Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Joan Kureczka on March 09, 2022, 09:56:16 PM
-
So, I'm finding my recording nerves are lately getting worse not better. My partner has improved the sound quality set up and wants to do more recordings, but at least for the set I really want to record, it's been getting worse not better. What I can play just fine in practice and generally now in performance just falls apart when we start the videoing. It doesn't help that I'm having to box myself in with a couple of mics (none set up on the instrument itself as yet) and that said partner gets testy about my problems playing, which is not helping my confidence. I'm getting increasingly tense about it all.
I already practice that one passage to death, including in slow motion, over and over -- which is how I've gotten it to being normally reliable in practice and other non-recording playing. But any further suggestions on how to relax are most welcome!
-
Let the recording run and (try to) forget it, so there's no expectation that 'the next one' will be perfect. Maybe try slowing down the tempo a bit.
-
That's what I've been doing for while, tirpous. It did a lot for my nerves, if not the end result for the listener!
The problem I now have is that my VLC gadget thing is distorting the recording when I try to edit out the rubbishy playing before and after the half decent bit. So now, it has to really be warts and all!
If you haven't already tried tirpous's remedy, Joan; I'd encourage you to give it a bash.
-
There is nothing more off putting than being pressurised by an impatient third party.
I record on an old Zoom H4. This has an auto start facility triggered by sound levels. Since I started using this it has helped a lot. If I make a fatal error I just stop playing for 3 seconds then start again. No need for any button pressing so once it's set going there's no need for the partner to get impatient. They can go and wait in the pub, or whatever.
I'm usually ok once I get going, so maybe a few false starts then I've nailed a take. This will be the last file in the folder I'm saving to. The rest can be deleted. Edit the associated video (left running continuously), adding the sound track.
The next question is, does your recording equipment or DAW have a facility like this? An awful lot do.
-
Don't think so, Greg. My partner -- who is playing with me and not bothered by recording -- runs the show. Just doing this off a video recorder but with a better sound set up. Two mikes for me, and his cittern plugs into whatever he needs. I'm not savvy on this stuff so I'm not sure what's all involved.
The advice to just let the video recording run through several takes sounds like the next best thing to try. We've gotten good recordings before but the current attempts have me spooked. I start worrying too much about the difficult passage and it all goes awry.
-
Joan, I sympathise. It happens to me.
Recording a video can open the whole Pandoras Box of things.
I find if I start making mistakes then there is often an ever increasing spiral downwards, the tune just gets worse.
I then simply stop and walk away and either come back later or leave it for the day.
I've found to lower my expectations too.
If I make a ' minor typo ' when playing then just keep going and accept it. After all I'm not a professional musician. This acceptance seems to relax me somewhat.
-
This is completely normal. If you say you feel “boxed in†, then if I were recording you I would move the mics. There is little point in capturing a sonically perfect take if the performance is bad because the performer is uncomfortable.
The left hand mic shouldn’t be close anyway - most mics will change their sound as the source moves closer/further away, so it needs to have plenty of space to capture the sound naturally.
If it’s practical I like to leave a recording rig set up for a few days. The half hour spent jiggling wires, computers and mic stands will surely ruin “the momentâ€. If the equipment is ready to go at the drop of a hat, and you can easily sit in the recording space and play when the moment feels right, you’ll get better recordings and have a lot more fun, and then forget about the equipment.
Gren
-
This is completely normal. If you say you feel “boxed in†, then if I were recording you I would move the mics.
Agreed, though if there's a cittern playing alongside there's a risk that the mics will then pick up too much cittern.
If it’s practical I like to leave a recording rig set up for a few days.
One advantage of this is that if you've been practising hard and then record, and you aren't happy with it, you may find on coming back after a few days that your playing has improved. It takes time for the results of practising to get embedded in your brain, and when the learning has moved from your conscious to your subconscious (motor memory) you can be more relaxed.
-
Recording video adds a whole other level of anxiety. Is it really necessary? Unless you are making a tutorial to demonstrate how to play something, surely the audio is most important? If you need something visual for say YouTube then display a still, or a sequence of stills.
If you must have video, does your new setup allows audio to be recorded entirely separately from the video? If not, can you separate the audio using editing software? If that can be done, then your best video take need not coincide with the best audio take. Maybe concentrate on getting a good video take where you playing through mistakes without hesitating or grimacing, and then record audio separately. Use a click track to keep everything at the same tempo, and then add the best audio track to the video using the editing software. I doubt anyone will be watching closely enough to spot if they're not exactly in synch throughout.
Get some audio editing software. There are plenty of free DAWs which will allow you to edit out mistakes, from shifting an individual note which is not quite in time to pasting in entire phrases from a better take. It takes practice, but it is hugely liberating to realise that mistakes don't matter as they can be repaired later. You can then relax and concentrate on getting the 'feel' of the tune right rather than worrying that a small mistake will ruin everything.
Whenever I have recorded with a professional engineer I have always been surprised how few takes he has required, two or three far from perfect takes are usually sufficient for him to work with. However we have also taken plenty of time to get comfortable and feel relaxed in the surroundings before we record.
Are you playing in duet with your partner? Are they getting tetchy because your mistakes are spoiling their efforts? A DAW would allow you to each record your parts separately, and this would also allow you to place the mics further away, and perhaps tell your partner to leave the room!
-
A DAW would allow you to each record your parts separately, and this would also allow you to place the mics further away, and perhaps tell your partner to leave the room!
Agreed. Recording each part in a separate session using a DAW or multitrack recorder is definitely the way to go. Get partner to record their part and then tell them to leave you alone while you record yours in your own time with as many takes as you want.
I use a Tascam Portastudio because the fan noise from my PC is too loud when recording acoustic instruments.
-
I'm left wondering if there isn't a Streb-like instrument which could be programmed with whatever it is we want to record, and then just set away and left to it? It could do away with nerves and/or mistakes all in one go!
-
A DAW would allow you to each record your parts separately, and this would also allow you to place the mics further away, and perhaps tell your partner to leave the room!
Agreed. Recording each part in a separate session using a DAW or multitrack recorder is definitely the way to go.
As the recording industry dried up a lot more bands went back on the road. And now there's a healthy view of recording the live experience rather than an immaculate one.
Personally I don't want to watch or listen to an edited version. 44 years after taking my grade 8 clarinet grade I decided it was time to take my grade 8 piano - I only play the piano for personal enjoyment. You can now record your grade submission at home and submit online. I did a recording of nearly 30 minutes playing and the thought of constantly seeking perfection in retakes would drive me nuts - no editing is allowed. So I just thought that the first one happened to be a fair reflection of my playing and left it at that. I'm much happier knowing that it was the real thing rather than a tinkered version. Strangely enough I got exactly the same mark 44 years apart. It was a rewarding preparation experience.
-
So I just thought that the first one happened to be a fair reflection of my playing and left it at that.
I think the OP's problem is that the recordings aren't a fair reflection of her playing.
I'm inclined to agree that a lively live performance is often preferable to a sterile perfect one, and that too much multi-tracking and overdubbing can be deadening. However recording nerves are a real thing, and sometimes you have to find other ways to do things in order to get around them. Nevertheless it is not necessary to seek perfection.
I think home recording can be more difficult than in a studio. At home you or your partner have to deal with the technical aspects as well as playing the music, and you don't have the benefit of an experienced producer or engineer, whose role is as much to get a good performance out of the musicians as it is to twiddle the knobs.
-
... and that said partner gets testy about my problems playing, which is not helping my confidence. I'm getting increasingly tense about it all.
Yeah? You wait till I see him.... :o
Actually can't wait to see the pair of you (:)
-
I have a simple way of preventing 'recording nerves'.....Don't
-
If you must have video, does your new setup allows audio to be recorded entirely separately from the video? If not, can you separate the audio using editing software? If that can be done, then your best video take need not coincide with the best audio take.
That's unlikely to work timing wise, but even one take with audio recorded separately to computer (simultaneously with video) often enables useful editing if the music contains repeat sections, unless you fluff the same part both first and second time. You can also make a second take of the audio and use bits of it to repair the main one.
Agreed. Recording each part in a separate session using a DAW or multitrack recorder is definitely the way to go. Get partner to record their part and then tell them to leave you alone while you record yours in your own time with as many takes as you want.
I don't like doing that unless I have to, but if the freedom to mess up while working on it alone reduces the stress, it might help in this case. My own experience, however, is that having to cope with heaphones, starting the recording and then getting into position to start playing can result in a comedy of tripping over cables and missing cues. Not to mention forgetting to turn the speakers off while recording...
I use a Tascam Portastudio because the fan noise from my PC is too loud when recording acoustic instruments.
My solution to this was to build a low noise PC. Careful selection of case, internal fans and hard disk mounting can make a near silent PC. But I have
long experience of building desktop and tower PCs from scratch; I accept that might not be for everyone.
-
"I have a simple way of preventing 'recording nerves'.....Don't"
A simple remedy for sure! I do find it easier to play to a live audience (Haha, a few friends maybe, or passers by!) as when people are actually there, they're not at all intimidating! They're there to enjoy whatever is going on, and they aren't expecting a JK'esque peformance.
-
It's definitely worth while learning to play through your mistakes, rather than stop whenever you think you think you've fluffed it. The only way to do this is to do it. Playing for dance helps a lot. This is in contrast to playing for practice when you want to pay attention to the awkward bits and make sure you're not practising your mistakes..
It's surprising how people often don't even realise it was a mistake.
-
Sorry - posted in error.
-
It's definitely worth while learning to play through your mistakes, rather than stop whenever you think you think you've fluffed it. The only way to do this is to do it. Playing for dance helps a lot. This is in contrast to playing for practice when you want to pay attention to the awkward bits and make sure you're not practising your mistakes..
It's surprising how people often don't even realise it was a mistake.
Yes, there are two main types of mistakes: "typos" that you can just smile at as they pass downstream, and showstopper mistakes that bring the whole tune down, usually because you fell off the rhythm. Part of getting better at an instrument is being better able to convert the latter into the former.
Winston mentioned a "JK'esque performance" but I've seen JK make plenty of typos live with no more than a raised eyebrow on his part (and probably the only ones who noticed are people who already knew the tune well). And I've seen him have the occasional show-stopper as well and he just laughs it off and starts again.
-
I think the main problem people have with recording is that when the red light is on you all of a sudden have a whole bunch of extra things to distract your focus. The concern that it has to be perfect causes you to take your mental eye off of what you're doing and start thinking about whether you'll make it to the end of the tune, etc. Then, video makes it even worse. Is the melodeon in shot correctly? Am I too close to the camera? Am I making stupid wasp chewing motions with my mouth that can be seen on the video?
When I'm playing well, my mind is focused in a relaxed way. Not really directing anything, but "watching" the present moment and guiding things to the next moment. It's a lot like riding a bicycle or driving a car. You're not thinking about every muscle movement necessary to direct the vehicle, but you are watching the road ahead for any tricky bits (e.g., potholes) and adjusting accordingly. But I find that if my mind starts drifting off to a complex daydream (spurred by something my fingers did, perhaps), or worse, if I start getting excited about playing well and looking forward to the end of the tune, it is very easy for it to fall apart. I'm not sure this ever really goes away, no matter how experienced you get with playing the instrument.
-
My experience with getting to a suitable take is to practice recording. In the past i have done this by getting to record a passable youtube clip. The exercise was not to upload a video for personal reasons but to get a tune to a repeatable playthrough that i am happy with. I could spend hours doing that then know i could go in to record with the confidence i can play through a tune without the showstopper. When you go back to the tune you have then improved the playiing of it and are more comfortable with it.
Recording doesnt interest me of itself though and i am drawn to making mistakes, i would much rather hear someone playing at the edge of their ability or over it while playing with me than just playing a bland same thing every time through. If you cannot interact with me while playing in a session, i might aswell be playing at home.
-
Jesse has touched on something.
It was always a thing with me that once every so often I'd pick up the box and play really well. Simply lost in the tunes, in the moment, and emerge later unaware of time but feeling immensely satisfied with my playing.
Then ( most ) other times stumble through tunes, not really settling and feeling very dissatisfied.
My conclusion was that something happens in my mindset, not fingers, and could I alter my attitude, mindset, whatever to improve my playing.
I ended up buying a music self help book that explains if you can quieten the stuff going on in you mind 'watch out, tricky bit coming up' ... 'oh speeding up again'... 'wonder what the next tune is' etc, then you can play to your ability.
I don't always succeed but do understand the concept and it has helped.
A thing Andy Cutting said at a workshop is that he constructs a mental map for a tune, and once entering it, then the tune can be played repeatedly. He couldn't express in words exactly what he meant but it sounds like a similar thing - go somewhere in your mind and cut out everything else to let the tune remain.
It might all sound a bit strange, but often it's your mind that puts off your fingers.
-
If you must have video, does your new setup allows audio to be recorded entirely separately from the video? If not, can you separate the audio using editing software? If that can be done, then your best video take need not coincide with the best audio take.
That's unlikely to work timing wise, but even one take with audio recorded separately to computer (simultaneously with video) often enables useful editing
Of course it's always better to use the same audio, but if they are unable to get both a useable video and useable (or fixable) audio in the same take, it's an option. Timing is obviously a potential problem and they'd have to make sure all the takes were at the same tempo, and playing to a click track can present its own challenges. However unless it's for tuition purposes I doubt most people will be watching closely enough to notice, or care about, slight inconsistencies in timing.
If getting good video and good audio together is a consistent problem, don't bother with the video.
Multi-tracking can also present its own problems, especially if you're used to playing with others when playing your part on its own can feel a bit lonely (I sometimes struggle to play tunes from my band's repertoire in sessions because they sound wrong without my bandmates there). However in this case part of the problem seems to be that the OP's partner is adding to the pressure on her, so getting them out of the room could help.
I said in another post that home recording is often more stressful than in a studio, where you have someone else to take care of the technical aspects (and who probably understands them far better). That's another reason just to set everything rolling and take your time, the faffing and comedy moments can be edited out later.
I use a multi-track recorder with a footswitch, which eliminates some of the jumping up and down. If only I could remember which of the three switches on it does what ...
-
For what it's worth, when I'm doing TOTM things I set the camera/recorder running, and just keep it going. Make a mistake, not a problem, start again... but don't worry about resetting the camera - just keep it going. I very rarely get a version I'm happy with first try; it can happen, but it's rare. This time round, 5 takes to get the theme tunes (Ken's Hornpipes) and Bouffard's Waltz on the first take (which as I say is unusual). The record is 23 takes. I then just edit out and throw away the failed attempts. Oh, and don't worry too much about the occasional typo.
-
For what it's worth, when I'm doing TOTM things I set the camera/recorder running, and just keep it going. Make a mistake, not a problem, start again... but don't worry about resetting the camera - just keep it going. I very rarely get a version I'm happy with first try; it can happen, but it's rare. This time round, 5 takes to get the theme tunes (Ken's Hornpipes) and Bouffard's Waltz on the first take (which as I say is unusual). The record is 23 takes. I then just edit out and throw away the failed attempts. Oh, and don't worry too much about the occasional typo.
Standard conversation with The Sainted Mrs Bailey on my return from recording a tune in the shed "The don't call me '15 Takes Bailey' for nothing" (:) and that's after in excess of 600 videos.
-
Lester, that is somewhat reassuring!
-
Lester, indeed that is reassuring to me. But unfortunately aggrevating to my husband, who is also my musical partner!
Jesse and Thrupenny bit -- you have indeed identified the problem I have. So I'm trying to get said husband to do at least two takes at a time (we play medleys so more than two can be a bit physically tiring). He's resistant but reluctantly willing to give it a shot. First try overcome problems in the problematic phrase but stuck me with more than acceptable mistakes in the normally fine tune! Will keep plugging away.....
-
Joan, in many ways just plugging away is the answer.
If it becomes a more regular and normal thing to do, less of a soecial event, then you're sort of de-sensitising yourself to the situation.
Keep plugging away ;)
-
Definitely keep plugging away Joan !
I don't really suffer from recording nerves, but am absolutely certain that the recording process is a wonderful way for me to find out whether I know a tune inside out (if only !) and have discovered all the possible ways to make a hash of it. So what I have done is use recording as a learning tool, with only basic technology. I'm more interested in critiquing and reviewing my own playing - so multiple takes are normal.
At the moment I've got two tunes in mind for the K theme - one I know well, session standard, so theoretically I should be able to record once and post immediately. However, when I listened to it, I was clearly playing much too fast so straight to bin and try another day.
The other tune is much more challenging and is going to require a lot of work - but the goal of sharing a version I'm happy with helps me focus when I can get so easily distracted. 15 takes ? More than that I think - but each will help me move forward (unless I give it up in disgust).
A final thought - and reminder for myself - it's sometimes easy to end up being concerned about the detail of a tune at the expense of the overall performance.
Julian
-
Julian, your final thought resonated wholly with me.
Realising the overall playing of the tune is more important than getting every minute detail right has helped me move forward. Hopefully in time, my accuracy of playing will improve too. It all takes time...
-
there seems to be a lot of people worrying about recording their renditions, presumably so they can then listen to their mistakes!
this process inevitably results in the making of mistakes as the player is tensed up and determined not to make mistakes! a sort of viscious circle ensues and the more one tries not to make mistakes the more are made.
for what its worth I have never recorded my playing for that or any other reason but I do listen analytically to what I am playing to make sure player ( in my opinion!) it sounds OK but not necessary exactly as writ. It is not necessary to play a tune precisely the same every time you play it and putting you own 'variations' does not necessarily detract from the overall efficasy of the rendition . If you make a 'mistake' first time through try to make it again second time through so it comes over as an 'arrangement"
a 'top of the pile' player is quoted as saying 'every time I play a tune I play it the way I want it'
-
...I'm trying to get said husband to do at least two takes at a time (we play medleys so more than two can be a bit physically tiring). He's resistant but reluctantly willing to give it a shot...
I don't want to complicate things >:E, but there is a school of thought, encouraged by Leveret, that maintains medleys are not a very good way for two or more musicians to make music. Rather, work on knowing a tune intimately and developing ways of bringing the tune to life. This can be a lot moire entertaining for the performers than bashing through a set of tunes in the same way, a given number of times. You're never sure where the tune's going to go and what its going to become.
-
More and more we seem to be going away from the early ideas of medleys. As Greg says, working a tune and really get into it.
It feels like reverting to how things were. The Hardys, father and son were fiddlers (Thomas Hardy junior being the famed 19C Dorset novellist) and it's recorded that they would play a (single) tune for a dance. The dance would involve the hosts dancing longway sets all the way to the bottom of the set and then back, so that's playing a single tune for ~ 15 mins plus.
We're not in those times, but starting to understand playing a tune for a while allows you to really get to know it.
-
all the unnecessary and added pressure during the recording has to go first
especially your partner should realize this is only going to happen with the utmost patience
it will take as many takes as it will take
for a 2 minute clip I will shoot likely 1.5hr of video
-
More and more we seem to be going away from the early ideas of medleys. As Greg says, working a tune and really get into it.
It feels like reverting to how things were. The Hardys, father and son were fiddlers (Thomas Hardy junior being the famed 19C Dorset novellist) and it's recorded that they would play a (single) tune for a dance. The dance would involve the hosts dancing longway sets all the way to the bottom of the set and then back, so that's playing a single tune for ~ 15 mins plus.
We're not in those times, but starting to understand playing a tune for a while allows you to really get to know it.
I was at a "playing for dance" workshop run by JK a couple of weekends ago and his challenge to everyone was to go away and play the same tune for an hour and see where it went. I am definitely a fan of this idea having previously managed about 0.5 hour (much to household consternation). He also reiterated the point that historically one tune would have been used for a dance regardless of how long it took the set to get back to the start. It is a stance that I find myself increasingly agreeing with. N :||:
-
I was at a "playing for dance" workshop run by JK a couple of weekends ago and his challenge to everyone was to go away and play the same tune for an hour and see where it went.
I was at one many years ago where we played the same tune for an hour in the workshop!
Leveret's approach is for each of them to spend many hours playing the same tune alone until they have thoroughly learned it and are familiar with lots of rhythmic and melodic variation possibilities, then when they get together it's basically improvised but it works because they are totally on top of what they are doing and can listen to each other without losing track of the tune structure. A bit like the way jazz relies on "standards" that everybody knows inside out so they don't have to waste time learning the tune, and can stray away but still come back reliably.
-
I was lucky enough to see Leveret again a couple of weekends back and that was exactly as Andy described their approach.
No working out fixed harmonies 'you play this and I'll play that' sort of thing, their knowledge of the tunes allows freedom within the tunes.
It is very refreshing to listen to.
Perhaps the way the old traditional players of wayback worked? It'd be nice to speculate that we're coming around full circle to the way our traditional tunes were, and should be played.
-
[
No working out fixed harmonies 'you play this and I'll play that' sort of thing, their knowledge of the tunes allows freedom within the tunes.
Perhaps the way the old traditional players of wayback worked? It'd be nice to speculate that we're coming around full circle to the way our traditional tunes were, and should be played.
[/quote]
indeed!
-
when playing for dancing ....anything from morris through old tyme to ceilidh i concentrate on getting the rhythm right for the dancers as that is what they dance to! on the hoof variations in the way the tunes are played can either add to or detract from the proceedings depending on whether ones thinking is rigid or flexible!
-
I was at a "playing for dance" workshop run by JK a couple of weekends ago and his challenge to everyone was to go away and play the same tune for an hour and see where it went.
I was at one many years ago where we played the same tune for an hour in the workshop!
JK has been beating this drum for decades. He keeps describing it in terms akin to mystical ecstasy, and I've a mind to try it sometime, just to see what all the fuss is about. I work from home these days, so maybe I'll take a lunch hour and go upstairs where hopefully any neighbors won't be able to hear. ;D
-
Mystical ecstasy ? Nowt to do with recording nerves, but many years ago when I was in JKs dance side, we played (and danced) Sir Roger de Coverley for getting on four hours. I think I played for most of that time. I eventually did recover.
I much prefer playing one tune per dance at ceilidhs.
Leveret do play sets of tunes, but definitely no fixed number of times through each, and only change (and end )when they collectively feel like it. And the amount of time they have put into working through the possibilities of a tune, individually and collectively is reflected in their performances. Most importantly, listening and feeding off each others playing.
Julian