Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Ben Prout on March 13, 2022, 07:40:25 PM
-
I've been lately obsessing over the idea of a new melodeon, much to the chagrin of my bank account, I know many also suffer with the same affliction... I can't afford really nice Castagnari or Salterelle boxes just yet and so my mind went to Hohner Pokerworks. They're of course lovely and I wouldn't dare say anything against them on this forum - especially as I've never played one myself! But I'm not sure I immediately go for the Hohner sound, and I was wondering if anyone had tried the Sandpiper range as they're sort of an in-between and unfortunately very undocumented.
I have read the other threads concerning the Sandpipers but they're quite old and really seemingly cover one or two types. Now there are quite a few in the Sandpiper range, I'm particularly interested in the Snipe and the Curlew. Any advice or feedback would be welcome, they seem lovely but I would really like to have some idea of how others feel about them.
-
My opinion of Sandpipers is that they have been designed with plenty of attention on producing a pretty box, but not quite so much care for playing quality. A Hohner will have more responsive reeds, and if you don’t like the wet tuning that can be altered.
-
Well you're probably one of the voices I was most interested in hearing, I appreciate that. I suppose I was a little close minded with my judgement of the hohners. I've been in contact with Martyn at Squeezeboxes and will eventually get round to trying a Sandpiper out, thank you for your input. I shall have to keep scouring the Buy and Sell page in the meantime!
-
Trying before you buy is the most important thing to do. If you want to try a Hohner I’ve just tuned one for Pete Ward of Acorn. It’s have somewhat less tremolo that Hohner factory tuning, but still a fairly strong tremolo.
-
My opinion of Sandpipers is that they have been designed with plenty of attention on producing a pretty box, but not quite so much care for playing quality.
Exactly this - however if you can find a good example second hand and at a good price it may be a good buy. The same would apply for a good used Hohner. Essentially, my advice for your first box would be to buy something you won't lose mone on should you not take to it or decide to upgrade.
A well-priced used Hohner should fit this criteria - as could a used Sandpiper. A new Sandpiper is likely to lose you money should you decide to move it on.
-
Trying before you buy is the most important thing to do.
Absolutely, although if you are an inexperienced or novice player it can be hard to determine good from bad or to know what works for you. If you can get advice from an experienced player, I would recommend that - although as a newbie that too can be difficult. That's how I ended up with an absolutely awful Delicia Popular for four months before getting a Pokerwork and moving on the Decidedly Unpopular through the magic of Ebay.
-
Trying before you buy is the most important thing to do.
Absolutely, although if you are an inexperienced or novice player it can be hard to determine good from bad or to know what works for you. If you can get advice from an experienced player, I would recommend that - although as a newbie that too can be difficult. That's how I ended up with an absolutely awful Delicia Popular for four months before getting a Pokerwork and moving on the Decidedly Unpopular through the magic of Ebay.
I haven't had a lot of luck finding used Sandpipers, but right now I play a Scarlatti Nero and while it has gotten me through my first few months, I'm beginning to find it a little difficult to get along with. It's awfully stiff to play and the high end is really not very appealing to me.
-
I haven't had a lot of luck finding used Sandpipers, but right now I play a Scarlatti Nero and while it has gotten me through my first few months, I'm beginning to find it a little difficult to get along with. It's awfully stiff to play and the high end is really not very appealing to me.
That's a real shame, I had a similarly disappointing experience with the Delicia I had for four months before switching to a Pokerwork. With a Sandpiper you might just be buying a better looking version of the same experience.
-
I haven't had a lot of luck finding used Sandpipers, but right now I play a Scarlatti Nero and while it has gotten me through my first few months, I'm beginning to find it a little difficult to get along with. It's awfully stiff to play and the high end is really not very appealing to me.
That's a real shame, I had a similarly disappointing experience with the Delicia I had for four months before switching to a Pokerwork. With a Sandpiper you might just be buying a better looking version of the same experience.
The vanity in me almost wants a Sandpiper just for the looks! They're so pretty and I love the bird imagery on the sides but alas, I'll see what Martyn says and I'll try them out if I can. Otherwise, a-hunting I will go!
-
Ignore the looks!
-
I bought a new Sandpiper G/C some years ago. It was pleasant enough to play but when the second spring broke within a couple of months I handed it back and went for a Hohner Morgane instead. If I was looking for a cheapish box that would play well and hold its value I would go for a used Hohner Erica that had been tuned and had the button travel limited by someone like Theo. You would be able to get your money back if you ever wanted to up grade. The Erica is just like a Pokerwork but with a rounded case that most people find more comfortable to play. Good enough for Jean Blanchard! Never mind the looks, the pleasure comes from the sound you make.
-
I started off with a Sandpiper, and I never regretted it.
Basically, I just went into the Music Room (a former music shop in Cleckheaton, now no longer in existence) and tried all the D/G melodeons within my budget price range.
Yes, there were a number of Hohners there, but I just didn't like the sound of any of them. There were some other cheap boxes (Delicia or Scarlatti maybe, not sure), which also didn't sound good to my ear.
The Sandpiper stood out as the one box at a reasonable price that sounded nice!
So I bought it and was happy enough with it for a couple of years after which I upgraded to a 3-row 12-bass Saltarelle.
So I'd agree with what others have already said - the best thing you can do is to try before you buy.
You'd be welcome to have a go on my Sandpiper if you ever happened to be in our area (Derbyshire). Or maybe you could book yourself onto the week-end event Melodeons in Wensleydale, which you might really enjoy anyway. I'm going, and I could take my Sandpiper up there for you to try.
-
I also wandered into the Music Room at Cleckheaton many years ago and came out with a D/G Sandpiper.
It was a good purchase back then but now it sits in its case unplayed on a shelf.
Mine is fairly dry tuned with silky sounding low notes. It has always played well and has a nice button action.
As JohnAndy said: "You'd be welcome to have a go on my Sandpiper if you ever happened to be in our area" (Sydney, Australia)
-
I briefly had a Sandpiper and I would echo Theo’s sentiments. It looked pretty but it was not a good player. I got rid of it as fast as I could.
-
You'd be welcome to have a go on my Sandpiper if you ever happened to be in our area (Derbyshire). Or maybe you could book yourself onto the week-end event Melodeons in Wensleydale, which you might really enjoy anyway. I'm going, and I could take my Sandpiper up there for you to try.
You're incredibly kind, thank you, alas I can't do this weekend's event and I doubt I'll be in Derbyshire any time soon as I'm stuck down South for the forseeable. I'm definitely going to try before I buy as you mention
-
alas I can't do this weekend's event
Sorry, I was unclear, it's not this week-end, it's 1st - 3rd April. But I see it's fully booked anyway.
Best of luck with your search.
-
IMHO You can't short cut your way to the best box for you. I've been playing for about 6 years and have bought and sold a total of 9 boxes. I've probably got my hands on another 20 boxes owned by others or in shops. I think you just have to work you way through as many different boxes as you can; visit as many shops as you can; pick up and play as many as you can at festivals and music stands. You'll gradually find out what you like. Have fun finding out! Good luck!
-
My limited experience: the high end of many D/G boxes is going to be shrillish unless...
low scale tuning
nice reeds with just right tremolo for the reed
three voice or God's gift: LM
not using D/G
not playing too much on the dusty end
-
I've played a few Sandpipers over the years either owned by friends or at workshops. They were easy to play and looked good, but the sound quality was very variable.
The best was one of the very early ones, when there was only one model. Whereas one or two of the later ones have felt like their sound was being throttled or a 'mute' had been fitted! I guess this is down to both reed quality and set up of the box, as Theo alluded to.
As Helena said a good second-hand Sandpiper as a good price could be a good buy, but you definitely need to try them. However as lots have already said, a well-tuned and fettled Hohner will give a better sound and definitely hold its value if/when you decide to upgrade again.
But definitely try lots of boxes before deciding.
-
My first box was a Sandpiper Curlew 21 button, 8 bass D/G and I regret selling it. It was a great box and I never had anything break on it, even having given it a bit of bashing playing for morris. I had Lester convert it to Anahata G scale so I suspect his fettling cured any minor issues that could have become major down the line. The 2 big things that a Sandpiper has over a Hohner to me are (a) a third stop on the bass end for neutral chords and (b) a paddle style air button like a Casta rather than the push-down button that I have always found remarkably uncomfortable on Hohners.
-
I got a sandpiper, but I found that the notes didn't sound together. So if you played a gentle chord with the RH, one or more of the notes would sound after the first. Probably not a problem for hacking out morris tunes, didn't suit my style.
I guess that can be sorted by a visit to Theo?
-
Probably not a problem for hacking out morris tunes ...
Ouch
-
The 2 big things that a Sandpiper has over a Hohner to me are (a) a third stop on the bass end for neutral chords and (b) a paddle style air button like a Casta rather than the push-down button that I have always found remarkably uncomfortable on Hohners.
There are many other boxes that offer those two things though, if you want them, that are not Sandpipers. Even some in a not-too-dear price range, like the Saltarelle Bouebe.
-
The 2 big things that a Sandpiper has over a Hohner to me are (a) a third stop on the bass end for neutral chords and (b) a paddle style air button like a Casta rather than the push-down button that I have always found remarkably uncomfortable on Hohners.
To be fair, I have a box with a thirds stop and a few boxes without. I don't find the lack of the stop actually stops me playing anything. So far as the button v. wedge air control goes, I found the wedge a lot harder to get used to than the button, to the extent that I seriously considered having it converted. Eventually I got used to it.
-
Having started on a wedge, I tried a Hohner with a button air button but found it very uncomfortable and cramping my thumb.
I have converted both my Erikas to wedges and find them very controllable.
But..... we are all different, and I might have got used to a button had that been my first 'learning' instrument.
Q
-
What about a used Castagnari Tommy for around a £1000? Only a few quid more that a new Sandpiper, and it may be all the OP needs, I'n not so keen on the LH 3rds though.
Bob.
-
The Tommy is a great instrument, but I doubt if you'll pick one up second hand for that sort of money. A Lilly maybe...
-
The Tommy is a great instrument, but I doubt if you'll pick one up second hand for that sort of money. A Lilly maybe...
Well, I tried one today, and had a very rushed play on it but it's a D/G (no reversals) so not in my comfort zone. It looked like a repair had been made on the woodwork, nice sounding box though..