Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: arty on February 25, 2022, 07:19:20 PM
-
I have 5 boxes in all, 2 Castagnari's, 1 Beltuna and 2 Hohner's but it is this old C/F PrePokerwork that makes my heart sing every time I play it. It is the first box that I bought, from Mike Rowbotham, while working in Cornwall and all I could afford at the time. Since then, I have returned it to Mike, who has completely restored it and I just love the sound that it makes! It seems to suit those lovely, slow melodic melodies that never really sound right on any of my other boxes.
Recorded today, here is Anna's Visa..... https://youtu.be/vYpWcrtnrsw
What is your favourite box? - why? - and do you have a recording of it?
-
My Hohner Pressed Wood modded to 4th button start and a thirds stop.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rgyxLgO7yf8
-
Ahh, Lester - I can hear that that box is special too! Lovely (:)
-
My Castagnari Jilly.
It was one of the original batch Pete at Acorn had in and I nabbed one.
I did something I've never advised - bought unseen following rave reviews at it's Whitby launch. I knew I could return it within so many days if it didn't work for me.
It took minutes to realise it was even better than friends had described following the Whitby launch and certainly was staying with me in its' new home in Devon.
I play it every day.
-
Got to be my favourite go-to instrument - my aged Saltarelle Pastourelle 2, tuned by the late and so very sadly missed Steve Dumpleton.
And this is a tune I remember him teaching in a workshop - a wonderful 3/2 hornpipe, with a great title as well.
https://youtu.be/Wo_qsQHWGzM
Julian
-
Got to be my favourite go-to instrument
https://youtu.be/Wo_qsQHWGzM
Julian
That's gorgeous!
-
Thank you Arty - and your C/F sounds so good - lovely tune as well.
Julian
-
My Bb/Eb early Hohner Club 1, with wooden levers, and screwed on MoP buttons.
SJ
-
Any G/C Hohner in fine fettle.
-
I think these days my overall favourite box is actually my beautiful Wheatstone Anglo, purchased from the estate of my dear friend Steve D. I guess this being Melnet I really out to stick to melodeons, although I love my Oakwood and the beautiful aged Pastourelle II which is the virtual twin of Julians (and which has been claimed by my husband), I think the one box I just keep going back to is my Saltarelle Nuage, the second one I have owned, after I saw the error my ways in selling the first one.
-
I think my current favourite is my 114C with the bottom button retuned on the pull, the bass chords turned to bass notes and the button travel restricted. I used to wonder why people went to the trouble of getting the buttons done, but I have to admit that it's made this one nicer to play. It's just now enjoying the weather here whilst it's friends and family are still suffering the chill in Windy Nook!
-
Like Arty, my favourite box is my old CF Hohner. Tuned by Mike R to "Anahata". It's a bit wetter than Arty's, though.
-
On balance it's still the Vienna Type A&D 6 bass "International". Stepped keyboard, MoP buttons. Dix Brass reeds. (Circa1903).
The top A octave covers the range of pipe music "at pitch"....albeit A435 rather than the high pitched A used by modern Highland pipes.
Second favourite is the "German Type" C/C# 19 key 4 bass "Wilkinson Excelsior" . (Dated 1926).
The Wyper keyboard layout gives it a Chromatic range down to fiddle low G
I like the sound and feel of these boxes. Both boxes can play quietly and have a response better than my fingers need.
-
I am tempted to say that my favourite is the one that I have in my hand at any given moment. I love all seven of my current boxes and would be loath to part with any of them. However, my overall favourite (by a small margin) is the 2.6 row box I made on a course run by Emmanuel Pariselle at West London College in 2011. It is a testament to his skill that under his guidance I had the good fortunate to produce a box with a light fast action and a lovely sweet tone. Running it a close equal second are the Castagnari 1914 that belonged formerly to Steve Dumpleton and the D/G/acc. three-row made for me by Clément Guais.
-
My ever-changing tastes mean that I often change up my line-up of boxes (one in, one out policy), but my current favourite is a 15 year old Paolo Soprani Jubilee iii (MMM) in D/C#. I made an entire new set of reeds for it using old, long-scale, handmade PA reeds (stamped Catraro) that are incredibly responsive and will easily play at barely a whisper but will also strip the paint off the walls...In general, it's a bit brighter than I'd like (the original reeds even more so), but it's such a fun box to play that I can't help but love it.
Here it is with the original reeds in it, although it sounds almost exactly the same with the new (old) reeds:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4Puh0VnEQ4
-
my current favourite is a 15 year old Paolo Soprani Jubilee iii (MMM) in D/C#. I made an entire new set of reeds for it using old, long-scale, handmade PA reeds (stamped Catraro) that are incredibly responsive and will easily play at barely a whisper but will also strip the paint off the walls...In general, it's a bit brighter than I'd like (the original reeds even more so), but it's such a fun box to play that I can't help but love it.
Here it is with the original reeds in it, although it sounds almost exactly the same with the new (old) reeds:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4Puh0VnEQ4
Grand vintage sound. Love it. :|glug
-
I guess that would be my Oakwood, as it's irreplaceable. Incredibly loud and fast-responding, basses well tuned to get weight without trying to go too deep (which wouldn't work on such a small box), and many people have commented favourably on the sound of it. I've mostly used it for dance music since I got the Dino Baffetti/Oakwood that I now play much more of the time because of its versatility.
But it doesn't seem fair to pick a favourite when I have that Hohner C/F Club which I love to bits for its sound, and the 1 row 4 stop in C which I've had so much fun with.
-
My favourite is the B flat Wesson Corvette made by my son Henry Wesson. It is the lead instrument in my Zydeco band Joe Le Taxi.
-
Depends what you mean by "favourite", as it can vary according to context. If you mean which is my go-to box, the one I would save from a house fire, then it would be the veteran Pastourelle II (and I see I'm not alone!). It had Nils Nilsson's magic worked on it when it was very new, and now that it's showing decided signs of age and wear (as am I!) it's still the one that feels right in my hands.
-
Although I probably play my Tommy more than anything else it could be replaced, so if the house was on fire I would grab the Wesson Clipper in D because it would be much harder to replace.
-
Anna’s Visa is a lovely tune!
My favourite box is my brand-new Dino Baffetti Binci, which I bought last month. Here it is playing The Railway:
https://youtu.be/RYADAZ4FreM
(Although if it came to a house fire I’d make sure to keep a hand free for the Hohner 4-stop that’s on loan from a friend, because it’s irreplaceable.)
-
Well, my go to box is my lowly Hohner Pokerwork dg, but there again it is the only box I possess. As I can’t play this one to my satisfaction seems little point in acquiring others?
-
What a question! Which of your children would you save?.......
Most of my boxes are now very personal to me, having been built for me, plus one built by me.
The box that I spend time with almost every day is my lovely G/C Serafini R2D2 and that is a definite hot favourite for sound and feel.
But it is probably just pipped at the post by my Hohner Rowbotham Pressed wood (3 voice, bass stop, 4 button start). It is my go-to D/G box and the one you'll find me playing in a pub somewhere!! Just a pleasure to play.
-
What a question! Which of your children would you save?.......
It's certainly true that you do love them all for different reasons. My Pokerwork for opening up the whole world of melodeons for me. It has been truly life changing and I have made many good friends along the way. The Oakwood for being the perfect morris box (and also my divorce melodeon), the Streb for being my 4am box when I needed one, the Lilly for fitting in a rucksack at festivals. The Saltarelles (currently too many I admit) for their lovely dry buzziness.
-
My 3 voice Pariselle.
It appeared out of the blue at a very difficult time for me and it was an amazing act of generosity and kindness.
It has opened up so many new avenues to my playing and I feel totally at home with it.
-
Hohner 4-stop that’s on loan from a friend,...
Very touching, Em, but it's a Castagnari Max! Replaceable except that it is one of the rarer brown wood ones.
Rob.
-
Mine is my D/G Hohner Pokerwork, whose sound I prefer to pretty much all others. The four-stoppers are such fun as well but certainly a bit more specialized than the Pokerwork.
-
Hohner 4-stop that’s on loan from a friend,...
Very touching, Em, but it's a Castagnari Max! Replaceable except that it is one of the rarer brown wood ones.
Rob.
;D Shoot me now ...
-
I am tempted to say that my favourite is the one that I have in my hand at any given moment.
Indeed. It also depends what mood I'm in. If I'm feeling a bit melancholic or reflective it's the Club BB/Eb. General noodling Pressed wood D/G. To make a cheerful noise because I can 114 in C. Which would probably be my desert island box. Ask me tomorrow and you'll probably get a different answer...involving the 1040 in A... :|glug
-
My forever box is an Excelsior, B/C 2r8b. Seven different couplers to use to suit whichever tune I'm playing.
When playing waltzes, I like to sometimes change from the master to the clarinet for variation.
-
Castagnari Melodeon ( MAX)
My GGFs Swiss made 2 1/2 row D/G from the 1920s
-
My Sag’né in E I was gifted on my wedding day by my wife.
-
The D/G Hohner Pressed Wood that Mike Rowbotham prepared for me several years ago (4th button start with a 3rds stop). It’s my Morris box, pub session box, and general box-about-town. Glorious tone, loud when it needs to be, and a real “looker†with its beautiful honey-coloured woodwork and red bellows.
-
I have
o 2008 Gaillard saphir F#GC 18 bass, natural wood LM voiced.
o 2012 vanderAa C#DG 18 bass, painted “obviously†LMM voiced
In both cases I use the outer row ½-tone away from middle, and a tritone away from inner, as my source of accidentals. Work it out and you’ll find that to 2 notes are duplicated on inner and outer rows.
I have filed the outer ones to get more chromaticity oral or reversal. So it does not work as a half tone system at all. The VanderAa hates anything in a flat, and the Gaillard anything in C#. Otherwise I can manage at least chording in virtually any key, and generally some tune (with a bit of practice).
Gaillard is the better instrument, but it’s heavier and more bulky. Yet I actually always play the VanderAa, which I can slip over my shoulder at a festival, and sit in with any song or musical group,and join in. It also likes keys like Bb/Gm, which very much suit my singing voice. I do need to play the other one, a bit, bellows are getting a bit stiff again! 🥴
Perhaps I should sell on? But it is always nice to have a spare box.
Everything else I have either sold here, or given away
-
I have favourite boxes for different 'jobs'. for a great many years it was a dg pokerwork which i used for everything and still have. 20 or so years I forked out for a dg serenellini mml dg box which has been my main box for dance band work, song accompanyment and many other things all to my satisfaction. I also enjoy plaaying a dg lilly which I bought a few years ago as insurance against old age! I tend to play mostly trebleonly on it and see it as the nearest melodeon you can get to a fiddle! great for haunting slow airs etc/
then there is my semitone boxes hohner trichord and hohner gaelic both of which are very versatile and chromatic and again as insurance for old age a hohner BC with very useful12 stradella bass. Then there is the wonderful hohner 4 stoper in G which is a wonderful 'thunderbox'
I like em all and all get played regularly.
-
Ok, I know which is my favourite box - the D/G Pastourelle 2, but then I wondered 'which instrument would be best if I ended up stranded on a Desert Island' ?
Adverse conditions, difficult if not impossible to tune or repair, and with the possibility of having to use springs as fishhooks or whatever ! I'd want to have a really robust but lightweight instrument. And if I did escape or get rescued, one I wouldn't worry about too much if I had to abandon - something replaceable. So it looks like a pokerwork is the answer -but I'd miss part row accidentals and would brass reeds have advantages ? And a 3v might be better just in case of reed failures.
Thinking about this has certainly taken my mind off horrendous world events for at least a few moments - and then there's the question of the eight desert island tunes to consider. Has there been a discussion topic on that before ?
Julian
-
My latest acquisition:a Castagnari Sharon D/C#, a sweet little bomb. I just can't wait to get home to play it. And then my Castagnari Hascy G/C. A wonderful instrument. I just love the sound and the response.
-
I always have nice instruments around so plenty to choose from. Paolo Soprani, Gaillard, VanderAA, Hlavacek, Baldoni-Bartoli, Busilacchio, Castagnari, Bellinger/Pariselle, lots of different Hohners. The instruments I most often see in my hands when I look down are my Castagnari Lilium in C/F and Hohner black & blond in E/A (below G/C). The Lilium is beautiful, simple, has flexible sounds, airtight and plays like butter. The Hohner was converted to EA MMH by using the reeds from a early 1900's 6 stop Hohner 'bread box' and adding two half-reedblocks and changing to longer pallets. Fantastic sound and fun to play but air hungry so it forces me to really learn the best spots in tunes for gulping with the air button.
Scott
-
That Black and Blond is a real stunner, and E/A below G/C must sound heavenly!
-
e,a,g,c, are all dead easy keys on a BC or BCC# box and I am surprised that not many on this forum favour them.
-
The next one. MAD -Melodeon Assembling Disorder.
25 boxes in the room, i only play one at a time.
-
Well, my go to box is my lowly Hohner Pokerwork dg, but there again it is the only box I possess. As I can’t play this one to my satisfaction seems little point in acquiring others?
the hohner pokerwork is far from being a "lowly" box . I started on one a long time ago and I still play it regularly because I like it!. The only reason I have my serenellini is because it has a low set of reeds MML and my castagnari lilly is there as an easy to play old age box as it requires much less bellows movement due to single voice.
For a many melodeonists a pokerwork can be a lifetime box and a costalloti is not necessary. when I did workshops at major festivals a pokerwork was fine, same for session playinng.
Costalotis are fine if you can afford them but are far from necessary for 'good playing'
george (ducking for cover!)
-
Well, my go to box is my lowly Hohner Pokerwork dg, but there again it is the only box I possess. As I can’t play this one to my satisfaction seems little point in acquiring others?
the hohner pokerwork is far from being a "lowly" box . I started on one a long time ago and I still play it regularly because I like it!. The only reason I have my serenellini is because it has a low set of reeds MML and my castagnari lilly is there as an easy to play old age box as it requires much less bellows movement due to single voice.
For a many melodeonists a pokerwork can be a lifetime box and a costalloti is not necessary. when I did workshops at major festivals a pokerwork was fine, same for session playinng.
Costalotis are fine if you can afford them but are far from necessary for 'good playing'
george (ducking for cover!)
I second every point made. Just add that the early Hohner 2 row CFs slightly outscore the Pokerworks, but only by a nose.
-
Costalotis are fine if you can afford them but are far from necessary for 'good playing'
george (ducking for cover!)
Hello, George...
What are you doing down here in the bunker? :||:
-
I have owned approximately 50 Diatonic accordeons.
My favorites are:
My GGFs 2 1/2 row Swiss made D/G with 6 bass buttons which I still own.
Hohner HA114 from the 50s
One of my 4 Castagnari Melodeons (MAX) , the C was the best of them.
One particular Castagnari Hascy D/G, memorable.
Clement Breton in D.. Fabulous.
A Castagnari Mory which was purchased new in 1996 and absolutely fantastic after spending another $600 to have it put right.