Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ross Dubois on March 20, 2022, 07:37:35 PM
-
Since the options for replacement buttons that are plug and play for hohner pokerworks, ericas, coronas, corsos and double rays are woefully limited, im wondering what my options are for replacing the factory buttons.
The buttons for these models have a hole at the bottom and are soft enough to be pressed onto the lever arms. Hohner sells black pearl/white pearl replacements but they are expensive ($4 ea) and will need to be glued on, which seems standard for acrylic buttons.
So I figure I will have to aquire black pearl buttons that I will have to drill out to the appropriate depth and width, and will then have to glue them onto the lever arms. I ordered two, one 12mm and the other 12.5mm from a seller on eBay to assess the quality and fit and it seems the 12.5mm will fit the keyboard fine. The seller also advised that I would have to drill them out if I wished for them to work. These are beautiful buttons and about $1.25 or so each. I'm happy to put in labor rather than opt for hohners more expensive replacements. Weltmeister have black press fit buttons that could work, but im after the black pearl look and hard acrylic feel.
So- have any of you done this before and if so, did you create a jig to get the center drilled just right each time? Id thought of using a soldering iron with a very narrow tip to start a pilot hole of sorts since the surface is incredibly slippery for the drill, but worry about deformation. Since the levers ends are stepped, i would have to make certain the hole does not exceed the width of the tip and make it large enough just to rest on the stepped part
I'm curious as to what methods you folks might have used. I see Martin Quinn replaces buttons on these boxes with black pearl buttons too, so it must be achievable. A chap on YouTube does a similar process, but started with a pre existing guide hole in his buttons and ive yet to find any of that ilk in 12.5mm
Any advice would be most welcome!
-
If you have a drill press, a simple board, with a 12.5mm hole in it to hold the button centered under the bit, should do.
If drilling by hand, add some kind of pre-drilled guide to locate the bit.
-
to which I would add drill a very narrow diameter guide hole first using the smallest drill bit you have or can get hold of. .then using this as a guide hole drill out to required diameter
-
The hardest part is probably finding the centre, if you haven't got a lathe available. The second hardest part is holding it steady and addressing the drill bit steadily with a pillar drill and secure clamp.
Amazon can provide a variety of solutions if you don't have access to a tool shop.
There are methods which don't rely on special tools, but all require a bit of technique. I'm sure spmeone can offer a way to make solutions, but I've never been in the position of having to.
-
Clamp your bit of wood for your jig onto the base of your drill press and drill it out to 12.5 (or whatever) and then don't move it! Just pop in the button and Bob's your uncle.
-
Clamp your bit of wood for your jig onto the base of your drill press and drill it out to 12.5 (or whatever) and then don't move it! Just pop in the button and Bob's your uncle.
Great way of doing it...if you have a drill dress press.
With a steady hand, you should be able to get to about +-0.2mm with a centre finder maybe better..
-
Drill pilot hole right through the wood, then drill the hole for the button part way through. Go back to the pilot drill and locate it in the pilot hole in the wood. Once in position clamp to the drill press table.
-
I cheat and mount the button in my lathe, but I suspect that most people don't have one.
When drilling acrylic it is important to not let the drill get hot. It will gum up the holes. You can use a wet sponge to cool the bit if this happens.
-
I cheat and mount the button in my lathe, but I suspect that most people don't have one.
When drilling acrylic it is important to not let the drill get hot. It will gum up the holes. You can use a wet sponge to cool the bit if this happens.
I have found using a spray fix and paper seems to act as a sufficient heat sink when cutting acrylic with a scroll saw. Don't know if it would help drilling, but I might try it.