Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Brian Wyneken on April 21, 2022, 06:49:16 PM

Title: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Brian Wyneken on April 21, 2022, 06:49:16 PM
Amongst others I have an old(?) two row (in GC) Hohner "International" box that, aside from being unusually heavy, plays reasonably well in most respects except one:  opening the air pallet and pulling in air takes a much harder than typical pull and produces a very loud wheezy sound. The wheeziness is not present when playing otherwise, so I believe the air button must be the source.

The hole for the air button pallet appears to be about the same size in diameter as that for most of the reeds - about 10mm. The existing square air pallet is 24.1mm on each side. Comparing this to a Pokerwork, the air pallet hole in that box is 19.9mm in diameter with a 29.2mm per side air pallet. Copying that Pokerwork proportionality, I'm thinking I will drill the "International" air hole wider to about 16.5mm to see if that reduces the wheezy sound.

I couldn't find this type of issue addressed elsewhere, so I am asking for advice on whether taking a drill to my box is a good or bad idea. It is a cheap box, but as it sounds OK it would be a shame to wreak it. I would put masking tape on both sides of the hole to reduce any splintering.

[Of course, I'm mainly just looking for someone to blame if this all goes south on me  ;D]

Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Rog on April 21, 2022, 07:32:35 PM
If it’s making a wheezy noise I’d investigate a) that the air pallet is lifting properly away from the hole and b) that the leather facing is not detached and therefore perhaps not clearing the air hole when you operate the lever. Take it to bits and have a close look at what’s going on while you work the air button.
  If you do actually decide to enlarge the air hole, use a (round) file on the hole and stick tape around the hole to prevent wood from chipping out. And you will need a bigger pallet obviously. A drill will probably just tear up the soundboard and wreck the instrument.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Theo on April 21, 2022, 08:21:44 PM
10mm is tiny for an air hole, I would enlarge it if it was mine. Be very careful if drilling.  A standard twist drill  is not suitable- it will tear the wood.  Either do as Roger suggests above and enlarge the hole with a file  or if there is space you could use a forstner bit, or an old style brace and bit.  Both of theses have a vertical cutting edge that will cut a clean circumference.  They both need something for the pilot screw to engage in so you will need to fix a sacrificial layer of wood over both sides of the hole and drill through that.  It will need to be fixed so that absolutely no movement of the sacrificial pieces while you are drilling.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Brian Wyneken on April 21, 2022, 09:43:02 PM
Thank you, Roger T & Theo!

The air pallet and facing are working as they should . . . . round file sounds like a starting point for me as I don't own a brace and bit set. I'll monitor this topic for another day and then give it a go.

Thanks again!
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Dick Rees on April 21, 2022, 09:57:15 PM
I have also found cases (sic) where the air hole was big enough but the end plate was  not allowing enough access for air to be drawn easily into (or expelled from) the bellows.

Just sayin'...
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Brian Wyneken on April 22, 2022, 01:31:30 AM
Replying to Rees:  Thanks - I thought the endplate might be the culprit (and was hoping so for a less complicated fix), so I removed it and played a few tunes - no difference unfortunately.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Rog on April 22, 2022, 01:28:22 PM
If I was enlarging the hole (having thought about it a bit more), I’d probably use a Dremel with a small drum sander (I have various sizes). Probably quicker than a file and not quite as involved as drilling, as per Theo's description. Mark the new hole perimeter first so you know where you are going. PS..the Dremel is my favourite power tool..it is sooo versatile. PPS…I *don't* use it for tuning (:)
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 22, 2022, 02:08:07 PM
Generally, if I was making a hole in thin timber a bit bigger, I would use a half round file, slightly smaller in diameter than the hole (at least, smaller at the end). If I hadn't got something suitable for a 10mm hole I would buy something. It's worth it, not to mess the job up.
Go slowly and keep checking  (by trial), because small changes can make a big difference.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: tirpous on April 22, 2022, 02:47:07 PM
Another possibility is to drill many closely-spaced small holes just inside the line of desired opening, using a backing board.  Then remove the 'donut' and clean the edge to the line with file or sandpaper.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Brian Wyneken on April 22, 2022, 03:08:47 PM
Thank you all - all better ideas than my sledgehammer approach to most jobs (not to mention my playing). I'm off to buy a set of round files (I presently just have one and it's too big for the job), but the pre-drilling small holes and the Dremel grinding/sanding are good ideas in case the filing is too slow . . . the sound board is thicker than the typical I've seen.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Graham Spencer on April 22, 2022, 05:48:52 PM
Another option is a conical rasp; they come in various sizes and coarseness/fineness grades and can be used in a power tool (if you have a steady hand, a speed controller and plenty of confidence!) or a handheld chuck. I have a few, and they're very useful for opening holes to "non-standard" (I think the technical term may be "non-preferred")dimensions.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 22, 2022, 05:54:49 PM
Another option is a conical rasp; they come in various sizes and coarseness/fineness grades and can be used in a power tool (if you have a steady hand, a speed controller and plenty of confidence!) or a handheld chuck. I have a few, and they're very useful for opening holes to "non-standard" (I think the technical term may be "non-preferred")dimensions.

This is a good shout, especially with a drill press. Once again, though. Go slow.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Brian Wyneken on April 22, 2022, 08:30:41 PM
Taking all into mind I bought a larger round file and bore out the air hole to 16mm (from 10mm). That did the trick - little wheeziness and much easier on the pull. Thank you all again for the advice!!!

The box (I was told) was originally purchased for a teenager in the 1990s - it could not have been any fun to play, and it wasn't going to "break in" with time. I wonder if it was a defect in just that particular box or whether the whole line of "Hohner International" were that poorly manufactured.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Rog on April 22, 2022, 08:47:14 PM
Well done. Simplest solution is often the best.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: rees on April 23, 2022, 12:08:25 PM
I seem to remember that the Hohner International were the first Hohners made in China. They weren't the best.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Kimric Smythe on April 23, 2022, 05:22:52 PM
Slightly chamfering the edges of the hole on both sides will cut down on noise and increase airflow. This becomes more important the higher the air speed. It can make a surprising difference since the air trying to change direction as it has to make that right angle turn as it passes under the pallet and into the hole causes a lot of turbulence.
 A tiny cone in the middle of the pallet to help direct the air to either side cuts down on turbulence and noise too. Noise=turbulence.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Brian Wyneken on April 23, 2022, 07:48:25 PM
Thanks Kimric! - I had to look up "chamfering" and so it's what I would have previously called "beveling" (but will henceforth call chamfering) the edge of the hole on both sides. I have a little room left to cut so I might give that a try as the plywood sound board is plenty thick.

My working career was aviation (navigator - I left the chamfering type work to those much smarter people who worked on the aircraft) so completely accept the idea of turbulence = noise - - I just hadn't thought of it in context of box design.

How would you add a cone on the pallet? Would you add that to the leather/felt or (seems more likely) add to the wooden pallet before padding?
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Kimric Smythe on April 24, 2022, 08:53:36 AM
I just stuck it to the leather pad face. You could make the cone by putting a piece of a dowel in a drill and spinning it against sand paper.
Title: Re: Question: Drilling an Air Hole larger to reduce wheezy sound - should I do this?
Post by: Brian Wyneken on April 24, 2022, 04:48:48 PM
Thanks Kimric - since there is still some residual air noise with this box it would be a good one to experiment with a cone addition.

Thanks again!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal