Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Andrew Kennedy on April 09, 2022, 10:12:46 PM

Title: Well, that was a day
Post by: Andrew Kennedy on April 09, 2022, 10:12:46 PM
Out playing for the swords and broke a spring at the first stand. Tried a fix but no good. So, at each spot I had to beg a melodeon from another musician.

Firstly, they were all lovely and just handed them over (one absolutely forced his on me).

Secondly, what a day. I played a Loffet, a Cairdin, a pokerwork, and a Saltarelle. Trying them in performance was so much better than in the showroom, and revealing, because I played them with no preparation and just as the performance demanded. One was too quiet whatever I did, one hurt my left hand appallingly, one fitted like an old pair of slippers, and one was easy and made a good noise to fill the space.

Draw your own conclusions. I'm saying nothing more, other than thank you to all the generous people who lent me their boxes in a time of need.
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Scobarandbar on April 09, 2022, 10:43:32 PM
Human nature can be just such a marvellous thing sometimes.  Especially in our own wee melodeon world where folk just want to help each other out!  Just back 10 mins ago from a concert where we had 60 kids performing on stage. It was just so good to see people playing music again. 

I would be interested to hear which boxes floated your boat the most….. ::)
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Andrew Kennedy on April 10, 2022, 06:20:44 AM
I'm reluctant to pass public judgement for fear of being thought ungrateful by someone who was good to me.  We are generally proud of, or at least pleased with, our choice of instruments, so I'll just accept that my preferences are, however odd it might seem, not shared by everyone.  As it is I've had a great experience trying an unexpected range of boxes under real-life conditions.
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Anahata on April 10, 2022, 08:10:34 AM
We're all different. It's quite possible that the boxes you found uncomfortable or hard work were absolutely fine for their owners.
I wonder how much the dancers notice the difference  when a familiar player uses a different box.
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Julian S on April 10, 2022, 08:32:57 AM
Certainly the best way to 'road test' different instruments ! What instrument do you usually play for the swords ? And do you now hanker after a different one ?

Having started with a pokerwork when there was really nowt else, I suffered the pain whilst playing for border Morris for so many years. Even when I had a much better box - which is certainly loud enough, the pokerwork could put up with the damp and wear and tear, whilst I used my Saltarelle for ceilidhs etc.

After a long gap, I started playing for a side again and used a Dino Super 3 for quite a while. Bound to be better than the pokerwork I thought. Certainly loud enough, not too heavy, and pretty good for more subtle stuff as well. Except it became uncomfortable to play the longer I played it - something to do with the shape and thickness of the fingerboard didn't suit me. So it was back to the old pain of the pokerwork for me - but that was before Covid, and somehow I doubt I'll play for Morris again.
(Though I do wonder which instrument I'd go for if I had the choice of any, for playing out there - and of course the money to spend !)

Julian
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Andrew Kennedy on April 10, 2022, 08:45:53 AM
For years I played a Lilly for outdoor dancing - clear, loud, and audible at the back of the crowd.  Also nice and light for carrying. Eventually the bellows went and, whilst waiting for new ones, I got a Chinese Erica as an emergency stopgap and found that once it was fettled I rather liked it for longsword and morris. I still prefer the Lily for rapper.

The dancers seem quite indifferent to any change of instrument, but then I'm still trying to persuade them to let me know what they propose to dance before they line up to start.
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Andrew Kennedy on April 10, 2022, 09:35:47 AM
When the bellows went it was the start of Whitby Folk week, where I was playing for both NW morris and for rapper .  Before I got the Erica I borrowed a big old 21x8 Castignari, a 2.7 Serenellini, something Chinese with an Italian name, and an early Oakwood.  Only the Oakwood appealed to me.
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 10, 2022, 11:10:44 AM
I understand your need for discretion.
By road testing boxes in a real life situation, you've managed to achieve something that the rest of us can't, which is a lucky outcome.
Also we'll done for taking the bull by the horns and continuing playing with whatever was thrown at you in a performance situation. That mustn't have been easy.

As for dancers, unless you're also a player, it makes no difference. As long as the tune is loud enough to hear and at the right speed for the dance, that's all we need.
The perceptive dancers will only notice if it's a melodeon or whistle.
Possibly  ::)
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 10, 2022, 11:19:15 AM
... and on reflection, I think style of playing is more noticed rather than box choice, depending on the dance.
In our Cotswold side we have 3 regular players each uses  a Pokerwork, Erica and DB Oakwood special depending on who'splaying.
Their subtle differences in style and how to emphasise the 'up' beat is more noticeable from a dancer's perspectivethat which box the sound is emanating from.
I'd think this point of view will differ depending on whether you're playing for Sword, Rapper, Cotswold etc.
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: george garside on April 10, 2022, 04:06:05 PM
to me the key to playing for any sort of 'folk' dance and  occasional 'ballroom'' dance  is to put the emphasis on the ''off beat''which is what provides the dancers with 'lift''  i.e. a short very brief "um" as the dancers land ( but  they dont really need it as they can't hover and gavity brings them down) gollowed by a strong 'PA' as in um pa'

The make model or type of box becomes largely irrelevent  be it one two or three row, piano or continental box as long as the rhythm is spot on anad strong. 

similarly  unless a dance is tune specific  the tune being played is not important as long as it has the appropriate rhytm eg 4/4  2/4 6/8 3/4 or whatever.

I have used battered old pokerwork for outdoor stuff and serenellini, castagnari, BCC# etcfor  indoors   the dancers been uninteressted in which box is being played

In other words the dancers don't care which or what box is used  but care verymuch about the way it is played

thats been my take on it for a very long time but each to his own of course
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Andy Next Tune on April 10, 2022, 06:20:23 PM

...... the dancers don't care which or what box is used  but care very much about the way it is played


Definitely.

Many morris dancers don't realise the impact good music actually has on their dancing. It can provide structure and signposts within the dance, as well as giving lift.
Until that is, they experience poor playing for dance!!!!
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Graham Spencer on April 10, 2022, 07:58:59 PM

similarly  unless a dance is tune specific  the tune being played is not important as long as it has the appropriate rhytm eg 4/4  2/4 6/8 3/4 or whatever.


While I agree largely with what you say, George, I'm not with you on this particular point. There's a distinct difference, for instance, in the feel of a "double jig" as opposed to a "single jig" - the former is much "bouncier", being counted "1&a-2&a-3&a" as opposed to a much smoother "1&  2&". The actual identity of the tune may not be significant, but its character - as opposed to its rhythm - certainly is.
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 10, 2022, 08:03:24 PM
There's a distinct difference, for instance, in the feel of a "double jig" as opposed to a "single jig"

as there is between a waltz and a mazurka.
There are all sorts of rhythmic variations within  time signatures.
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: george garside on April 10, 2022, 08:12:20 PM
I  dont  disagree with graham and greg.

 (:)
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Anne Croucher on April 25, 2022, 12:21:12 AM
A few years back I was at Swanage when a seagull unloaded right above me - it is totally impossible to play a melodeon coated with such slippery stuff. I was loaned a lovely loud Dino which was probably a 3 voice but I was so anxious about keeping it clean I did not really register what it was or where it came from.
As I am the only musician for the longsword I was very grateful - it took a lot of cleaning to get the buttons back to non slip and everything clean again - though when preparing for the first dance out this morning I discovered that one of my hat ribbons was still streaked with grey and required soaking to get it clean.

The job description for morris musician, if done with full disclosure would make interesting reading. Good thing it is not a paid profession and there is no union.
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 25, 2022, 12:30:19 AM
A few years back I was at Swanage when a seagull unloaded right above me

Thank the Lord that cows can't fly  ;D
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 25, 2022, 12:28:29 PM
‘
   I had the same experience on my first trip to Whitby, 1970. I had just commented as a seagull
      swooped low over the harbour, discharging onto the water, “I’m glad I wasn’t under that”.

   Less than a minute later I was! (It tastes of fish)  🤢
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Julian S on April 25, 2022, 04:52:49 PM
I must have a charmed life - I've spent a lot of time in Whitby - particularly in my childhood - and never been hit by a gull...yet !
(Though I'll never forget managing to tangle my leg bells with another dancer's bells as we passed, dancing in the old Market Square during the Folk Week, years ago. Result - badly sprained ankle requiring much alcohol based pain killer !)

Julian
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 25, 2022, 06:06:58 PM
Sadly you only need to live close to the sea to get the 'full benefits' of the gulls.
Down here they aren't called "Sh*t hawks" for nothing.
The abundance of their blessings bestowed on the driveway and cars does make me wonder if there actually has been inter breeding with cows... ::)
Title: Re: Well, that was a day
Post by: george garside on April 25, 2022, 06:57:55 PM
in the 20 or so years I did Whitby  neither me nor my box was shat on by a seagull. I did however have a n uneaten burger swiped out of my hand  when I was about to take the first bite. The seagull didnt touch me just grabbed my burger in mid flight and carried it away whole and entire. 

very skillfull fliers the whitby seagulls so I can only assume that any box shat on was carefully aimed at









1

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal