Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Babuan on March 04, 2022, 07:54:19 AM

Title: Baffetti Carnival III Vs Castigari Marie Nicole?
Post by: Babuan on March 04, 2022, 07:54:19 AM
I've been playing a poker work for a few years now, and am looking to acquire a box capable of more subtlety and variety.  I am drawn to the Carnival III or the Marie Nicole as both have 3 voice with stop on the treble side and a 3rds stop on the bass end.  I had a brief play on a Marie Nicole at the recent playgroup at Bretforton and really liked it, but it's quite a lot of beer vouchers. On paper the Carnival III looks very similar (and I can still afford a few beers).   Is there anyone that has experience of both to help me make a decision?  Thank you  :||:
Title: Re: Baffetti Carnival III Vs Castigari Marie Nicole?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 04, 2022, 08:33:04 AM
I've yet to play the Marie Nicole but have a general observation.
Last summer I attended several sessions at the Sidmouth festival with my Castagnari Jilly.  I was surrounded by Dino Baffettis of various types.
I was surprised at the difference in sound. My bass end of the Jilly seemed to provide a sound best described as 'a low warmth', against a more strident sound from the DB's.
Which sound you prefer is down to your personal likes, but to my ears there was a noticeable difference in sound.
Apart from sound, there will be a difference in feel, balance, action etc. Best felt by trying a DB in your hands.
These choices are seldom black and white, down to personal preferences and also cost!
Title: Re: Baffetti Carnival III Vs Castigari Marie Nicole?
Post by: Theo on March 04, 2022, 08:36:56 AM
You get better quality reeds in the Castagnari which should mean it’s more responsive and has a better dynamic range - especially ability to play more quietly.  You do tend to get what you pay for. But as Thruppeny Bit says you may prefer the sound and feel of either one and the only way to judge that is to try playing both.
Title: Re: Baffetti Carnival III Vs Castigari Marie Nicole?
Post by: Rog on March 04, 2022, 08:52:57 AM
Dino B's are great boxes. I don’t really understand the vast differential in price between a DB and a similar Casta, even if you add on the notional extra for better reeds. And you can get Binci reeded DBs, though they be boxes for hand to hand combat rather than a delicate boudoir tune…
Title: Re: Baffetti Carnival III Vs Castigari Marie Nicole?
Post by: Tufty on March 04, 2022, 01:45:16 PM
If you are after "subtlety and variety" go for the Castagnari, the Carnival III is more loud and raucous, which is great for playing outdoors but then your pokerwork is fine for that. A cheaper option than the new Marie Nicole could be a used Tommy.
Title: Re: Baffetti Carnival III Vs Castigari Marie Nicole?
Post by: Gena Crisman on March 04, 2022, 05:13:08 PM
I’ve played both. How new a Carnival III is kind of important but, while it’s still a good, similarly styled instrument, it isn’t really at any point across the board as good as a Marie Nicole.

If you like the way one plays and responds to bellows pressure, you’ll probably like the other, but it’s easy for me to tell which one is the more premium instrument. They’re very similar, but you’re more likely to find big, definite basses on the Dino. The lowest bass note may or may not suit you on either instrument and I think historically varies even among similar boxes. It was C as the lowest, I think, on the MC I tried, which doesn’t quite suit me.

Like, you say you liked the MC, but are you besotted with it compared to other 3v 2r instruments? Plus, if you’re on the Morris circuit, make friends with people playing dinos and ask to have a go (it worked for me)
Title: Re: Baffetti Carnival III Vs Castigari Marie Nicole?
Post by: Helena Handcart on March 04, 2022, 07:49:52 PM
No contest IMO, and I'm not even usually either a fan of either a) Castagnari or b) 3v boxes without independently switched voices. Carnivals are sort of OK but really much improved by being converted to a Binci. The Marie Nicole is quite simply a gem, it's one of the few boxes that can genuinely go from moany-groany crossy-rowsy tunes to punchy morris style in a twinkling. If I were only to have one 'posh' box the Marie Nicole would be a serious contender.

In the Carnival's favour, if you can find one second hand you might get a bit of a bargain. That way, at least you won't lose much when you decide to upgrade to the Marie Nicole

YMMV and all that.
Title: Re: Baffetti Carnival III Vs Castigari Marie Nicole?
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 05, 2022, 10:26:01 AM
I have also played both (although I own neither). For me, the Marie Nicole wins hands down. The only reason I don't own one is that around the time the MarieNicole was released, I acquired a 1914 from the late and sorely missed Steve Dumpleton, and I couldn't justify buying a MarieNicole as well.
Title: Re: Baffetti Carnival III Vs Castigari Marie Nicole?
Post by: Babuan on March 09, 2022, 07:43:53 PM
Thank you everyone for sharing your experiences and thoughts.  Seems like the Casti will be the box that best suits what I'm after.  I may be a bit thirstier for a while tho'  ;-)
Thanks for your help  :||:
Title: Re: Baffetti Carnival III Vs Castigari Marie Nicole?
Post by: pete /acorn on March 09, 2022, 09:38:43 PM
Hi,
Whenever you would like to try the Marie Nicole give me a shout.
Acorn Instruments will be all over the place this year from Yorkshire to Taunton,to Witney,To Diss,and places inbetween.

See web site

www.acorninstruments.co.uk (http://www.acorninstruments.co.uk)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal