Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: AlexCJones on February 27, 2022, 06:01:10 PM
-
A friend found her father’s old 3-row GCF 31 key “Cyclops†brand accordion. It is not in playable condition, so I offered to look it over. If there was anything beyond repadding pallets, re-valving, tuning and making new straps, then I figure I can post these other repair needs here and see what your opinions are about whether this is worth repairing.
So, I thought I would start with my biggest concerns.
First, is the keyboard. Most of the button-assemblies function with sufficient spring to return to their home position. But for a few of them, the spring needs to be replaced or fixed. Also, for a few, the levers get stuck in their slots, because the slot has become too tight. I was able to remove the keyboard, since it was held on by screws, but there is no apparent way to open up or take apart the keyboard. For some of these getting stuck in the slots, it looks like it is caused by the wood slightly warping. I guess it can be fixed by widening the slots slightly or narrowing the lever arms with some filing or sanding,
(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=28028.0;attach=35393)
Then, there is an issue with one of the bass reed-blocks. The one holding the reeds for the root notes seems to be glued in place. The other one, holding the chords, conveniently comes out, and is secured by typical means. The treble reed blocks are secured by the typical means and come out easily too. But this one reed block that is glued in means that I can tune the reeds only when they are out of the reed block. Once they are back in the glued-in reed block, it will be difficult to do a final tuning, since I won’t be able to use the tuning bellows.
(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=28028.0;attach=35395)
But for all of the reed blocks, the reed plates are not secured by only the beeswax. They are also all secured by these offset-head nails. I supposed I can pull each nail out slightly with some long-nose pliers to release each reed plate so I can re-valve both sides.
(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=28028.0;attach=35397)
Going to a lesser challenge is a small issue with the hardware for securing the bellows to the ends. Two of them must have been damaged, and someone simply bent a nail or whatever was left, to hold the loop part. This means that the ends cannot be completely separated from the bellows, but I can work around that for the most part
(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=28028.0;attach=35399)
The rest is not too much of a challenge. The bellows are in fine condition. I have created straps before, and I have tuned and re-valved (20-button accordion-reeded) concertinas. There is 1 bass and 1 treble button-top missing, but I have a of an old Hohner to get those from. Also, the accordion owner’s husband said he can fabricate a new wooden grill.
So does it seem like it would be worth it? Is it easy to fix the keyboard without being able to take it apart? I can fashion safety pins into springs if needed, right?
Has anyone ever worked with a reed-black that is glued-in? Or reed-plates held in with offset nails?
Given those challenges, would it be worth the trouble to repair?
Thanks
-
I'm really not qualified to advise on some of your queries, but as far as the reed nails are concerned, I think it's generally agreed these days that they're superfluous. You might want to keep them for the sake of historical authenticity, but mechanically they're pretty well redundant, and you can remove them without worry. AS long as you clean away all the old wax, the new wax will secure the reeds perectly well.
-
Whether it is “worth it†depends what you get out of the project. If you want the satisfaction of getting an old box back in playing condition then yes, and you will learn a lot along the way.
One of the valuable things you can learn is to tune the reeds with the blocks in situ. It’s not difficult once you have learned how and the tools are very simple.
Coming back to the practicalities I think the keyboard is the priority, because if you can’t get that operating smoothly all other efforts are in vain. My experience suggests that it will be essential to remove the axle rod so that you can properly service the levers. I’ve found that keys often stick because of tightness where the axle rod goes through the lever. This can be a result of wear on the rod, abrasive dust or grit that has got in there, wood swelling so as to make the hole smaller, and only rarely from warping of the wood to make the levers rub. If it is the latter you will be able to see wear marks clearly only after you have taken the levers out. If you can’t get the axle rod out there is always the possibility of building a new keyboard.
-
I've only ever seen, or heard of, one other Cyclops box! I bought it relatively cheaply, did a bit of work on it and then resold it, again relatively cheaply. It was horrible!
If you're intent on going ahead with it, I may have one or two of the bellows clamping screws with the bent over ends and knurled nuts lying about But I'll not be home before the 4th of April, then I'll br able to have a look.
-
I've only ever seen, or heard of, one other Cyclops box! I bought it relatively cheaply, did a bit of work on it and then resold it, again relatively cheaply. It was horrible!
If you're intent on going ahead with it, I may have one or two of the bellows clamping screws with the bent over ends and knurled nuts lying about But I'll not be home before the 4th of April, then I'll be able to have a look.
That would be awesome!
Thanks!
I think the work on trying to get they keyboard in playing condition will keep me busy for most of March, so I don't mind waiting until April to find out.
-
The nails holding the reed plates don't have to come out, they can simply be turned sideways to release the plate.