeds are mounted. I was also happy to see they are brass reeds because I like the sound of them. I play the English concertina which has steel accordion reeds and after hearing someone with an old brass reed instrument I just love the way they sound. My goal is to get this thing to play again, give it a second life so to speak. Your comment that it could be a very good box is encouraging, but I'm not holding my breath!! Let's hope we can say that for sure after I've finished with it.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 14, 2022, 05:17:42 AM
I've run across Meinholds occasionally; they were a budget brand in Klingenthal,and made both button and piano accordions. I don't know if they were the same Meinholds who made autoharps.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 14, 2022, 08:48:41 AM
From accordion links.com

Meinel & Herold was a manufacturer of accordions from Klingenthal, Germany, founded in 1893. [MH] [WM]
W. L. Meinel was a manufacturer of accordions and concertinas from Untersachsenberg, Germany, founded in 1853. [MH]

Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 14, 2022, 11:33:10 AM
From accordion links.com

Meinel & Herold was a manufacturer of accordions from Klingenthal, Germany, founded in 1893. [MH] [WM]
W. L. Meinel was a manufacturer of accordions and concertinas from Untersachsenberg, Germany, founded in 1853. [MH]

That was my first thought, "Meinhold" being a contraction of "Meinel & Herold";  but the "Meinhold" brand was apparently Moritz Meinhold of Klingenthal, a different firm (info also from accordionlinks.com!).
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 14, 2022, 11:41:18 AM
Interesting, thanks to all. Any idea as to when it was made? I'm guessing sometime after 1900. Regarding my reconstruction/restoration questions I'll start posting those over in Design, Construction, Repair.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 14, 2022, 01:29:52 PM
The way the reeds are mounted is something new to me. On first sight it looks like a typical cheapo German box but the reeds are on individual plates that are fitted a little like traditional concertina reed shoes from the look of it. This might be a very good box!

Te reeds look very much like harmonium reeds.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Mike Hirst on February 14, 2022, 03:51:22 PM
reeds look very much like harmonium reeds.

My thoughts exactly. I made a quick search for Meinhold harmoniums, but found no match.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 14, 2022, 04:15:42 PM
Though harmonium reeds usually have the rivet at the square/outboard end.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on February 14, 2022, 04:25:49 PM
Aren't harmonium reeds singles? Just suck or just blow?
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 14, 2022, 05:05:06 PM
That's right Pete.  The photo is very small, and I hadn't looked closely enough to see that these are in pairs.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 14, 2022, 05:41:59 PM
Here are two closer images of the reeds. They are not what you are calling single I believe, because you can see the other side of the reeds through the pallet holes. Am I correct in assuming that?
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 14, 2022, 06:28:21 PM
That clarifies things, it’s a very elegant design.  Yes yours have a pair of reeds on each plate, one for press and one for draw. Harmonium reeds are similar in general shape. Harmoniums only have one direction of air flow so only need one reed per plate.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 14, 2022, 08:41:59 PM
Thanks Theo, for all the great information.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Pete Dunk on February 14, 2022, 09:20:53 PM
I repeat. This is an unusual, possibly a very rare instrument. That doesn’t suggest that it’s particularly valuable, it may or may not be. It is certainly of interest to box nerds like me and no doubt many others on this forum. Please be very careful in the way you treat this box, it may just be a prototype, one of a kind and utterly unique. Again this doesn’t reflect any particular value but it is, seemingly, of historical value. I, for one, am exceedingly jealous!
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Peadar on February 14, 2022, 09:29:27 PM
I repeat. This is an unusual, possibly a very rare instrument. That doesn’t suggest that it’s particularly valuable, it may or may not be. It is certainly of interest to box nerds like me and no doubt many others on this forum. Please be very careful in the way you treat this box, it may just be a prototype, one of a kind and utterly unique. Again this doesn’t reflect any particular value but it is, seemingly, of historical value. I, for one, am exceedingly jealous!

Seconded.
As a retired cabinet maker you presumably once worked with "hot glue". Hide glue is an effective adhesive for leather valves if you take the "traditional material" approach to restoration.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 14, 2022, 09:50:47 PM
Pete, You are making me nervous!! I completely understand what you are saying and I feel the same way. I don't care what it's worth, as I said I bought it as a project. I think now I need to assess what I'm going to do with it, restore it as best I can and keep everything original or restore and change things to make it a more usable instrument. We collect striking antique clocks and with those I only clean them and repair broken parts and clean the movement so they work, I try to keep all the signs of their life intact. The following pictures show things better than others I've sent. PEADAR, yes I have used hide glue for years on all antique that I have worked on, love that stuff. I buy the granular stuff you mix with water, but have also used the Titebond brand and like that as well. As you can see in the pictures the box has one stop, and when I saw what that stop knob looked like that's when I decided to buy that box!! It's just awesome!
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 14, 2022, 09:52:33 PM
4 more pics
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 14, 2022, 09:59:25 PM
As you can see the pallets are pretty thin, and I believe they are cardboard. I got the keyboard apart, pallet levers with the buttons on them. I would love to replace the three missing buttons with originals from another box, hopefully. The pallets i will have to make but was thinking of using wood unless I shouldn't if I'm trying to keep things original, not sure what to do now. I'm going to be asking some technical questions pretty soon but will post over on Repairs page.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 15, 2022, 07:14:53 PM
Before I move over to Design, Construction and Repair in order to ask repair/restore questions, it will be helpful for me to know how far I'm going to go with this Meinhold melodeon restoration. Meaning, should I restore it to stabilize the instrument in order to lessen deterioration, should I patch it up so it will play, should I modify things to make it better? I'm just curious to know what some of you, who I'm sure have been where I am, would do. My plan is to repair it so it will play again, to some degree, not necessarily for long periods of time either.  How far I go is going to depend on advise by others and on what is actually feasible. I believe that repairs on antiques should be visible and they become part of it's life story, so I'm not concerned with "patching" things. I want to try to keep most things as they are, if possible. I guess if it was an incredible, one of a kind and valuable instrument that should be in a museum then maybe I would have to leave it as it is, and hunt for another project. I'm going to be asking a lot of questions, some probably somewhat crazy, I plead ignorance on those!! I'm going to ask the first one now. Can I patch up the bellows? I just love the decorative papers on them and the maroon bellows tape and don't want to loose them. Can I re-enforce with cardboard where they have come apart from the inside? Can I put new leather gussets on the whole bellows from the inside and leave the original ones in place, even the torn ones?  Can I get matching bellows tape and go over old stuff where it's worn away? If I remove the gussets I will destroy the decorative papers on the outside of the bellows because the gussets are under them. In my overly positive opinion the cardboard the bellows are made of looks pretty good, obviously except where they have come apart, but that's because of failed leather gussets. Well that's it for now, thanks to all for all the good advise. Tom
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Pete Dunk on February 15, 2022, 10:14:56 PM
Pete, You are making me nervous!!


I’m sorry that wasn’t my intention, I just wanted to draw your attention to the unusual features and innovative design of the box. Bellows are always a consumable item and it’s not always practical to conserve them. Seeking out sympathetic paper designs and bellows tape is as much as we can do to retain a sympathetic restoration but from my point of view it’s more important that the instrument retains its primary function, to play music. Preserve what you can but remember that it was intended to play music to the delight of the musician.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Peadar on February 15, 2022, 10:35:59 PM
As you can see the pallets are pretty thin, and I believe they are cardboard. I got the keyboard apart, pallet levers with the buttons on them. I would love to replace the three missing buttons with originals from another box, hopefully. The pallets i will have to make but was thinking of using wood unless I shouldn't if I'm trying to keep things original, not sure what to do now. I'm going to be asking some technical questions pretty soon but will post over on Repairs page.

Given the direction this thread has already gone you could ask Theo (Admin) to move the topic over onto the repair page - That way the technical questions/answers will be part of the continuing (and hopefully supportive) discussion.

You are the OP (Originating Person?) so it's your call.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Pete Dunk on February 15, 2022, 10:43:10 PM
You are the OP (Originating Person?) so it's your call.


I think OP means Original Poster.


Nitpicking of course, sorry about that.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 15, 2022, 10:55:10 PM
I messaged Theo last night about moving it and he responded saying he thought he would leave it were it is. I'm getting to the point where I need to ask technical questions so I am going to start a new post over in Design, Construction and Repair. Tom
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 16, 2022, 09:40:30 AM
Following on from Peters comment about bellows:  worn bellows are one of the hardest things to repair.  On instruments as old as yours it’s normally not possible to find matching materials for the exterior.  If the cardboard is beginning to split at folds that suggests that the material is degraded.  If you make repairs more splits are likely to develop with playing.  In Addison making many internal patches to bellows folds and gussets will make the bellows thicker in places when closed and stiffer.  If you were very lucky you might find a good set of secondhand bellows of the same size.  If you have to get new bellows the cost will make the project rather expensive.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 16, 2022, 12:03:24 PM
Theo, I hear what you are saying and agree. I was just wondering if it's ever done, but with something so old I'm sure it will just keep deteriorating around repairs. I saw on Ebay cardboard cardstock bellows from Bossetto. I believe the folds are pretty close to the same size as my old one and I could get all I need from the one for my project. This is where I need help, am I buying the correct things? I would really like to try to make my own, of course ignorance is bliss I know but I'd like to make the attempt. I don't know what to get for gussets, size and thickness, and appropriate look for a restoration like this. I also want to change all the leather valves and don't know what to get there either. Some valves are thicker some thinner. I don't own a pair of metric calipers, yet, so don't know the MM of the old valves. Can one buy a pkg. of assorted sizes and just pick from that or do I need to measure all valves and order those sizes? Is it that important to be that accurate with valves or will "close enough" work? The bellows are going to be my biggest obstacle I think. I will also as you say see if I can find an old set that are the same size but I can't imagine that will be easy! I haven't looked but is there a classified/for sale section on this forum? If there is I can always ask there if anyone has something that will work. Thanks for the help. Tom
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Winston Smith on February 16, 2022, 12:08:46 PM
My first melodeon was a good example (as Peader would attest as he ended up with it!) the bellows eventually had more cereal packet than original cardboard.
I just kept scouring eBay for cheap old rubbish until I found one which looked the same size and type, then asked the seller for measurements before I bought it.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 16, 2022, 12:35:44 PM
Valves are easy, you can buy ready made leather valves from Charlie Marshall at cgmmusical.co.uk.  Use the smallest size that will cover the vent, and trim to length with sharp scissors if necessary. 

Making your own bellows is possible but will challenge your skills!  There are youtube videos showing various methods.  Again you can get all the parts from Charlie.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: dino.pafftti on February 16, 2022, 01:42:22 PM
Valves are easy, you can buy ready made leather valves from Charlie Marshall at cgmmusical.co.uk.  Use the smallest size that will cover the vent, and trim to length with sharp scissors if necessary. 

Making your own bellows is possible but will challenge your skills!  There are youtube videos showing various methods.  Again you can get all the parts from Charlie.

great job
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 16, 2022, 02:00:34 PM
Those are nice!! My melodeon has a center frame separating two bellows. Also it has no metal corners, just the tape which runs in one piece, corners mitered, with the end seam on the bottom. I'm thinking it may be easier for me because each separate bellows is smaller, that is if I attempt to make them. I'm also thinking that if I buy unfinished bellows that I have to cut to size and if they are wider, meaning the folds are wider, the only thing that would happen is the inside dimensions of the finished bellows would be smaller and probably not have any real effect on playing. I have a lot to do before I get to that and can be hunting for a used pair that fit in the meantime. Tom
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 16, 2022, 03:25:20 PM
I have a lot to do before I get to that and can be hunting for a used pair that fit in the meantime. Tom

Post your measurements here and i (and probably others). will have a look for you.

Bellows without metal corners are a feature usually only found on very early instruments.  That, and the unusual reeds makes me think this is a 19th century, or very early 20th century instrument.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 16, 2022, 04:14:59 PM
There are two bellows, each with four folds between a 3/8 +/-" thick frame. At the beginning of this post there is a picture of them. They measure 6 1/4" x 12 3/4". The frames they were glued to are 1/16" larger in both directions. Do you not include the half a fold that is glued to the frames when referring  to how many folds bellows are, or is it just assumed that there is a half that is used to attach them? It would be nice to find some bellows made the same way, with the center frame, and no metal corners,even though they may be newer. Not sure how far into the 20th century they were made that way.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 16, 2022, 07:59:17 PM
I have some bellows that are 6 1/4" wide but 12 3/4" is very tall.   Most of the old ones I have are around 11"
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 16, 2022, 08:29:12 PM
Thanks for looking Theo. Maybe I'll hear from someone else.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 18, 2022, 11:33:49 AM
If you use Facebook it would be worth posting some photos on the Accordion Appraisal and sal page https://www.facebook.com/groups/accordionvalue

Look out for comments from Paul Groff or Stephen Chambers who are both very knowledgeable on older instruments.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 18, 2022, 01:36:46 PM
Thanks Theo, I'll watch for Paul Groff and Stephen Chambers. We don't do Facebook anymore so that's out. I'm not in any rush on this project so even though it may take awhile I think I'll find parts I need.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 20, 2022, 01:58:37 PM
Just thought I would post some pictures of my progress with this Meinhold melodeon. These are obviously the keys, before removal and then two shots of them out. The last is of the pallets.  Please correct me if I'm wrong in referring to them as keys. I'm sure every part has it's own name and I'm sure you all know what the things are without me telling you. I'm going to make new pallets probably out of quarter sawn mahogany. I showed Charlie Marshall the pallets and he wondered if they were replacements. The pallets for the Air and Basses are wood, somewhat quarter sawn and about 3/16" thick. There were only two in place, the others down inside the melodeon, and I remember the buttons were very high up out of the keyboard which made me think the originals were perhaps thicker.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Theo on February 20, 2022, 02:05:00 PM
Those pallets look ok, I’d just clean them up and use them. 
You can’t rely on button heights to tell you what was there originally because the wire part of the lever is easily bent.  In practice bending the wire lever is the way to adjust button height.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 20, 2022, 02:35:39 PM
Theo, What do you think of my idea of making new ones of wood? I don't know how wood, as thin as the original cardboard ones, will work. The cardboard of originals is very dense and flat. My fear is even heavy cardboard of today may warp once pallet leather is glued to it. Tempered masonite would work but not sure I can get it that thin. Any suggestions?
The following images are of a split in the board the pallets rest on. It was a tedious process. I put masking tape over the holes and split on the pallet side then clamped another on the inside, just to make sure the wood at the split was flush. I used replaceable Weatherseal putty for putting around windows for drafts to make little dams at the ends of each split at ever hole. I then used JB Weld to fill the holes. It worked like a charm. JB Weld sands very nicely and the whole thing came our great. I've used JB Weld for lots of repairs and some have lasted for years and are still in place. I'll post more images as I move forward with the project. Tom
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 21, 2022, 03:07:32 PM
Two more Questions.
1) The first picture is of the bass reed block, the larger one. There are two large single reeds, from left to right, then a double reed. The left reed is on the underside hence the leather valve on top. The second reed is on top so I thought there should be a leather valve on the underside, (see second picture), but there isn't. Should it be that way? Is it valveless so it works on push and pull? If it had come off it would have been loose under the block when I removed it. I'm sure the blocks were never removed since it was built, at least there is no evidence of them having been removed.
2) The third picture is of the board the treble end reed block is glued to, the fourth picture is of the reed block with the reeds still in it. If you look close you can see the shine of the old hide glue on the board, it is around the perimeter and all around the round holes. Is it necessary to glue it back on as it was (around the round holes) or will just gluing around the perimeter suffice?
Also the reed block was nailed with small brads from outside of board into the block at each corner.   I'm wondering if anything at all is necessary.  All the brads are going to do now is to act as locators and not really have any holding power. I'm thinking bolts would be good if it ever had to be remove but then you would need to use gaskets and that would raise the block, and the slide for the stop would be too thin.
Thanks to all, Tom
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Winston Smith on February 21, 2022, 07:33:23 PM
Those single tongue reeds look exactly like the reeds from an American Organ/Pump Organ/Harmonium. The reeds  that I have, have the note stamped into the shoe, I think at the foot of the tongue.
Title: Re: Anyone know of this maker,Meinhold's ?
Post by: Thomas Barnatt on February 21, 2022, 10:37:50 PM
Winston,
I have seen on YouTube a man cleaning harmonium reeds and they are single sided with the note stamped on them. They do look just like mine, although mine are not stamped. I just removed all the reeds on the treble end and am being very careful not to get them out of order!!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal