Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: mselic on March 01, 2022, 05:00:35 AM

Title: Sean Gavin - G/G# or C/C#?
Post by: mselic on March 01, 2022, 05:00:35 AM
There is a post on "thesession.org" regarding Sean Gavin's new album, wherein the claim is made that he plays a G/G# box:

https://thesession.org/recordings/7494

Looking up Sean Gavin on YouTube brings up a plethora of videos of him, always playing an old Paolo Soprani Pepperpot with a lovely, deep, mellow tone.  The tunes are coming out in Eb (and relative pitched keys for an Eb box player), which might suggest he's playing a C/C# box with B/C fingering, however I believe Eb would work on a G/G# as well.  Here is an example:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g4jtrQziqn8

Would you say that is a G/G# box as claimed in the “session.org" thread, or would it be C/C#?
Title: Re: Sean Gavin - G/G# or C/C#?
Post by: CAB on March 01, 2022, 10:42:01 AM
What a fascinating puzzle!  I may well be wrong (it's happened before) but here's my take on it.

The 4 notes of the 1st tune use 4 buttons: inner row buttons 4 & 5, an outer row button then inner row button 6.  This is a 23 button box.  If he was playing a 21 button C#/D and starting on the 3rd button, that would be the fingering (minus 1 button, so starting on button 3 etc.) for the key of A.
Transposing to Eb, you'd be playing a G/G# box.  His Eb (aka D#) certainly seems to be pushed.  So I think it might be a G/G#

That's my best guess.  Now to enjoy the clip at normal speed!!!
Title: Re: Sean Gavin - G/G# or C/C#?
Post by: pgroff on March 01, 2022, 07:40:26 PM
Agreed, I'd say it's a GG# box.

To keep it simple, the 3 tunes are played B/C style  (on a B/C those same fingerings would result in those tunes sounding in the keys of G, D, and G, normal for those particular tunes).

But the box is a major third interval ( 4 semitones) flat of a B/C box. So with B/C fingering, G tunes come out in Eb, and D tunes come out in Bb.  Some B/C box players would call that box a "Bb" box because of the way it transposes their usual settings down from D pitch to Bb pitch.

Great ensemble sound from these wonderful musicians, "Bb" box with the viola and the Bb whistle.

PG
Title: Re: Sean Gavin - G/G# or C/C#?
Post by: komat on April 01, 2022, 12:49:44 AM
Liner notes on his CD indicate G/G#!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal