Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: arty on February 22, 2022, 01:34:45 PM

Title: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: arty on February 22, 2022, 01:34:45 PM
I have occasionally heard players ‘bending’ a note, in the same way as a guitarist would by pushing a string sideways on the fingerboard.
How is that done....does anyone know?
Title: Re: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: Winston Smith on February 22, 2022, 02:04:29 PM
Many moons ago we'd do this with the moothies by just forcing the air through the reeds, so I expect it's the same principle with our instruments. I'm sure Mr Ryall will give a more definitive answer shortly, as he's a blues man.
Title: Re: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: Kon on February 22, 2022, 02:28:25 PM
I don't usually do this deliberately, but on my GC Erica (which I play with the grille off, in case that makes any difference) I find that some of the lower notes (on the pull especially) can sound quite "bend-y" when the pallet is very nearly closed / the button is barely pressed. So that might be something to experiment with - keeping constant bellows pressure rock backward and forward very slowly on one button and see whether you can achieve the effect you're looking for. Like I say, it's not something I do deliberately, but on slow tunes it has occasionally crept in as an audible effect, which at least suggests it could be done deliberately. It's more like a harmonica bend though (bending the note down) than a guitar bend (which raises the pitch).

I also find more in the middle of the keyboard that a sharp pull on the bellows can produce a slightly bendy feel (in this case upwards), but I'm not sure the pitch actually changes, it might just be bendy dynamics if that makes any sense.
Title: Re: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 22, 2022, 03:00:51 PM
Many moons ago we'd do this with the moothies by just forcing the air through the reeds, so I expect it's the same principle with our instruments. I'm sure Mr Ryall will give a more definitive answer shortly, as he's a blues man.

Yes, easy to do on a gob-iron on the  "draw" (sounds more refined than "suck"!), more difficult on the blow. Theoretically do-able on a melodeon, I'd have thought, but far more challenging because of the stouter and more complex construction and less direct passage of air over the reeds. Also I'd guess the greater mass of melodeon reeds compared with harmonica reeds will be an issue. I'm not quite sure how you'd approach it on a box - if I'm adding a bit of  bluesy "harp" to a song I tighten the grip of my lips on the instrument and suck hard (I think......), but you don't have as direct an influence on the airflow in a box.
Title: Re: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: Dick Rees on February 22, 2022, 04:57:56 PM
I have occasionally heard players ‘bending’ a note, in the same way as a guitarist would by pushing a string sideways on the fingerboard.
How is that done....does anyone know?

Actually, it's the opposite.  The guitarist raises the tone in pitch when stretching the string while a "harp" player lowers the pitch.
Title: Re: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: nigelr on February 22, 2022, 05:24:42 PM
I saw Chris Parkinson demonstrate it at a workshop once.  It was really only possible on the lower notes on the keyboard and involved slowly opening the palette by pressing the button in whilst pushing or pulling the bellows very hard.  It seemed like a lot of faff for not much of an effect to me.
Title: Re: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: george garside on February 22, 2022, 05:33:15 PM
whilst effective on a mouthy for the reasons quoted I think it is best avoided on a melodeon  as it adds very little to the proceedings and is more likely to detract from a tune rather than enhance it

G
Title: Re: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 22, 2022, 07:52:36 PM
There was a discussion about this last year. If I remember correctly, the conclusion was that you can only do it effectively on a single reed. I know that I find it natural on my (single voice) concertina, but it doesn't work on any of my (two voice) melodeons.
Title: Re: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: Mark Anderson on February 22, 2022, 08:38:59 PM
I've played with this a bit.  I think it's not so much about pressing the button slow as it is about pressing it only a small distance, barely opening the pallet.  For this reason I find it much easier to do on the draw than the press.  I think that in general, pushing really hard on the bellows tends to push the pallet open, making it harder to hold the button steady at 1/6 depression or whatever it is.  (Or it may just be me, since I have a bit of a tremor in my pumping arm that comes out mostly on the push.) 

This topic got me to try bending again to see (hear) how far I could bend notes, measuring the average bend with a tuner app on my phone.  On the lower octave or so of my two-voice, dry-tuned C#/D box (D3 to G4), I can pretty reliably get a 30--50 cent drop in pitch on the inner row.  On the lowest notes I can sort of bend down more than a semitone (ca. 125 cents), but it doesn't sound any good.  Volume suffers, but more importantly the two reeds do not bend the same amount, and often one or the other chokes intermittently.  Either case sounds terrible. 

Interestingly, I found it much harder to bend on the outer row.  Those pallets move much farther off the fondo for a given button movement and I think that made it too tricky to keep the pallet close enough to the holes.

The biggest bends you can get out of a harmonica rely on a coupling to the other, lower reed. The pitch control and stability relies on a coupling to the chamber size/shape of the player's mouth.  Squeezeboxes have valves on low reeds, ruining the reed-reed coupling, and the mouth stuff is pretty hard to emulate on a box too.  Maybe that's some of what the low pallet thing is all about.  Then again, Stevie Wonder could bend notes pretty well on a chromatic harp with wind savers (i.e., valves), so maybe I just need to practice more.

Maybe a single-voice box like a Castagnari Lilly with the valves off would be a better bending box.  Anyone tried something like that?  Ah, cross-posted with TDG.  Thank you for answering my question in advance, Greg.  :D
Title: Re: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 22, 2022, 10:04:23 PM
Just a few comments. I think it was split from another discussion.

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,27266.msg328689.html#msg328689
Title: Re: ‘Bending a note’
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 10, 2022, 02:41:13 PM
Many moons ago we'd do this with the moothies by just forcing the air through the reeds, so I expect it's the same principle with our instruments. I'm sure Mr Ryall will give a more definitive answer shortly, as he's a blues man.

sorry to be a bit late coming back, Winston. And please do call me Chris like everyone else. If you must use my title I would prefer Doctor 🙂

You will not have much luck with tremolo MM reeds, They stabilise each other. 

Technique is a little counterintuitive, but, yes very much like a mouth organ. It works much easier on the pull, and in the low-middle of the range. Experiment as to which notes bend better. It is easiest with a single voicing.

1 Pull gently on the bellows and very slightly depress the button until the sound starts, slightly strangled.
2. At that point pull harder on the bellows and the note will bend.

You tend to control it more with the air pressure than finessing the button, but do experiment with both to find out what works with your kit. They all have different personalities. My kit has some very low, (i.e. weighted) bass type reeds at the head-end on the right. I can bend them by up to a semitone.  I can slip in a bend judiciously within a song or tune, and it is also a nice way to finish the accompaniment of a song. Ease back on the bellows and it fades away to nothing
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal