Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: george garside on March 30, 2022, 06:26:10 PM

Title: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: george garside on March 30, 2022, 06:26:10 PM
the series of ?4 books 'ceilidh collection' published by Taigh na Teud on Isle of sky are, if still in print a very useful source of dance tunes for the box player.

They also give a recommended metronome speed for various dances which I have found very useful  as a starting point for a dance whilst of course watching the feet of the dancers aand making any small adjustments  according to age , ability etc of the dancers.

examples are reels 116 to 120. strip the willow 126, gay gordons 100, canadien barn dance 138  etcetc. 

I don't know if the books are still in print as I have had mine for many years  but  is not probably second hand on ebay

Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: Dick Rees on March 30, 2022, 06:52:32 PM
In the beginning, I often played guitar or piano backing for musicians 40-60 years my senior.  Many held the view that you take your tempo from the dancers:

If their shoulders are ahead of their feet, it's too slow.

If their shoulders are behind their feet, it's too fast.

FWIW 8)
Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: george garside on March 30, 2022, 06:56:22 PM
absolutely!
Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: MikeK on March 30, 2022, 07:20:19 PM
 [ The series of ?4 books 'ceilidh collection' published by Taigh na Teud on Isle of sky are, if still in print a very useful source of dance tunes for the box player].
 
 This collection as well as some other very good music books are available at Scotlandsmusic.com.   
Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: george garside on March 30, 2022, 10:47:27 PM
just to clarify things the metronome timings I have quoted  are a good guide for practicing dance tunes and  are  good speeds to start a dance  as the music has to start  for the dancers to start dancing! 
from that point on i.e once the dancers are dancing  its vital to watch the feet of the danacers and ajust the  speed of the beet ( by a small amount either way)  to match the way the dancers are dancing aand to continue to watch the feet of the dancers throughout the proceedings.


as to getting a band playing iin unison when leading I started setting the pace on the box and the drummer  picked this up more or less immediately ...other band members could then easily take the beat from the drummer,

I have seen some bands more or less sitting in a acircle on the stage anad doing their own thing  leaving the dancers to cope as best they could with whatever the band dished up!

a dance band is there to play for the dancers and for no other reason!!!!!

Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: Mark Anderson on April 04, 2022, 06:57:19 AM
If only Messrs. Garside and Rees had been playing the last contra dance I went to (going on three years ago)!  The music plodded so awfully that many of the dancers (and the caller) routinely wound up off the music by a bar or more.  What a mess.

Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 04, 2022, 12:10:13 PM
.
 The best thing any musician can do to learn the right speeds for dancing, is to get up and dance
Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: CAB on April 04, 2022, 05:52:06 PM
Experience of playing for our local Irish set dancers is that you play it as fast as you possibly can and they still ask you to speed up a bit.
Recommended metronome settings are:  reels 123; hornpipes 105; slides 136; polkas 135 and jigs 130. 
The reels, hornpipes and polkas in particular are pretty brisk.

I've tried Chris's advice more than once but always end up feeling like I'm in a Charlie Chaplin movie!
Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: george garside on April 04, 2022, 06:51:54 PM
thats fine if your playinng for the same group of dancers regularly as you know exactly what speed they want and can manage for what dance.   

when I played for north west morris, rapper,  clog dancing and border morris sides I knew exactly what suited each best, but again allowed a bit of leeway either way on the day!'

However if playing for  village hall, church hall or whatever  type of barn dances, ceilidhs or whatever they were billed as the speeds I quoted from the ceilidh colllection books were good starting points  but only that particulary if playing for the first time with a particular hall full of dancers many of whom may not be used to dancing on a regular basis. 
this is why its important to watch the feet and indeed the whole body of the dancers  so you settle on adjustments to the starting speed that make it pleasant and copable with by the dancers  age, young, old, mixed etc etc  were all important particularly if working with  a  new to you caller. 

With a regular caller I relied on discreet hand signals from the caller  to slow down or occasionally to speed up a bit  but never departing greatly from the basic speeds.

If there were  a fair number of elderly non dancers  I would put in one or two 'smoochy' walses  which actually went down well with the speed merchents simply because they were different.

Playing for dances is or should be in it self part of the evenings entertainment







Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: Graham Spencer on April 04, 2022, 07:33:11 PM
.
 The best thing any musician can do to learn the right speeds for dancing, is to get up and dance

Couldn't agree more! If there were a "thumbs up" emoji available I'd use it here!
Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 04, 2022, 09:28:25 PM
... If there were a "thumbs up" emoji available I'd use it here!

Echoes my thoughts on many a post.
Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: Julian S on April 05, 2022, 10:45:30 AM
And before I start looking at some of the Breton tunes introduced by Thierry Beuze's workshop in Hawes, I'm going to be reminding myself of the dances. A bit of Breton Danceaerobics should be a good warm up exercise !

More dancing please !

Julian
Title: Re: plauing for ceilidhs,country dances or whatever
Post by: CAB on April 05, 2022, 11:01:26 AM
With a regular caller I relied on discreet hand signals from the caller  to slow down or occasionally to speed up a bit  but never departing greatly from the basic speeds

Agreed, if it's a barn dance/ceilidh with a caller, then communications between band and caller are crucial.  I often play for my wife's calling and she soon gestures (discreetly or otherwise) if she disapproves of my tempo.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal