Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: arty on June 01, 2022, 10:08:18 AM

Title: Music as Language
Post by: arty on June 01, 2022, 10:08:18 AM
Someone recommended this Ted Talk to me, yesterday, and I found it very, very interesting, inspirational even. It made me think...that is how folk music was/is passed down and is so apt for the instrument that we all play.
The talk is given by one of the world’s greatest bass guitar players, who is also a teacher.
I would be interested to know what everyone thinks....
https://youtu.be/2zvjW9arAZ0
Title: Re: Music as Language
Post by: Corinto on June 01, 2022, 10:49:39 AM
Great!
Thank you arty!
Title: Re: Music as Language
Post by: CAB on June 01, 2022, 11:46:07 AM
Thanks from me too.  Loved it! 

I spent a lot of my career teaching people about child language acquisition - it was one of my favourite topics on the syllabus.  But I've never properly made the connection with music before.  It's obvious that so many great musicians grew up in musical families.  No doubt in many cases there was explicit instruction.  But just being surrounded by music and being able to join in must be invaluable.  The brain is just soaking up how music works, without even thinking about it.  It's especially true at an early age - and there's a definite cut-off point for first language acquisition.  But maybe with music the cut-off point isn't so definite.  His idea reinforces and illuminates the importance of listening (frequently pointed out here by various members).  Something I do far too rarely is play along with recordings of my heroes: I dislike noodling in public sessions but noodling in private is all about learning. 

There you go Arty - that's what I thought.  Agreed, interesting and even inspirational.
Title: Re: Music as Language
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 01, 2022, 12:34:38 PM
This is true,  even of classical music timer for example Beethoven’s Eroica (celebrating Napoleon), Tchaikovsky‘s 1812 (celebrating his defeat!) and particularly true of the 1920s French and British modal compositions. Bolaro? Lark ascending?

Personally, musical language really struck home to me when I started improvising. There are questions, and answers in there, contrasts, jokes,  quotes and contradictions. You can shout or … speak very softly. You can make innuendos (of all kinds) 😉

In 2002 I got over to Memphis and saw B.B. King play. The genius told a ‘story’ with his guitar, as a raconteur would, including generous pauses for you to think about what he was saying. More recently I’ve come back to Jimi Hendrix brilliant star spangled banner at the Woodstock festival. It’s evocation of the horrors of warfare is quite incredible?

   Hendrix: https://youtu.be/q3-b3ViNTMI

[edit] Watching the Ted talk (18 minutes) just now 🙂 He’s very right I think. Music “embeds” in a child’s development just as the maternal language does, (we lose that ability at puberty). And very, very right that playing with others is more about listening than “right notes in the right order”.

   Eric Morecambe’s notorious musical conversation with André Previn 🤔 https://youtu.be/uMPEUcVyJsc
Title: Re: Music as Language
Post by: Gonk on June 14, 2022, 03:26:55 PM
Arty, thanks, I've shared this with many people since watching.  I've had similar thoughts, like "it's rather backward to teach reading music before playing it, isn't it?   We don't do that with spoken/written language" ...In other words, thinking in terms of the efficacy of teaching methods...but his deeper observation about "remaining free" is so important, and he presents it very movingly.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal