Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Chris Ryall on March 17, 2022, 06:38:23 PM
-
All in French, but … it’s always best to go to source. The Savoyard steps are very similar to those we use in England, and to those that I saw and danced elsewhere in France.
Note use of a single tune, these people would not dream of abrupt medley into a different tune, with a totally different rhythm 🥴
When dance music loses its connection to dancers, it has somehow lost its purpose, and arguably its soul?
https://www.savoie.fr/web/sw_86513/Culture/DecouvrezpartagezetdansezlebranledeMontvalezan
-
I cannot comment on the specifics, my French being limited to ordering lunch ;D However I think you are being too dogmatic about only ever playing a single tune for a dance. I would agree that it is often the best way but some traditions certainly use multiple tunes e.g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kYYeX8W3Dqk
Recordings from Irish dance halls in London during the 1960s, such as "The Favorite" and the early "Rakes" recordings make full use of tune sets and I cannot see their "music loses its connection to dancers" or has "somehow lost its purpose, and arguably its soul?" Rather I think they were way ahead of some of our popular bands today when it comes to a connection to dancers. Another example would be the Maraichines de Vendee which always seem to use sets of tunes
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nery9N5Hxi4
-
No dog in this fight but:
"When dance music loses its connection to dancers, it has somehow lost its purpose, and arguably its soul?" is pretty hard to argue with.
Bootsy certainly makes the point far better than I can.
You don't need to read Portuguese to understand he knows a thing or two about soul.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3RyO4ilbnWo (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3RyO4ilbnWo)
Mick
-
Straying a little bit,and showing my age, I suppose.
Bootsy? I immediately wondered what he could possibly be doing in connection with dance or playing for dance? But then I remembered that his name was spelt B-o-o-t-s-i-e, as in Bootsie and Snudge!
Sorry.
-
Not that old, "Bootsie and Snudge" aired from 1960-63. I remember it well.
-
Ah, nostalgia! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JvpIBQmwB74&list=PLwygboCFkeeATCtbtAt3A3wL47R-iUYg- (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JvpIBQmwB74&list=PLwygboCFkeeATCtbtAt3A3wL47R-iUYg-)
-
I merely offered it as real source music, and that sessioners here understand what a branle “isâ€. I suspect that it might be news to many?
Anything else would be a … cultural variation. But nor would it still be “traditionalâ€.
When I still did pub sessions, eg Horses Branle is just getting going, people are trying variations, then someone abruptly medleys into some awful renaissance tune with a different rhythm. It would destroy any dance going on! It no longer informs those steps and half steps, let alone the spin.
I tend to get up, and by a pint 🥲 Anyway. You’ve all now seen the real thing.
-
When I still did pub sessions, eg Horses Branle is just getting going, people are trying variations, then someone abruptly medleys into some awful renaissance tune with a different rhythm. It would destroy any dance going on! It no longer informs those steps and half steps, let alone the spin.
It would possibly destroy any dance going on, but you say you were in a session so it is safe to assume there is probably no dancing going on (I know it's not a 0 chance but in 40 odd years of going to sessions I can count the occurrences on the fingers of one hand) so it doesn't really matter. If that set is the local set it will be being played because people like it and importing 'rules' from other settings is pointless.
ps Medley is a noun or an adjective never a verb
-
ps Medley is a noun or an adjective never a verb
Oh I dunno. See attached.
-
I am a first language English speaker, and I will use the verb medley whenever I want. 👍 And how I want.
Melodeonista is now an English word, first used here, by me. (My latest contribution is Brexicutioner 😉)
-
(My latest contribution is Brexicutioner 😉)
I like that. My contribution to the lexicon is persona non grater - someone who doesn't eat cheese.
Sorry - very off-topic now. ;D
-
I am a first language English speaker, and I will use the verb medley whenever I want. 👍 And how I want.
In that case you should cease complaining when people choose to play medleys when ever they want
-
I am a first language English speaker, and I will use the verb medley whenever I want. 👍 And how I want.
In that case you should cease complaining when people choose to play medleys when ever they want
Language as a living tradition ;D ;D ;D
-
And most importantly play nicely ! >:E
Julian
-
I appreciate learning more about the branle.
Which holds a special place in my heart as such a dance tune was the first melody I learned on a box.
Preaching to the choir about the connection between music and dance.
I'm a Texan and growing up, only schmoes didn't know how to dance.
Okay, Motown was beaming in like the Voice of America for y'all.
But it was exotic and how would we ever learn those dances?
Nothing's changed in decades.
Except lots of millennials and snowflakes hanging around the periphery who don't know how to dance.
Branle in y'all's world, cumbia is resurgent in mine.
Mick
-
https://www.savoie.fr/web/sw_86513/Culture/DecouvrezpartagezetdansezlebranledeMontvalezan
Thanks for sharing this interesting video with nice tune and dance to fit. Have tried to find dots for the Branle de Montevalezan tune but nothing springing up on web searches. If anyone happens to have a source that's be much appreciated to know about
-
ps Medley is a noun or an adjective never a verb
I'm trying to work out how "medley" could be used adjectivally - but then I'm only a retired secondary school Head of English.......
-
ps Medley is a noun or an adjective never a verb
I'm trying to work out how "medley" could be used adjectivally - but then I'm only a retired secondary school Head of English.......
adjective
ARCHAIC
mixed; motley.
"a medley range of vague and variable impressions"
GCE O Level English
-
ps Medley is a noun or an adjective never a verb
I'm trying to work out how "medley" could be used adjectivally - but then I'm only a retired secondary school Head of English.......
More from the OED online. Examples from 1350 to 1908. As a former Head of English, you'll recognise the Chaucer "He rood but hoomly in a medlee coote":
B. adj.
†1. Of a mixed colour; variegated, motley. Obsolete.
c1350 Apocalypse St. John: A Version (Harl. 874) (1961) 191 (MED) Amatist..is as purpre & haþ þe colour medle as of þe violett & of þe rose.
▸ c1387–95 G. Chaucer Canterbury Tales Prol. 328 He rood but hoomly in a medlee coote.
c1450 in T. Wright & R. P. Wülcker Anglo-Saxon & Old Eng. Vocab. (1884) I. 597/7 Multicolor, Medle.
1499 Promptorium Parvulorum (Pynson) sig. kv/1 Medle coloure, mixtura.
?1518 Cocke Lorelles Bote sig. Bv A ryche pal..Made of an old payre of blewe medly popley hosone.
1530 J. Palsgrave Lesclarcissement 244/1 Medley colour, mellé.
1595 in Hist. MSS Comm. (1894) XLVIII. 309 A tall man..wearing a medly russet mandilliane of red and blue, with..a pair of medley russet venetians.
1622 G. Hakewill King David's Vow (new ed.) vii. 252 Hee would not haue his family like a motley cloth, or a meddly colour.
1681 W. Robertson Phraseologia Generalis 876/2 A medley colour; Color mixtus.
2. Composed of diverse or incongruous parts or elements; mixed, motley. See also chance-medley n. Now rare.
a1400 (▸c1303) R. Mannyng Handlyng Synne (Harl.) 10122 (MED) Þe paste..Shal nat be of no medel corne, But alle onely of wete.
c1575–85 in R. H. Tawney & E. Power Tudor Econ. Documents (1951) III. ii. 205 Item, for Burdows in gaskoine blacke, Bristowe frizes and medleye fryses, some fyne and some sortinge.
1594 T. Nashe Terrors of Night in Wks. (1883–4) III. 229 A Medley kinde of licor called beere.
1597 Bp. J. King Lect. Ionas vii. 99 A garment of diverse stuffes as of linnen and wollen, shall not come vpon thee... [May] such medly garments sit vpon the backes of our enemies.
1624 H. Wotton Elements Archit. 98 I could wish such medlie and motlie Designes, confined onely to the Ornament of Freezes.
1642 T. Fuller Holy State iii. vii. 167 A medly view (such as of water and land at Greenwich) best entertains the eyes.
1708 J. Philips Cyder ii. 55 This the Peasants blithe Will quaff, and whistle,..Pleas'd with the medly Draught.
1745 E. Haywood Female Spectator (1748) II. 288 That strange, squeaking, meddly thing of the doubtful gender, Mr. Mollman.
1798 W. Wordsworth Peter Bell i. xxiii Of courage you saw little there, But, in its stead, a medley air Of cunning and of impudence.
1839 C. Dickens Nicholas Nickleby xxiii. 220 Who could do anything from a medley dance to Lady Macbeth.
1878 W. Stubbs Constit. Hist. (ed. 2) III. xxi. 557 The medley multitude that held up their hands for or against the nominees of the hustings.
1908 A. Austin Sacred & Profane Love 104 Still growing burden on your patient back, Piled are the medley miseries of mankind.
-
ps Medley is a noun or an adjective never a verb
I'm trying to work out how "medley" could be used adjectivally - but then I'm only a retired secondary school Head of English.......
adjective
ARCHAIC
mixed; motley.
"a medley range of vague and variable impressions"
GCE O Level English
For example, he was a medley poltroon.