Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Johnny S on April 26, 2022, 05:06:37 PM

Title: Can reed wax condition affect tuning
Post by: Johnny S on April 26, 2022, 05:06:37 PM
I am embarking on my next project, to re-wax and tune a 3 row, 3 voice Paolo Soprani Club in C/F. I have examined the current reed configurations and tuning and summarised what I can see on the chart below. I am assuming that the original tuning was LMM+. I have 2 questions:

Q1.  Am I correct in assuming that for LMM+ and the register config shown below, reed rows A&D and B&E would be tuned to pitch and rows C&F to be tuned higher for tremolo?

Q2.  Currently, all rows are tuned to either approx  10/15 Cents or 30 Cents.  None are even close to pitch.  On all reed rows, there is a crack (stable so reed is not coming loose) in the wax that runs along the top of all reeds.  Could it be that the crack has raised the reed pitch by approx 15 Cents.  In other words, if I was to re-wax a reed, would this lower the pitch of the reed by 15 Cents?
Title: Re: Can reed wax condition affect tuning
Post by: Theo on April 26, 2022, 05:16:27 PM
Cracked wax can affect tuning but it’s not usually a regular amount + or -.  It’s much more likely that your Paolo is tuned to 441 or 442.  Rewaxing is unlikely to shift all the reeds down (or up)
Title: Re: Can reed wax condition affect tuning
Post by: Gonk on April 26, 2022, 08:36:03 PM
To determine the effect the crack is having, you could jot down the current measurements of a few notes, then heat a cheap knife in a flame and use it to re-flow the wax along the crack (by no means a permanent fix, just a temporary measure) -- and test the notes again.  If anything, I usually find that leaks drop pitch a bit.  Old stiff and curled valves have a pretty profound effect too.

And I second that it does look like it is pitched high, even to A=444.  442 is about 8c higher than 440, and 444 is about 15c higher.  That would put it at a more normal +0/+15 spread.  I have an old Italian box in 444 - I gather that standard was popular there in the '30s-'40s.
Title: Re: Can reed wax condition affect tuning
Post by: Theo on April 26, 2022, 11:30:34 PM
A quicker way to check for loose wax is to sound the note then wile it is sounding press the reed plate firmly onto the block with something like a small screwdriver.  If the wax has allowed the reed plate to move yiu will hear an immediate change to the sound as the plate is held firm.  Usually an increase in volume and a rise in pitch.
Title: Re: Can reed wax condition affect tuning
Post by: Johnny S on April 26, 2022, 11:56:46 PM
I suspect that you are right and the tuning is pitched high.  It is difficult to date this accordion but it definitely not 30s/40s (see photo) so could it be that it is not the original tuning?
Title: Re: Can reed wax condition affect tuning
Post by: rees on April 27, 2022, 08:07:30 AM
I'm not an expert on Paolo Soprani but the red badge with two stars and the capital letters on the name badge would indicate that it is from the 1970s or later.
Title: Re: Can reed wax condition affect tuning
Post by: richard.fleming on April 27, 2022, 09:12:07 AM
Not so sure. Red badge with two stars more 60s than 70s, though I'm not exactly sure when they went over to the black badge. The sequence is blue, red, black,  and they went over to black badges fairly early in the 1970s I think.. Red badge models are relatively well thought of, though of course the models with 9 couplers have gone out of fashion somewhat.
Title: Re: Can reed wax condition affect tuning
Post by: Johnny S on April 27, 2022, 11:43:01 AM
I used to  play a 'horse shoe pattern' B/C Paolo Soprani that many people dated to 1959 that also had a red badge with character and 2 stars - see picture below.  The difficulty with PS badges is that the colours may be the same but the pattern often differs. The 1959 one has the words 'Paolo Soprani' on the badge but my C/F red badge one doesn't.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal