Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Kimric Smythe on March 28, 2022, 06:00:29 PM
-
I watched a video about the Flaco instrument that Gilberto did with the Smithsonian and apparently the accidentals on the end of the keyboard have been changed. Does anyone know what the layout is? I have someone who wants me to convert their Corona II.
-
I had a conversation about this with Flaco in the late eighties, in fact so long ago that I can't remember what he said! Duh!
-
Hi Kimric and Reese,
I've seen a few modifications of Hohner Coronas used by Norteno and Tejano players, including often flipping one or more of the pairs of reeds for the accidental buttons so that these notes are in reversed bellows directions.
From possibly that same Smithsonian article*, I pulled the attached layout diagram for Flaco. Looks like (for a GCF box) the reeds for the #1 button on the G row are flipped. This will have the Eb / C# notes in the same direction for the G row and the F row. And I *think* what is implied here is that the F# reed on the C row #1 button is tuned to Bb ( ?? a major third higher).
PG
* source: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smithsonian-institution/remarkable-rebirth-button-accordion-180967626/
-
Just for fun. Kimric, did you ever meet Ramon Trujillo Sanchez? Great great player who was out in California. He explained a lot of these mods to me back in the early 1990s at an eclectic musical party in Sonoma county (maybe in Sebastopol?). As I remember he had flipped accidental reeds on his Corona and had built up the wood of the bass-side reedblocks to accommodate more reeds there! Yes, I know some players on the 3 row boxes take out all the bass/chord reeds but not Ramon. I have notes in a file folder somewhere. Here's a pic from 30 years ago.
-
From possibly that same Smithsonian article*, I pulled the attached layout diagram for Flaco. Looks like (for a GCF box) the reeds for the #1 button on the G row are flipped. This will have the Eb / C# notes in the same direction for the G row and the F row. And I *think* what is implied here is that the F# reed on the C row #1 button is tuned to Bb ( ?? a major third higher).
PG
* source: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smithsonian-institution/remarkable-rebirth-button-accordion-180967626/
Thanks, that is pretty much exactly what I was looking for. I called Hohner and they said they would get back to me but I think this covers it.
-
This is a lot of great info. I have had people ask me to flip some of the accidentals in the past, but this makes sense now.
I carry boxes with and without the bass blocks since the Cumbia players do use the bass, and i have run into a couple of other folks who make some use of it. My music theory is not great since i come more from a mechanical background and most of my music experience is from singing mostly by ear. I lean on my staff when it comes to music theory.
If you can draw up a reed map i can probably do it.
-
This is a lot of great info. I have had people ask me to flip some of the accidentals in the past, but this makes sense now. . .
If you can draw up a reed map i can probably do it.
That's it in a nutshell! As long as the player can explain what they want then a tuner can work with them. It's all so much easier if the player can come in to the shop and test things out, then you can work back and forth until they're happy. Harder if you are dealing with a mail-order customer.
In the case of this Flaco layout, personally, I'd find a pair of G#/Bb or Bb/Ab reeds already made up (which are a standard pairing available from Hohner) rather than retuning an F# up to Bb but those reeds are low and long enough that you might be able to "file up" the F# as the note says.
Another thought, if Gilbert Reyes or Hohner don't get back to you. Kimric, not sure if you were into accordions back in the 1980s and 1990s but another guy I knew out in California at that time was Brad Williams (Bradley Jaye Williams) who later moved to Austin. He was playing with a few bands in different styles from indie to polka, later had a group called Los Pinkies, and has done accordion tuning. He'd be all over those different tunings and mods for Coronas.
-
I probably have the reeds I need since I bought the entire stock of the Weltmeister USA warehouse about 20 years ago when it closed. It has proven handy many times over. I usually got through my stock when I have stuff like this and see what the closest stock reed configuration I have is.
I have probably met these people you mention but I have a terrible head for names.
Now that I have the note chart I can move forward.
I was supposed to get a call/email back a couple of days ago but I am not surprised that i have not heard anything. I think they see me as competition since I have done work for Weltmeister. They have been really unhelpful regarding warranty issues that I tried to help customers with.
-
In a similar vein, does anyone know the layout of Steve Jordan's signature "Rockordeon"? Apparently that was also a modified Corona.
-
It is my understanding that the Steve Jordan instrument was dry tuned, possibly without bass notes (?). Low octave notes were tuned in near unison, with higher notes octave tuned. Giving a similar efect that found when using the crossover switch on Hammond (B3?) organ. The same effect is found on short scale harmoniums.
-
Somewhere I have a late 80s music tech jiz mag with a review of the Rockordeon. Can't find it so I guess it is in deep storage (= the attic).
I'll look it out. In the mean time I have made a quick google search. Though I can find no specifics, images show instruments with bass buttons, so I guess I was wrong about bass blocks.
IIRC there was a piano keyboard instrument made by Hohner round the same time, with a similar/same name. This had bass blocks replaced with electrics and external vol. controls.
-
It is my understanding that the Steve Jordan instrument was dry tuned, possibly without bass notes (?). Low octave notes were tuned in near unison, with higher notes octave tuned. Giving a similar efect that found when using the crossover switch on Hammond (B3?) organ. The same effect is found on short scale harmoniums.
Hi Mike, I wonder if by "crossover switch" you mean the "foldback" that is built in to Hammond console organs like the B3. That is pretty much what you describe - those are wired so that when you add higher harmonics via the drawbars (a similar effect to adding octaves of reeds to an accordion via couplers or stops), the highest notes of the highest harmonics "jump down an octave." This fills in the sound of the higher keys on the keyboard. The spinet models of Hammond such as the M3, M100, L100, etc lack this foldback so when playing on the highest keys of the keyboard the sound can get thin, and along with the extended manuals this foldback is one of the most important advantages of the console Hammonds vs the spinet Hammonds. There's also foldback of the lowest notes (upward) on Hammond organs.
More info here:
http://www.dairiki.org/HammondWiki/HarmonicFoldback
and
https://electricdruid.net/technical-aspects-of-the-hammond-organ/#foldback
PG
-
Thanks Mike and Peter -- but I think there's more to it than that. In a few places, including this obituary from a Texas publication https://www.austin360.com/story/entertainment/music/2016/10/21/steve-esteban-jordan-gave-the-accordion-a-new-sound/10197611007/ it is suggested that like Flaco he also tinkered with the layout and tuning to get to runs, chords, and keys otherwise impossible. I read somewhere that he described his instruments as "Jordanized".
-
It is my understanding that the Steve Jordan instrument was dry tuned, possibly without bass notes (?). Low octave notes were tuned in near unison, with higher notes octave tuned. Giving a similar efect that found when using the crossover switch on Hammond (B3?) organ. The same effect is found on short scale harmoniums.
Hi Mike, I wonder if by "crossover switch" you mean the "foldback" that is built in to Hammond console organs like the B3. That is pretty much what you describe - those are wired so that when you add higher harmonics via the drawbars (a similar effect to adding octaves of reeds to an accordion via couplers or stops), the highest notes of the highest harmonics "jump down an octave." This fills in the sound of the higher keys on the keyboard. The spinet models of Hammond such as the M3, M100, L100, etc lack this foldback so when playing on the highest keys of the keyboard the sound can get thin, and along with the extended manuals this foldback is one of the most important advantages of the console Hammonds vs the spinet Hammonds. There's also foldback of the lowest notes (upward) on Hammond organs.
More info here:
http://www.dairiki.org/HammondWiki/HarmonicFoldback
and
https://electricdruid.net/technical-aspects-of-the-hammond-organ/#foldback
PG
Paul
Exactly that.
I have recently spent some time looking for a reed organ with crossover + manual coupling for my 93 year old uncle,
There is much in the language of these descriptions that "crosses over".
Thankou for that clarification.
AtB
Mike
-
Thanks Mike and Peter -- but I think there's more to it than that. In a few places, including this obituary from a Texas publication https://www.austin360.com/story/entertainment/music/2016/10/21/steve-esteban-jordan-gave-the-accordion-a-new-sound/10197611007/ it is suggested that like Flaco he also tinkered with the layout and tuning to get to runs, chords, and keys otherwise impossible. I read somewhere that he described his instruments as "Jordanized".
Oooo....
I'm intrigued.
If anything ever comes of this please let me know.
AtB
Mike
-
I did the job a couple of weeks ago.
It was hard to get much information on the wetness of the instrument since Hohner never got back to me. i listened to some videos and it seemed that Flaco just had it generally drier so i dried out the higs a bit, but not a lot. One of the accidentals had to be changed in one direction by quite a lot , so i just filed it. It would be possible to use a accidental from a MI tuned instrument (from looking at the charts) as a direct drop in if one is available.
I had to clean up the tuning and gapping on some reeds as the instruments from Hohner of late have pretty rough tuning and gapping.
-
One of the accidentals had to be changed in one direction by quite a lot , so i just filed it.
Somewhere in one of Gilbert Reyes conversations about Flaco he talks about how he had mastered the work of changing reed tongues, riveting in replacements to get to the tuning where he wanted it. Reyes has his own Youtube channel, which includes a very interesting more recent interview with Jiminez here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cs007i9xTzU (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cs007i9xTzU). The way he talks about the limitations of diatonic accordions, and how that influences musical choices sounds very familiar.
Quotes that struck me include "On a piano it's all there. We have to find it" and "In Ireland . . . There's many good players around that area".
-
I have done some re riveting of reeds but i find refiling a new reed to match gives good results in most cases. The high reeds are a problem since there are sometimes two radically different sized reeds on a single plate. Finding a tongue that is the same taper,width,length and has the same size rivet hole is not always possible so a larger reed will have to be filed down to size. If it it is a hand finished reed you will need to grind/file the curve into the reed before tuning it too. This can take up to an hr to do.