Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Rog on March 03, 2022, 06:50:07 PM
-
https://youtu.be/lHi9W0YxFTI
Cue: outraged forum members at his use of a rotary tool…
(:)
-
I have to admit the sparks flying off the reeds makes me cringe… ;D
-
Without understanding his words it’s hard to tell exactly what he is trying to demonstrate. It all looks a bit haphazard though. Should get all the valves right first, then pre-tune if necessary, then tune with the blocks inside the instrument. And the grinder - it’s so slow the way he does it. Ok for a few reeds but adds a lot of time in a full retune.
-
If you could file fast enough, you could possibly get some sparks going!
When I was building my bass instrument, I needed some reeds (on more or less normal sized plates) to go pretty low. I used some PA bass reeds, and after looking at some others, it was plainly obvious that they had been ground down using a rotary stone of some description.
In for a penny and in for a pound! I took a few down a long way, without having to overload them with solder, by carefully and neatly grinding away the lower portion of the reed tongue to about half it's thickness for about a third of its length. I had noticed a good number of original reeds which were done that way.
I've also seen a great number of original treble end reeds with rotary stone markings on them, when I've been using a file or a scratcher.
-
Hohner reeds are tuned at the factory using a grinder. Italian reeds not.
Why do you want to avoid loading reed tips with solder? You can often get a better performing reed that way. Thinning too much can exacerbate the tendency for the pitch to flatten when played hard.
-
Even older Italian reeds? I'm sure that some of the ones I'm talking about were out of old Italian PA's.
I didn't want to avoid using solder, it's just that they will only take a certain amount before it all starts to fall off!
-
Well it looks like a thriving business in Medellin (lots of Hohner three rows), so I guess however he does it, it works ok.
-
The sparks! :o