Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on October 31, 2009, 01:55:00 PM
-
can any one tell me what key bobby gardiners 1 row four stop is in? ???
-
can any one tell me what key bobby gardiners 1 row four stop is in? ???
Which one? ???
He likes Hohners in G, but his Melodie is in D.
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHOVnFLOV4
the one here.... i love how he plays it... :||:
-
That's in D, as far as I can tell.
-
Definitely in D.
-
Great Irish 1-row playing. Wish my Hohner 4 stop knew how to play like that (:)
Thanks for posting the link.
Andy
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHOVnFLOV4
the one here.... i love how he plays it... :||:
That appears to be a newer Chinese-made Hohner in D, but he's been a friend for a long time now and I know from our many conversations about melodeons that he prefers older models in G. We were comparing his newly-acquired (but secondhand) Melodie and my new Acadian, only a couple of months ago, in Miltown Malbay (the Acadian won, hands-down).
Here's a 1982 clip of him playing a Hohner that sounds like it's probably in G: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhOj9vCR0cQ (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhOj9vCR0cQ)
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHOVnFLOV4
the one here.... i love how he plays it... :||:
I have listened to this many times. It is beautiful; man and music melded perfectly.
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHOVnFLOV4
the one here.... i love how he plays it... :||:
I have listened to this many times. It is beautiful; man and music melded perfectly.
Bobby would be my favourite Irish box/melodeon player. I'd especially recommend his 1982 Comhaltas LP The Best of Bobby Gardiner (if you can find it!), on which he plays some great melodeon tracks.
-
That appears to be a newer Chinese-made Hohner in D, but he's been a friend for a long time now and I know from our many conversations about melodeons that he prefers older models in G. We were comparing his newly-acquired (but secondhand) Melodie and my new Acadian, only a couple of months ago, in Miltown Malbay (the Acadian won, hands-down).
What leads you to believe it is a Chinese-made?
Is it the gold ends, or something else? ..I was led to believe that the gold end plates were
introduced in the late 1970's, when they were still being made in Germany.
Your opinion would be welcomed. Thanks.
-
What leads you to believe it is a Chinese-made?
Is it the gold ends, or something else? ..I was led to believe that the gold end plates were
introduced in the late 1970's, when they were still being made in Germany.
Your opinion would be welcomed. Thanks.
No, it's the gold on the pokerwork sides, which always seems more garish and much shinier on the Chinese models, not forgetting the newness of it...
-
Here's a 1982 clip of him playing a Hohner that sounds like it's probably in G: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhOj9vCR0cQ (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhOj9vCR0cQ)
Definitely in G.
-
is bobbys style of playing associated with a certain area of ireland or do all one row players play like that?
-
is bobbys style of playing associated with a certain area of ireland or do all one row players play like that?
Bobby is originally from North Clare (near Lisdoonvarna), where they have a lively and strongly rhythmic style of playing - you'll very much hear it in the music of the Kilfenora Ceili Band from the locality, who he played with at one time.
The melodeon was formerly popular all over the country here, but the hotbed of playing these days would be Connemara, where it is the instrument-of-choice for the (old-style) sean nós dancing (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=slI5cQNpEJ0) - we even get regular TV programmes of step-dancing here! Notable players there would be Johnny Connolly and John Gannon.
Otherwise, there were some amazingly loud single-row (six and eight-voice) accordions built for Irish-American players in the 1930s (to be heard in dancehalls, before amplification). Here's my friend Anders playing a 1.3 row Baldoni one for set dancers: Clare Lancers Set. Figure 3 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KELhz077OOs)
Edited to reinstate "sean nós dancing" link that had "gone missing"
-
what a great sounding box!
-
The "Acadian won, hands-down"
precisiely what did the Acadian win ?
-
The "Acadian won, hands-down"
precisiely what did the Acadian win ?
Jeff,
It won the comparison of course - Bobby thought it a much better melodeon than his Melodie...
We all know you have a personal gripe with Marc Savoy, you've made that abundantly clear, but everybody who has played my new Acadian has loved it, including some well-known players, and members of this forum.
-
what a great sounding box!
You mean the Baldoni?
That one's an 8-voice, though we've come to the conclusion that my 6-voice one is actually louder! :o
-
have you got any vids of it or your acadian on youtube? id love to see that...
-
'Fraid not, in fact I've only very recently started to try videoing a few clips (on my new "still" camera) and putting them on YouTube, but only one (of the three) so far is musical, and that's of Charlie Harris and Anders playing a pair of grey Paolo Soprani D/D# boxes, along with Des Mulkere (who played with Joe Cooley) on banjo. I'm afraid it's very dark (due to the pub lighting): Waltzing to Des Mulkere, Charlie Harris & Anders Trabjerg (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RLuzk5w0qYI)
I should have filmed "liammcg" last weekend, when he played the Acadian!
-
well, im gonna get me a 114 and learn some of those tunes. :||:
-
I was asking "specifically" such as
tone, playability, projection, volume etc
and not intended to create any animosity or negative responses...
I don't have a "personal gripe" with Marc Savoy
I have met him and talked with him and [[[ Um, no. Personally defamatory comments get edited out. Thanks, Clive ]]]
I strongly doubted that before my 5 encounters,,, and it took 5 such episodes for it to sink in...
I am a slow learner. Others have the same experiences including a very fine local native French speaking Quebec fiddle and box player...
He also butt joints his frames... a "marc" of expedient building and a low level of skill
as well not as attractive or as strong as a proper mitre.
I much prefer his accordeons of 20 years (and more) ago to his new ones.. which may or may not be made by Marc himself;
and that is common knowledge
That said, his accordeons still seem to be quite popular. Evidenced by the "sellout" of his ten 50th anniversary special boxes.
Just my opinion....based on actual experiences....
I have had very positve encounters with other Cajun accordeon makers...none were like Savoy.
I am happy to drop this
Glad you like your Acadian box
-
I was asking "specifically" such as
tone, playability, projection, volume etc
Jeff,
I can reply yes to all those things, by a considerable margin, and on appearance too.
The rest of it we've been over (and over) before, ad nauseam... ::)
Glad you like your Acadian box
It's the best melodeon I've ever played, in fact my other boxes have been gathering dust since I got it. :||:
-
I've had the chance to play both an Acadian and a Melodie in the past 6 months, and both are very different from eachother.
I felt the Acadian was a more rugged / traditional type of build, while the Melodie seemed more of a new kid on the block, and very very ergonomic.
I think appearance wise, the Melodie stands out, and is unmistakenbly recognizeable, as the Acadian blends in as it seems all cajun built accordions do to eachother (I'm sure they have their differences, but at a glance, one would no doubt recognize the Melodie IMHO)
Perhaps it was just the way this Acadian was tuned, but I felt the Melodie had more bite to it, for my taste. I also agree with the mitred corners arguement, I was never the biggest fan of having big metal corner plates covering an accordion.
Don't shoot me!
-
... the Acadian blends in as it seems all cajun built accordions do to eachother (I'm sure they have their differences ...)
They're all based on the old German-made Sterling and Monarch models, so they do have similarities, like the German originals.
Perhaps it was just the way this Acadian was tuned, but I felt the Melodie had more bite to it, for my taste.
I can only comment on Bobby's (which is the only Melodie I've played) and I was seriously disappointed, whilst he was very taken with the Acadian - you should have heard him play it! Mind you, it does have 16 cents of tremolo on it... ;D
I was never the biggest fan of having big metal corner plates covering an accordion.
I like them, they're traditional, and wait 'til you have one (in a gig bag) fly out the back window of a car that's rolled over, and feel the relief when you take it out to find the only damage is a slight dent in one of those metal corner plates, not a shattered mitred corner - it's happened to me! :Ph
-
I can only comment on Bobby's (which is the only Melodie I've played) and I was seriously disappointed, whilst he was very taken with the Acadian - mind you, it does have 16 cents of tremolo on it... ;D
Was the Mélodie dry-tuned? If so, I wonder whether someone "messed" with it. I have never known anyone to be "disappointed" with a Mélodie. I learned to play box in Quebec, and I used to play on an Acadian that I bought from Marc Savoy. I sold it (to Theo) because, while it seemed a nice box, it failed me on a number of counts for the music that I was playing. The action was decent but still not fast enough. The tone was nice but still not quite right for French Canadian music. I visited the Mélodie workshop and played one of their boxes, and knew right away that I needed to switch, ASAP. It took years to get my Mélodie but in the meantime I sold the Acadian, played a Castagnari and a used Mélodie. Now, the Mélodie's slightly angled keyboard does make it somewhat more comfortable. And then there are the aesthetic issues -- I guess that for some, it is important that a box resemble a Monarch or Sterling; I prefer the "pinned" bellows frame of the Mélodie's double bellows.
I think that it is interesting to note that in the eighties, a number of notable players in Quebec played Acadians. (Relative cheapness was a huge factor!) At this point, most of them have "passed them on" to others. I think that Yves Lambert still has an Acadian but has become more of a Gaillard man (two row) in the meantime. Sabin Jacques has moved on to Beltuna, right? Denis Pépin sold his old Acadian years ago. And basically anyone from the Quebec-city and Montmagny areas is playing Messervier or Mélodie.
-Andy
-
Was the Mélodie dry-tuned?
Andy,
No, but it is secondhand and I don't know if it's been retuned at all, whilst the Acadian was made new with +16 cents of tremolo for me.
I used to play on an Acadian that I bought from Marc Savoy. ... The action was decent but still not fast enough. The tone was nice but still not quite right for French Canadian music.
Maybe a significant consideration here is that I don't play French-Canadian music? ??? Whilst the Acadian has all the melodeon "growl" and "bite" that both Bobby and myself would be looking for.
Though (as I've said before) I'd order a box off a French-Canadian maker if I got to try one that I liked better - I'm not blinkered about it.
And then there are the aesthetic issues -- I guess that for some, it is important that a box resemble a Monarch or Sterling ...
More importantly, that it should sound like one. In fact my "newest" (to me anyway) melodeon is going to be an old Globe "Gold Medal" 4-stopper that's being restored at the moment...
-
I don't have an axe to grind here, I'm just tired of having to justify myself...
I don't think that you'd have any reason to justify yourself if you hadn't boasted about your accordion "winning." Rather than focussing on what the differences were (and there are several) on an objective level -- like stating that one played more loudly, or was more capable of playing quietly, or that one seemed to use more air, or had stiffer bellows, instead we were given something that resembled the finish line at a horse race.
As a more serious consideration, years ago Marc Savoy changed his reedblock design with significant benefits to the sound; Mélodie also changed to a slightly different reedblock design (not the same change, but I believe a similar goal -- optimizing the size of the chambers). I'm not certain of the details, but I know that my newer Mélodie has the "flat" reedblocks angled upwards on the side of the reeds' tips. I had an older Mélodie that predated this change. The difference in responsiveness is considerable. I recall that Marc made some kind of change, but would like to hear more details.
-
I don't have an axe to grind here, I'm just tired of having to justify myself...
Andy,
Funnily enough it seems you were replying to that comment whilst I was editing my post - and deleting it! That was because I thought it might be misunderstood, and it has been - it wasn't referring to you, but to a certain someone who does seem to have a personal axe to grind concerning Marc Savoy, and has been making me feel "under attack" over having bought a box off him ever since I mentioned it here - making me defensive on the subject... :(
I don't think that you'd have any reason to justify yourself if you hadn't boasted about your accordion "winning." Rather than focussing on what the differences were (and there are several) on an objective level -- like stating that one played more loudly, or was more capable of playing quietly, or that one seemed to use more air, or had stiffer bellows, instead we were given something that resembled the finish line at a horse race.
That was a passing remark (because I thought people might be curious about the outcome), in parentheses, in a thread that's about Bobby, and related only to those two specific instruments and our responses to them at that time. It wasn't intended as the start of a debate about the merits of the two makes.
But I'm happy to have a sensible discussion of the subject and, since you ask, the Acadian had a much wider dynamic range, being capable of playing almost at a whisper, or screaming and shouting. Bobby's Melodie sounded dull in comparison with it, but I don't know that instrument's life story, and I'd be very interested to try another example.
As a more serious consideration, years ago Marc Savoy changed his reedblock design with significant benefits to the sound; ... I recall that Marc made some kind of change, but would like to hear more details.
I got to play several of his older instruments whilst I was in Louisiana, and can confirm that the newer ones do seem to have an better tone and be more responsive, but I don't know what change he's made as I don't have an older one for comparison.
-
The "Acadian won, hands-down"
precisiely what did the Acadian win ?
Jeff,
It won the comparison of course - Bobby thought it a much better melodeon than his Melodie...
We all know you have a personal gripe with Marc Savoy, you've made that abundantly clear, but everybody who has played my new Acadian has loved it, including some well-known players, and members of this forum.
I have to agree that the Acadian is a superb instrument, quick to respond, has a rich tone but give it a yank and it GROWLS!
-
'Fraid not, in fact I've only very recently started to try videoing a few clips (on my new "still" camera) and putting them on YouTube, but only one (of the three) so far is musical, and that's of Charlie Harris and Anders playing a pair of grey Paolo Soprani D/D# boxes, along with Des Mulkere (who played with Joe Cooley) on banjo. I'm afraid it's very dark (due to the pub lighting): Waltzing to Des Mulkere, Charlie Harris & Anders Trabjerg (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RLuzk5w0qYI)
I should have filmed "liammcg" last weekend, when he played the Acadian!
I'm sure there's someone better than myself to show off the melodeon's capabilities ;)
-
... give it a yank and it GROWLS!
Yep, that's why I tell people "don't be afraid of it" - it always has more to give, if you go looking for it...
I should have filmed "liammcg" last weekend, when he played the Acadian!
I'm sure there's someone better than myself to show off the melodeon's capabilities ;)
Don't knock yourself, you made a great fist of it! :||:
-
Here's my friend Anders playing a 1.3 row Baldoni one for set dancers: Clare Lancers Set. Figure 3 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KELhz077OOs)
Does anyone know the name of the tunes he is playing?
-
The Boyne Hunt / The Abbey Reel
-
And I expect I'll be seeing Bobby in the next week, seeing that it's Willie Clancy Week, so I'll be very interested to see how he's getting on with his new Beltuna.
-
Bobby is one of my favourite one-row players; I really like the rhythmic style of his playing. I know he used to play a Hohner 114 in G, a Melodie, and now a Beltuna. I've played the first and latter, but never a Melodie, which I'm eager to try. You said in an earlier post that he wasn't happy with his Melodie? Do you know what it is that he didn't like about it? I too would be curious to hear his opinions on the Beltuna...
-
well, im gonna get me a 114 and learn some of those tunes. :||:
This is good news... :|glug :|glug
-
"You said in an earlier post that he wasn't happy with his Melodie? Do you know what it is that he didn't like about it? I too would be curious to hear his opinions on the Beltuna"
Considering that he did not have to deal with Vezina...
I wonder what he did not like about the Melodie ie the box itself.
I have played a few more since my fiasco.. a box I never played...not even of one push of a button.. as it was NOT my box..
I did not like any one of the three some.. a few years old, some newer.. no character, no guts, no personality.