Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Andy Duckering on May 08, 2022, 01:41:48 PM

Title: Castagnari Benny
Post by: Andy Duckering on May 08, 2022, 01:41:48 PM
Other than lack of stops what are the compromises that must exist (in my head at least) in the Benny, given its lightness, please? I had a play on one at Wensleydale and it was... distractingly nice....
Title: Re: Castagnari Benny
Post by: Scobarandbar on May 08, 2022, 02:42:41 PM
Hi Andy

I suppose the only things for me would be to make sure you are happy with the size of the bellows with it being a smaller instrument.

Emmanuel spoke to me at Hawes and told me he likes the extra 2 bass buttons on a 14 over a 12 bass as it gives more flexibility for bass runs etc. so that might be worth a thought?

Other than that….which layout to pick.

You must have been doing a fair amount of pondering since MIW!

Scott

Title: Re: Castagnari Benny
Post by: Lizzy on May 08, 2022, 08:40:42 PM
 I considered a Benny for a while, actually I really wanted one!   

I prefer a light  and responsive box , which I think the Benny is, and I like  a subtle sound and  yield under the fingers. The bellows are a restriction but it depends on the way you play, and it is possible to  get a lot of notes and sounds from a very limited movement. Thinking about it I'm not sure how subtle  it is  but as always it depends on the player. 

Still playing my Tommy

Lizzy

Title: Re: Castagnari Benny
Post by: pete /acorn on May 09, 2022, 12:51:36 AM
Hi Andy,
The Benny being 2 voice treble doesn't really require a stop on the treble side and there is the option of a third stop on the bas end,which are standard on my boxes.
If you want more than 12 bass then I have the Benny 18.
In your case as we have discussed on several occasions,it is what feels right in your hands,the buttons are small and what you get out of the box by the way of cross rowing depends on your dexterity.
Bob Ellis had a Benny and a friend of mine has one in Grimsby Morris which he has had for a while.
It may be best for you to come and spend a while at by showroom and try them properly,I have DG acc, Heim layout,ADG, all 12 bass and I have 18 bass Bob Ellis layout.
No obligation.

 
Title: Re: Castagnari Benny
Post by: CAB on May 09, 2022, 11:32:00 AM
I had a play on one at Wensleydale and it was... distractingly nice....
I got to the same stage after spending some time with Pete's 12 bass Heim demonstrator at Bellows & Buttons last year.  A lovely box to play (despite the efforts of a certain Melnetter to persuade me that a Dony would be a better buy!).  Not as sonorous in the bass as a bigger instrument (which was his point) but light and agile, with all the accidentals and reversals you could wish for.  For me, Bob's well-designed layout is ideal - it makes up somewhat for the lack of low voice, compared with the Tommy, say, - by apparently allowing you to play most tunes in the bottom octave.  (I haven't tried one with Bob's layout but that's what the chart suggests - does it really go that low?).  There are also easy fingerings for plenty of major keys (certainly Bb, F, C, G , D, A) and minors (Gm, Dm, Am, Em, Bm) mostly matching bellows direction for the appropriate basses (3rds out). 

As has been said, the significance of the small bellows depends on how you play.  Presumably two factors here:  1. possible time in one bellows direction when row-crossing; and 2. dynamic capability/control.  So a matter of personal preference, as is the button size/spacing.

I'm surprised they're not more common.  Maybe when I've sold something else  :-\ or found an nice second-hand one.
Title: Re: Castagnari Benny
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 10, 2022, 05:27:35 PM
I originally designed my layout for the Benny and had two of them for many years. The reasons I no longer have one are:
1. I made a Pariselle 2.6 row in 2011 and bought a Clément Guais 3-voice 3-row a few years later. Both boxes offered me greater versatility than the 2-voice Bennys.
2. The Benny has smaller buttons that are closer together than those on a standard box, so transferring between the Bennys and my other boxes led to a level of uncertainty as to the precise location of the buttons when changing from one box to another. Therefore, I decided to standardise on boxes with the larger buttons.
Having said that, Bennys are great boxes, and I derived a great deal of pleasure from playing them.
Title: Re: Castagnari Benny
Post by: Steve C. on May 11, 2022, 01:18:41 PM
Andy:
What Tiny said.
Plus, too many buttons.  I have swore off 3 row boxes.  Not enuf time left in life to master.
The Benny leads one unto temptation. I loved it and had it retuned a couple times, ended up with a super-nice Heim-ish 3rd row.
It is a nice box.
Title: Re: Castagnari Benny
Post by: Mr Squeeze on May 11, 2022, 02:20:53 PM
I bought one from Acorn last Nov.  A 'Big' Benny, and it is seriously lovely.
  :D
Title: Re: Castagnari Benny
Post by: Andy Duckering on May 30, 2022, 09:17:46 PM
I bought one from Acorn last Nov.  A 'Big' Benny, and it is seriously lovely.
  :D
The one I looked at was too. Definitely an itch that won't go away!
Title: Re: Castagnari Benny
Post by: BobM on May 31, 2022, 01:44:10 PM
My Serenellini (G/C) Lady 21/8 is a similar size to the Benny, and using the LM reeds I don't feel too constricted air wise, I have other issues.. But is the required playing volume and increased use of the deeper bass reeds key here?

Here's a nice Benny demo.

https://vimeo.com/319062978
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal