Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Winston Smith on March 18, 2022, 01:16:27 PM
-
This question is prompted by Anahata's post in the "Dutch garmoshka" thread.
I've often had a fancy to try one of these B or C system unisonoric things, but have no idea how they are usually (or can be) played. My only experience of them is listening to three marvellous players in Krakow, whilst on holiday there. So..........
Is it possible to play up and down the row, like with our 1 rows and our 4th apart boxes, other than that they have all the notes instead of just the diatonic scale of course? If so, I might keep my eye out for a cheapie somewhere!
Thanks for any relevant info.
-
For a short while I had a 24-bass 3-row unisonoric Hohner CBA (don't ask what model it was, because it's so long ago I can't remember!), which I bought to save weight; I'd been playing a 120-bass 4-voice PA, and it was getting a bit of a drag to cart it round on morris gigs. I found the little CBA quite easy to pick up - bear in mind I was used to a Stradella bass, so I could concentrate on what the right hand was doing. Then, in a road-to-Damascus moment (I think at Bromyard FF, but I couldn't swear to it) I defected to the push-pull side of the street and, frankly, never looked back. I have tried to play a small PA since then, but my brain has become completely rewired to push-pull and I couldn't even get a simple morris tune out of it because I kept wanting to change bellows direction. Your experience may vary......
Graham
-
Is it possible to play up and down the row, like with our 1 rows and our 4th apart boxes, other than that they have all the notes instead of just the diatonic scale of course?
You can't play along the row but there's a repeatable pattern which you can start anywhere and still get a scale - so you can easily play in any key. Mudchutney (OTP) has lots of useful Youtube videos to give you an idea:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/RDxfQEUzeCU (https://www.youtube.com/shorts/RDxfQEUzeCU) - up and down a G scale on 3 rows (the other 2 are optional, I think!)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbrYYZWP7Xc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbrYYZWP7Xc) - very quiet but lets you see how scales work on a bigger screen.
-
Thanks for that, Graham.
"my brain has become completely rewired to push-pull and I couldn't even get a simple morris tune out"
That was exactly my experience when I picked up an English concertina after being converted to the melodeon for a while, and also when I tried to play a couple of small PA's which I've had through my hands. However, you omitted to answer my question.
But thank you CAB, I'll certainly have a look at those vids.
-
On a CBA the note layout doesn’t work straight up and down the rows. Arpeggios and maj/min scales have a pattern that you have to learn…with lots of practice. And you have either the stradella or freebass on the lh. You have to cover quite a bit more keyboard real estate to, say, get a scale or arpeggio, than you do on a diatonic box, though not quite as much as a regular piano keyboard. Plus the (say) pattern for a major scale is the same in all keys (sort of…if you have a 5 row box…the scales have to 'wrap' around the edges…esp on a three row… so you still need to know where the individual notes are, like a piano). The most compact chromatic arrangement is (probably) the semitone/Irish trad button box layout (e.g. the BC or CC#) or the Jimmy Shane/JK bcc# box. Well …I think so anyway.
-
Thank you, Roger, as well. I'm obviously on completely unknown territory here.
-
the continental chromatic boxes come in 2 systems. B system or c system . Also in 3,4 or 5 row format. (same note on press and draw) the 5 row boxes are easies#t to learn as one scale works for 12 keys - just start in a different place. 4 row needs a bit more praactice and 3 row more scales to be learned.
fir anyone starting from scrathc either system is as easy to learn and much easier to get the hang of than the BCC# box which is not as difficult as many think! The BCC# box is much easier to play than either a BC or a CC# as it is in essence a combination of the2. BCC# usually come with stradella (piano accordion} bass which is much more versatile and suprisingly easy to get the hang of . the smallest BCC# is the hohner trichord but only 12 bass which is quite limiting , 96 bass hohner gaelic are reasonably available at around a grand and are very versatile. Good Shand Morinos come up from time to time but don't come cheaply.
going from a DG,CF or whatever box is not that difficult as anyone so doing is already used to the notion of 2 notes per button.
-
However, you omitted to answer my question.
OOPS! Sorry - must have been the cats wanting to be fed or fussed! What the others have said - the patterns, once learned, can be shifted up and down the keyboard as required. I seem to remember they were fairly easy to learn, but I was much younger then..........
-
That's the point in the discussion where I talk about the French chromatic system ;D that was used by players like André Verchuren, and that has the favour of some diatonic accordion players (that still play both systems or that have switched to CBA, like Thomas Restoin, Lolita Delmonteil-Ayral, Yann-Loic Joly... or myself). This is due to the direction with which you progress along the scale : it is inwards and upwards, as is the case for 4th-apart boxes on the pull (whereas the B system is outwards/downwards and the C system inwards/downwards).
That makes it very easy and natural to play when you come from the bisonoric world.
I expect that for similar reasons of you're a B/C/C# player the switch is easier to B or C system.
-
The feeling in the hands on a CBA is more like "shape" (as one might think of hand shapes for chording on a fretted instrument). The "shape" thinking involved in playing cross-row on a diatonic is also definitely helpful. If you're used to playing an entire scale on the draw on a club or 3-row instrument, a CBA will not feel too alien.
You can think of each column of buttons as a string, and the rows as frets. So if you were to start on the inner row, and walk outward (diagonally up or down depending on B or C griff) to the next row, and the next, along a column of keys, you'd hear it climb a half note each time, just as if you were walking up the frets on a guitar string. Neighboring columns are spaced as minor thirds, so if you played along a single row you'd get an arpeggio, specifically an argpeggiated diminished chord, like C-Eb-F#-A.
Just as with playing scales on a fretted instrument, you're really memorizing intervals -- whole steps and half steps. The nice thing about the CBA is that the geometry of the intervals is consistent regardless of the starting button. It's very logical, and that helps the learning curve.
-
Graham, please don't give it a second thought.
George and -Y-, be gentle with me please, I need to let things sink in a bit!
From what I've gleaned from your two replies, am I right in thinking that the B/C/C# plays inward and upward, like playing from the outer row on a 2 row but with an extra row? (But also will play fine along the rows, like three 1 rows?) Whereas the B System plays more like a misaligned 2 row (i.e. a D/C#, for example) only with unisonoric buttons. And the C System plays (rather more logically, IMO) inwards and downwards, although again unisonorically, hence it could possibly be more of a natural progression for a 1 row player?
When I play 2 row boxes, I tend to play them like a 1 row which has accidentals (well, missing notes shall we say) on the 'other' row. I don't have a 2 row with me, so I cannot really check to see if my above comparisons are anywhere near correct.
-
dg/
on the row or mainly on the row players of DG/CF etc boxes dont usually practice scales . Players of all other accordion syustems - piano, continental B and C system and , yes, BC, CC# and BCC# do practice scales in many keys,and this is very much the norm.
A scale is simply the musical "road" along which a tune goes back and forth.
stuggle to think whre the next note is on the box and whether its push or pull makes learning new tunes much more difficult
ps and dg cf etc players can benefit greatly by learning and practicing on the row scales the full lengh of the keyboard and any cross row variations that are possible
once scales are properly mastered it is advisable to keep pracicing them eg for a few minutes whenever you pick up a box as a sort of warm up exercise
dg
1
2
2
2
cf
-
"on the row or mainly on the row players of DG/CF etc boxes dont usually practice scales"
Thanks again for your wisdom. Your above statement is exactly what I've found in my in own playing.
If I had to actually sit down and 'practice', then I just wouldn't bother playing at all. With the 1 row, I've found that as long as I know the tune in my head, then I can pick up the box and play it. That's the beauty of a simple instrument for simple people, intuitiveness is the key!
So, armed with the advice so far, it would seem that the C system 5 row, with its repeating pattern of buttons v scales would be the only really suitable unisonoric button box for me to have a go at?
-
if starting from scratch on a continental chromatic there is little to choose between B or C system so go for the best bargain which in UK is likely to be a B system.
I dont "practice" scales on a Dg etc box but I do run through the full length of the keyboard a couple of time to warm my fingers up before going onto whatever tunes i want to play
-
I take it that the different coloured buttons denote a scale, or what?
The B system would seem to be less intuitive, having different fingering progressions for each scale. Maybe that's why the C system ones are more expensive?
Thanks again, anyway.
-
It’s just the same as playing a DGaccs 3 row in an oft piste key, mine likes Bb, Gm etc
Basically you turn up the line of its scale, playing on the pull obviously, and do your melody there. You should also learn the chords for that key. Bobs your uncle Tom until you want to play in Ab 🥴
The beauty of a CBA system is that it is the same pattern, a different start for the scales and chords in any key, all 12. Add the buttons are mono tonic. So the same patterns and systems also work on the bush. Very powerful, they just tend to be … rather heavy 😅
-
I take it that the different coloured buttons denote a scale, or what?
The B system would seem to be less intuitive, having different fingering progressions for each scale. Maybe that's why the C system ones are more expensive?
Thanks again, anyway.
I think B and C are pretty similar, in that there are three fingering patterns for all major scales on a C, which I attempt to play. I would expect the B system to be the same. The white and black buttons on the treble keyboard are identical with the white and black piano keys. White are naturals, black sharps and flats. The different values of secondhand CBAs relate to supply and demand. The new instruments are the same price for both systems.
-
"Very powerful, they just tend to be … rather heavy"
Dr Chris, I copied and pasted that sentence as it's the only one which I can understand! I thank you for trying to pass on a little of your undoubted extensive knowledge, but your explanations are completely lost on me. Just to let you know the extent of my musical knowledge.......to know which button plays which note and what it may be called, I have to refer to the layout pages here on melnet.
Chris Rayner (also a Doctor, I believe?) thank you as well. That's sorted the coloured keys fpr me!
-
the B and C sytems are both just as easy to learn from scratch on the B system you work from the inside out and on the C system you work from the outside in. Neither has a particular advantage over the other.
''''the continental chromatic boxs are not in any way related to our 'diatonic' 2 notes per button boxes and being able to play doany sort of diatonic box does not mean you can transfer knowledge of the diatonic keyboard to the continental chromatic .
However because they ae different it is relatively easy to play both systems ( continental chromatic and diatonic) without getting ones knickers in a twist --- they are completely different instrumeents to play. There are readily available tutor books for both systems
-
Thanks for that, George. And thanks for always simply calling me Chris, as is normal courtesy on this group 👍
-
thanks Chris.....for anyone interested in how the continental chromatic B and C systems work there are several very clear keyboard charts on t'internet. Have a look and all will be revealed without need for gueswork or speculation!
-
I summarised the layouts in one image, attached below. The gray buttons are optional rows that are repeats of rows 1 and 2 and allow to have the same fingering for all 12 keys.
I also added arrows to indicate how you go up the scale, you'll see more clearly how the socalled French system is close to the pull direction for 4th-apart boxes.
(I only made it for 12 buttons, as it's a repeating pattern)
There are variations for B and C system where the C (the note) can be on other rows, but it's only a transposition of these layouts.
-
An interesting discussion. I must admit to occasionally finding myself looking at CBA’s. If merely for the times when I need a box with a more ‘esoteric’ key. Out of interest, how useful are the smaller CBA’s on the market ? I’ve seen 30 button ones. Does that give a enough keyboard real estate? Or do players tend to find themselves being drawn to larger CBA’s to cover more octaves?
-
An interesting discussion. I must admit to occasionally finding myself looking at CBA’s. If merely for the times when I need a box with a more ‘esoteric’ key. Out of interest, how useful are the smaller CBA’s on the market ? I’ve seen 30 button ones. Does that give a enough keyboard real estate? Or do players tend to find themselves being drawn to larger CBA’s to cover more octaves?
In my case, quuite the reverse; the little Hohner gave me all the range I needed (as a morris musician, so nothing too esoteric!) in a much smaller and lighter package than the PA I was then lugging around. Having said that, 30 buttons across 3 rows does seem a bit tight......
-
Depending on your repertoire, but for tunes that are traditional or assimilated, you don't necessarily need a big ambitus. For instance 30 buttons gives you nearly 2.5 full chromatic octaves. If you speak in termes of diatonic scales it can be a bit shorter, but it still gets you at least two octaves in each key.
I was under the impression than beyond a given number of buttons (like 42 actual notes and beyond), the main difference was rather with the left-hand side. With models that have few basses, in some keys you end up having to play chords and basses that are split between the top and bottom sides of the keyboard. Higher number of basses models circumvent this drawback, at the expense of being bigger.
In short, if it's to experiment with, small sized models should be enough. There are plenty of those, in second-hand market, Hohners or Sopranis for instance.
-
I was under the impression than beyond a given number of buttons (like 42 actual notes and beyond), the main difference was rather with the left-hand side. With models that have few basses, in some keys you end up having to play chords and basses that are split between the top and bottom sides of the keyboard. Higher number of basses models circumvent this drawback, at the expense of being bigger.
Smaller accordions are often 48 bass, arranged in a 6x8 grid, meaning that only 8 keys are available rather than the 12 keys of a larger accordion with 72 or more basses. Three of those four missing keys you’re unlikely to miss, but the one you will miss is the “B†row, meaning there’s no Bm chord. Unfortunately Bm is a really, really useful chord! You can fake it by playing a B bass note (which you do have) together with a D Maj chord, to give you Bm7 which is close enough to Bm for many purposes, but it’s still inconvenient.
-
An interesting discussion. I must admit to occasionally finding myself looking at CBA’s. If merely for the times when I need a box with a more ‘esoteric’ key. Out of interest, how useful are the smaller CBA’s on the market ? I’ve seen 30 button ones. Does that give a ' enough keyboard real estate? Or do players tend to find themselves being drawn to larger CBA’s to cover more octaves?
smaller cba's are exactly the same as smaller piano accordions in the bass department and for 'folk' music a wide range of keys is not generally required'.
For those who wish to stick with push boxes but want extensive bass range of bass accompanymentthere are of course the larger BCC# instruments with from 12 to 120 stradella (piano accordion)bass
to me the whole point of the simple 2 row 4th apart DG etc boxes and the multi stop one row veriety is that whilst the range of possible keys is limited as is the very limited range of bass ( that doesnt necessarily have to be played all the time) using a bit of imagination and experimentation a very full and nicely harmonic and rhythmic sound can be produced even on a one row box.
this can be done by pressing buttons as well as the 'tune button' to provideright hand chords and/or added rhythmic accompanyment by a simple process of experimentation that requires absolutely no knowledge of musical theory - and that is the joy of the simple 1 or 2 row melodeon
for those who enjoy wallowing in musical theory and'correctness' I would would suggest that a large piano or continetal box would meet their every need, but would be devoid of the "fun factor" inherent in the simple melodeon.
and for what its worth I pllay 1 and 2 row 4th apart eg Dg and one row melodeon. BC and BCC# 3 row accordion and continental chromatic systems and can knock a tune or two out of a piano box
-
An interesting discussion. I must admit to occasionally finding myself looking at CBA’s. If merely for the times when I need a box with a more ‘esoteric’ key. Out of interest, how useful are the smaller CBA’s on the market ? I’ve seen 30 button ones. Does that give a ' enough keyboard real estate? Or do players tend to find themselves being drawn to larger CBA’s to cover more octaves?
to me the whole point of the simple 2 row 4th apart DG etc boxes and the multi stop one row veriety is that whilst the range of possible keys is limited as is the very limited range of bass ( that doesnt necessarily have to be played all the time) using a bit of imagination and experimentation a very full and nicely harmonic and rhythmic sound can be produced even on a one row box.
this can be done by pressing buttons as well as the 'tune button' to provideright hand chords and/or added rhythmic accompanyment by a simple process of experimentation that requires absolutely no knowledge of musical theory - and that is the joy of the simple 1 or 2 row melodeon
for those who enjoy wallowing in musical theory and'correctness' I would would suggest that a large piano or continetal box would meet their every need, but would be devoid of the "fun factor" inherent in the simple melodeon.
Thanks George
For what it’s worth I play three row diatonic boxes (g/c/acc and d/g/acc) - I don’t own a 2 or even 1 row diato. Some keys (and modes) fit under my fingers better than others, but I get a pretty wide sweep of most of the keys / modes I want to play in. The issue is of course you are working very different patterns for each one. When I’ve picked up a CBA it is surprising how quickly you can work out a scale and then just move it to change key etc. The bit that makes me rethink though is I enjoy the idiosyncrasy of the diatonic system. The push / pull element gives things a ‘life’ that I don’t think I would be able to get on a CBA. But I sometimes envy how flexible the CBA is in its ability to easily change key or for being able to easily respond for a request to play something in a different key.
-
Schnorbitz, that's just how I look at it.
The push pull gives everything a life that even the best CBA players can't emulate. (Just my opinion. Don't kill me!)
And I listen to a LOT of CBA players.
-
Schnorbitz, that's just how I look at it.
The push pull gives everything a life that even the best CBA players can't emulate. (Just my opinion. Don't kill me!)
And I listen to a LOT of CBA players.
I once witnessed a brilliant argument between a bagpipe player and fiddle player over which was the better instrument. The fiddle player took the line that a violin is a better instrument because you have ‘all’ the notes. The bagpipe player argued that because the pipes only had nine notes that you had to work within the limitations of the instrument. That meant you created something unique - the piper held the line that in his mind it was ‘better’. I feel we are on similar ground here - not necessarily note wise, but a unisonoric box doesn’t necessarily mean ‘better’ - they are different beasts and a push/pull system seems to almost breath. But that said I still do envy the CBA ease of being able to quickly change key.
-
I think it's a biased discussion, most people that play diatonic instruments have multiple instruments in other keys. And are playing a music that is designed for such instruments, so in practice there is very little, if none, impression of limitation.
Also, there are fiddlers that have multiple violins to play in certain keys, as some styles require to use the open strings.
Also, melodeon does not necessarily equate push/pull playing. There are multiple styles, or individuals, that involve mainly cross-rowing. There is, inevitably, some push and pull involved, but not as a main feature. And also many CBA players that use the bellows to have similar phrasing than what we have.
-
I think it's a biased discussion, most people that play diatonic instruments have multiple instruments in other keys. And are playing a music that is designed for such instruments, so in practice there is very little, if none, impression of limitation.
Also, there are fiddlers that have multiple violins to play in certain keys, as some styles require to use the open strings.
Also, melodeon does not necessarily equate push/pull playing. There are multiple styles, or individuals, that involve mainly cross-rowing. There is, inevitably, some push and pull involved, but not as a main feature. And also many CBA players that use the bellows to have similar phrasing than what we have.
Yes, this is true. Ironically, yet again the ease I have found when picking up a CBA is that I normally cross row on a melodeon. The CBA just uses a different system of 'shapes', but it is not hard to learn these and (to me) seems to use a similar area of my brain. The bottom line here, is there is no one size fits all instrument. They all have their quirks and ultimately it is the 'driver' who gets the most out of the instrument.