Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Rog on June 29, 2022, 10:40:41 PM

Title: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: Rog on June 29, 2022, 10:40:41 PM
I was fixing a Paolo Soprani PA this afternoon, with 4 voices, LL+ MM+, which I have to say is a combination I’d not seen before. It’s for a German national so maybe it’s a more common voicing in Germany? The couplers gave a variety of combinations, the common LM and LMM+ and obvs MM+, but also LL+ and LL+M (sort of the opposite of LMM+). The teacher liked it because (and I quote) it’s a light instrument I can easily throw on… :o….although it weighs about the same as a wardrobe. The master switch as you can imagine gives a v thick sound. It also has a stonking bass reed layout with the sort of chimney L shaped arrangement to pack the reeds into a small (ish) space. Anyone else seen this voicing? On a melodeon…maybe a BC Paolo?
Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: pgroff on June 29, 2022, 11:57:06 PM
I was fixing a Paolo Soprani PA this afternoon, with 4 voices, LL+ MM+, which I have to say is a combination I’d not seen before. It’s for a German national so maybe it’s a more common voicing in Germany? The couplers gave a variety of combinations, the common LM and LMM+ and obvs MM+, but also LL+ and LL+M (sort of the opposite of LMM+). The teacher liked it because (and I quote) it’s a light instrument I can easily throw on… :o….although it weighs about the same as a wardrobe. The master switch as you can imagine gives a v thick sound. It also has a stonking bass reed layout with the sort of chimney L shaped arrangement to pack the reeds into a small (ish) space. Anyone else seen this voicing? On a melodeon…maybe a BC Paolo?

Hi Roger, It's not uncommon in DC# Irish-American Accordions in the 1950s. I think I've seen it most often in 4 voice 19 melody / 4 bass O'Byrne DeWitt Baldonis that were not made by Paolo Soprani. Yes, a thick sound with all 4 voices. Usually these had 2 couplers so switched from MM to LLMM.

In a way this sound is related to the MMHH voicing that was fairly common in some pre-WW2 1-row, 4-voice boxes in C or G (Such as some Hohners in C and some Globe and International boxes in G).*

PG

*
http://www.forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=4354



Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: Rog on June 30, 2022, 07:49:26 AM
Thanks. So are there also examples of LLL (-, 0, +)….?
Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: rees on June 30, 2022, 08:28:35 AM
I have a Castagnari Roma D/G made in 1990, bought secondhand from an Italian musician. It is tuned  LLL (-, 0, +).
I'm guessing that, like the French, the Italians play in the upper octave so D/G LLL would make sense.
Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: pgroff on June 30, 2022, 02:13:55 PM
Thanks. So are there also examples of LLL (-, 0, +)….?

All depends on which octave you consider "M"

. . . .  this is evident when you consider that a DG box in "MM" has its G row an octave higher than the G row for a GC box in "MM"

But I have an Eb / Ab instrument that I would consider to be voiced in LLL. It's in 3 voice musette tuning with the Eb row approximately * an octave lower than the Eb row of a typical Bb / Eb box voiced in MMM.

Here it is in the photo below, possibly made by Ficosecco (thanks to Stephen Chambers for his discussion of this). See also this thread:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=21144.0

PG

* Actual pitch is a bit high of A 440

Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: Theo on June 30, 2022, 04:08:09 PM
I have worked on one example of a DG tuned LL. it belongs to a member here.

I have a Hohner Elysium CF club system that is LLM.  It’s other unique feature is that it’s 8 bass buttons are all basses, no chords.
Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: Andy Next Tune on June 30, 2022, 07:30:12 PM
I have a 2r+2/8b DG tuned LL, with third-less chords i.e. an octave lower than a standard MM D/G. It is a Simplex8 made for me last year by Antoine Errotoberea in France.
Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: Theo on July 01, 2022, 07:27:26 AM
That make two members here that have DG boxes with  LL voicing!
Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: Rog on July 01, 2022, 10:56:51 AM
Well how interesting! I was informed that the owner is a tall strong lady, who likes repairing barns and things, so 'throwing on' a 4 voice 96 bass PA is not too much of a chore (:)
Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: pgroff on July 01, 2022, 10:57:18 AM
That make two members here that have DG boxes with  LL voicing!

And I have one that's LL plus a third voice an octave still lower, a 1940s Ficosecco
Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: mselic on July 01, 2022, 02:11:02 PM
That make two members here that have DG boxes with  LL voicing!

And I have one that's LL plus a third voice an octave still lower, a 1940s Ficosecco

So the lowest bank of reeds on the D row would be one octave lower than the L octave of a LMMH 4-stop? Wow!! I can’t imagine those lowest notes would even sound!
Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: pgroff on July 01, 2022, 03:04:54 PM
That make two members here that have DG boxes with  LL voicing!

And I have one that's LL plus a third voice an octave still lower, a 1940s Ficosecco

So the lowest bank of reeds on the D row would be one octave lower than the L octave of a LMMH 4-stop? Wow!! I can’t imagine those lowest notes would even sound!

Discussed in a long thread back in 2016:

Not to dispute anything written above (which explicitly focuses on English music), but I have seen the occasional low-octave D/G Italian box turn up in the US, seemingly made ca. 1940s- 1950s.  The one I have at present is a ca 1950 (? plus or minus a decade?) Ficosecco in high-pitch D/G (around A 450, not really high enough to be considered a low-pitch Eb/Ab), voiced LMM but with each of those sets of reeds an octave below a typical English D/G in LMM. Maybe this should be indicated "L, LL"

Thus the inside G row of this D/G Ficosecco is very low-pitched; it has reeds in the octave you would usually find in an Italian LMM box in the keys of G/C. But its outside D row has reeds that are a fourth interval lower still.

I think Malcolm Clapp wrote me that he also had a "low LMM D/G" box in similar keys, voicings, and octaves.

The Hohners from the 1930s in DGC (also with a very low octave D row) that turn up in the US have been discussed in other threads on this forum over the years.


PG


Photo below. I was writing from memory in the above quote, and when I re-checked the pitch of that unrestored Ficosecco, it was centered closer to A 446.   Here's the whole 2016 discussion thread on D/G box history:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=19434
Title: Re: LL+MM+ 4 voice
Post by: Mike Averill on September 30, 2022, 06:45:00 PM
I have a DC# Walters in LLMM, viennese tuned. Its quite a fully sound for playing ceilidhs without a  PA.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal