Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Mel Knowles on June 23, 2022, 07:47:45 PM
-
I recently acquired this melodeon and wonder if someone can tell me more about it.
-
Campbell’s was a big mail order music business. The melodeon would have been made lat 19th or early 20th century in Saxony in what is now eastern Germany.
-
Being melodeon unknowledgeable, can I ask some more questions...
How do I know what key the melodeon is tuned?
What purpose do the two stops on the top have?
Does this melodeon have any special value?
Thanks for your help.
-
The key might be marked somewhere on the woodwork, but more likely not. C is the most common key for this type of instrument. The third button from the end with the lowest pitch notes with bellows going in plays the key note, and with the bellows going out plays the second note of the scale. So if it's in C that button will play C on push and and D on pull. It's very likely to not be in concert pitch.
I can't make out straps in your photo, but I think they will be to keep the bellows closed when not playing.
It's not a high value.
-
A two stop melodeon has two sets of reeds (voices) inside. Each stop is connected to a slide valve (a thin piece of wood with holes in it). They stop off or open up the individual reed banks. The voices are tuned very slightly apart so that when both sound they produce a tremelo effect.
Campbells and Wilkinsons were the two big music shops in late nineteenth early twentieth century Glasgow. Both as Theo says had a huge mail order business.
-
Sometimes, one of the stops is a decorative dummy, as with the International 1 row which I first started playing on.
-
Sometimes, one of the stops is a decorative dummy, as with the International 1 row which I first started playing on.
True. If there is a dummy stop you can play a tune with with both stops down. I suspect this example doesn't have a dummy stop.
-
As the pallets are very small so only covering one hole I suspect that it does have a dummy stop.
-
As the pallets are very small so only covering one hole I suspect that it does have a dummy stop.
Is it one of those strange models with a central keyboard and a second set of pallets below the key board?
-
As the pallets are very small so only covering one hole I suspect that it does have a dummy stop.
Is it one of those strange models with a central keyboard and a second set of pallets below the key board?
Ah yes, it could be. That would explain the rear stop being set so far back.
-
Hi, I have the same model. I will attach photos later showing the internal reed plates. From memory there are two slides, one under each plate.
The double pallet mechanism is a bit fragile so take care if you take the keyboard off to reface the pallets. Best to clamp the keys.
Once set up they work well. Hope this helps.
John
-
Here are photos:
-
A higher definition photo of reed plates and slides:
The double pallet mechanism is interesting. I have it half renovated in my workshop. I might have another go at it.
PS it is in the old tuning (well below A440). I think mine is in C.
-
First of all, thank you all for your good information...I have learned a lot about the melodeon.
From what I can determine on my Campbell Melodeon, with only the front stop open, I get a "D" note. With only the back stop open, I get an "E" note. This is on the push at the third button from the top of keyboard.
-
First of all, thank you all for your good information...I have learned a lot about the melodeon.
From what I can determine on my Campbell Melodeon, with only the front stop open, I get a "D" note. With only the back stop open, I get an "E" note. This is on the push at the third button from the top of keyboard.
If you have both stops open do is sound a note that is more or less OK to your ear?
You could try testing push on the 3rd 4th, 5th, 6th buttons
See (and note down!) whether you get D F# A D with the front stop open. Then do the same with the back stop open. I am asking because if one single reed has gone way out of tune the others may help identify what the original key was.
-
Front stop open:
Buttons:
Push Pull
3-D 3-E
4-G 4-G
5-A 5-B
6-D 6-D
7-G 7-E
Back stop open:
Push Pull
3-D 3-E
4-G 4-G
5-A 5-B
6-D 6-D
7-G 7-null (squeak)
Both stops open, melodeon sounds good to ear.
-
How very odd. It appears to be tuned to the major pentatonic scale of G.
-
Strange. Can I ask …. how you are determining the notes? Are you measuring actual frequencies or using an app/tuner to determine the note?
Looks like it might be a key of D to me (sharps high?) ?
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/1%20Row%204%20Stop%20-%20D.jpg
Not an expert though.
-
The previous list of notes from individual buttons, push and pull, we're determined by a KORG guitar tuner. I have since gone online and found two tuners/note detectors. One was: "OnlinePitch Detector" and the other "theonlinemetronome.com". Both gave essentially the same readings which are as follows:
Front Stop Open
Push Pull
3-D# F
4-G G
5-A# C
6-D# D
7-G F
Back Stop Open
Push Pull
3-D# F
4-G G#
5-A# C
6-D# D
7-G null
-
Sharing just the musical note, but not how 'out of tune' it was reported as being, may be concealing helpful information. For example, a 49 cents flat G and a 49 cents sharp G are both a G, but in actuality, they were almost a semitone apart.
edit to add- and similarly, a couple of Hz different around the midpoint between two notes, for example if the notes are sounding halfway between an E and an F, then a few Hz one way, you get E, and a few hz the other way, you could see F, despite that they are trying to sound the same note.
Point being, including the Hz the tuners report could be a good idea.
Regardless, Eb major would be written as:
3 4 5 6
Eb/F , G/Ab , Bb/C , Eb/D
But this could easily also be be written as:
3 4 5 6
D#/F , G/G# , A#/C , D#/D
Which looks like your back stop open progression, I think. So, given your most recent post there, possibly it's registering as Eb major on the tuner, but, it could also be tuned to a different A standard.
-
Whatever it is, I'd be inclined to tune it to a more typical setup, including putting it at A440 if you intend to play with other musicians. Of course, some ears are more sensitive than others. I don't think mine are particularly, but it really bothered me when our church's pipe organ was at A438 and the piano was at A440.
-
Of course, some ears are more sensitive than others. I don't think mine are particularly, but it really bothered me when our church's pipe organ was at A438 and the piano was at A440.
Hmm, maybe your ears are better than you think ! From a quick Google it seems the smallest pitch deviation the ear can reliably recognize is about 5-6 cents. 438 vs 440 is -7.9 cents...
-
Might be misapplying what you've read, can't we all fairly easily hear how 'wet' our MM tuned instruments sound because the notes are playing together? Might not be able to tell an M from a few cents different M+ played alone in an A/B test, but play them together and the difference in their tuning becomes much clearer, no?
-
Just read. On the tuning issue. I have just v quickly checked the one I have and I suspect that it’s the same tuning as yours. 3rd key is D-E but way off re cents. So it’s an old tuning.
I will map it in Hz when I get time and report. Should be able to work out what it was meant to be as long as it’s not wandered too far off.
Best tuning app I have found is the Peterson one (iStroboSoft).