Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Arnold on March 13, 2022, 08:12:11 PM

Title: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 13, 2022, 08:12:11 PM
Hello,

I decided to keep the Hohner and just chip away at it until I'm happy. I have limited the button movement using a strip of wood and some foamy stuff slid snugly under the levers, and I'm happy with that. The G Bass gap still needs sorting but I don't yet have the tools. Therefore my next job is tuning the 'A' note in the pull F Chord, which is a little too sharp (attached mp3: push, pull, push, pull!..)

I wanted to see first, whether my tools are up to the task. Here is a scraper from a Lee Oskar Harmonica tuning kit. I can't find any information regarding it's material. I'm guessing it's some kind of hardened steel? I sharpened it to a 45° angle but other threads I think suggest sharpening to a 90° angle (square, what?!..). I've only used it on brass harmonica reeds. Will it work do you think?..

I very much appreciate your thoughts and suggestions... Thanks
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 13, 2022, 08:13:30 PM
Here's close up of scraper tip...
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 13, 2022, 08:15:12 PM
And the mp3 file!..
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Theo on March 13, 2022, 08:21:22 PM
Most melodeon/accordion scratcher are circular in section, and ground at right angles.  The best way to asses the suitability of you scratcher is to try it.  It will have the best chance of working if you touch up the ground surface.  If it’s designed for use on non-ferrous harmonica reeds it might not be hard enough, but you can’t do any harm by trying.
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Peadar on March 13, 2022, 08:21:47 PM
If it takes metal off (i.e. leaves a visible scratch mark) it'll do the job.

(Edited to add) As Theo says - it's the hardness that counts. If it's sufficiently harder than the reed steel to leave a scratch mark (needs to be sharp enough to create stress beyond shear strength of reed material at the contact point) it'll work. If it isn't it won't.

PS I'm grinding tips of old needle files at the moment for much the same reason.
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 13, 2022, 08:33:19 PM
Most melodeon/accordion scratcher are circular in section, and ground at right angles.  The best way to asses the suitability of you scratcher is to try it.  It will have the best chance of working if you touch up the ground surface.  If it’s designed for use on non-ferrous harmonica reeds it might not be hard enough, but you can’t do any harm by trying.

Ah, I see, ok so it's just like the reed forms a tangent to the circular cross section of the scraper, which is why it just scratches thin lines? If I have that right I think I understand!..
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 13, 2022, 08:37:15 PM
If it takes metal off (i.e. leaves a visible scratch mark) it'll do the job.

(Edited to add) As Theo says - it's the hardness that counts. If it's sufficiently harder than the reed steel to leave a scratch mark (needs to be sharp enough to create stress beyond shear strength of reed material at the contact point) it'll work. If it isn't it won't.

PS I'm grinding tips of old needle files at the moment for much the same reason.

I might have to find an outside reed to tune first then, as I can't see the one I'm targeting!.. I'm a bit reluctant now though that I know the profile of a proper melodeon reed scraper. Back to the drawing board... (again!..)
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Squeaky Pete on March 13, 2022, 09:51:30 PM
I have tuned a few (not many) fairly standard Hohner boxes but I found the 1040 the most difficult.
The case is in the way for easy access with a straight scratcher and lifting and supporting the reed is awkward with a pinger.
I'm sure with practice and experience it can become as routine as retuning a pokerwork. I'm not saying this to put you off, rather to say this if you find it tricky, that's because it is tricky.
This is just my opinion of course. Theo and others might say I'm being a wimp.
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 13, 2022, 10:46:48 PM
I have tuned a few (not many) fairly standard Hohner boxes but I found the 1040 the most difficult.
The case is in the way for easy access with a straight scratcher and lifting and supporting the reed is awkward with a pinger.
I'm sure with practice and experience it can become as routine as retuning a pokerwork. I'm not saying this to put you off, rather to say this if you find it tricky, that's because it is tricky.
This is just my opinion of course. Theo and others might say I'm being a wimp.

Yes, it occurred to me as I looked into the box, that those big glued in bass reed blocks might somewhat get in the way of proceedings!..

I know from experience that Hohner has put it's name on many shonky instruments (my first guitar was a Hohner), but I do believe that this one takes the biscuit!.. Anyway, I'm stuck with it now, so persevere I will...
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Squeaky Pete on March 13, 2022, 10:58:26 PM
That wasn't a criticism of the box or Hohner.
The construction contributes to the sound. It just has to be worked around.
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on March 14, 2022, 12:11:59 AM

Yes, it occurred to me as I looked into the box, that those big glued in bass reed blocks might somewhat get in the way of proceedings!..

I know from experience that Hohner has put it's name on many shonky instruments (my first guitar was a Hohner), but I do believe that this one takes the biscuit!.. Anyway, I'm stuck with it now, so persevere I will...

Don't be fooled. The 1040 is far from shonky. In it's way it's one of the best instruments Hohner ever made. Great sounding reeds.
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Peadar on March 14, 2022, 12:35:22 AM
Point is that flat mounting of reeds is almost universal in 2 voice 1 row boxes. Done like that to maximise sound output. Old 3 stops (i.e. not the HA113) aretypically set up HMH - the two High reeds being flat and the Medium being set up as a wing plate.
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Rog on March 14, 2022, 07:53:43 AM
The problem with flattening a 1040 inside treble reed, is you need to support it, otherwise you will tend to open the gap/set as you scrape the belly of the inside reed…it will then need to come off so you can sort that out. I have a strip of brass I can bend (to any angle needed)  to get it in as a support (after pulling the inside reed with a hook). But the little reeds can be difficult.
The end of a needle file works quite well as a scraper. The little cheap packets of 5 include at least two with a handily sharp point. And even the corner of the flat square file is good enough.
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 14, 2022, 06:21:28 PM
Quote from: Tone Dumb Greg link=topic=28077.msg336805#msg336805


Don't be fooled. The 1040 is far from shonky. In it's way it's one of the best instruments Hohner ever made. Great sounding reeds.

You could be forgiven for believing it was shonky if you saw how the bass reeds were mounted. They seem to lean quite a bit but that could have been done by whoever put in the upside down reed I suppose, who knows?!..

Reeds can only really be said to be great sounding if they are first in tune, and therein lies the problem!.. 
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 14, 2022, 06:29:24 PM
Ok. I think I need a scraper with the last 1 1/2 inches or so at a right angle so I can kind of scrape along the reed from above? Also, an Italian style lifter for when I need to raise the pitch of an inside reed (I don't like the Look of how the german ones work - ouch! ). I think I could possibly make that. Anything else?..
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on March 14, 2022, 06:37:06 PM

...You could be forgiven for believing it was shonky if you saw how the bass reeds were mounted. They seem to lean quite a bit but that could have been done by whoever put in the upside down reed I suppose, who knows?!..

Reeds can only really be said to be great sounding if they are first in tune, and therein lies the problem!..

Just out of interest, I will have look at the basses in mine and see what they look like.
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 14, 2022, 06:45:04 PM

...You could be forgiven for believing it was shonky if you saw how the bass reeds were mounted. They seem to lean quite a bit but that could have been done by whoever put in the upside down reed I suppose, who knows?!..

Reeds can only really be said to be great sounding if they are first in tune, and therein lies the problem!..

Just out of interest, I will have look at the basses in mine and see what they look like.

I'll take a photo later. They work, so I'm not too worried about them, but they don't look great and so give a bit of a bad impression as to the overall quality of the instrument!..
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 15, 2022, 06:36:23 AM
I just looked again at the bass block and examined it more closely. It appears to be the wooden support blocks to the side of it that are not straight giving the impression that the bass block itself is wonky, but thankfully that's not the case!.. Anyway, I managed to get the bass end pins out for the first time, which is something, so I'll be able to get a little closer to the reeds to work on them at least!..
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: chris hall on March 15, 2022, 02:56:28 PM
Ok. I think I need a scraper with the last 1 1/2 inches or so at a right angle so I can kind of scrape along the reed from above? Also, an Italian style lifter for when I need to raise the pitch of an inside reed (I don't like the Look of how the german ones work - ouch! ). I think I could possibly make that. Anything else?..

yes that would be handy for this model but i haven't come across any like that. i find if you use the thin scratcher that has some flexibility you can bend it so that it runs along the reed for flattening. yes italian reed lifters are easy to make so that you have them in various sizes and thicknesses....i use thicker material for larger reeds..thinner material for smaller reeds. I find some reeds respond to the italian lifter and some to the german. I usually go german first and if it proves reluctant resort to the hook. Occasionaly on the smallest reeds i find the gap can be so fine its hard to get a support under it...in such cases i use a small neodynium magnet glued to a coffee stirrer just to get the reed to lift enough to get a support under.
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Rog on March 15, 2022, 06:43:08 PM
Sometimes these flat mounted treble reeds can be tricky to tune, esp the smaller ones and the inside tongue (and on Italian organetto the casing can be quite deep, so they are b*ggers to access). I have occasionally resorted to removing the reed, making fine adjustment, then temp reattach with a bit of tape, repeat, until it’s ok, then fix it back in. Otherwise it’s easy to mess up the set of the reed and the blimmin thing won’t speak when it ought. Same technique works on PA bass, flat mounted H reeds, if they are being difficult.
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Theo on March 15, 2022, 08:07:30 PM
Ok. I think I need a scraper with the last 1 1/2 inches or so at a right angle so I can kind of scrape along the reed from above? Also, an Italian style lifter for when I need to raise the pitch of an inside reed (I don't like the Look of how the german ones work - ouch! ). I think I could possibly make that. Anything else?..

You can make a scraper like that from an old needle file.  Heat the part of the file to be bent to cherry red and allow it to cool slowly to anneal the steel. Reshape the file to a round section and square off the end.  Then bend as required.  It's safer to heat it again and bend while red hot.  Reheat to Cherry red and quench in water to harden
Title: Re: Hohner 1040 tuning etc
Post by: Arnold on March 15, 2022, 09:53:07 PM
Great advice as usual thanks. I just need some time now!..
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal